Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Perspective from staff within NHS

314 replies

lowercaseletter · 04/01/2023 04:44

Posted anonymously by an A&E doctor:

Im writing this because I’m angry. Actually more than that, I’m fu*king livid.

I’m an A&E reg with 9+ years experience in A&E both here and overseas. This morning was the first time EVER that I cried in my car after a shift.

I was on nights over this New Years period, but New Year was not the issue, every shift is like this now.

Where 5 years ago we had 50 patients in the department on handover at night, we now have 180. It used to be around 20 patients to see with a 1-2 hour wait for clinician, it’s now 60-70 with a 10 hour wait.

People used to lose their minds if patients were coming up to 4 hour breaches. Last night 60% of the patients in A&E had been there for more than 12 hours, some for more than 40. Many I saw the night before, still in the same place when I came on.

No triage or obs after 2 hours of arrival, no bloods or ECGs or gas for 4 hours. Regularly finding people in the waiting room after 4 hours with initial gases showing hyperkalamia or severe acidosis or hypoglycaemia.

87 year olds coming in after falls sitting on chairs for 18 hours. Other elderly patients lying in their own urine for hours because there’s no staff, or even room to change them into something dry. As the reg in charge of the shift, Ive had (on multiple occasions) to help the sole nurse in the area change patients by holding a sheet around the bed because we have to do it in the middle of a corridor. People lying on the floor because there’s no chairs left, trolleys parked literally wherever we can put them.

Things have been getting even worse for the last 3 months. 5 weeks I came home raging to my wife that people are sitting in their own piss for hours and it’s so inhumane. Now we’ve got to the point where people are actually dying. People who’ve been in A&E for 2-3 days,

The media and public might blame the A&E nurses and doctors for this, but honestly what the fu*k are we meant to do with 180 people in a department built for 50. With 8 nurses rather than the MINIMUM staffing of 12. 1 or 2 nurses per area, giving meds, doing obs, trying to provide basic cares to 25-30 people, an absolute impossibility. And there’s less nurses every week, because honestly why would you put yourself through this day after day?

Resus patients are quickly assessed and stepped down to make room for the next pre-alert, going to the area with those same poor nurses, already overstretched, now inheriting an severely unwell patient.

We need to accept the truth, the NHS isn’t breaking, it’s broken. And the same bastards who broke it are doing reality TV shows and writing books about how they saved the NHS whilst refusing to increase nursing pay. We try and shovel shit with spoons whilst they pour it in with dump trucks

The NHS as we knew it is dead, and it breaks my heart, because it’s a beautiful system. It shouldn’t be like this, and those of us who have been around for longer than 5 years know it wasn’t always like this.

The public have no idea, they don’t really know how dangerous this all is. When they come in they’re horrified, but most of the population don’t know how bad it is. This could be their mum on a trolley for 17 hours, or their wife or son or daughter.

I genuinely feel it’s now our responsibility to speak out. We don’t for fear that it will make our hospital look bad or harm our careers. But it’s not a hospital problem, it’s a national problem, and it’s a problem brought about by the politics of the people in power.

We need to shine a light on what they’ve done, make the public so angry that they demand a change. Massive recruitment of nurses through a proper wage/paid uni/free parking/free Nando’s if that’s what it takes would be a start.

If anyone has any idea how we could coordinate some kind of campaign to show the state of emergency departments in the UK right now please write a response, because I can’t work in this much longer, and more importantly I’m not sure the patients can survive it.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 04/01/2023 08:38

I know its incredibly complex but I suppose the problems all stem from overuse of a&e. Could any a&e doctors say whether they all should be there (in which case we need more capacity for a&e) whether half or more should really have waited for a gp in the morning (I know easier said than done but for the purposes of this question did they need a&e) or whether most of the patients actually should have come through a&e but the real issue is that there's no bed elsewhere in the hospital so they can't be admitted?

I'm guessing the answer is a bit of all 3!

From personal experience I see a lot of the issues are related to an aging population, and more people with serious chronic illnesses. My dp's dm has been to a&e 4 times in 28 months for falls, twice for infections sent by her gp. She lives alone, has mental capacity and has no desire to move (the children do not have power of attorney). She's one person, 6 trips all by ambulance (she calls herself), she isn't alone (and yes we feel bad but she's 100 miles away, offered to bring her here but she refused)

Snowmoab · 04/01/2023 08:37

maeveiscurious · 04/01/2023 08:35

I agree with the social card dude needs addressing. What about drink and drugs. I was in an A&E a while ago midweek in the day and 70% was drug and drink related.

They need to have a drunk|drug tank for these cases. Most of the care is watch and wait so this doesn't need to be in A&E

Or they could increase access to support services? Address the societal and mental health reasons that make people drink or take drugs to excess?

