Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Perspective from staff within NHS

314 replies

lowercaseletter · 04/01/2023 04:44

Posted anonymously by an A&E doctor:

Im writing this because I’m angry. Actually more than that, I’m fu*king livid.

I’m an A&E reg with 9+ years experience in A&E both here and overseas. This morning was the first time EVER that I cried in my car after a shift.

I was on nights over this New Years period, but New Year was not the issue, every shift is like this now.

Where 5 years ago we had 50 patients in the department on handover at night, we now have 180. It used to be around 20 patients to see with a 1-2 hour wait for clinician, it’s now 60-70 with a 10 hour wait.

People used to lose their minds if patients were coming up to 4 hour breaches. Last night 60% of the patients in A&E had been there for more than 12 hours, some for more than 40. Many I saw the night before, still in the same place when I came on.

No triage or obs after 2 hours of arrival, no bloods or ECGs or gas for 4 hours. Regularly finding people in the waiting room after 4 hours with initial gases showing hyperkalamia or severe acidosis or hypoglycaemia.

87 year olds coming in after falls sitting on chairs for 18 hours. Other elderly patients lying in their own urine for hours because there’s no staff, or even room to change them into something dry. As the reg in charge of the shift, Ive had (on multiple occasions) to help the sole nurse in the area change patients by holding a sheet around the bed because we have to do it in the middle of a corridor. People lying on the floor because there’s no chairs left, trolleys parked literally wherever we can put them.

Things have been getting even worse for the last 3 months. 5 weeks I came home raging to my wife that people are sitting in their own piss for hours and it’s so inhumane. Now we’ve got to the point where people are actually dying. People who’ve been in A&E for 2-3 days,

The media and public might blame the A&E nurses and doctors for this, but honestly what the fu*k are we meant to do with 180 people in a department built for 50. With 8 nurses rather than the MINIMUM staffing of 12. 1 or 2 nurses per area, giving meds, doing obs, trying to provide basic cares to 25-30 people, an absolute impossibility. And there’s less nurses every week, because honestly why would you put yourself through this day after day?

Resus patients are quickly assessed and stepped down to make room for the next pre-alert, going to the area with those same poor nurses, already overstretched, now inheriting an severely unwell patient.

We need to accept the truth, the NHS isn’t breaking, it’s broken. And the same bastards who broke it are doing reality TV shows and writing books about how they saved the NHS whilst refusing to increase nursing pay. We try and shovel shit with spoons whilst they pour it in with dump trucks

The NHS as we knew it is dead, and it breaks my heart, because it’s a beautiful system. It shouldn’t be like this, and those of us who have been around for longer than 5 years know it wasn’t always like this.

The public have no idea, they don’t really know how dangerous this all is. When they come in they’re horrified, but most of the population don’t know how bad it is. This could be their mum on a trolley for 17 hours, or their wife or son or daughter.

I genuinely feel it’s now our responsibility to speak out. We don’t for fear that it will make our hospital look bad or harm our careers. But it’s not a hospital problem, it’s a national problem, and it’s a problem brought about by the politics of the people in power.

We need to shine a light on what they’ve done, make the public so angry that they demand a change. Massive recruitment of nurses through a proper wage/paid uni/free parking/free Nando’s if that’s what it takes would be a start.

If anyone has any idea how we could coordinate some kind of campaign to show the state of emergency departments in the UK right now please write a response, because I can’t work in this much longer, and more importantly I’m not sure the patients can survive it.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 04/01/2023 14:31

Becas4 · 04/01/2023 14:25

That’s great if they have. It will take a while to take an effect thou

Yes I thought it was good when my friend told me. Funny there didn't seem to be any big announcement about it, maybe they didn't want to announce another U turn.

Everanewbie · 04/01/2023 14:28

LeccyBillShill · 04/01/2023 14:20

@Becas4

“I think the 2 main reasons the nhs is broken is chronic underfunding for years by the Tory party“

www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-budget

This. I know that blaming those evil tories and their rich pals is a great soundbite, but the reality is that more and more money is going in, and the experience is getting worse and worse.

Becas4 · 04/01/2023 14:25

That’s great if they have. It will take a while to take an effect thou

RethinkingLife · 04/01/2023 14:25

ancientgran · 04/01/2023 14:20

I believe bursaries have been reintroduced, a friend whose daughter has started her nursing degree told me she gets £5k, I don't know if everyone gets it but she says her DD definitely does.

