Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Divorce settlement and DD

161 replies

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 01:07

I’ve name changed as probably outing, I’m a long term user of Mumsnet.

Exh and I divorced 3 years ago. I offered to take a reduced settlement to avoid going to court. Ex and his solicitor insisted on the court route as they didn’t think the outcome would be a 50/50 split.

50/50 split was the outcome. House to be sold when DD is out of full time education at age 18.

So this time is fast approaching, she finishes college this summer.

DD is aware of the ruling, but not of all of the details.

It has clearly been playing in her mind. Her father has not sat her down and talked sensibly to her. He is pension age, has a decent civil service pension so income wise he is comfortable.
Nor has he started to look into what he can do accommodation wise. Realistically he would either buy a two bed terraced, or rent.

I have another 15-20 years to work, have a house with a mortgage. Ex resides in marital home, which is mortgage free.

DD has rung me tonight in hysterics. Saying it’s my fault that she will be homeless (!) as she will not live with me if her father cannot afford to buy a house big enough for the both of them. I am in no doubt that this will damage our relationship, which is absolute priority to me.

When I bought this house, I was self employed and my loan to value ratio was low. A family member offered to loan me a deposit which I accepted, with the plan that I will repay them when I have my settlement.

Last year, exh looked into equity release, and whilst this won’t be the full settlement, I am now considering accepting this in order to protect my relationship with DD.
I can use this plus a loan to repay family member the deposit.

I don’t know enough about equity release, what would happen when exh dies, would the house have to be sold then to repay the equity company?

Sorry this is long, any advice much appreciated.

OP posts:
titchy · 04/01/2023 11:07

Could you point out to her that his plan means she won't inherit a penny from him, whereas you have prioritised having a property to leave when the time comes.

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/01/2023 10:59

Livetoplay · 04/01/2023 10:31

I’m going to go against the grain and say that if I was financial comfortable I wouldn’t want to see my ex struggle or lose a house he wanted to stay in if there was an alternative.
can you sit down and talk to him realistically about this?
if he can’t afford to buy a place with what’s left and he’s pension then it may be worth finding a compromise. I can see why your DD is upset.

How much can he afford to give you if the house isn’t sold? Do you need that money right away or can you put an agreement into place that he stays, you both own it and on his death his half goes to DD?

How much would Equity release give you - presuming his does it and you take that ££ with no other claim in the house?

I wouldn’t lose my DD for the sake of £80k that I didn’t really need - look at it from her POV, her DDad - elderly and retired- is about to lose his home.

Op is not in a comfortable position though. She has to service her mortgage and has promised to return the money she was loaned for the deposit on her property once the joint marital home is sold. Her dd is 18 and her creditors rightly should expect their money back.

ILoveMyBedTooMuch · 04/01/2023 10:59

Getoff · 04/01/2023 10:43

My first though on the OP, which wasn't helpful in any way, is how can a 50:50 settlement of actual assets be fair, when there's a 20 year discrepancy in human capital. 50:50 means the OP will spend the bulk of her life with far more assets than he will have for the remainder of his. Unless she was a much higher earner, or contributed more to the marriage, I don't see how that is fair.

Now that I know the amount of assets in question is so small, I'm far less bothered though. The amount of assets could well be outweighed by other financial considerations.

I'm guessing she didn't take any part of his pension.

mellicauli · 04/01/2023 10:47

If the judge thought it was the fairest outcome, it probably is.

Do not accept a lower settlement: your daughter will not be homeless. She is 18 years old and doesn't understand how these things work. You really need to secure your own future rather than pandering to her emotional manipulation.

Do not get involved with equity release - it is a complete rip off and not in your interests.

Also sure that when you get your settlement that the loan which is owed on it is not part of the 50%. SO if it is a 200k house and the loan is 20k, the loan should be paid off (180k) then split between the 2 of you (90 each). You both owe that money, not just you. The equity and the debt needs to be split between the two of you.

StripeyDeckchair · 04/01/2023 10:45

You stick to what the court ordered - how your Ex decides to action this is up to him and not your issue.

Your daughter needs to grow up a bit and see that this is the outcome of divorce & reflects the input into the marriage by both parties. The court was impartial & unbiased in making the ruling.

Do not let your Ex manipulate your daughter so you suffer financially

Getoff · 04/01/2023 10:43

My first though on the OP, which wasn't helpful in any way, is how can a 50:50 settlement of actual assets be fair, when there's a 20 year discrepancy in human capital. 50:50 means the OP will spend the bulk of her life with far more assets than he will have for the remainder of his. Unless she was a much higher earner, or contributed more to the marriage, I don't see how that is fair.

Now that I know the amount of assets in question is so small, I'm far less bothered though. The amount of assets could well be outweighed by other financial considerations.

purpledalmation · 04/01/2023 10:40

I would definitely not go down the equity release side of things as it would probably decrease your ultimate share. Speak to a solicitor if you are looking at this to protect your asset. Could you defer the sale of the family home until DD is 21? Or even until she leaves home?

Livetoplay · 04/01/2023 10:36

He’s going to struggle to get a mortgage at the age of 70

Puckthemagicdragon · 04/01/2023 10:36

Equity release - avoid avoid avoid. The interest eats away the value of the house so eventually you're left with nothing. Or to put it another way, your daughter will have no inheritance

Theunamedcat · 04/01/2023 10:36

I wouldn't sit down and be reasonable with someone who tried to turn my children against me

Stick to the court order your hands are tied

Getoff · 04/01/2023 10:33

If he has a good pension, surely he could afford to pay interest on an 80K interest-only mortgage? That would probably be a small monthly outgoing?

I don't know if he could get such a mortgage at a good interest rate, but I feel it ought not to be a problem. Technically this would probably be categorised as equity release, but it's not a bad option in the way that traditional equity release usually is.

In the last thread on equity release, there were people arguing that equity release nowadays is a completely different thing than it used to be, it's just a loan, and the interest rates aren't necessarily bad. I haven't looked into it, so I don't know if that's true.

Livetoplay · 04/01/2023 10:31

I’m going to go against the grain and say that if I was financial comfortable I wouldn’t want to see my ex struggle or lose a house he wanted to stay in if there was an alternative.
can you sit down and talk to him realistically about this?
if he can’t afford to buy a place with what’s left and he’s pension then it may be worth finding a compromise. I can see why your DD is upset.

How much can he afford to give you if the house isn’t sold? Do you need that money right away or can you put an agreement into place that he stays, you both own it and on his death his half goes to DD?

How much would Equity release give you - presuming his does it and you take that ££ with no other claim in the house?

I wouldn’t lose my DD for the sake of £80k that I didn’t really need - look at it from her POV, her DDad - elderly and retired- is about to lose his home.

BakersYeast · 04/01/2023 10:28

It doesn't matter what he wants - a court made a ruling. End of.

Did you get half of his pension as well as half of the house? I hope so.

As regards equity release he will get a small amount and there will be no house at the end of it after all the interest is paid - no inheritance for your daughter. Explain that to her if you think she needs to be involved in it.

Heronwatcher · 04/01/2023 10:28

Yeah good advice here. Do not countenance equity release. Support your daughter but be clear that the court has made its decision plus half that house was always yours, plus he will have enough money to buy somewhere big enough for them both if he actually gets off his arse and starts doing something about it. Don’t be manipulated or drawn in to the hysterics.

Ariela · 04/01/2023 10:27

Firstly she needs to be made aware of what you offered and what the court ordered, it's not fair on you otherwise that she isn't being told the facts.

Is your DD going to Uni or going to work?
If she's going to Uni can you vary the agreement by 3 years so the house is still there for her till she is working.
Then can she buy her Dad's half (with you still owning your half) by raising her own mortgage? And her Dad paying you off with the amount raised by her mortgage. Obviously wills need to be in place etc
Would need to speak to a financial adviser to see if this is possible.

Testina · 04/01/2023 10:25

I completely disagree with all the people saying to stay away from equity release.

Because… it’s not your problem!!!

So what if it’s a bad deal? It’s his bad deal, not yours 🤷🏻‍♀️

The only thing I’d advise against is accepting less than your £80K if that’s the full release amount.

You are owed your £80K, the court decided that was fair, he’s had 3 years to decide how to manage it. If he raises the money in a way that’s a poor financial decision for him, that’s his lookout. People have a knee jerk against equity release, and I’m not a fan either, but he’s not always a bad decision. If you’re clear what the costs are, you can decide (he can decide) that it’s worth it. For some people, keeping the house is a valid pay off. A lot of the equity release horror stories are people who didn’t realise what they were doing. But none of that is your problem.

It might reduce inheritance for your daughter - but so might care home fees, you can’t worry about that 🤷🏻‍♀️

I would tell her: this is the court judgement, known about for 3 years, and you need to repay your loan so you don’t have a choice.

