Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at holiday prices! Do your take your DCs out of school??

91 replies

Yesiminsane · 03/01/2023 22:44

Have you done it if so how long and did you pay a fine?

DC is in reception and one of oldest in the year so wondering about taking him out for a week in summer...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JazbayGrapes · 26/04/2023 09:52

Surely the lockdowns illustrated this.

They showed the opposite.

AllTheChaos · 26/04/2023 08:24

I am thinking to do this the last one or two weeks of summer term, not because of cost but because if there’s another 40 degree heatwave I don’t think I can bear London. It was brutal last summer, school asked parents to keep children home if they possibly could as they didn’t even have fans to help keep them cool. Those children in school weren’t able to learn in that heat, and in fairness to school they didn’t even attempt to make them study, it was just survival mode all round. They couldn’t even go outside to play (primary school) as it’s just a tarmac playground with no shade. If that happens again then I really think being somewhere out of London, where it’s green and cooler, would be preferable on every level! Really cannot afford it but saving hard to try.

SpringIsTooFarAway · 04/01/2023 13:14

As a lone parent I'm limited how much I can do this because trying to cover the school hols with annual leave etc is hard enough already. But with two parents to do that, I don'r see it as an issue, at all.

SpringIsTooFarAway · 04/01/2023 12:56

My parents took me out for 2-3 weeks every June. I still remember so much from those trips, learned so much, it was wonderful. I got straight As at school as did my siblings, in absolutely uesless schools. We all have very good degrees and successful careers. I wouldn't think twice about it. The fine is a token amount compared to the holiday cost so if it means the children get a better experience and more varied travel it is worth it. If the children are intelligent and have good attendance the rest of the year it will make zero difference to their educational outcomes.

MaverickGooseGoose · 04/01/2023 12:53

We have never been able to take ours out as DH is a teacher but I totally would have done if he wasn't. I'd not do it in secondary but the last week of term in primary, yep. Although be careful as some of the prices don't drop that much becuase of the scottish and NI holidays which come earlier.

the week before the october half term is still cheaper as the companies haven't cottoned on to the fact that lots of schools are now on a two week HT.

JusteanBiscuits · 04/01/2023 12:51

DdraigGoch · 04/01/2023 12:34

I wish that school holidays were staggered like they are in Germany. Then the peaks and troughs in prices would be more even.

Fine till you have two kids at two schools with different holidays! We live on the edge of two different education authorities. Primary is in one authority, high school in the other! Fine now they're both at high school, but when I had one at primary and one at high school is was already a completely pain that October half term is different weeks, and term start / end dates were different by a few days.

DdraigGoch · 04/01/2023 12:34

I wish that school holidays were staggered like they are in Germany. Then the peaks and troughs in prices would be more even.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 04/01/2023 11:46

shivawn · 04/01/2023 10:57

I'm curious about the fines charged in the UK (except Scotland as I've learned from this thread). I didn't realise this was a thing.

What is the money used for? How much are they generally? If it's a long absence due to genuine illness can you still be fined?

In our local authority the fine is £60 per parent, per child I think. Their policy is to fine after 10 session of unauthorised absence (each session is 1/2 day). So previously I have try to arrange it so we are. Only missing fewer than 10 sessions.

illness should be an authorised absence, but sometimes some schools will ask for ‘evidence’.

I think fining varies massively between local authorise. Some fine and take parents to court more often than other local authorities. The descretion around if something counts as authorised or unauthorised lies with the head I think, thought many will just follow the policy from their Academy/LA.

I heard of one head who was allowing parents to have their child out of school for 1 weeks a year, provided it didn’t coincide with any important exams etc. that seems sensible to me.

personally I don’t believe fining improves outcomes for children who desperately need support. Richer parents will pay, poorer parents will avoid fines and children with very significant issues (eg neglectful parents/mental health school refusal) won’t be helped by fines.

BellaCiao1 · 04/01/2023 11:28

BodyShapeWoes · 04/01/2023 08:47

I never did until covid…both of mine had 100% attendance from when they started school…we just sucked it up went camping and did long weekends in holiday cottages

Since covid both of my children who were where they were required (ish) to be are now around 18m behind in their schooling and as a key worker mine went to school during most of it… still have no idea what they did for 30 hours a week not learn anything apparently

Now I don’t give a shit and have booked to take them away after Feb half term and will also do it again in May! An extra week behind isn’t going to make a dent in their education at this point.

They can fine me all they bloody want and I might even fight it…

I am paying for a tutor twice a week to catch them up as school don’t seem particularly interested in helping them more money I don’t have but yet again the Tories have fucked up another generation of young people

I don't disagree with a lot of what you have said but key workers children weren't in school to be taught. They were in school to be supervised.

Whatsshecalled · 04/01/2023 11:01

Yep a week every other Feb to ski. My reasoning is the ski season is short basically its Feb half term or during term time (Feb half term is 4 x the cost of the weeks either side). They learn so much, not just how to ski but they're in lessons with kids from all over europe learning to communicate despite language barriers its really valuable but could never afford Feb half term so the alternative is we wait until they've left school at 18?

QuentininQuarantino · 04/01/2023 10:58

We just get flights and an airbnb somewhere lovely, it’s hundreds, if not thousands cheaper than a resort.

I suppose it depends what a holiday is for you. If you want an AI resort then of course it is expensive, and you might need to save over years for one holiday like that, but if it’s about discovering somewhere new, it doesn’t have to be that expensive and you can therefore do it more regularly.

im a teacher so can’t take them out of school but I would do it if it wasn’t missing exams.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/01/2023 10:58

glasshole · 04/01/2023 10:38

Wet use to do this when we had 4 kids at home. We would always try to go over the mayday period as our kids school was also shut for voting in that same week so two "approved" days off school meant they were below the threshold for fines. Turkey , Tunisia and southern Greece is fine in early May and can save £££ if you factor in approved days off into your weeks holiday.