FixundFoxi · 04/01/2023 08:36

Stickortwister · 04/01/2023 06:20

I agree with you.

Ive become very burnt out this winter.

I think people are getting what the voted for.... however this probably all started under labour ( blair and pfi anyone) so not sure the alternative is any better.

Ah that's ok then 🙄
@FangedFrisbee I loved theatres, really good team effort and you can actually care for your patients ! Good luck !

maeveiscurious · 04/01/2023 08:35

Grumpybutfunny · 04/01/2023 08:22

Ability to buy the antibiotics with the most resistance over the pharmacy counter would help. They aren't much use for serious infections but will help with milder infections and not risk us losing another antibiotic. Would also help with all the parents convinced their kid need antibiotics for a virus!!!

Social care has to change, the NHS being responsible for safe discharge has to stop. It harsh but it needs to become the families responsibility. Nightingale staffed by the army/volunteers as an immediate solution. Tho it's looking like flu has peaked so may be to late for this to work now.

Next year a plan for a separate flu A&E for the elderly so serious illness aren't missed in normal A&E. Could look at this being staffed by students and AHCPs with a set protocol in place.

Defined criteria for attending A&E so you have to answer the questions at the counter if you don't have a reason to be there your sent home by security.

MH crisis teams to be available 24/7 in major A&E with a secure place to take patients other than A&E possibly with police support.

I agree with the social card dude needs addressing. What about drink and drugs. I was in an A&E a while ago midweek in the day and 70% was drug and drink related.

They need to have a drunk|drug tank for these cases. Most of the care is watch and wait so this doesn't need to be in A&E

Changes17 · 04/01/2023 08:35

KangarooKenny · 04/01/2023 07:43

The was a statement sent out showing that those children who’d had the nasal flu spray were less at risk of strep A. This was from info during the nasal flu pilot, yet take up was down again.

My dc’s class was due to have their flu vaccine at school in December - but it didn’t happen and has been rearranged for February. I imagine it was down to staff shortages

Stickortwister · 04/01/2023 08:35

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/01/2023 08:28

Paying back PFI is about 2% of the NHS budget per year. And we did get something for that money - new hospitals after many years of Tory neglect during the 1980s and early 90s.

I'm no fan of PFI, but I think it's a bit of a stretch to blame it for all the NHS's financial troubles.

My point is that the stripping of assets and a few people making ££££ from the nhs started under labour. The nhs is, and continues to be run and funded with shorttermism in mind. Private car parks and getting patients to pay for their own parking , the purchaser/provider split, the privitisation of various " easy " parts. All this is making a lot of money for a small amount of people ( and its not the clinicians actually doing the work!)

sheepisheep · 04/01/2023 08:34

DolphinWars · 04/01/2023 08:18

I’m not arguing, as I don’t know enough about the situation, but surely the long term restricting of trainee drs has directly led to there not being enough staff to keep training them, and long term the only way to fix the shortage of hospital drs and GPs (as I understand there is a shortage) is to recruit and train more, somehow.

I’m certain there is very little can be done to improve things without a huge overhaul, but surely part of that must be increasing numbers of staff to a workable level?

In the meantime the government should be doing something to alleviate the immediate pressure on the health service.

The only reason med school places have been restricted is because there have been no plans to increase foundation programme positions, and its entirely unfair to put students through 5 years of med school without them ever being able to work as a doctor at the end of it.

olympicsrock · 04/01/2023 08:34

One of the first things they should do is to revise doctors pensions. Many senior consultants from 50 are unable to offer extra sessions because it actually costs them to do extra work.
They are retiring early for the same reason. It’s a big problem in my team of consultants as if one of us is sick then others are reluctant to cover as no incentive to do a locum.
The younger colleagues often cannot do more due to family needs with young children.

So who does the extra work?? Mr/ Miss Nobody

Snowmoab · 04/01/2023 08:34

Lalliella · 04/01/2023 08:32

Anyone who voted for the Tories and/or Brexit - this is your fault. Don’t vote Tory ever again.

Or people can discuss the numerous issues which are more likely to bring change? Whilst people seem to fully lay blame with the tories nothing will change.

Lalliella · 04/01/2023 08:32

Anyone who voted for the Tories and/or Brexit - this is your fault. Don’t vote Tory ever again.

Toddlerteaplease · 04/01/2023 08:30

I qualified in 2004 as a paediatric nurse and is also the worst I've ever seen. We had a nice shift last night. And we commenting on how nice it was to actually have three nurses on. This should be our norm, not an occasional thing. I really had to hit me tongue when a Facebook friend was apoplectic because her sons ophthalmology appointment was running 20 minutes behind schedule. I really want to tell her to go and look in A&E.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/01/2023 08:28

Stickortwister · 04/01/2023 06:20

I agree with you.

Ive become very burnt out this winter.

