Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Divorce settlement and DD

161 replies

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 01:07

I’ve name changed as probably outing, I’m a long term user of Mumsnet.

Exh and I divorced 3 years ago. I offered to take a reduced settlement to avoid going to court. Ex and his solicitor insisted on the court route as they didn’t think the outcome would be a 50/50 split.

50/50 split was the outcome. House to be sold when DD is out of full time education at age 18.

So this time is fast approaching, she finishes college this summer.

DD is aware of the ruling, but not of all of the details.

It has clearly been playing in her mind. Her father has not sat her down and talked sensibly to her. He is pension age, has a decent civil service pension so income wise he is comfortable.
Nor has he started to look into what he can do accommodation wise. Realistically he would either buy a two bed terraced, or rent.

I have another 15-20 years to work, have a house with a mortgage. Ex resides in marital home, which is mortgage free.

DD has rung me tonight in hysterics. Saying it’s my fault that she will be homeless (!) as she will not live with me if her father cannot afford to buy a house big enough for the both of them. I am in no doubt that this will damage our relationship, which is absolute priority to me.

When I bought this house, I was self employed and my loan to value ratio was low. A family member offered to loan me a deposit which I accepted, with the plan that I will repay them when I have my settlement.

Last year, exh looked into equity release, and whilst this won’t be the full settlement, I am now considering accepting this in order to protect my relationship with DD.
I can use this plus a loan to repay family member the deposit.

I don’t know enough about equity release, what would happen when exh dies, would the house have to be sold then to repay the equity company?

Sorry this is long, any advice much appreciated.

OP posts:
Aroundthetwist · 04/01/2023 10:01

Equity release is a terrible idea, it would basically mean your EXH is giving DDs inheritance to a finance company just so he can stay in the house.

That said, I guess as long as you definitely get your half, that is his selfish decision to make. I agree that if DD wants to be more invested, she could take out a mortgage for your half if she has an apprenticeship or similar. And later she would perhaps inherit the other half from her dad.

I did draw a diagram, as it’s a slow work day……

Divorce settlement and DD
GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/01/2023 09:58

To those saying the DD is being a selfish teenager etc. Divorce is hard enough for younger DC but teenagers especially involved in divorces are hit emotionally very hard.

We don’t know if she’s studying etc. It also sounds like the exDH is doing a great job of then at time of the divorce and now, emotionally blackmailing and poisoning his DD against her DM.

TheTeenageYears · 04/01/2023 09:53

I have a very limited knowledge of equity release but do personally know of someone who's family member took equity of c.50k which no one knew about until the relatives death. The amount owning was something like 750k (about 20-25 years later).

Dacquoise · 04/01/2023 09:53

Also @Rookriver , suggestion. Many ways to divide a cake and all that.

diddl · 04/01/2023 09:53

If he could buy a 2 bed terrace then that's enough isn't it?

he is not your problem and nor should you take on his financial woes

I agree with that.

I wouldn't be taking out a loan to repay a loan if I was due the cash that would pay it off!

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/01/2023 09:52

I actually feel quite sorry for your DD who’s been poisoned and manipulated by your ex-DH.

I worked for a divorce lawyer with a similar case and age DC where the ex-DH was having to buy a smaller house and for I think study reasons his DC were living in the marital home. All got very murky and complex.

Do not touch equity release at all but continue to emotionally support your DD. Your exDH will be fine, he has financial options but he’s being very unfair dragging your DD into this and emotionally manipulating her.

Dacquoise · 04/01/2023 09:52

Playing devil's advocate here, do you know how much he would be able to raise with equity release on the house? Your aim here is to get as close as possible to your £80k share minus selling fees. Whilst I wouldn't advise you to do equity release for yourself, the consequences of this would be on your exH, not you. Is there negotiation room regarding him handing over savings to top up what you need to be free of him? Not to cave in to his manipulation but to get out of this as cleanly as possible. Selling up won't be a bed of roses either. You could also appear reasonable to your daughter who is probably attached to the family home.

It's not uncommon for older people to not want to move house, that's what happened with my step father when my mother divorced him. Big age gap too He wanted to stay in the house, not a flat and ended up handing over the whole house to her in return for lifetime interest in the house, against the advice of both solicitors. She's effectively now his landlord and they have all sorts of issues with the arrangement. This is why clean break settlements are better.

Quitelikeit · 04/01/2023 09:49

Op

follow the court order. This is a greedy manipulative approach that he is taking.

he is not your problem and nor should you take on his financial woes

you need to sit down with your daughter and give her a few home truths especially about pensions and how his was left alone and that he probably got a lump sum a few years ago.