Details of the bursary and terms & conditions.

www.nurses.co.uk/blog/do-student-nurses-get-an-nhs-bursary-and-how-you-can-apply-for-it/

Merrymouse · 04/01/2023 14:24

The sheer size and scale of the population is the elephant in the room.

The main problem is the age distribution. The birth rate is decreasing but people are living longer in poor health, so the working population becomes proportionately smaller.

ancientgran · 04/01/2023 14:20

Becas4 · 04/01/2023 14:09

Its heartbreaking.

I think the 2 main reasons the nhs is broken is chronic underfunding for years by the Tory party and staff shortages across the board, 40,000 in nurses alone I read the other day.

With regards to the shortages - Theresa may scrapped nurses bursaries, so now to become a nurse you have to study for 3 years (mainly working in hospitals) and be able to finance yourself to do so, most people I know can’t afford to work 40 hours a week unpaid for 3 years , at the end of which you enter a profession where you may need to use a food bank to supplement your income, you will be overworked, undervalued & risk burnout. Not an attractive prospect.
The nhs also lost a lot of staff after brexit when they decided to go back to their home countries, leaving even more of a shortfall. The ones that are left are at greater risk of burnout due to this lack of staff and are also leaving because to this.

Now I think we are in a position where what we are seeing is the result of staff shortages, years of underfunding, a bad flu season, and a backlog of medical issues that weren’t dealt with during the pandemic. it’s very easy to blame the public for wasting resources, but when people can’t see a doctor and don’t know what else to do so they turn up at a&e. issues that could have been treated by a gp become urgent. There are no clear public health messages about how to access care. Underfunding in mental health services also means people in mental distress also turning up at a&e. lack of social care leads to bed blocking when there is nowhere to discharge patients.

These are not quick fix issues. I don’t know what the answers are, but addressing staffing shortages and paying nhs staff fairly is a good start. I fear that this is deliberate and the tories will announce that the only way to fix it is to introduce American style insurance, we really will be in a bad place if that is allowed to happen,

I believe bursaries have been reintroduced, a friend whose daughter has started her nursing degree told me she gets £5k, I don't know if everyone gets it but she says her DD definitely does.

LeccyBillShill · 04/01/2023 14:20

@Becas4

“I think the 2 main reasons the nhs is broken is chronic underfunding for years by the Tory party“

www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-budget

Perspective from staff within NHS
ancientgran · 04/01/2023 14:13

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/01/2023 12:55

Please could you share where you can check this? many thanks, sounds very useful

This is where we check for my area www.torbayandsouthdevon.nhs.uk/services/urgent-and-emergency-care/ed-miu-waiting-times/

The main hospital is Torbay, the urgent care is in Newton Abbot and then there is the minor injuries in Totnes. Dawlish is closed at the moment.

It is a good system as it helps the patient and it must reduce numbers just going to A&E because they don't realise the help they can get elsewhere.

Becas4 · 04/01/2023 14:09

Its heartbreaking.

I think the 2 main reasons the nhs is broken is chronic underfunding for years by the Tory party and staff shortages across the board, 40,000 in nurses alone I read the other day.

With regards to the shortages - Theresa may scrapped nurses bursaries, so now to become a nurse you have to study for 3 years (mainly working in hospitals) and be able to finance yourself to do so, most people I know can’t afford to work 40 hours a week unpaid for 3 years , at the end of which you enter a profession where you may need to use a food bank to supplement your income, you will be overworked, undervalued & risk burnout. Not an attractive prospect.
The nhs also lost a lot of staff after brexit when they decided to go back to their home countries, leaving even more of a shortfall. The ones that are left are at greater risk of burnout due to this lack of staff and are also leaving because to this.

Now I think we are in a position where what we are seeing is the result of staff shortages, years of underfunding, a bad flu season, and a backlog of medical issues that weren’t dealt with during the pandemic. it’s very easy to blame the public for wasting resources, but when people can’t see a doctor and don’t know what else to do so they turn up at a&e. issues that could have been treated by a gp become urgent. There are no clear public health messages about how to access care. Underfunding in mental health services also means people in mental distress also turning up at a&e. lack of social care leads to bed blocking when there is nowhere to discharge patients.

