Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my parents not to shout at my 4yr old?

212 replies

TooConflictedConfused · 03/01/2023 22:17

My DC (4years old) came back from the grandparents today and told me and my OH that they didn’t like going to my mum’s house. The reason being that when ‘they do wrong things their gran shouts at them’. Then we asked what wrong things they did they said they couldn’t remember, they only remembered the shouting and that they did wrong things all the time. And they also said that’s why they don’t miss their gran cause they get shouted at all the time by her.

Occasionally I ask my parents to help with childcare but it’s no more than once a week. My DC was meant to go to my parents again tomorrow but now I’m thinking of keeping them at home and taking a day off from work.

Any advice on how to approach this with my parents? AIBU to expect my parents not to shout?

My DC is only 4 and generally a super well-behaved kid and never has any complaints from school or after school nanny re behaviours.

My dad is a mild mannered person but generally leaves the childcare to my mum. For background my mum is a school of tough love parent and shouted at me a lot whilst I was growing up and also used corporal punishment. I hence was super triggered by the revelation and would love some objective advice on how to deal with the situation.

OP posts:
mswales · 04/01/2023 20:13

I'm really really surprised you would let your mum look after your child without a conversation about how she "disciplined" you as a child and that you did not want the same to happen to your child. And even more surprised that now your child is saying they are being shouted at you aren't immediately going to talk to your mum about it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2023 19:37

I wouldn’t use your mum for childcare. Yes, children can sometimes call “shouting” when it’s just telling off, but from the way you describe your childhood it sounds like she’s behaving in the same way as she did toward you.

Id pay for childcare and visit your mum with your children so you can ensure there’s no shouting, whilst being in charge of behaviour yourself.

MeridianB · 04/01/2023 19:34

I can’t believe someone would seriously come onto a thread to support adults shouting at children.

BMrs · 04/01/2023 19:19

Are you close enough to speak to her about it and have a frank discussion.

My parenting style is vastly different to the one of my parents. My mum has occasionally said or done things I don't agree with and I've immediately told her straight I don't like it and politely but firmly asked her to not do it again as we don't parent that way.

I think it took some getting used to from her but she's respected our boundaries as parents and has made a few nice comments to say how patient we are and how she always felt she had to shout a lot but perhaps patience is a better way to go about things etc.

Hope that helps!

Calphurnia88 · 04/01/2023 19:06

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 18:44

It’s unacceptable because it doesn’t address the root cause of the behaviour. Its intention is to silence the child into complying with our wishes, rather than teaching them how to properly behave.
Hence shouting parents will always be shouting parents because shouting and fear based parenting doesn’t work; it doesn’t teach anything

none of the softie softie approaches work either, mn loves to talk about the best route of parenting and teaching kids discipline but I've yet to see it outlined.

Here are some great suggestions, none of which involve raising your voice.

www.unicef.org/parenting/child-care/how-discipline-your-child-smart-and-healthy-way

You're welcome 😊

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 18:54

I would not send your child to them again and would tell them exactly why

that's quite rash and a sure way to cause a rift. There is such a tendency on mn to go in with all guns blazing in any situation involving kids reporting being shouted at.

It is ironic as those who say to do it are giving the advice to be gentle in your approach rather than shout and that people should talk things through rather than shout and yet the advice of automatically confronting the teacher, go to the headmaster, tell the parents no more unsupervised visits etc is exactly the same as shouting in that it's a rapid inflammatory response.

You can't automatically take the word of a child. They tend to exaggerate, misconstrue situations or omit key pieces of information in their favour when reporting back. By all means ask what happened but do it with tact and ease. Automatically just taking a child's word and going to war with the gps is just extreme and over escalating a situation.

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 18:44

It’s unacceptable because it doesn’t address the root cause of the behaviour. Its intention is to silence the child into complying with our wishes, rather than teaching them how to properly behave.
Hence shouting parents will always be shouting parents because shouting and fear based parenting doesn’t work; it doesn’t teach anything

none of the softie softie approaches work either, mn loves to talk about the best route of parenting and teaching kids discipline but I've yet to see it outlined.

sgtmajormum · 04/01/2023 18:42

My mum used to shout at me as a child. As an adult I get triggered by arguing/shouting people which I think is related to this childhood trauma.

