Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my FIL to fuck off

129 replies

Relevancyiskey · 03/01/2023 23:04

Does anyone else's FIL constantly act as if their son has the hardest life imaginable and deserves all the breaks in the world?

He has recently started making comments about how DH needs to find more time for himself and I should "let him". Keep in mind I'm a SAHM and also rarely get time for myself as we have a baby and toddler. We were even out to dinner last week and my husband was complimenting me on my hard work (i've been struggling recently) and FIL starting talking about how going out to work is harder than staying at home. I've done both and can assure you it's fucking not.
In the same sentence FIL started talking about how all through DH and BIL childhood he would go running for 2-3 hours every evening. He said and I quote "He still needs to do things for himself" yeah not 15-20 hours a week... we went on a holiday entirely dedicated to DH hobby (snowboarding) only a month ago where he got to snowboard all week and I looked after the children. FILs comment "I was glad you finally got to go, you deserved a break where you didn't have to think about the children".

Do I just have to suck this up? Is this a common trait in 60 year old men and I just need to accept things were different 30 years ago? Is it even that bad or am I just oversensitive?

OP posts:
GerbilsForever24 · 04/01/2023 09:38

I'm always banging on about this on threads like these, but these supposedly "old fashioned" ideas are such bollocks. I'm nearly 50 and when I was growing up in a more old fashioned/conservative environment, lots of my friends' families had dads who were the main breadwinners and mums who worked part time or were SAHMs.

But, newsflash, those men did NOT just go to work and come home and do NOTHING else. They prided themselves on being family men and on some level I suspect there was a sense of being "real" men. So they worked but they also did lots at home - maybe not cooking and cleaning (although mine did) but would be on top of all DIY, garden chores, bins,... anything that required more "muscle". They were also the ones who did most of the lifting and carrying on weekends - it was the dads ferrying us all around to sports activities, doing late night pick ups from parties etc (frankly, it was all a bit misogynist really ie "ooh, women shouldn't drive at night" but the point was that they weren't sitting at home on their butts).

My Dad had a sports hobby which he did 3x a week and yes, that was inviolate in our house. But when he wasn't doing that, he was either at work or doing stuff at home. There was also, I sense, a sort of sense of pride in having a wife who was social, well dressed, well groomed etc. It's hard to define but certainly, all those SAHMs weren't being restricted in what they spent or what they did,

This is all a long winded way of saying your FIL is a dick. Unless there's more going on and your DH is struggling and has confided in your FIL. But I think it's the former.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 04/01/2023 09:30

IWineAndDontDine · 04/01/2023 00:30

That's not fair at all. Things change as generations are born. Now is very different to 30 years ago is very different to 50 years ago etc etc etc. I'm asking if it's to be accepted as that was the norm back when DH was a child

It really wasn't the norm when your dh was growing up. I'm 58 and the norm when I started working was for women to work.

Colleagues 15-20 years older than me were more likely to follow the traditional route you refer to but they would be late 70's and up now.

Your fil is just an asshole.

beachcitygirl · 04/01/2023 09:27

Tigertigertigertiger · 04/01/2023 00:52

Is it harder to be home with kids or harder to go out to work ?
There’s no definitive answer , it depends on so many factors .

in my case my paid employment was much harder. But I would not have wanted one of my parents to say so in front of my stay at home husband.

Whatever. Your FIL should butt out.

Nope.
Delusional. Going out to work is never harder than being a sahm.
Never.

TheCallOfTheMild · 04/01/2023 09:25

It isn't an age thing it is an asshole thing. this.

Neither my 64 year old husband or 93 year old father in law would come out with such misogynist rubbish. As most mothers also have paid jobs, we know which role is generally harder - for me, I went to work for a rest!

catfunk · 04/01/2023 09:22

No, I'd be correcting him each and every time.

Coolheadedbird · 04/01/2023 09:18

Christ the words of one of the posters here that says 'What sort of holiday would involve you being alone with kids while the fucks off in the snow all day' are a wake up call.

DO NOT FORGET ABOUT YOUR OWN HOBBIES, INTERESTS, YOU

Don't let all these dickhead men walk all over you. Start making a plan of some return to work when the kids are at school (even if it is working school hours, with holidays at an actual school). Get on even ground where you are both in the same boat, otherwise I am afraid this looks like a dangerous expoitative environment for you. Imagine - when the kids do go to school what the hell will they say then? That you sit at home all day. If they are doing it now, they will be doing it then. There are lots of pat time roles in admin, marketing, finance, teaching, seriously, start planning.

Honour yourself as much as you honour your husband and you can not go wrong.

And stop apologising for being ALIVE. This snowboarding holiday is a mindfuck. Never again. Say that it's really important you choose something for everyone next time around. Stuff his hobbies.

KettrickenSmiled · 04/01/2023 08:43

FIL starting talking about how going out to work is harder than staying at home
"How would YOU know? Anyone who reckons that has obviously never done it."

"You're right! That's why DH is taking over, I'm going back to work because he needs a break, 'just' staying at home raising the children."

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/01/2023 08:30

peaceinourtime · 04/01/2023 01:23

it's an old man thing. They all (mostly) wind up being the same.

I’m 53 and DH is 58 neither of us are decrepit pensioners thinking old thoughts. Our teenagers would take the piss mercilessly if we were wandering around spouting rubbish like the FIL. Nice bit of ageism though.

MoltenLasagne · 04/01/2023 08:29

If he's in his 60s he was raising his kids in the 1990s not the 1890s! He's just a prat who is trying to use "back in my day" as an excuse for his own shitty parenting.

ZED55JAX0 · 04/01/2023 07:38

Ask him to babysit all day and night then see what he has to say!!