These are not quick fix issues. I don’t know what the answers are, but addressing staffing shortages and paying nhs staff fairly is a good start. I fear that this is deliberate and the tories will announce that the only way to fix it is to introduce American style insurance, we really will be in a bad place if that is allowed to happen,

RethinkingLife · 04/01/2023 13:34

RethinkingLife · 04/01/2023 13:20

It's limited in area but it's this for finding out where to go.

nhsquicker.co.uk/

There are areas with a WaitLess app like this that will tell you about probable wait times in A&E.

www.waittimes.uhnm.nhs.uk/

However, a number of areas did it as a pilot but didn't continue it. Wales has come up with a version (see below) but there are areas with different systems.

www.waittimes.uhnm.nhs.uk/

Wales is here

aeinfo.nhs.wales/

RethinkingLife · 04/01/2023 13:20

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/01/2023 12:55

Please could you share where you can check this? many thanks, sounds very useful

It's limited in area but it's this for finding out where to go.

nhsquicker.co.uk/

There are areas with a WaitLess app like this that will tell you about probable wait times in A&E.

www.waittimes.uhnm.nhs.uk/

However, a number of areas did it as a pilot but didn't continue it. Wales has come up with a version (see below) but there are areas with different systems.

www.waittimes.uhnm.nhs.uk/

dollybird · 04/01/2023 13:12

Badbadbunny · 04/01/2023 13:01

@WeNeedMoreFairyLights

It sounds like you work in GP surgery? Would I be right in thinking GPs get paid more for patients with depression? My GPs and diabetic nurses constantly ask me if I'm depressed and look slightly disappointed when I say no, and I've always wondered why. I've never presented with depression problems, so they must have a reason for asking. It's not as if they ever ask me if I have any other random ailments/conditions. Not just in the annual diabetic check up either. They'll ask when I go for other things, even asked me if I was depressed when I first went to get a referral for hearing aids which I thought was particularly strange!

I worked in primary care finance until quite recently, and not aware of any incentive for having patients with depression. There are payments for health checks on patients with severe mental illness or learning disabilities, but that's not the same thing.

XingMing · 04/01/2023 13:05

A European system will force people to associate the deductions for healthcare with the costs and their entitlement rather that thinking it's all "free". Germany has a cut off point at about €65k of earnings above which a person is required to join the mutual insurance system. From that, the patient (and dependent family) can access a slightly wider choice of services and specialisms. It's not just working people either; better off pensioners have to contribute too, regardless of their age.

Morielle · 04/01/2023 13:02

I see you OP. My heart breaks for you and your colleagues. It's a travesty, it makes my piss boil. I'm scared for my family. We should all be marching in the streets of London for you.

Badbadbunny · 04/01/2023 13:01

@WeNeedMoreFairyLights

It sounds like you work in GP surgery? Would I be right in thinking GPs get paid more for patients with depression? My GPs and diabetic nurses constantly ask me if I'm depressed and look slightly disappointed when I say no, and I've always wondered why. I've never presented with depression problems, so they must have a reason for asking. It's not as if they ever ask me if I have any other random ailments/conditions. Not just in the annual diabetic check up either. They'll ask when I go for other things, even asked me if I was depressed when I first went to get a referral for hearing aids which I thought was particularly strange!

FixundFoxi · 04/01/2023 12:58

It is far too easy for the very rich to avoid paying tax.
There is a lot of waste - the procurement system is ridiculous.
PFI is extortionate.
We need to move to a European system.
The rich avoiding tax will never change particularly whilst 'the rich 'are inextricably linked with the majority governing party. And actually I think you mean the super rich..
PFI was created to meet a specific need at the time (read up on Maastricht).
Amount spent on PFI has been over exaggerated (not ideal though).
How will a European system magic up thousands of medics, nurses, pharmacists, physios ? Will it be for profit or non profit ? Not happy to 'pour ' money in to the current system but presumably happy to hand it over to Kaiser Permanente or likely Serco whose share holders take priority ?
When folk talk about 'streamlining' 'efficiency savings' 'stripping back on managers 'etc the wards cannot get any more streamlined 😂 and 70% of managers are clinically based.

Badbadbunny · 04/01/2023 12:58

WeNeedMoreFairyLights · 04/01/2023 12:37

You are right in tick boxes is how the Gps get paid. How else would they do it? They want change too? They get the same for a patient who sees them once a decade as they do someone requesting an appointment every day.
They have to meet targets to get funding to you know, pay the heating bills and staff. Trouble is they hit these targets and to get the same money next year they have to hit a higher target. Practices sit and decided at the beginning of the year not to try for some things as they need to focus on patient care.

You can’t magically know your HBA1C without that blood test, and that’s what the funding is for. You might stay stable until you die, but what about the other diabetics who would get missed if not seen?

