Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Divorce settlement and DD

161 replies

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 01:07

I’ve name changed as probably outing, I’m a long term user of Mumsnet.

Exh and I divorced 3 years ago. I offered to take a reduced settlement to avoid going to court. Ex and his solicitor insisted on the court route as they didn’t think the outcome would be a 50/50 split.

50/50 split was the outcome. House to be sold when DD is out of full time education at age 18.

So this time is fast approaching, she finishes college this summer.

DD is aware of the ruling, but not of all of the details.

It has clearly been playing in her mind. Her father has not sat her down and talked sensibly to her. He is pension age, has a decent civil service pension so income wise he is comfortable.
Nor has he started to look into what he can do accommodation wise. Realistically he would either buy a two bed terraced, or rent.

I have another 15-20 years to work, have a house with a mortgage. Ex resides in marital home, which is mortgage free.

DD has rung me tonight in hysterics. Saying it’s my fault that she will be homeless (!) as she will not live with me if her father cannot afford to buy a house big enough for the both of them. I am in no doubt that this will damage our relationship, which is absolute priority to me.

When I bought this house, I was self employed and my loan to value ratio was low. A family member offered to loan me a deposit which I accepted, with the plan that I will repay them when I have my settlement.

Last year, exh looked into equity release, and whilst this won’t be the full settlement, I am now considering accepting this in order to protect my relationship with DD.
I can use this plus a loan to repay family member the deposit.

I don’t know enough about equity release, what would happen when exh dies, would the house have to be sold then to repay the equity company?

Sorry this is long, any advice much appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stravaig · 05/01/2023 10:19

@Newname50 It sounds like you're on the right track. She will figure it out with more life experience. Hard though it is, try to keep focus on what will be best for her and for you in the long term, instead of scrambling to preserve a sweet relationship with her in the present.

It's unfortunate that she's not moving away to study/train, as that would give her some distance from the situation in a very natural way. Given her father's age, I'd worry about him roping her in as ad hoc carer if she doesn't fledge the nest soon.

Talia99 · 05/01/2023 10:15

The thing is, the Judge didn’t say the house had to be sold, he said you had to be paid half the value when your DD turned 18. Your ex was mortgage free. He should have been saving as hard as possible to pay you out for your share if he wanted to keep living there.

There is no way you should be financially disadvantaged because he hasn’t planned.

Also, you’ve said you owe a big chunk of the equity to someone else. I don’t think you have any choice but to force a sale in the circumstances.

caringcarer · 05/01/2023 10:03

The judge made a decision based upon what was fair for both you and exh. If exh refuses to follow court order drag him back to court. Make it clear to him the house will be sold as per court order. When your dd is 18 put the house up for sale. We ith.a court order he can't stop you. You dd be will g try ow up eventually. I had a similar situation in that my exh poisoned DD against me because when exh cheated on me I refused to give him another chance. My dd was at uni through DH cheating, which she refused to believe. She was not at home to see court proceedings and sale of house. Exh fed her crap about poor Daddy on his own with nothing while I moved on quite quickly into new relationship. My dd refused to speak to me for 3 years during which time I got engaged and remarried. It was only a year later when she got engaged she contacted me as she wanted me at her wedding. She had point blank refused to attend my wedding and was rude to my new DH. I went to her wedding and she grudgingly allowed my new DH to attend with me. We have patched things up and she has given me 2 dgc now. The relationship withy DD has never gone back to how close we were before I divorced her Dad and she occasionally makes a comment about poor Dad.....is on his own......can't afford a nice house like you have etc. I try to ignore it but it is hard not to snap and say he has what he deserves.

Newname50 · 05/01/2023 09:34

@Stravaig that has been my concern for years. I always try to be the parent who provides positivity and balance.

I do need to talk with her about this, she already knows that it is ok to end relationships when they aren’t right for whatever reason.

It’s just difficult when it’s her father who is the toxic one.

OP posts:
bellabasset · 05/01/2023 09:05

I agree with others that you shouldn't agree to accept a figure lower than the court awarded amount. Your dd may not want to leave her childhood home which is understandable. So I think you need to explain the costs that you've spent on housing since your separation and that without the help of your relative you wouldn't have been able to buy a house but that your debt now needs to be repaid.

I doubt your ex will be able to release 50% equity to satisfy your share. As a child you don't think about housing and clearly your ex hasn't made any long term plans.

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/01/2023 05:57

I think you should remind your dd that you rented for some time and that yoy were only able to buy because you borrowed all of the money. Have you told her how much you owe on the mortgage and to the person you borrowed from?