My kids hated going to their grandparents, especially my oldest who is ND. I stopped asking my parents to look after the kids as it just wasn't working.

Don't let your daughter be scared of her grandparents.

zingally · 04/01/2023 16:54

To my mind, once a week isn't "occasional childcare". That's frequent childcare.

I assume you're not paying your parents to mind your child? If so, it's a little bit beggars can't be choosers.

Personally I'd speak to your mum about it. "DD came home a bit upset and said you'd shouted at her? What happened/what did she do?" I wouldn't automatically take a 4yos word as gospel truth.

Maybe your mum just isn't young enough to cater to the demands of a 4yo any more? There's a reason having kids is a young persons game.

Kennykenkencat · 04/01/2023 16:34

fUNNYfACE36 · 04/01/2023 13:13

I would just tell her to behave herself instead of doing 'wrong things'.

But if the shouting is all that is remembered how can the child know what they have done wrong.

Kennykenkencat · 04/01/2023 16:30

I want my DC to have a relationship with their grandparents that’s why I let them visit there

Why?

You know what your mother is like. Why would you think she would change with your dc?

NC with my own mother who shouted and screamed at me every single day of my life. I realised I could no matter how hard I tried ever please her. She was a deeply disturbed woman.

I have never shouted at my children. Most people saw it as lax parenting but I thought they were just like me and wanted to run around and for that I would be shouted at for something I needed to do. I remember the pain of not being able to move around when I wanted and I didn’t want that for my children. (I used to join them running around the park or the garden)
Turns out we all have ADHD.

Even if I wasn’t NC with my mother there is no way would I leave my children with her ever.

MichaelFartblender · 04/01/2023 16:05

GregoryFluff · 04/01/2023 16:01

I know you're right, it's just so frustrating, I don't know what sparks the reaction and I hate to think of people seeing her as the aggro toddler and I worry about her starting nursery next January, I'd be mortified if she starts shoving/smacking other children
But sorry to derail thread

But people are also seeing you come down on it every time, and not ignoring it, which really helps.

I wouldn’t worry about it, it most likely is just a phase.

GregoryFluff · 04/01/2023 16:01

MichaelFartblender · 04/01/2023 15:51

@GregoryFluff toddlers don’t have to have seen someone hit to hit. They have poor impulse control and are testing to see what will happen.

I know you're right, it's just so frustrating, I don't know what sparks the reaction and I hate to think of people seeing her as the aggro toddler and I worry about her starting nursery next January, I'd be mortified if she starts shoving/smacking other children
But sorry to derail thread

CristinaNov182 · 04/01/2023 16:00

@GregoryFluff it is just a phase if you keep telling her and showing her it’s not ok. It might take months but she’ll outgrow it. Otherwise she might not, seen examples, or might still do it but not as often, thinking it’s an ok thing to do.

My DD saw 2 boys at nursery hitting other children and she took it home to us, not hitting other kids but me and her dad. It took a few months. Apart from explaining it hurt me, it’s not ok, I’ve also added consequences, no more tv that day, no more ice cream or park etc, one of these. That worked better than explaining it hurt, bc I could see on her eyes she didn’t understand or believed me. When they are very young they can’t really imagine how it is for other people.

MyAnacondaMight · 04/01/2023 15:59

Supervised visits only, and explain why. Don’t choose appeasing your mother over keeping your child safe.

Blanketpolicy · 04/01/2023 15:51

Be truthful and have a chat with your mum, and hopefully get your dad on side.

Explain to her most children nowadays do not get shouted at either at home or in school, parenting styles have changed. So therefore dc is very frightened of her when she shouts very loudly and while you fully support discipline could she try to reign the shouting in a bit as they have started saying they don't want to go. Tell her dc loves her and you really want them to have a close relationship but the shouting cannot continue, give her some ideas of how you discipline at home.

If she doesn't try (give her some leeway as it will take time to remember not to slip into her natural habits), then tell her dc can't visit her without you until they are at least a few years older, then you will revisit the idea.