That’s a good tip. 1/5 is a bank holiday. And 4/5 local elections and 8/5 bank holiday (king) so if your school shuts for polling for 3 days off you can have a 10 day holiday - you won’t get fined 3 days off.

FriedEggChocolate · 04/01/2023 10:57

We hvae a DC in Reception this year. We're doing one week in a caravan rather than take her out of school. I'd rather cut our cloth based on what we can afford than get the DC used to going out of school for holidays and then stopping in Yr 1 for the phonics assessment and in Yr 2 for KS1 SATs etc. If you want to go abroad, look at October half term which is significantly cheaper and better, heatwise, for 4- 5 years olds than a mid-summer holiday.

shivawn · 04/01/2023 10:57

I'm curious about the fines charged in the UK (except Scotland as I've learned from this thread). I didn't realise this was a thing.

What is the money used for? How much are they generally? If it's a long absence due to genuine illness can you still be fined?

Dixiechickonhols · 04/01/2023 10:54

Look at your holidays and see if they differ from standard at all. Lots of religious schools and academies have different holidays now. Think outside the box eg Glasgow flights are cheaper late summer as Scotland back (if you are northern England)
My dc isn’t back until 7/9 this year - first week of September is much cheaper.

shivawn · 04/01/2023 10:52

life is too short and learning happens everywhere, memories made means a lot more than a week in school imo

@Sarah061991 Completely agree
**

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 04/01/2023 10:52

I’m taking my children out of school.
not sure if I’ll be fined. I’m hoping not because I’m staying below the number of days that our local authority fine for (according to their policy). But I’ll pay if it happens

DoubleGauze · 04/01/2023 10:51

We don't. We book our week away at Easter a year in advance and pay it off over 10 months. Most can do this if they are organised enough. School is important. Surely the lockdowns illustrated this.

CheapFoodShits · 04/01/2023 10:50

I've always taken DS out in term time but made it so it's only 3/4 days of school he's missed. He's in Y6 now and we're going away for a week in May but I just made sure it was after his SATS. I can't afford the extortionate prices to go in the school holidays and he otherwise has great attendance. He also has SEN so taking him away at less busy times means he can actually enjoy himself.

FunctionalSkills · 04/01/2023 10:47

@LibbyL92 not sure why you say chances of being fined are slim.

Our local schools forward on all cases of 10sessions plus (ie if you miss a whole week) for automatic LA fine. Lots of friends have done this and chosen to do the fine (ie for disney in America).

I actually thought schools were compelled to by the gov these days...

(We don't normally do school time holidays as can see how a week's chunky of learning can bite you later (ie missing a weeks maths might mean you moss a topic) but we did last year. We made sure it was 4 days to avoid the fine...

Rayn22 · 04/01/2023 10:46

Frosty1000 · 04/01/2023 09:39

I'd never take a child out of school, really disrespectful to the teacher - a holiday to me is a luxury and if you can't afford it when you're meant to take it then you just don't go.

We're looking at £1300 for a week in a proxy caravan in the UK - that's taking the p*ss really so I get it but wouldn't do it myself.

You will find that most teachers go with it and agree. I am a teacher and completely understand why parents do it.

CLLock · 04/01/2023 10:45

You can also look at only taking them out for a few days rather than the full week. If you tag this on to a school holiday, you should get a cheaper holiday.
For example, we've just priced up a holiday to a 4 star hotel in lanzerote for the feb half term. For a family of 4, it's coming back at £2100, which is half the price we pay for a holiday abroad in the summer. If we go on the Tuesday of the half term, and don't return until the Tuesday after half term ends (meaning the kids miss two days of school), the holiday reduces to £1400.

glasshole · 04/01/2023 10:38

Edwardwilliamnancy · 03/01/2023 23:00

No but this year and last year we booked going away on an inset day meaning its slightly cheaper we also go easter holidays as its cheaper than may/summer time.
Going away a day earlier has saved £550 for 4 of us. Also choosing different flights saved us a bit and gives us extra day in resort.

Wet use to do this when we had 4 kids at home. We would always try to go over the mayday period as our kids school was also shut for voting in that same week so two "approved" days off school meant they were below the threshold for fines. Turkey , Tunisia and southern Greece is fine in early May and can save £££ if you factor in approved days off into your weeks holiday.

glasshole · 04/01/2023 10:34

My sister and I absolutely took ( and will take again) our kids out of school for holidays. I refuse to feel guilty about it. Last year I paid a £120 fine reduced to £60 for prompt payment. But flights in June were £80 return each ( Manchester to Rome ) and human travel caravan self catering accommodation was £35 each for a week. Transfers £20 each. So £135 for a week away plus food costs and day trips etc . My sister and our kids shared a caravan.

Worked out £360 each in total for everything for me and DD. It was AMAZING. My 13yo DD enjoyed it and so did my 9yo DN. They went to the Vatican and the colosseum and saw the Sistine chapel and the trevi fountain. Very very educational. The other 5 days were spent in the pool at the brilliant camp site we chose.

Next year we are going to Beziers in France. Even cheaper. Flights £67 return. Caravan £40 each. Transfers £16 each. For a week in June! The site looks simply brilliant and I am really excited to go as my grand kids and daughter are also coming along and staying in a caravan. Lovely big family holiday ❤️

Comefromaway · 04/01/2023 10:21

Dh teaches so we have never had the option to take the kids out of school anyway though it was awkward when his terms did not match theirs.

We tended to go on camping/caravanning holidays (self catering cottage style ones were too expensive) or just have day trips.

Swipe left for the next trending thread