I think a really frank conversation about how you bought your current house for x, you borrowed y from the bank and z from (I presume) family all whilst her father stayed in the marital home mortgage free, which was specifically done for her. You struggled. Her father did not. Now you have a debt to pay to x relative and they are expecting their money. A matter of honour and so forth.

What about going onto rightmove with your dd and showing her what he can get for 80k? You say he has savings and a decent pension, ergo he could get more. If you know how much more, also show her those houses.

Your dd is 18, I don’t see anything wrong with discussing your finances with her.

Orangepolentacake · 04/01/2023 23:49

JLoti · 04/01/2023 23:04

We all think that! I wish I had put myself first more than I did. I now have one child who lives 60 miles away who visits every 12 weeks and one who lives 30 miles away who I see once every 4/6 weeks. At least she calls though. I had good relationships with them too! Stop worrying about her. You will be the least of her worries when she finds her someone and settles down. Parents become a bind when older and you then wonder why you invested so much time in them and worried about them so much. She is being dramatic. Don’t pander too it.

so one should not be concerned about what/how their children feel in case they visit less often than once every 6 weeks when they reach adulthood?

I’d love to hear your adult children’s view on this

samqueens · 04/01/2023 23:38

Not your dad - your DD 🤦🏻‍♀️

samqueens · 04/01/2023 23:37

Also obviously you’re also completely entitled
to just explain to her that this is what court decided, even though you offered to do it differently and avoid court, and so this is what’s happening. As PP have said - don’t feel bullied into taking a worse deal.

Just thought that if there’s a gap between your entitlement and your immediate need there may be another way to go at this which gives you more security and control than the equity release, puts your dad in a better position (assuming she will inherit), but is also a win with your relationship with daughter, that’s all.

Blossomtoes · 04/01/2023 23:34

MillicentBystander2022 · 04/01/2023 23:32

I didn't think you could do equity release on mortgage free properties?

I think mortgage free properties are the only ones eligible for equity release.

MillicentBystander2022 · 04/01/2023 23:32

I didn't think you could do equity release on mortgage free properties?

samqueens · 04/01/2023 23:25

I’m no expert in this stuff but a couple of suggestions to consider if you’re priority is helping DD with her feelings of unfairness (clearly these are not warranted, but she’s only young and her dad seems a good manipulator) while not shafting yourself (or her - because, after all, she may well be impacted by his poor financial choices eventually)

Am assuming you currently have a home with space for her and that she spends time at both your houses, but that she considering his house her childhood home etc

so -

Are you (and the person you owe money to) in a position to consider a written addendum to your agreement which allows him to stay in the marital home until she finishes university/full time education and sell at that point? From what you’ve said this is possibly only 3/4 years away (if that is the path she is taking) and it seems more likely she will be able to disengage from her ties to this home once she’s finished studying and is getting a job and her own place anyway.

Alternatively would you be prepared, if it came to it, to loan him back any money once the place was sold, to ensure he can afford something reasonable? You could put a second charge on the property/have it all drawn up legally, so that money comes back to you eventually.

I realise none of these options are ideal for you, and I think there are probably some instances when children can be given more details than is healthy. But she’s 18 and she is (at her dad’s behest) inserting herself into the situation.

So maybe try and sit down and have a conversation about her concerns and what you can do to help alleviate them. If her concern is her connection to the house then option 1 and she has time to get used to the idea. If it’s more “what will happen to dad” then option 2, but don’t be pushed into agreeing the fine details with her - that has to be between you and him and depends on what is actually affordable for you etc. it’s more like - of course I will help make sure you he has somewhere suitable to go if I am in a position to do so, I won’t let him fall through the cracks etc

Try to be non judgmental and focus on the behaviour she sees from you and want you want to model to her in terms of compassion/security etc. Don't let the unfairness of the fact that you’re still cleaning up his rubbish undermine the end game. Eventually she will be a fully fledged grown up and she will either see through his manipulation or she won’t - but this way she will see you as fair minded and reliable, rather than whatever picture he tries to paint (money grabbing/unfair etc). Own your relationship with her and your actions, don’t let him undermine that.

i know it’s a bit alternative as a perspective, but hope it’s in some way helpful to think about it from this angle.

JLoti · 04/01/2023 23:04

We all think that! I wish I had put myself first more than I did. I now have one child who lives 60 miles away who visits every 12 weeks and one who lives 30 miles away who I see once every 4/6 weeks. At least she calls though. I had good relationships with them too! Stop worrying about her. You will be the least of her worries when she finds her someone and settles down. Parents become a bind when older and you then wonder why you invested so much time in them and worried about them so much. She is being dramatic. Don’t pander too it.

