Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my parents not to shout at my 4yr old?

212 replies

TooConflictedConfused · 03/01/2023 22:17

My DC (4years old) came back from the grandparents today and told me and my OH that they didn’t like going to my mum’s house. The reason being that when ‘they do wrong things their gran shouts at them’. Then we asked what wrong things they did they said they couldn’t remember, they only remembered the shouting and that they did wrong things all the time. And they also said that’s why they don’t miss their gran cause they get shouted at all the time by her.

Occasionally I ask my parents to help with childcare but it’s no more than once a week. My DC was meant to go to my parents again tomorrow but now I’m thinking of keeping them at home and taking a day off from work.

Any advice on how to approach this with my parents? AIBU to expect my parents not to shout?

My DC is only 4 and generally a super well-behaved kid and never has any complaints from school or after school nanny re behaviours.

My dad is a mild mannered person but generally leaves the childcare to my mum. For background my mum is a school of tough love parent and shouted at me a lot whilst I was growing up and also used corporal punishment. I hence was super triggered by the revelation and would love some objective advice on how to deal with the situation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MarkHemmings · 19/01/2023 15:50

Only inadequate adults shout at young kids.

SaponificationQueen · 06/01/2023 16:56

I grew up with an abusive mother. After my father passed, my sister allowed her 2 children to stay with our mother for the summer. When I went to see them, she was constantly screaming at them for something or other. It brought back some pretty bad memories from my childhood. I tried to tell her to stop, but it didn’t do any good. She yelled at my nephew for dancing down the hall. She told my niece to go put on a t-shirt to go to the pool. My niece put the t-shirt under her swimsuit. My mother called her stupid and screamed at her to go do it the right way. These kids were 7 and 9. They did not deserve to be treated like that.

I told my sister about it after the kids were back home. She wanted to know why I hadn’t said anything while they were there. I told her she must know since that’s how she treated us as children. They never were allowed to spend time alone with her again.

WhereYouLeftIt · 06/01/2023 16:05

"My parents actually said they don’t see DC enough and they want solo time. But nevertheless I think we do need a reset so kept DC at home today. I’ll let them do a school pick up and quick trip to playground sometime next week. See how it goes from there but keep any exposure time short and less likely to result in escalation."

Interesting. Their response to being told their style of grandparenting is not acceptable is to push for more access. And not just access, but solo access where you will not see their behaviour.

You might have talked to them, but they clearly aren't listening.

browneyes77 · 06/01/2023 13:59

Calphurnia88 · 06/01/2023 11:57

Of course someone was going to mention walking into a busy road 🤦🏻‍♀️

A situation where a child's life is at risk is obviously not the same as dealing with normal infant behaviour, so unless DGM is laying out death traps for DGC then I see no excuse for her to be shouting to the extent where the child says he doesn't want to see/doesn't miss his own grandmother.

She either doesn't understand that shouting isn't an effective form of discipline or she has anger issues. I suspect a bit of both given OPs childhood experiences.

Because I was responding to another poster specifically, who was talking about shouting in general not teaching discipline but instilling fear.

The point I was making to that poster is that sometimes shouting is necessary.

Calphurnia88 · 06/01/2023 11:57

browneyes77 · 05/01/2023 18:54

If a child goes to walk into a busy road, do you think a soft voice saying “now please don’t, come back please” is going to work as well as more stern, shouting voice that portrays and emphasises the danger?

Sometimes shouting is beneficial if it helps a child understand something is serious.

Of course someone was going to mention walking into a busy road 🤦🏻‍♀️

A situation where a child's life is at risk is obviously not the same as dealing with normal infant behaviour, so unless DGM is laying out death traps for DGC then I see no excuse for her to be shouting to the extent where the child says he doesn't want to see/doesn't miss his own grandmother.

She either doesn't understand that shouting isn't an effective form of discipline or she has anger issues. I suspect a bit of both given OPs childhood experiences.

Bignanny30 · 06/01/2023 11:43

Have a calm chat with your mum. Don’t question her as such. Just say that DC says she sometimes shouts. And say that you know that was the way in her day but these days it’s not what we do and it’s not what DC are used to. So PLEASE try not to do it. Also maybe rather than DC be there for a few hours alone, make your next few visits with you there too, so that DC can enjoy Grandma’s company again,in a less stressed situation. Because it’d be a shame for there to be a rift between them.

OriginalUsername2 · 06/01/2023 11:23

DaughterofZion · 05/01/2023 23:06

THIS!!!

Do you really think it’s necessary to set of a small child’s fight or flight response to raise a child with discipline and resilience?

Can’t say being scared of my parents did anything for me! I’ve been an anxious, undisciplined mess most of my life 😅

H007 · 06/01/2023 11:05

My DC used to tell me that she was being told off and that’s why she didn’t like x, y, or z. The reality was that she was just being told what to do, for example in swimming the teacher would say “well done …., next time do x” and DC would perceive that as being told off. She’s now at school and does the same with the teacher when she is corrected. For this reason I wouldn’t always take what my DC say as gospel, but I would find out more.

Stewball01 · 06/01/2023 07:09

Speak to your mum and then speak again to DC.

Mamanyt · 06/01/2023 00:02

You are only being unreasonable in expecting that she would treat your child differently than she treated you. I'd be trying to find other, reliable child care, and not leaving the child with your parents. And, if asked, tell her why, but DO tell her that they are welcome to visit when you can be there, as well. Too soon and too little to be slamming doors in the faces of family.

