Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my parents not to shout at my 4yr old?

212 replies

TooConflictedConfused · 03/01/2023 22:17

My DC (4years old) came back from the grandparents today and told me and my OH that they didn’t like going to my mum’s house. The reason being that when ‘they do wrong things their gran shouts at them’. Then we asked what wrong things they did they said they couldn’t remember, they only remembered the shouting and that they did wrong things all the time. And they also said that’s why they don’t miss their gran cause they get shouted at all the time by her.

Occasionally I ask my parents to help with childcare but it’s no more than once a week. My DC was meant to go to my parents again tomorrow but now I’m thinking of keeping them at home and taking a day off from work.

Any advice on how to approach this with my parents? AIBU to expect my parents not to shout?

My DC is only 4 and generally a super well-behaved kid and never has any complaints from school or after school nanny re behaviours.

My dad is a mild mannered person but generally leaves the childcare to my mum. For background my mum is a school of tough love parent and shouted at me a lot whilst I was growing up and also used corporal punishment. I hence was super triggered by the revelation and would love some objective advice on how to deal with the situation.

OP posts:
browneyes77 · 05/01/2023 18:47

Remaker · 04/01/2023 04:51

Shouting was my mother’s go to method of discipline with her own children. Also corporal punishment which was normal back then. She has provided childcare to 9 GC and never shouted at any of them, apart from the odd shriek if someone was about to jump off a roof or something. It is patently ridiculous to suggest that a GP is incapable of adapting their style when caring for GC. Caring for a child for a few hours is nothing like 24/7 responsibility for several kids.

I have watched my otherwise lovely and well behaved 4yo niece make up a complete bald faced lie in order to be cuddled and comforted by her mum and to get someone else in trouble. I’d gently try to get to the bottom of the ‘shouting’ with the aim of maintaining the relationship.

I quite agree!

CrazyLadie · 05/01/2023 18:46

FangedFrisbee · 03/01/2023 22:23

Totally agree.

See also shouting 'I don't know this person' when I removed them from an area for bad behaviour!!! Blush luckily he looks just like me!!

🤣🤣🤣 bloody kids, sometimes ya just wanna throttle them 😅🤣🤣🤣

CrazyLadie · 05/01/2023 18:45

DuplicateUserName · 03/01/2023 22:21

I think I'd gently find out more first.

My DS used to say someone 'shouted' at him when he was just upset at being told off. I know this because he used to accuse me of doing it 😂

My boy is the same, any sterness to my tone and I am shouting 🙈😆

MsAngst · 05/01/2023 18:40

I had something very similar but with my Dad. My parents don't do regular childcare in the week so a bit different but my Dad was also from the tough love school. He has very fixed ideas about how a child should behave and gets cross quite quickly. To give context to how I dealt with it (apologies for the essay, I'm not good at concise) We had an incident one day we were visiting for the weekend (I was there too) and my son (who was about 8 yrs old at the time) got down from the table before he'd asked to get down. My Dad shouted at him and my son got upset and went to run off so my Dad grabbed his arm hard to pull him back which hurt my son and made him even more upset.
I stood my ground and told my Dad in no uncertain terms that his behaviour to my son was not acceptable and if he did that again he would not be around him again.
As this is my Dad's nature, I then got shouted at (at the age of 42) in a similar vein. I would normally have just conceded to being spoken to like that as its how I grew up but I was in tiger mum mode and didn't care if he perceived my behaviour as disrespectful and rude (in his eyes) I calmly reiterated that his behaviour was not acceptable and that we would leave. He didn't speak to me for a month but my Mum (the more placid one) talked him round. Whilst he does still get a bit shouty at my son it's not really that bad anymore and nothing like it was as he's realised that seeing his DGS is more valuable.
What I'm trying to get at is have a talk with your Mum and find out what went on, you may not get the truth though and if you catch her shouting at your son, take her to task on it calmly and rationally and be firm. She may not like it but I'm guessing she does love your DD and she doesn't know any better if you say she was like it with you. It may be she needs some home truths to make her sit back and realise. You say your Dad is calmer, could you have a talk with him and ask him to talk to your Mum about it?