I think people are getting what the voted for.... however this probably all started under labour ( blair and pfi anyone) so not sure the alternative is any better.

Paying back PFI is about 2% of the NHS budget per year. And we did get something for that money - new hospitals after many years of Tory neglect during the 1980s and early 90s.

I'm no fan of PFI, but I think it's a bit of a stretch to blame it for all the NHS's financial troubles.

cptartapp · 04/01/2023 08:28

Grumpybutfunny · 04/01/2023 08:22

Ability to buy the antibiotics with the most resistance over the pharmacy counter would help. They aren't much use for serious infections but will help with milder infections and not risk us losing another antibiotic. Would also help with all the parents convinced their kid need antibiotics for a virus!!!

Social care has to change, the NHS being responsible for safe discharge has to stop. It harsh but it needs to become the families responsibility. Nightingale staffed by the army/volunteers as an immediate solution. Tho it's looking like flu has peaked so may be to late for this to work now.

Next year a plan for a separate flu A&E for the elderly so serious illness aren't missed in normal A&E. Could look at this being staffed by students and AHCPs with a set protocol in place.

Defined criteria for attending A&E so you have to answer the questions at the counter if you don't have a reason to be there your sent home by security.

MH crisis teams to be available 24/7 in major A&E with a secure place to take patients other than A&E possibly with police support.

Social care is the responsibility of the individual, not to be lumped on the family.
As functioning adults we should all think seriously and realistically about how we will cope as we age. Is our house suitable? What adaptations do we need? What caring services can I utilise? Is where I am living accessible? Do I need to downsize? Etc etc etc. This would go a long way to minimising the current situation of hundreds of thousands of elderly people in A&E and hospital beds due to falls and poor self care.

DolphinWars · 04/01/2023 08:26

“Ability to buy the antibiotics with the most resistance over the pharmacy counter would help. They aren't much use for serious infections but will help with milder infections and not risk us losing another antibiotic. Would also help with all the parents convinced their kid need antibiotics for a virus!!!”

With the overuse of antibiotics leading to resistant strains of bacteria I imagine this would be a potential nightmare.
I wonder though if it would work if pharmacists or GP surgery based nurses could perform swab tests and prescribe appropriately which would take a huge load off GPs.

sheepisheep · 04/01/2023 08:26

MissyB1 · 04/01/2023 08:07

@sheepisheep
tye vast majority of consultants are nearing retirement age, who is going to replace them? Particularly as a lot of junior Drs are emigrating?
I do understand the pressures of supervising juniors and having quality training places, but workforce planning has to include training enough staff. It’s only part of the picture yes, because keeping the staff they train also has to be addressed.

I think you've missed the point. I was saying the merely increasing medical school places is not the answer. There needs to be proper workforce planning with decent supervision and pay, and care for junior's wellbeing. If conditions were better people would be less likely to emigrate or leave medicine entirely. Increasing med school places does not solve the problem, it creates a lot of challenges in training and supervising and also conversely risks a worsening of work conditions and pay, potentially increasing the fallout rate in line with recruitment. How does that help anyone? It just wastes money on training.

Snowmoab · 04/01/2023 08:24

Evergreen82738 · 04/01/2023 06:49

This is what happens when people can't get to see their GP. A&E gets clogged up with people who aren't emergencies but still need treatment. This has got progressively worse since 2020 lockdown. People need to be able to access and see a GP!

There is a shortage of GPs, perhaps if the government bothered to address this when it was clear it was going to a problem we'd be in a better position. As they didn't (quelle surprise) the system is fucked. Staff are the most important asset in healthcare, when the government and a portion of the population treat them with contempt and don't deem them worthy of fair pay of course this happens.

olympicsrock · 04/01/2023 08:23

Beautifulsunflowers · 04/01/2023 07:57

The whole system needs a major overhaul - GP Surgery’s should work 7 days a week - we live in a society that’s open 24/7 and our gp surgery’s are operating on a 30 year old model.
our social care system is broken too - no more places in care homes and no carers to accommodate those who need at home care. People are waiting in hospital medically fit waiting for something to come up.
Op you are right - the general public have no idea - and it’s being kept out of the media too. only the good things are reported on.

For those of us sitting in our cars not wanting to go in to work today (me) have a hand hold. I’m with you and I hear you.

Why on earth would any GP want to work weekends routinely?
Where are you going to get the doctors to staff a 7 day service?
Are you going to pay doctors more to work more antisocial hours and miss family time?

If my children got A grades at A level I would not suggest medicine as an attractive career option.

GPs are not supposed to be emergency care providers… they are about managing chronic conditions .

Merrymouse · 04/01/2023 08:23

Currently the Tories are just providing the worst of both worlds. They don’t believe in the NHS, so have little interest in its improvement, but also know the NHS is popular with voters so don’t seriously suggest anything else.