Naddd · 04/01/2023 23:04

May sound harsh. However ur daughter is not going to live you with him forever. In the mean time why can't she have one of the two bedrooms? If he can afford a 2 bed.

If not then the reality is she would need to live with you hardly homeless.

I suspect she is being manipulated. However by the time she realises it will be too late and you'll have been screwed over.

Get the house sold take ur 50%. Equity release sounds a terrible idea.

Explain things to your daughter that he can get a 2 bed and she always has a home with you.

I would not get screwed over financially because u allowed myself to be manipulated by a near enough adult. Child or not.

You need to remember long term its for her benefit as well.

Stravaig · 04/01/2023 22:49

Yes I do worry about her. I worry about how this will affect her. You only have to look on the relationships board here to understand that viewpoint.

My first thought on how it might affect DD is that if you try to spare her the full truth of the toxicity of her father, she could well end up in relationship with someone just like him. Bit horrifying, I'm sorry.

Xenia · 04/01/2023 22:48

You are entitled to £80k. That is not particularly much money so he might well be able to remortgage, cash in his pension or do equity relase so probably could pay without having to sell the home and therefore the daughter would still be housed but that is for him to decide.

SD1978 · 04/01/2023 22:46

As others have said- she is old enough now to have some awareness that you were left 'homeless' in the split, and were forced to make do and improve your circumstances how you could. He's had the advantage of having a stable home, and years to organise a solution to his housing- you were given none of that. And she's old enough now that to be honest I would be having that conversation frankly with her. I don't agree with children being brought into situations regarding finances and separation usually, but he's inserted her with half truths- she's almost 18 and I'd be telling her clearly the view from your side.

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 22:41

@JLoti well I hope I’ve built up a good enough relationship for us to be having more frequent contact than that!

Yes I do worry about her. I worry about how this will affect her. You only have to look on the relationships board here to understand that viewpoint.

OP posts:
JLoti · 04/01/2023 22:33

Parents worry too much about kids. By the time you are 70 she will probably visit you once a month and ring for 10 mins once a week.

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 22:26

@Testina oh I certainly did 🤣🤣

Ah thank you. I don’t feel as though I have any other choice but to stand firm.

OP posts:
Testina · 04/01/2023 22:24

@Newname50 sadly it wasn’t really a serious suggestion - but I thought you’d enjoy the idea of it 🤣
Good luck to you. You have to stand firm and it’s quite “lucky” that you need to pay off the family loan so you can tell your daughter than you simply have no option to wait.

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 22:19

That would really get to him @Testina! And as much as I like that idea, he would never go for it. Also, I can’t raise the funds to pay the loan off.

@NancyJoan, he didn’t care one not about that. He was just happy to stay in his bloody castle.

I didn’t buy straight away, rented for a few years.
This has been dragging on for years.

OP posts:
NancyJoan · 04/01/2023 22:14

Does she understand that by staying in the house he made you homeless? That you had to borrow from family to put a roof over your head and hers? He was happy to do that to his early-teens daughter.

Testina · 04/01/2023 22:01

How about a double or quits offer? 😉

He either buys you out of your half now, or signs the house over to you in its entirety and you let him live there until such time as he dies or goes into a home. All sorted out 100% legally.

Downside is that you’ll pay CGT and have to find some way of paying off the family loan.

Upside is your daughter still stands to inherit exactly the same, and long term you get £80K ish more than you settled for 😉

Newname50 · 04/01/2023 21:39

Thank you for all the advice!

To answer some questions-

Yes, DD is a bit dramatic. But she is, naturally, worried about her fathers future, and ergo hers.
Deep down she knows that she won’t be homeless, but because, in her eyes, I am the one who is taking her fathers home, then I am the bad guy.

So although she could live here with me if he ends up somewhere that she cannot have a room, then her animosity towards me would be high, and she would not live here due to that.

No, it isn’t any of my business how exh raises the settlement. But it will affect DD however he does so, in that the house will be sold and won’t, as he has told her, always be her home after he dies.

I cannot express how angry I am with him for poisoning her and making these false promises. For not being organised in readiness for this to minimise the distress to her. He is so bitter, and he is allowing that to over spill and cloud everything else.

DD is not planning to move out of the area and go to uni, her career choice means this won’t be necessary.

Yes, he could buy a decent ish property with 80k, but that is for him to decide.

OP posts: