Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why Rishi Sunak shelving the 'childcare reform plans' as a bad thing

135 replies

Mummyof287 · 03/01/2023 21:54

Firstly because increasing the ratios would be unsafe and unkind for children, and and unfair for childcare practitioners.
(I used to be one)

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

So why is it being seen as a bad move? Or is that just the media's viewpoint 🤨

OP posts:
RoseAndGeranium · 03/01/2023 23:17

motherfugga · 03/01/2023 22:17

@luxxlisbon this from the poster who made an idiotic and unnecessarily divisive comment about stay at home parents leisurely drinking hot chocolate at the park!

I work to get a break and think stay at home parents are doing the work of gods. It's exceptionally hard work - especially in the early years - and nothing is more important.

From a stay at home mum taking a career break to look after her kids because the combined cost of childcare and a long commute made her job unviable, thank you for saying this. I adore my children and am grateful every day that we can afford this for a couple of years but my god it’s hard work.

tiggergoesbounce · 03/01/2023 23:16

I am another one who thinks diluting the quality of care is a terrible idea by changing ratios.

tiggergoesbounce · 03/01/2023 23:14

It would have changed staffing numbers though - the same amount of children would need fewer staff

Because surely if tiggernursery currently has 20 kids and 10 staff abd ratios are you need 1 staff to 2 kids, if the laws changes and i now only need 2 staff for 4 kids are you suggesting i then sack 5 staff (predominantly women) or am i going to just increase my children numbers if i can per square footage??

(all numbers are examples to keep it simple)

Getoff · 03/01/2023 23:11

Or maybe the fact that something is less safe doesn't automatically mean it should be ruled out, because there are lots of pros and cons that need to be weighed up.

Getoff · 03/01/2023 23:08

Confitofduckand · 03/01/2023 22:18

If you are assessing risk, increasing ratios in settings that are well run will not pose as much safeguarding risk to children as where the setting is not well run.

In this scenario, some children will be more at risk of serious safeguarding failure if ratios are increased.

If 3:1 is better than 4:1 because it's safer, then presumably 2:1 would be even better, and to go further, 1:1 would be the second-best you could do, the best being too completely ban childcare, thus achieving a 100% success rate at children not coming to harm while in childcare.

tiggergoesbounce · 03/01/2023 23:05

It would have changed staffing numbers though - the same amount of children would need fewer staff

Am i missing something, if the idea is not to increase numbers of children into childcare settings, what you are suggesting is they are looking at ways at reducing the amount of workers (women mostly)?

greenteafiend · 03/01/2023 23:05

The ceiling on the maximum numbers permitted in the UK is exceptionally low by international standards; I don't see anything wrong with raising the ceiling a bit on what is permitted (to be more in line with other countries), and allowing childminders, nurseries and parents to make their own decisions on this. There is presumably nothing to stop individual parents and providers choosing to continue to offer lower child:adult ratios if they prefer to do so.

VestaTilley · 03/01/2023 22:50

Sorry I meant I agree with OP that childcare ratios shouldn’t be relaxed.

VestaTilley · 03/01/2023 22:49

Agree with childcare ratios - relaxing them would be horrendously dangerous.

Trymein · 03/01/2023 22:30

“Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.”

It’s not pushing is it? Nobody is forcing this. It’s giving people an option. I’m going to ignore your ridiculous emotional crap. Facts are: women are paid less; women are more likely to be the single parent or bear the brunt of the childcare/custody arrangements. Making childcare unaffordable keeps women from getting a proper pension, not progressing in their career, and therefore have a more comfortable life when their children eventually leave home, etc.

As you can see on here, there are a lot of shit men who keep finances separate, make women fund the childcare and maternity leave, leave and don’t give proper childcare allowance, leave and go on to have more children leaving their others underfunded.

Women do bear the physical, emotional, and financial cost of providing a new generation un-proportionally to men. How would stopping the option of having affordable childcare benefit women in any way?

Iam4eels · 03/01/2023 22:21

It was a shit plan that wouldn't have worked in practice so instead of consulting with stakeholders about what would work and what is needed, they've shelved it with no Plan B to replace it.

Yet another example of our weak PM and his weak government being absolutely useless. It appears that their plan for governance is to just hide away for the next two years, doing as little as possible while remaining in power.

Confitofduckand · 03/01/2023 22:18

LittleBearPad · 03/01/2023 22:02

Why? What is the evidence that 3:1 is safe but 7:2 or 4:1 is dangerous for example

If you are assessing risk, increasing ratios in settings that are well run will not pose as much safeguarding risk to children as where the setting is not well run.