How about moving to a model where they get paid for appointments and work done, rather than a fixed amount paid "per patient" with add-ons for those with chronic conditions which may or may not need much attention?

Where longer appts are needed, they get paid more. You know, just like most other "businesses" where the more you do, the more you're paid. The idea was fine to pay "per patient" to encourage a more holistic approach, but it just hasn't worked. Why should the GP get paid the same for someone who goes monthly compared with someone who goes once a decade.

Why should a GP "waste" an appointment just to tick boxes to get funding when they could use that appointment to actually do a consultation with someone who needs it?

Orangesandlemons77 · 04/01/2023 12:55

ancientgran · 04/01/2023 11:12

I live in South Devon and You can go online and see how many people are in A&E, urgent care or minor injury units, so when I fell and broke a bone we logged on and checked the waiting times for A&E, the urgent care centre and the two nearest minor injury units. DH drove past A&E to the next town as they had the lowest numbers waiting, I was seen, xrayed, plastered and wheeled out to our car by the nurse within two hours. Currently waiting times range from 33 minutes to 2hrs 20 minutes so I know which one I'd choose. Obviously somethings have to go to A&E but people with less serious injuries being directed elsewhere must help.

I don't know if other areas have the same sort of thing but I think it was well worth the time it took to check before we left home.

Just checked and currently the waiting time in the urgent care centre is down to 25 minutes.

Please could you share where you can check this? many thanks, sounds very useful

XingMing · 04/01/2023 12:41

The sheer size and scale of the population is the elephant in the room. The supermarkets' data suggests that the population is actually closer to 90 million than 70 million. Which explains why there's such pressure on housing, education and health. An ID card system and database needs to exist to access public services legitimately.

If the NHS is to keep going, then I think there has to be a tiered system, like the difference between the basic fixed price restaurant menu and an a la carte menu where the luxury and more complicated dishes are shown separately. So everyone qualifies for and basic emergency care, including tests, x-rays and scans and generic/off-patent pharmaceuticals. Everything else from IVF, cosmetic and gender reallocation surgery comes with a price and from specialist private providers.

Also agree with the PP who suggested that GP referrals should not be needed for access to specialists like OB/Gyn or paediatric care or physio. Leaving GPs a bit more time to do proper consultations and reach considered diagnoses. And FFS, get rid of all the blinking quota payments for hitting targets.

VeryTiredofThis · 04/01/2023 12:40

I work in maternity on a busy city delivery suite, so slightly different to many of the comments up-thread about primary and emergency care, but similarly to other acute services many of our shifts are unsafe and more and more shifts feel unworkable.

Care in labour should be 1:1 but so often we don't have the staff for this. Our midwifery led unit is almost permanently closed in order to staff the obstetric unit but even this is usually running at capacity, not because we don't have the physical space but because we don't have the staff. Our triage service tries to put women off from coming in for as long as possible, or sends them home when they perhaps should be admitted which increases the numbers delivering before arrival. It feels like we've had so many more babies unintentionally born at home or in the car park recently which can be an intensely scary experience for those women and their partners. We're meant to send women to other hospitals if we're full but usually if we're closed so are the surrounding units, nowhere has the capacity to accept patients and how far can we reasonably expect someone in labour to travel?

I know many community midwives who feel uneasy attending home births just in case they need to call an ambulance and none are available, who now counsel women about the possibility of there being a delay if transfer to hospital was required. These are midwives who are passionate about supporting women's choice, but who also don't want to be the person managing an emergency with no backup available.

We have a safety huddle every shift and on every single shift staffing is a safety issue. We're so used to being understaffed and managing it we don't even realise, the numbers we're running at have become the norm. On some shifts though I live in fear of pulling the emergency buzzer and nobody coming, there are times this has been a real possibility.

The service continues to run on good will, midwives and doctors not having breaks, picking up additional shifts to provide cover, and staying beyond their shift to provide care or complete documentation. We often end up pulling midwives from other areas like postnatal care or the home birth team to ensure our delivery unit can stay open but this just pushes the problem into other areas and creates a bed block further along. We try to get new mums out the door as quickly as possible after birth, it feels like a production line, it isn't the level of care any of us want to provide.

I don't know what the immediate answer is. It's easy enough to say hire more midwives but we need to train them first and there isn't capacity for this. So many midwives leaving the profession because they are fed up, and it's not just those nearing the end of their careers but newly qualified midwives who have already had enough. We have a ridiculous number of staff on long term sick with stress who we obviously can't replace, but who without making changes to the way the service is run can't reasonably come back to work and be okay.