Rookriver · 04/01/2023 09:48

Not sure if anyone else has mentioned this, but some mortgage companies will accept a civil service defined benefit pension as income. It's more guaranteed than an actual job! So he may be able to get a mortgage.

paintitallover · 04/01/2023 09:47

I agree with this-

Give her a factual account of the divorce arrangements as you have here and then step back. If there is an impact on your relationship it will be temporary.

Chimna · 04/01/2023 09:43

Sounds like she's at the selfish teenager stage, so I would explain the situation to her as if she is you.

'Imagine you bought a house with a man, contributed this amount, paid this amount monthly towards the house. Then was so kind as to leave until your child turned 18, meanwhile you DD have to pay your own mortgage. Would you give it all up or would you want what you are entitled to?' If it still doesn't sit with her tell her to get a job to pay towards his living costs as it's not your job anymore. She'll come around as she gets older and understands the world more.

ThanksItHasPockets · 04/01/2023 09:40

I suspect your ex knows that your relationship with your daughter is a source of anxiety for you and he feels confident you would fold if you thought it would keep her on side. This is why he is using her to manipulate you now. You must not capitulate. If you do, it will only protect your relationship until the next time 'poor Dad' uses her for his next financial wishlist. Don't negotiate with terrorists.

Give her a factual account of the divorce arrangements as you have here and then step back. If there is an impact on your relationship it will be temporary.

fruitbrewhaha · 04/01/2023 09:37

Don't take less than your 50%. You are already at a disadvantage that the house may have now gone down in value below where it was 3 years ago. I assume he has until June/July. In the summer you either need to sell or he buys you out of your half.

Perhaps you could suggest to DD that she get a job and and then her and her father get a mortgage between them to raise the 50% to buy you out. If she was to earn £20k a year she may get a mortgage of £60k and then your ex has to find £20k, or perhaps under those circumstances you'd be willing to accept £10k less upfront as long as she gave you an extra £200 a month / or £1000 a year for the next 10 years. She would then of course have to stay living with her father for the next 25 years. Would that work for her? Or would she rather be independent?

Iwouldliketogovegan · 04/01/2023 09:35

Completely agree with all the advice here OP- your ex will absolutely have had a lump sum with his pension so may well be sitting on a nice little nest egg he doesn't want to share. I understand that DD wants to continue to live in her childhood home, and 18 is still an age of raging emotions, but the failure to plan for that to happen is your ex not yours. Seems like your ex is still trying to create a low settlement for you as well as poisoning your relationship- thank goodness you got out !

Blossomtoes · 04/01/2023 09:31

Lalliella · 04/01/2023 08:43

Presumably he needs to give you half of the value of the house at the date of your DD’s birthday? So as long as he does this, does it matter how he gets the money? You need to ensure you no longer own half the house though, as you could be liable for negative equity in the future. So he needs to borrow the money somehow and pay you your half, then he’s bought you out and it needs to be his name solely on the deeds.

This. It’s his business how he raises the money. As long as you get the amount decreed by the court order it doesn’t matter how he gets it.

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 04/01/2023 09:29

I’m no expert on divorce but whatever you do, don’t consent to equity release. The only winners are the equity release companies.

My MIL did equity release 10 years before she died and released about £20k from a £140k property. When she died she owed more than double this - and the house was worth less. DH was very lucky to receive any inheritance at all - which was by no means something he felt entitled to but MIL was very keen to leave the property to him and I think would have been quite shocked at how little was left after the equity release.

Under the circumstances, she would have been much better off downsizing and buying a retirement flat or other suitable property.

Bookworm20 · 04/01/2023 09:25

So house is 160k, I'll assume its at least a 2 bed, so he would likely get another 2 bed for a very similar amount, possibly lower amount for a smaller place. So lets say he could get something for 140k, is that realisitic?
He has 80k to put down once house is sold, so thats a hefty deposit. If he has a good pension, usually you can draw lump sums from those, so that could be an option for him to add further cash towards the house purchase. And not sure if he would get any type of mortgage at all, but he may be able to get a 7 year mortgage to top up the rest.

Or, he sells the house and rents something until he figures out his best position buying wise, or until something affordable comes on the market - such as a 1 bed (or very small 2 bed) when dd moves out - which may be as soon as 3-4 years time depending on her circumstances.

Or he rents for 3-4 years and if dd goes down the employment route as opposed to uni, she could take a small mortgage using his 80k deposit to purchase something, as assuming on his death she will inherit the house anyway.

But end of the day, she won't be homeless and neither will he. She can stay with you and he can rent.

MiddleOfTheNightAgain · 04/01/2023 09:23

Stop being manipulated. Sell the house. He will manage and she will adapt.

