Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my parents not to shout at my 4yr old?

212 replies

TooConflictedConfused · 03/01/2023 22:17

My DC (4years old) came back from the grandparents today and told me and my OH that they didn’t like going to my mum’s house. The reason being that when ‘they do wrong things their gran shouts at them’. Then we asked what wrong things they did they said they couldn’t remember, they only remembered the shouting and that they did wrong things all the time. And they also said that’s why they don’t miss their gran cause they get shouted at all the time by her.

Occasionally I ask my parents to help with childcare but it’s no more than once a week. My DC was meant to go to my parents again tomorrow but now I’m thinking of keeping them at home and taking a day off from work.

Any advice on how to approach this with my parents? AIBU to expect my parents not to shout?

My DC is only 4 and generally a super well-behaved kid and never has any complaints from school or after school nanny re behaviours.

My dad is a mild mannered person but generally leaves the childcare to my mum. For background my mum is a school of tough love parent and shouted at me a lot whilst I was growing up and also used corporal punishment. I hence was super triggered by the revelation and would love some objective advice on how to deal with the situation.

OP posts:
PetraBP · 04/01/2023 12:39

Generational issue most likely.

When I was a kid shouting and smacking was normal mum behaviour from
both mine and other peoples mums.

Not how we do it now though so better have a word with her and explain it’s not OK now.

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:37

BeeColourful · 04/01/2023 12:35

It’s unacceptable because it doesn’t address the root cause of the behaviour. Its intention is to silence the child into complying with our wishes, rather than teaching them how to properly behave.

Hence shouting parents will always be shouting parents because shouting and fear based parenting doesn’t work; it doesn’t teach anything.

It leads to mental health issues, power struggles, rebellion, and doesn’t allow the child to see why what they did was wrong and how they should behave in future and why. It doesn’t promote emotional intelligence or resilience and is very damaging.

It also doesn’t lead by example. You don’t want your kids to be shouty and aggressive towards you or others, but by shouting at them you are telling them that it’s okay to act like that. It isn’t.

Better tell the army they are training their troops wrong or prison wardens they are not teaching prisoners to be law-abiding people correctly

SeeYouNextTLol · 04/01/2023 12:35

Super

BeeColourful · 04/01/2023 12:35

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:09

Why is it unacceptable?

It’s unacceptable because it doesn’t address the root cause of the behaviour. Its intention is to silence the child into complying with our wishes, rather than teaching them how to properly behave.

Hence shouting parents will always be shouting parents because shouting and fear based parenting doesn’t work; it doesn’t teach anything.

It leads to mental health issues, power struggles, rebellion, and doesn’t allow the child to see why what they did was wrong and how they should behave in future and why. It doesn’t promote emotional intelligence or resilience and is very damaging.

It also doesn’t lead by example. You don’t want your kids to be shouty and aggressive towards you or others, but by shouting at them you are telling them that it’s okay to act like that. It isn’t.

Isthisexpected · 04/01/2023 12:28

BritAbroad101

^ do some research into the neurological damage it does. You are very ignorant of decades of research here.

forrestgreen · 04/01/2023 12:17

Ring your mum and ask how dc behaved. If she says all was good then ask why dc says she shouted.
I'm predicting she'll then shout at you, or maybe apologise. That'll tell you how to proceed.

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:09

BeeColourful · 04/01/2023 12:08

@BritAbroad101 Shouting is fear based parenting. It is unacceptable and doesn’t address the issue.

Why is it unacceptable?

starfishmummy · 04/01/2023 12:09

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 05:07

My DS used to say someone 'shouted' at him when he was just upset at being told off. I know this because he used to accuse me of doing it

this exactly. I hear so many kids say this when really it's because they got told off.

Not even told off. My ds would accuse anyone of shouting for just telling him something he didn't want to hear

BeeColourful · 04/01/2023 12:08

@BritAbroad101 Shouting is fear based parenting. It is unacceptable and doesn’t address the issue.

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:06

Isthisexpected · 04/01/2023 12:03

Sometimes I wonder if people on this site are actually bothered about raising a child with discipline and resilience. They need to learn that actions have consequences. If they don’t like the feeling of being shouted at, then don’t be naughty/disobedient!

^ this is a four year old learning about the world through experimentation and about autonomy through disobedience. It is completely normal. There are lots of healthy ways to teach a child about boundaries and if you have any parenting skills you can discipline effectively without resorting to fear based rule. Presumably you don't shout at colleagues who make the wrong decision?

There is a difference between making a wrong decision in error and being naughty/bad/careless etc and doing this repeatedly (as I’m sure the child did for the grandmother to raise their voice)

If people deliberately and repeatedly did things incorrectly at work (or through carelessness) then they would be spoken with sternly in raised voices and/or dismissed by their superiors!

WinnieFosterReads · 04/01/2023 12:05

Chat to your DM. My DC used to say people had shouted and were shouting when they weren't. We came to the conclusion it was because people use a different tone of voice if saying something serious - our DC confused tone with volume.