Angrywife · 05/01/2023 23:48

She's looking after him like she did you, that's how she parents. Not sure why you expected her to be different with your son?

DaughterofZion · 05/01/2023 23:06

BritAbroad101 · 04/01/2023 12:00

Might not be your style (which is fine) but there is nothing wrong with raising your voice at children who are being naughty and under your care

Sometimes I wonder if people on this site are actually bothered about raising a child with discipline and resilience. They need to learn that actions have consequences. If they don’t like the feeling of being shouted at, then don’t be naughty/disobedient!

THIS!!!

T1Dmama · 05/01/2023 22:56

If your mother believes in ‘corporal punishment’ maybe it’s time to find a childminder or friend to help you out?! I wouldn’t send my child at any age into an abusive environment… by continuing to send her after she’s told you Gran scares her is condoning this behaviour and sending a message to child that you think this ok! Then she starts doing it at school or to siblings or at you, because you’ve condoned it.
Honestly isn’t worth the free childcare for the trauma it causes

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 05/01/2023 21:59

I'd say to your mum 'did <insert your child's name> play you up when he was around here last week? He said he was told off.'

See what she says, if he was doing something silly maybe it was warranted 🤷‍♀️

Dominoeffecter · 05/01/2023 21:42

PortiasBiscuit · 03/01/2023 22:22

Er no, no one ever got to shout at my kids except me.. and four is very very young.

😂😂

Missingpop · 05/01/2023 21:41

You know how your mother was with you & this has niggled you enough to consider taking time off from work; so would you be happy for your mother to speak to & treat your Dc the same way she treated you?
Yes then take Dc back tomorrow
No take time off & make fresh arrangements
either way you do need to talk to your parents together; to explain your actions.
Jow she takes it will decide how you deal with future visits but protecting your child is the most important thing x

Middleagedspreadisreal · 05/01/2023 21:36

I made a lot of mistakes with my children, I don't make them with my grandchildren. I don't shout at them or hit them. The thought appalls me. It is possible to change. I can't say wether your Mum has, but tell her what your child has said and ask what happened. It doesn't have to be a confrontation, but you need to let her know that you don't want your child to be subjected to being shouted at.

AnnieSnap · 05/01/2023 19:14

@TooConflictedConfused reading your most recent post, it sounds like you are handling this really well. From what you say, your mother’s default is to shout. You insisting on a boundary on this is a good things and it seems she didn’t argue, so fingers crossed, it will be good going forward.

hiredandsqueak · 05/01/2023 19:14

I'd check whether the shouting is actually shouting or a stern voice because my dc used confuse my being stern with shouting. I do childcare for dgs and whilst I don't shout I will tell dgs off if he needs it. I generally tell dd if I've needed to tell him off but if dgs complains dd always reinforces that gangan would only tell him off for doing something he shouldn't so he shouldn't do it again. You can't really expect childcare and demand that the child isn't chastised if needed but equally your dm needs to know that shouting isn't acceptable either

PUGMEISTER21 · 05/01/2023 19:14

Depends what you mean by shouting. My DD says I have shouted at her when I am just being firm and telling her off. Believe me she would know if I was shouting, I could have made a town crier with my lungs. So it it is not unreasonable for them to discipline her but aggressively shout/raise voice yes, unreasonable.

CrazyLadie · 05/01/2023 18:58

Greenfairydust · 04/01/2023 08:20

Most people seem to be ignoring the fact that the OP's mother thought it was OK to shout at her routinely and use ''corporal punishment'' with her...

None of that is OK.

This is not about an adult who had to shout because the child was doing something dangerous for example and had to be quickly stopped, it sounds instead like someone who believes this type of parenting (shouting and hitting) is acceptable.

I would be concerned that she has not changed and learned that you should not deal with children that way and will do the same thing to your child. I would stop using her as childcare.

I got all that as a kid too, it was the 80's majority did. But as grandparents I don't think they have ever so much as raised their voice nevermind lift their hand. It was different times when different things were classed as acceptable. I did have a conversation and give them boundaries just so we all knew where we stood and how I wanted to raise my child.

browneyes77 · 05/01/2023 18:57

See also shouting 'I don't know this person' when I removed them from an area for bad behaviour!!! Blush luckily he looks just like me!!

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

browneyes77 · 05/01/2023 18:54

Whotsit · 05/01/2023 04:30

Strange to hear some parents actually recommend shouting to discipline. I question what this teaches … ie making people do something through fear and that shouting gets someone what they want. Both rubbish life lessons to take into adulthood.

If a child goes to walk into a busy road, do you think a soft voice saying “now please don’t, come back please” is going to work as well as more stern, shouting voice that portrays and emphasises the danger?

Sometimes shouting is beneficial if it helps a child understand something is serious.

CrazyLadie · 05/01/2023 18:49

FurAndFeathers · 03/01/2023 22:26

But the OP has actually experienced an entire childhood of being shouted at and hit by her mum.

what are the chances she’s suddenly morphed into a non-shouty caregiver?

It can happen but you need to set boundaries for them. I was spanked as a child and screamed at quite regularly but as Grandparents they are awesome, couldn't fault them but then I sat them down and told them what I would and would not tolerate for my child.

pillow56 · 05/01/2023 18:48

Going against the grain here but if my 4 year old DC didn't like spending time with someone they see regularly I would be concerned

appears to be the prevalent thought so you aren't going against the grain

Swipe left for the next trending thread