Teaandsympathy · 05/01/2023 18:34

Going against the grain here but if my 4 year old DC didn't like spending time with someone they see regularly I would be concerned.
I agree I wouldn't take what they say as gospel but I would be concerned.

Jayne35 · 05/01/2023 18:16

Not sure why you allow it at all if your mother shouted at you and hit you?

My parents were totally different with me to how they are with grandchildren. It was a different age then and smacking was common. My Mum absolutely wouldn’t smack my daughter, though I was smacked occasionally.

Madamum18 · 05/01/2023 18:12

Going forward I’ve made it clear to my mother she needs to exercise more patience and not shout especially when there were no big wrongs. End of the day my kid is sensitive so shouting teaches them nothing. She should be a better role model but lacks self awareness and control. I think my dad gets it more and I want to give them a chance to be better

I think she needs to also think about alternatives to shouting. So your child didn't wash his hands when told to. Simple answer is "Ok, your choice, if you don't wash your hands you don't have tea!" Shouting is so totally unnecessary and she needs to understand that!

Also have you had any discussion regarding physical punishment is absolutely and completely not to happen with your son, however difficult he might be as perceived by your mother? If not, I think you need to!!

NannaKaren · 05/01/2023 18:06

Ask you Mum and discuss it calmly with her !

HayleyGg8821 · 05/01/2023 18:02

Exactly this. Perfect response in my opinion, and exactly the same stance I would take! 👍🏻

Rosie22xx · 05/01/2023 17:59

She clearly hasn't changed since your childhood. There will be no words you can say to her for her behaviour to change. You either accept she is that way with your child or you do not send dc there unattended again.

godmum56 · 05/01/2023 17:45

TooConflictedConfused · 03/01/2023 23:44

Yes sorry I realised I phrased it all wrong. As in I meant they see DC once a week AT most on average.

So if it’s the school holidays my mum will ask to see DC cause she’s knows they are available. And ill agree and say ‘do you want to look after them on x day’.

This week they volunteered to have them for 2 afternoons - not the whole day. Today n tomorrow. Pre Christmas we probably didn’t see them for about 2-3 weeks.

Point is I don’t rely on them on childcare but say they want to do it. So I take DC over there to spend time with them.

I want my DC to have a relationship with their grandparents that’s why I let them visit there.

It’s first time DC has brought it up to me and I guess it thrown me a bit.

Not sure why you allow it at all if your mother shouted at you and hit you?

Abigail69 · 05/01/2023 17:43

TBH I feel sorry for your dad

MrPickles73 · 05/01/2023 17:40

'Occasionally I ask my parents to help with childcare but it’s no more than once a week.'
I would say once a week is alot and a 4 year old is pretty exhausting. I would see if your Mum is enjoying it..

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/01/2023 10:57

pillow56 · Yesterday 18:54
I would not send your child to them again and would tell them exactly why”

that's quite rash and a sure way to cause a rift. There is such a tendency on mn to go in with all guns blazing in any situation involving kids reporting being shouted at.

It is ironic as those who say to do it are giving the advice to be gentle in your approach rather than shout and that people should talk things through rather than shout and yet the advice of automatically confronting the teacher, go to the headmaster, tell the parents no more unsupervised visits etc is exactly the same as shouting in that it's a rapid inflammatory response.

You can't automatically take the word of a child. They tend to exaggerate, misconstrue situations or omit key pieces of information in their favour when reporting back. By all means ask what happened but do it with tact and ease. Automatically just taking a child's word and going to war with the gps is just extreme and over escalating a situation”

I disagree. We would not dream of shouting at our grandchild. It’s not our place to do so.

As a general rule, we believed our children and as far as we know they were not liars. They’re good, honest adults now.

anyone shouting at their grandchildren should not be given unsupervised access to them.

poetryandwine · 05/01/2023 10:36

Sounds like a great start, OP. Well done

Calphurnia88 · 05/01/2023 08:52

pillow56 · 05/01/2023 00:39

You sound uneducated

can you not debate a topic without having to resort to insults? There was a poster upthread who said her friend's kid is now out of control as the mum was all ''we don't shout''. That's the problem here, parents have went too far the other way to be super soft with their kids and they lose control.

Ironic that an adult who advocates shouting at children can't handle being called uneducated by a stranger on the internet.