Grumpybutfunny · 04/01/2023 08:22

Ability to buy the antibiotics with the most resistance over the pharmacy counter would help. They aren't much use for serious infections but will help with milder infections and not risk us losing another antibiotic. Would also help with all the parents convinced their kid need antibiotics for a virus!!!

Social care has to change, the NHS being responsible for safe discharge has to stop. It harsh but it needs to become the families responsibility. Nightingale staffed by the army/volunteers as an immediate solution. Tho it's looking like flu has peaked so may be to late for this to work now.

Next year a plan for a separate flu A&E for the elderly so serious illness aren't missed in normal A&E. Could look at this being staffed by students and AHCPs with a set protocol in place.

Defined criteria for attending A&E so you have to answer the questions at the counter if you don't have a reason to be there your sent home by security.

MH crisis teams to be available 24/7 in major A&E with a secure place to take patients other than A&E possibly with police support.

DolphinWars · 04/01/2023 08:20

The Twitter thread I read also pointed out that moving to a truly 24/7 NHS, including GP surgeries, would mean a 40% increase of staff, so not something that can be fixed quickly and easily, as there aren’t the numbers of trained staff ready to take on these roles.

DolphinWars · 04/01/2023 08:18

sheepisheep · 04/01/2023 08:04

Ok let's say there's no restrictions on how many medical school places universities can offer. Then what? Do you realise its not possible to practice medicine independently in the UK with just a medical degree? You need at least a year of supervised practice. And that needs to be cover general medicine and general surgery. Where are we going to fit them in? How do you propose we fund them? Who is going to supervise the extra newly qualified doctors? How much are you going to pay for the supervision and where is that money coming from?

So tired of people making sweeping statements without understanding anything about medical training or workforce planning.

I’m not arguing, as I don’t know enough about the situation, but surely the long term restricting of trainee drs has directly led to there not being enough staff to keep training them, and long term the only way to fix the shortage of hospital drs and GPs (as I understand there is a shortage) is to recruit and train more, somehow.

I’m certain there is very little can be done to improve things without a huge overhaul, but surely part of that must be increasing numbers of staff to a workable level?

In the meantime the government should be doing something to alleviate the immediate pressure on the health service.

sheepisheep · 04/01/2023 08:17

Beautifulsunflowers · 04/01/2023 07:57

The whole system needs a major overhaul - GP Surgery’s should work 7 days a week - we live in a society that’s open 24/7 and our gp surgery’s are operating on a 30 year old model.
our social care system is broken too - no more places in care homes and no carers to accommodate those who need at home care. People are waiting in hospital medically fit waiting for something to come up.
Op you are right - the general public have no idea - and it’s being kept out of the media too. only the good things are reported on.

For those of us sitting in our cars not wanting to go in to work today (me) have a hand hold. I’m with you and I hear you.

Cool cool. Who's going to pay for the additional hours for gps to work 7 days? Are you going to restrict weekday appointments to create more at the weekend? Where are you going to get the staff from, given the current retention and recruitment crisis in gp?

BellaCiao1 · 04/01/2023 08:17

chopc · 04/01/2023 08:09

How will getting the tories out fix the NHS? What are labours plans?

The tories are actually right and we need a semi private system. Do you know any other country with a fully free national health service?

We pay for it with taxes though, should the system change to become semi private why should the taxation remain the same?

What treatments should go under private and what should be through NHS?

I also have went private recently for one of my children for a health issue in the hope it would be dealt with quicker. The initial assessment required for it could only he completed in the NHS so as it stands there are many things private can't even offer.

BestKnitterInScotland · 04/01/2023 08:17

This idea that simply voting in another government who will throw loads of money at the NHS and wave a magic wand to make everything better is just so simplistic. And wrong.

No the NHS is not fit for purpose. It cannot carry on the way it has in the past.

The same sort of people who think it's all the Tories fault are the same people who start on about the American model as if it's a binary choice between the two ideas. Impossible to have a reasoned debate about the way forward with this sort of nonsense floating about, and the idea of the NHS as a sacred cow which shall not ever be criticised. Or that everyone working for the NHS is a selfless angel.

anyolddinosaur · 04/01/2023 08:16

If training places in a&e were increased then junior doctors who currently locum would be working in a&e for less money than they get as locums. They work as locums because they get better pay and can choose to work less or get work the same and get a house deposit together. Pay matters.
More doctors wouldnt help the bed blocking issues but more nurses might mean community hospitals could be reopened and some people shifted there.

Covid means we need more health staff long term, so more training places.
In the short term we need to hang on to every one we have, that means better pay. The government need to come clean and say we have to tax more to pay for it or this is what you get.

There is no easy solution. I didnt vote tory, am fully vaccinated, still wear a mask in crowded spaces so I havent had covid or flu, havent been near a gp in years. My conscience is clear -how many people complaining now can say the same?