The conditions we work in have been gradually chipped away at and we've adapted to work in them, but it has reached a point where adaptation is no longer possible and care is being impacted.

We try our best for everyone who walks through that door, to keep them safe and provide a good experience but we are only human and there are a finite number of us. Increasingly shifts are stressful and disheartening, many of us are becoming compassion fatigued, and the longer it continues to spiral down like this the less safe it becomes for everyone

WeNeedMoreFairyLights · 04/01/2023 12:37

Badbadbunny · 04/01/2023 11:53

I've well managed diabetes. Medication hasn't changed in over a decade. Yet, still I apparently "need" a consultation with either a GP or the diabetic nurse every year (used to be twice a year before covid). We have a lovely chat, but that's basically it! What's the point? I know my HBA1C levels because I test blood sugars daily and my HBA1C literally never changes from one year to the next. I have a blood pressure monitor, so know my blood pressure is fine. I can check my feet myself.

So, the yearly "chat" comes down to answering the same questions on their screen. Do I smoke, Do I drink? What exercise do I take, etc! I know it word for word. My answers havn't changed since I was first diagnosed 20 years ago. I didn't smoke or drink then, and have no intention of starting, yet they ask the same questions every year, taking up their valuable time to tick the same boxes.

We all know that the GP surgery do it to claim the extra funding for "managing" my diabetes. During covid, they phoned me up to ask those same questions, tick their boxes, and "kerr-ching" money into their bank account.

That's the kind of thing that needs to be changed. Concentrate on things that matter, i.e. providing relevant advice to people who need it, and not having a 20 minute appointment for no other reason that to tick boxes just to get the funding!

You are right in tick boxes is how the Gps get paid. How else would they do it? They want change too? They get the same for a patient who sees them once a decade as they do someone requesting an appointment every day.
They have to meet targets to get funding to you know, pay the heating bills and staff. Trouble is they hit these targets and to get the same money next year they have to hit a higher target. Practices sit and decided at the beginning of the year not to try for some things as they need to focus on patient care.

You can’t magically know your HBA1C without that blood test, and that’s what the funding is for. You might stay stable until you die, but what about the other diabetics who would get missed if not seen?

nolongersurprised · 04/01/2023 12:32

EhLov · 04/01/2023 10:51

I paid $20 for doctor, $100 for scan and I’ll pay about $250 for gyne. Surely this has to be a better system.

Really. You think that's a better system? For whom? Rich people?

Luckily, as per my post above, Australia also has a public health system where scans and gynaecology appts are free at the point of use, just like the NHS.

endofthelinefinally · 04/01/2023 12:31

I wrote a long post but deleted it. In summary, IMO,
Nobody wants to pay what is required.
It is far too easy for the very rich to avoid paying tax.
There is a lot of waste - the procurement system is ridiculous.
PFI is extortionate.
We need to move to a European system.

Falalalalalalaetc · 04/01/2023 12:31

Whilst maybe there are disaster capitalists (Rees Mogg) in the Tories who just want to make money and run from the death and destruction they leave behind, in the longer term it makes no sense to leave the NHS as it is. Moving to a health insurance model will cause massive wage inflation and costs to business.

I've read in a number of places (link below just one) that increased disability / chronic illness in the working age population is part of the reason why the UK is not seeing the same level of economic growth as other economies. (other reasons are available: e.g Brexit).

With the NHS on its knees and public health measures basically non existent, this will damage the economy. So the party which is pro-economic growth should really care, but they're just incompetent I think.

A lot of the people in the cohort seeing massive increases in disability and not being able to work as a result are parents of secondary aged kids. Surely, ventilation and air filtration in schools would be worth it just to improve this? It would also save money in terms of those children then relying on free school meals etc once their parents can't afford to pay and are out of work.

www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/charts-and-infographics/is-poor-health-driving-a-rise-in-economic-inactivity

Swissmountains · 04/01/2023 12:30

The elephant in the room are the sheer numbers.

We need to pause all in coming immigration for two years(unless it is qualified medics and health care professionals). We need housing for the Afghans and Ukrainians and tens of thousands of families already living in cramped hotels and b&bs first and foremost. We can’t even currently look after the people that are actually living here, taking refuge.

We need to get a grip seriously.
The jug is literally overflowing now and people are needlessly dying as a result.

Swipe left for the next trending thread