Don’t get into renting to him - he won’t pay, and you can’t evict him from your half of the house, all the while with your daughter in your ear about making him homeless…

Keep in my mind that he can’t just go to an equity release firm and do that easily - because you will have a charge on the house from the divorce. There’d have to be a sequence of steps (managed by a conveyancing solicitor) to remove your interest in the property.

I think to avoid court, it is worth accepting less. But I’m saying if you’re owed £80K you might take £70K. Not £40K!

Your relationship with your daughter: haterz gonna hate. Whatever way you do it, she’ll side with him for now. Be a broken record: this was agreed 3 years ago so you didn’t have to move until you were an adult. Go talk to your dad.

ReneBumsWombats · 04/01/2023 10:23

Ask her how she feels about him being so cavalier about her future.

No, don't. Do not pit her against her father. Just explain, factually, why this would be financially ruinous.

Xenia · 04/01/2023 10:22

He needs to consider things like the following to live in the house forever with his daughter:

  1. Can he get a mortgage (even based on his pension income) to buy out your half share?
  2. Can he cash in his pension? I cashed all mine in aged 55 before they started paying out to help the older children with housing (HMRC took 45% of 25% o f it too - lucky Big State) and I will work until I die.
  3. Can he get a job which could be used for a mortgage to buy out your half?
  4. Then there is equity release which tends not to be a great option but is possible.
jtaeapa · 04/01/2023 10:16

She needs to understand that he wanted a court order, a court order was obtained and now it will be carried out. My dad shafted my mum in a divorce "deal" like this. My mum consented because she wanted to be free and thought that ultimately he would leave his estate to us kids. However, having got the lion's share, he's leaving it to his new wife, who will then leave it to a charity. Depriving my mum's kids (four of us) of money that my mum wanted to leave us.

Bookworm20 · 04/01/2023 10:12

I'd also explain the equity release route to your daughter, and how it would leave her with nothing from her father on his death, which I am sure he wouldn't want. As if the interest builds up to more than the house is worth, I think they take out the shortfall from any other elements of the estate - which would be his pension I imagine. (I'm not 100% on this though, just what I have heard)

Katapolts · 04/01/2023 10:11

I think you just have to reiterate to her that dad went to court and this is what the judge decided is fair for everyone.
Dad is financially ok.
You have a loan you need to pay back with your share.
She will always have a home with you and/or her dad, but she is an adult now and will soon want to go to university, travel, move in with friends etc - she needs to look forward to her life and not worry about her parents who are both doing fine.

heathspeedwell · 04/01/2023 10:09

It's clear that he is manipulating your daughter.

Equity release might make life a bit easier for him, but you would lose out significantly, and so would your daughter. It would remove all her potential inheritance from him.

As a previous poster mentioned, teenagers are often selfish. Perhaps you could explain to her that although equity release might seem easier in the short term,
it is only in her father's benefit but definitely not hers.

He is already 70 and most parents his age are starting to consider what inheritance they can leave to their children. In contrast he wants to choose equity release which would leave her with nothing, instead of a life-changing lump sum.

Ask her how she feels about him being so cavalier about her future.

Undertheoldlindentree · 04/01/2023 10:04

There are no guarantees, but as your ex is so much older, leaving your portion of the settlement tied up in the ex-marital home will possibly see it eaten up in equity release or future care costs. If your portion of the funds is in your home instead, DD is more likely to inherit long-term from one or the other of you, as the risk is split (unless both need care later of course). Or could you use the settlement from you rmarotal house sale to pay off your family loan now, but look at downsizing in a few years to release funds for a house deposit for DD. All gives you more flexibility and choice to support DD in the future.

Has your ex looked at housing for the over 50's? I often see less expensive 2 bedroom properties and flats on age-restricted developments. Fairly basic, not sheltered etc, but seem good value compared to the open market in some areas. Maybe shared ownership is an option for him as well?

Agree present to DD as this is the court decision and not her worry. I've seen teens in this position under a lot of pressure, with negative mental health and significant self-harm, all due to worry about reaching 18. It's a really negative aspect of these agreements. Keep being calm and firm that it is not her worry and she is to look forward to being 18 and all the freedom that it brings.

Itisbetter · 04/01/2023 10:03

Sell, repay debt to family member, when she wants to buy give dd a leg up if you want to. Any other option is you buying a relationship with your child.

Dacquoise · 04/01/2023 10:02

I am assuming you are tenants in common in this set up , not joint tenants so equity release, if possible, on his share not yours.