Anycrispsleft · 04/01/2023 06:22

His views are irrelevant and badly informed (he has no basis for comparison between working and looking after children; you do). The next time he starts banging on, why not let your boredom show on your face? Talk over him if you like. He's not being polite, why should you?

StarsSand · 04/01/2023 06:03

ssd · 04/01/2023 05:58

Why is FIL so involved in your lives?

Just dont bloody tell him so much.

Agreed. Stop giving him information. How often do you see him?

ssd · 04/01/2023 05:59

peaceinourtime · 04/01/2023 01:23

it's an old man thing. They all (mostly) wind up being the same.

60 isnt old

ssd · 04/01/2023 05:58

Why is FIL so involved in your lives?

Just dont bloody tell him so much.

StarsSand · 04/01/2023 04:40

My MIL was like this. Really felt the need to advocate for DH within the marriage while treating him like crap otherwise. Feel to pieces complementing him every time he lifted a finger in our home or for the baby, making it very clear she thought I was lazy if he do much as stirred his own tea.

Cappuccino17 · 04/01/2023 04:10

I wouldn't bat an eyelid. What do most men understand about giving birth and staying at home with the kids anyway? He clearly didn't do it. Pay no attention to this man.

Motelschmotel · 04/01/2023 04:08

It’s small-dick stuff, trying to assert his masculinity and by extension of him, his son’s.

It’s dull as fuck, even having to listen to the male ego witter on. Just get on with your life happy that you can figuratively mute him when he goes off on one.

Pemba · 04/01/2023 03:47

From my experience (DD just turned 30) parenting of young children in the 90s was pretty much as today. Most decent fathers would get stuck in and be hands on with parenting.

My father on the other hand cheerfully admits that he never changed a nappy! This would have been in the sixties.

Your FIL is just a dinosaur, I'm afraid and quite selfish and misogynistic. Two or 3 hour runs every evening, poor MIL! He is trying to encourage his son to be the same way and I'm sorry to say that he seems to have succeeded to a certain extent. You will just have to try and counteract his bad influence on your DP.

Littlebabynothings · 04/01/2023 02:28

“n the same sentence FIL started talking about how all through DH and BIL childhood he would go running for 2-3 hours every evening”

2-3 hours of running a night?!
what was he a professional standard runner or running to his mistress every night?

Whilst I’d love some me time, 2-3 hours out the house away from his family a night just seems odd and too much. His poor wife.

Whotsit · 04/01/2023 02:12

it also might be worth you taking mil away as a special treat for 24 hours and DH staying with FIL. Maybe DH could go for a 3 hour run? Leave FOL in charge. He needs a dose of reality.

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 04/01/2023 02:05

I had a nuclear argument with my FIL when he attacked me in a similar way. My DH is very “hands on” and doesn’t want to miss a minute, which is amazing but I’m more relaxed and so it always appears as though he’s doing everything. We split all chores and both work. DH still has always played sport all weekend etc. I was at home with both children when they were little and I can categorically say that work was a piece of piss in comparison. I’m a lawyer.
I believe it is a generational thing, my dad can be similar. FIL’s wife and mum did everything for him, he just worked. Unfortunately for my FIL I’d had enough and fought back and told him in no uncertain terms that his behaviour was unacceptable . He’s always been respectful since then but I keep my distance.

I've thought a lot about it since and how fucking unfair it all is. For instance, our friends had a party for their son and the mum spent the entire time doing the cake, sorting out party bags, playing with the children/doing the party etcetera. The husband spent the entire time drinking beer and talking to friends and having a relaxed time. Nobody batted an eyelid. I said to my husband imagine if those roles were reversed - everybody would be talking about the Mum. People would judge her. They would pretend they didn’t but they would.

RiverSkater · 04/01/2023 01:54

Just start saying things like 'what is it about having a penis that makes you come out with these out -dated notions!?

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/01/2023 01:42

Ah, also, I don’t mean to infer that working mothers don’t love their babies but sometimes, it’s nice to have that little time away, even if at work, where you can focus in something else. And I don’t mean to infer anything about SAHM either!

I’ve done both SAHM and work, as I was lucky to do 12 hour shifts in an NHS hospital so worked 4 days one week and 3 the next so spent lots of time at home as well, and working was a darn sight easier than being a SAHM!

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/01/2023 01:39

@Relevancyiskey

This is most certainly not a thing and I know this because my husband is nearly 63 and would never say anything so effing stupid, because he knows I would kill him and he might not recover from that!

Parenting 24/7 is bloody hard work (which maybe why some mothers prefer to go out to work and have a nanny or childminder to help with the heavy lifting) and your FIL is a twit because he A) has proven by opening his mouth so stupidly that he never really understood that challenges his wife was dealing with and B) has proven as per A) that he never actually did any childcare! Which might have been the way for fathers born in the 1940’s but certainly not (and I feel like I can speak with some authority as I observed my own DH and his mates) for fathers born in the 1960’s.

Next time he’s spewing such rubbish forth, shame him! Say very sweetly and in your own words “I really feel for you FIL because it must’ve been awful never spending time with DH and BIL when they were little” and when he says he did, call that BS out by responding “oh sorry, it’s just that the way you talk about parenting young children, which is a lot of heavy lifting, I just kind of thought that you didn’t have a lot of input, that’s all”, and shrug and smile at him. Then follow up by saying to Dh, with that smile “DH loves the minimal amount of time he’s able to spend with DC between work and snowboarding on holiday, but next vacation it’s my turn to choose a holiday, so he’ll be able to do more childcare then!” And DH is either going to out himself as a twit a là FIL or will have to say “of course”, even if it’s just with gritted teeth!

OdeToBillyJoe · 04/01/2023 01:37

That's the sort of thing my FIL would say.

I went no contact about nine or ten years ago. My husband still sees them but that's his choice. I don't want to!

Swipe left for the next trending thread