In this scenario, some children will be more at risk of serious safeguarding failure if ratios are increased.

motherfugga · 03/01/2023 22:17

@luxxlisbon this from the poster who made an idiotic and unnecessarily divisive comment about stay at home parents leisurely drinking hot chocolate at the park!

I work to get a break and think stay at home parents are doing the work of gods. It's exceptionally hard work - especially in the early years - and nothing is more important.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 03/01/2023 22:16

Therr should be more recognition that some kids do better at home rather than trying to get everyone into nursery and mothers into the workplace, I think. that’s fine until it takes 2 incomes usually to run a household/ probably more like 3 incomes in reality the way prices are going.

AnotherAppleThief · 03/01/2023 22:15

As a childminder I'm not prepared to look after more children (as higher expenses as a result) for the same amount of money.

daisymade · 03/01/2023 22:12

My childcare works out around £5 an hour. Comparatively the firm I work as a fee earner charge me out at £235/hour…
childcare is cheap if you actually consider what you’re paying people to look after, the most precious thing in any of our lives.

luxxlisbon · 03/01/2023 22:12

@motherfugga Therr should be more recognition that some kids do better at home rather than trying to get everyone into nursery and mothers into the workplace, I think. My youngest is in childcare part time and doesn't love it so as much as I'd appreciate the extra hours, I'm not keen overall as I'd probably feel pressurised to use them. Some children adore full time nursery and thrive while others do not.

Your post just comes across quite selfish though. So other working families who need to have their children in childcare full time shouldn’t receive additional financial help because you don’t want to use them and don’t want to be tempted to?

Making childcare more affordable doesn’t stop someone from keeping their child at home instead of nursery if that’s what suits the family, nor does it encourage it.

Plenty of mothers want to work, affordable childcare doesn’t force them.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 03/01/2023 22:11

The extra hours wouldn’t have been properly funded though- look at the 30hr system currently.

LittleBearPad · 03/01/2023 22:10

Aside from anything else they were only proposing to change ratios and not floor space (you need a certain amount of floor space per child) so it was lip service and wouldn't have changed anything.

It would have changed staffing numbers though - the same number of children would need fewer staff

MaverickSnoopy · 03/01/2023 22:08

I'm thrilled it's been shelved. It was a stupid and ill thought out idea. I work in the sector as does my husband. We don't know anyone IRL or childcare worker Facebook groups who was open to the idea. Childminders (my area) were saying they wouldn't accommodate it full stop. Even nurseries were saying no with staff saying they would leave the sector. It would have crippled the sector further. Aside from anything else they were only proposing to change ratios and not floor space (you need a certain amount of floor space per child) so it was lip service and wouldn't have changed anything.

But. Something must be done. The whole model needs an overhaul. For working parents and for the sector which is on the brink of collapse due to lack of funding and a workforce on it's knees.

motherfugga · 03/01/2023 22:07

I agree though would be unlikely to admit that to anyone in real life!

The proposed childcare ratios would have been a huge backwards step. A civilised society invests more in children, not less.

I'd far prefer to see more Scandi style incentives for fathers to take paternity leaves and other breaks from work personally, which we know help women to take a more equal role both in the workplace and also at home because men do more on the domestic front.

Therr should be more recognition that some kids do better at home rather than trying to get everyone into nursery and mothers into the workplace, I think. My youngest is in childcare part time and doesn't love it so as much as I'd appreciate the extra hours, I'm not keen overall as I'd probably feel pressurised to use them. Some children adore full time nursery and thrive while others do not.

fajitaaaa · 03/01/2023 22:07

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age. you don't HAVE to use it. Childcare basically saved my career and probably my mental health.

StrawberryWater · 03/01/2023 22:07

It’s a bad thing for women who find it tough enough as it is to work with school aged children. For many it’s going to be nigh on impossible to work now until the kids are much older (secondary school aged). Women shouldn’t be made to feel like their only value comes from the home and raising children. It’s not the 1950s any more.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 03/01/2023 22:07

I don't really have an opinion on the ratios (gut feel it would be bad but apparently it works fine in Scotland and I haven't seen data either way hence no opinion).

BUT my understanding is that that was a headline and all aspects have been shelved so there will be no looking into nor support for what a terrible state the industry is in and how expensive it is for parents. That's not good.

luxxlisbon · 03/01/2023 22:06

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

🙄🙄

God imagine prioritising putting food on your table over spending leisurely afternoons with your children playing in the park and drinking hot chocs.

You’re right, most people do just choose to send their children to daycare unnecessarily and pay some of the nights highest rates in Europe to do so.