MichaelFartblender · 04/01/2023 15:51

@GregoryFluff toddlers don’t have to have seen someone hit to hit. They have poor impulse control and are testing to see what will happen.

GregoryFluff · 04/01/2023 15:44

PetraBP · 04/01/2023 12:40

That said, it’s the quietest most passive mums that seem to have the loudest and hitty-est kids in my social circle…

I'm having a real issue with my 2 year old hitting her slightly older cousin atm
I come down on it every time, make her apologise and encourage them to hug. If it happens a few times, play date over
She has never been hit, only TV she has ever seen is CBeebies, hasn't started nursery yet, can count on one hand the amount of time she's been away from me or DH (we work opposite days), we don't even rough house or wrestle etc as she's quite a sensitive soul
I genuinely have no idea why she does it, people say it's just a phase and I hope so. She's only ever once tried it on a different kid and yet we socialise a lot (play dates with friends/playgroup/swim lessons/park)
I do fear people will secretly suspect we hit her, I have no idea why she's so aggressive and ironically she adores her cousin, asks for him all the time

Elastigurl · 04/01/2023 15:39

All parents shout IMO. If you, hand on heart, have never shouted at your child then I genuinely take my hat off to you because you are a better person than I am. I HATE shouting but I often am shouty mum. The difference is that a) I'm their parent, I'm with them 100% of the time more or less so we get on each other's tits more (that applies to my DC as well as me!) and (b) if I've over reacted and shouted I admit it and apologise.

Generally the grandparent generation, when shouting, didn't think they were doing anything wrong.

My Mum has my DC a lot and I don't think she's every shouted at any of them. I wouldn't send mine back there.

Calphurnia88 · 04/01/2023 15:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ah yes, the two classic parenting styles.

A cosy chat with biscuits OR shouting to the point where your own grandchild doesn't want to see you anymore.

🥴

Sherbetdib · 04/01/2023 15:19

Childcare is where you need someone to drop your children off to because you have to be elsewhere.
Spending time with grandchildren for the sake of it is where there is not a 'need', but a 'nice to' and where of course grandparents can come to their grandchildren's home.

Mybonnielad · 04/01/2023 15:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sherbetdib · 04/01/2023 15:10

I remember reading an article ages ago about Grandparents and childcare. They found that Grandparents reverted to parenting in the way they raised their own children. And of course, this could be at odds with the approach their own children now were adopting. So the child gets very mixed messages about things. They concluded that agreements ahead about the way things need to be is what is required. Easier said than done though.

Calphurnia88 · 04/01/2023 15:08

DangerousAlchemy · 04/01/2023 14:51

I wouldn't describe 'ocassionally' as once a wk! If your parents look after your 4 year old all day once a week I think that's a lot to expect of them tbh! How old are your parents? I spend time with my 6 year old nephew (I'm 47 but my kids are 14 18) and I find him exhausting after a while. I'm always relieved to wave goodbye & head home and spend time with my lovely teenagers. 4 year old boys are often hard work imo!

OP has clarified that she isn't reliant on GP for childcare, and they want to do it to spend time with their GC.

But even this wasn't the case, I fail to see how any of what you have written is a reason or excuse for shouting at a 4yo child to the extent where they don't want to see you anymore?

There seems to be a bizarre notion on Mumsnet that if someone is providing free childcare (which is a twisted way of saying spending time with GP) then parents lose any right to complain about things that are obviously not in the best interests of the child.

GUARDIAN1 · 04/01/2023 15:06

I'd have a chat with your parents. As others have said, children can experience being told off as shouting even if voices were not particularly raised. If your mum IS really shouting a lot though, I would ask her either to consider the impact it's having on her relationship with her grandchild or see if you can agree how discipline will be handled. Shouting can really impact children's self-esteem, especially if this is by a primary care-giver. When it's a grandparent it's likely to damage the relationship long-term and I'd guess your mum would be upset to think of this happening. I'm by no means perfect. My grandchild lives with me so it's more a parental relationship and I do occasionally raise my voice. I always feel shit afterwards when I see their crestfallen look, and try to avoid it as much as possible.