Isthisexpected · 04/01/2023 12:03

Sometimes I wonder if people on this site are actually bothered about raising a child with discipline and resilience. They need to learn that actions have consequences. If they don’t like the feeling of being shouted at, then don’t be naughty/disobedient!

^ this is a four year old learning about the world through experimentation and about autonomy through disobedience. It is completely normal. There are lots of healthy ways to teach a child about boundaries and if you have any parenting skills you can discipline effectively without resorting to fear based rule. Presumably you don't shout at colleagues who make the wrong decision?

BeeColourful · 04/01/2023 12:02

Once a week childcare is not “occasionally”.

You knew what they were like when you were growing up so should have expected them to treat your son the way they treated you.

Time to find alternate childcare.

Usernamesarboring · 04/01/2023 12:01

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 05:26

Believe your DC

the child is 4, it's probable that the child at that age isn't lying. But at the same time a kid's much more likely that they have perceived a situation wrongly because of their naivety and young age. So grandma may have gently but firmly gave an instruction but child interprets it as shouting.

However having said that, I was a year 1 ta for many years and you'd be amazed at the amount of 5 year olds who tell barefaced lies about what the teacher said and did to parents. I witnessed the lies myself. Children of that age can be very manipulative and deceptive.

Pillow56, do you find shouting at kids ok? You have posted 5 times back to back defending shouter and finding their criticism sad but in this scenario mother of the said child had herself experienced shouting and corporal punishment as a child and says that gran believes in tough love.

You are sad over hypothetical situations but why are you not sad about the fact that child had requested the parents to not send him to gran? Whatever the level of shouting is he feels uncomfortable with there.

Just because another poster's niece lies to get attention, doesnt mean this kid too. Context is more important than what another unrelated child does. This is not a discussion of child psychology.

PeekAtYou · 04/01/2023 12:01

I would try and find out what happened. Maybe ask if dc behaved badly because they mentioned being told off.

In the mean time I would stop using your mum as childcare because the possibilities are

  1. She can't cope/ finds it difficult
  2. Dc is naughty for he
  3. She is repeating the past and unnecessarily shouty. Possibly has unrealistic views that were used in the past like clearing a plate at mealtime.

All of those point to her being an unsuitable babysitter. Do you spend time with her and dc at the same time ?

Isthisexpected · 04/01/2023 12:00

They can have a relationship by spending time with grandparents when you're free too.

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:00

Might not be your style (which is fine) but there is nothing wrong with raising your voice at children who are being naughty and under your care

Sometimes I wonder if people on this site are actually bothered about raising a child with discipline and resilience. They need to learn that actions have consequences. If they don’t like the feeling of being shouted at, then don’t be naughty/disobedient!

Calphurnia88 · 04/01/2023 11:58

watchfulwishes · 03/01/2023 22:35

You were shouted at and hit by your mum, I think you know what she's like, and she's not going to change.

Stop subjecting your kids to this.

This.

But I would explain exactly why I longer feel comfortable with DM being around DS unsupervised (including DF).

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 04/01/2023 11:57

Personally with your own experience in the frame I would cease her giving any childcare and stick to social visits only when you can be present as the parent.
There are a thousand things you should do before you reach in the tool box for shouting if you're got halfway decent parenting skills. Everyone has shouted if they've lost their rag, but as an exception it's one thing, if that's your parenting style it's another.

DaphneFlower · 04/01/2023 11:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread.

redskydelight · 04/01/2023 11:51

For background my mum is a school of tough love parent and shouted at me a lot whilst I was growing up and also used corporal punishment. I hence was super triggered by the revelation and would love some objective advice on how to deal with the situation.

My parents were similar. My children do not spend time alone with them as I do not trust them not to treat my own children in the same way.

I would suggest you re-evaluate your need for childcare over your child going through the same experience as you did.

stemthetide · 04/01/2023 11:51

Surprising how many parents post on here about their awful upbringing at the hands of their parents yet use these same people for free childcare.

Visit grandparents with your child if you don't trust them.

Twiglets1 · 04/01/2023 11:49

I would try having a chat with your mum. Try not to sound judgemental just ask her politely to please not shout at your daughter as that is not the way you are bringing her up.

fuckthemail · 04/01/2023 11:48

@TooConflictedConfused similar situation. Almost all the time my children spend with my parents is also in my company

KettrickenSmiled · 04/01/2023 11:45

Calmdown14 · 04/01/2023 11:28

@KettrickenSmiled what are we talking about by 'corporal punishment ' though?

My mother used to chase us with a slipper and we certainly got a slap round the legs (not often and it was more of a threat when quite frankly we were being naughty) but she was and is an amazing mother

There's a massive scale to this stuff and some discipline is required. My child was partly deaf when little so I would seem shouty to some but if he was doing something dangerous it needed to be loud.

You'd have to ask OP, as only she will know what her mother used to do to her.

Your own mother was out of line.
She wouldn't have chased an adult with a slipper or slapped their legs. Not only is it illegal, but the other adult might have retaliated. But she was happy to hurt children, who couldn't defend themselves.

You call her an amazing mother, but here you are, banging on about some "scale" of physical punishment being required for "discipline". Children don't need to be "disciplined" they need to be TAUGHT, & led by example.