Newmum0322 · 04/01/2023 09:20

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 04/01/2023 06:41

I understood what OP meant. Rather than ex sell the house and split equity with her, he'll stay in the house and use equity release funds to pay her a reduced settlement. She'll then make up the shortfall in what she owes family member with a loan.

Yup. This was my understanding too. Didn’t require 30 years in financial services to figure it out IMO

LinesAndDot · 04/01/2023 09:20

My advice:

  1. Take a deep breath. Your DD has obviously only just heard the full details and is reacting emotionally. Give her a few days to process and let the emotions settle before you attempt to speak with her. You have more chance of what you say being heard.
  2. Absolutely no to the equity release. Don’t you make a knee-jerk emotional decision now that will leave you far poorer.
  3. Depending on how your daughter is when she calms down (she might see this more fairly, she might be a bit excited for her own independence, or she still might still blame you), it sounds as though you will have to speak with het about the settlement. Don’t go into too much detail as to contributions etc - it gives her a chance to find points to argue back or makes her think she has a say in it. The points to drive home are that an extremely experienced Judge looked at all the material and made this decision, which is fair at law. She may think after hearing her father’s side that it isn’t fair. However, she has to accept that an experience Judge who knows more about the law than her decided this. Secondly, it wasn’t appealed. Therefore both parties - you and your ex - agreed (on some level) that the result was fair and they weren’t going to challenge it further. This means she has to accept two things - that this result IS fair, even if she doesn’t think so, and secondly that if someone is telling her it isn’t, then that person is trying to emotionally manipulate her. If you’ve never discussed this before, you might use an example from her own life where she is in your shoes as to the emotional manipulation.

If she is ready to hear it, you may then say, what does the person asking you to believe this have to gain from this situation vs the loser, and see if she can point to the fact that your ex will continue to live rent-free in the bigger house. Vs you have had to do what ex now does, it’s just you had to do it 3 years earlier.

Baby steps. Remember this means she is losing her home, and I am sure in an unstable divorce having the same bedroom/house did alot to help steady her. Hopefully you can also help her see that her room at your place is now equally
a home and/or that at 18, and exciting adventure awaits for her in new places and she can jump off out of both homes and into an exciting life of her own.

Bunce1 · 04/01/2023 09:19

Equity release is a terrible idea.

Rainbowsparkles29 · 04/01/2023 09:18

Your dd needs to wind her neck in. Lay the facts bare for her and make it clear that you're no longer financially resppnsible for her dad and that it's his responsibility to find a home for himself and if he wants dd to live there her too. Make it clear thay you're having this conversation once then it's none of her business. Maybe also make clear that she'll be an adult soon and as such neither you or her dad are obliged to provide her with a home and you're definitely not obliged to provide her with the home that she demands. Politely tell her to grow up. She will do just that one day and apologise for how she's talked to you but she probably won't do this if you pander to her. She's nearly an adult. Time to look after yourself. Don't give up a penny for her or dad's benefit. Neither will thank you for it

Ukholidaysaregreat · 04/01/2023 09:07

Hi OP I think you are getting some really sensible advice and answers on this thread. I wonder if it would be worth showing DD to read with out you so she has time to process your side of the story? I'm sure discussions with her around this are heightened emotionally as you are both invested in this situation and family. Sounds like your Ex has been drip feeding his own point of view to your DD for a long time. Good Luck with this situation.

diddl · 04/01/2023 09:07

she will not live with me if her father cannot afford to buy a house big enough for the both of them.

That is her choice.

If your ex is in a mortgage free house surely that is down to you?

Don't let that be for nothing!

So I'm thinking that you left & set up own your own & your daughter hasn't forgiven you?

If that's right & that's her stance then just giving in to her probably won't change that-she'll just take as she thinks she's entitled to it.

ReneBumsWombats · 04/01/2023 09:06

Don't ever do equity release. It's a terrible idea, should only be done as an absolute last resort and even then, if it really, truly is your best option, a lot of things have gone wrong already.

Ask your daughter to sit down with you so you can explain properly what the financial situation is and why this isn't an option. I think a lot of people really overestimate an 18 year oldest ability to understand this sort of thing by osmosis. Try not to be patronising or talk down to her...address her as an equal as you do it and don't shut her down with "now I've had my say, I don't want to talk about it any more". And don't bad mouth her dad, twat as he is.

She'll need some time to absorb it but this behaviour probably comes from feeling disregarded, so make sure she feels heard and respected. But don't agree to his godawful demand. It's ruinous.

And yes...why wouldn't there be room for her with him in a two-bedroom house?

Swipe left for the next trending thread