There is a wealth of information and research about why shouting isn't an effective form of discipline, and the alternatives (spoiler: it's not all or nothing). A lot of it for free, including the UNICEF article I posted above, but you have clearly chosen not to read.

Instead you're repeating worn-out clichés and providing pointless anecdotes about 'softie softie' (sic) parents.

Whotsit · 05/01/2023 04:32

Shouting is very poor relationship destroying communication

Whotsit · 05/01/2023 04:30

pillow56 · 05/01/2023 00:39

You sound uneducated

can you not debate a topic without having to resort to insults? There was a poster upthread who said her friend's kid is now out of control as the mum was all ''we don't shout''. That's the problem here, parents have went too far the other way to be super soft with their kids and they lose control.

Strange to hear some parents actually recommend shouting to discipline. I question what this teaches … ie making people do something through fear and that shouting gets someone what they want. Both rubbish life lessons to take into adulthood.

MrsHughesPinny · 05/01/2023 04:13

Your Mum sounds exactly like mine. She screamed and shouted (and hit) our entire childhoods but no one thought there was anything wrong with it back in the 80s.

She still shouts at me now and I’m 40! I had to walk away from her on Christmas Eve because of it and she told me I was being dramatic! She shouts at my DS even though I try not to, but he’s old enough now that it’s water off a duck’s back. She says I’m too soft on him but he’s a good kid. Sounds like your Mum doesn’t really like providing childcare…

Kennykenkencat · 05/01/2023 04:05

pillow56 · 05/01/2023 00:39

You sound uneducated

can you not debate a topic without having to resort to insults? There was a poster upthread who said her friend's kid is now out of control as the mum was all ''we don't shout''. That's the problem here, parents have went too far the other way to be super soft with their kids and they lose control.

I never shouted at either of mine.

If they did something that was not good I would get down at their height and look them in the eye and talk to them about why it wasn’t a good thing to do and what to do in future to not get into that position or what they should have done.

I think a little less shouting and more parenting might help.

Also pick your battles. If you are shouting over a small thing, what do you do when something is a huge deal.

My mother would shout if I was 2minutes late home or 2hours late. (No idea how I was supposed to know the time I didn’t have a watch) There was no difference so if I had actually missed my opportunity to get home in time and I was enjoying my self I just wouldn’t go home. I reasoned the later I left it the less time she would shout at me before I went to bed. So if i arrived back at 6.30pm instead of 2 minutes past 2 it was 4.5 hours of shouting I wouldn’t have to listen to.

pillow56 · 05/01/2023 00:39

You sound uneducated

can you not debate a topic without having to resort to insults? There was a poster upthread who said her friend's kid is now out of control as the mum was all ''we don't shout''. That's the problem here, parents have went too far the other way to be super soft with their kids and they lose control.

Calphurnia88 · 04/01/2023 23:46

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 23:17

End of the day my kid is sensitive so shouting teaches them nothing

or your kid doesn't like being disciplined, not getting her own way or anything that isn't the softie softie approach?

You sound uneducated.

pillow56 · 04/01/2023 23:17

End of the day my kid is sensitive so shouting teaches them nothing

or your kid doesn't like being disciplined, not getting her own way or anything that isn't the softie softie approach?

Isthisexpected · 04/01/2023 22:39

Have you actually spoken about being physically punished as a child and how you don't want this for your child? I'm a bit surprised you think your mum will somehow have learnt knew parenting skills.

TooConflictedConfused · 04/01/2023 21:16

Thanks all for the advice. I’ve had a chat with my parents and DC since.

It seems that there were faults on both sides a) my child being a petulant git and not doing what they’re told (wash hands before dinner etc.) and b) my mother being shouty, impatient thinking she is talking to a 14 year old rather than 4 year old.

Going forward I’ve made it clear to my mother she needs to exercise more patience and not shout especially when there were no big wrongs. End of the day my kid is sensitive so shouting teaches them nothing. She should be a better role model but lacks self awareness and control. I think my dad gets it more and I want to give them a chance to be better.

My parents actually said they don’t see DC enough and they want solo time. But nevertheless I think we do need a reset so kept DC at home today. I’ll let them do a school pick up and quick trip to playground sometime next week. See how it goes from there but keep any exposure time short and less likely to result in escalation.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread