Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why Rishi Sunak shelving the 'childcare reform plans' as a bad thing

135 replies

Mummyof287 · 03/01/2023 21:54

Firstly because increasing the ratios would be unsafe and unkind for children, and and unfair for childcare practitioners.
(I used to be one)

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

So why is it being seen as a bad move? Or is that just the media's viewpoint 🤨

OP posts:
Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 16:11

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:49

Old enough to have done enough research to know it’s not ideal for children to be away from their parents and shoved into nursery for 45 hours a week. It’s why when I have children I’ll be the one looking after them. I have to be a certain age to care about the psychological effects of children being shoved into nursery all day?

I don't think sending young children to a good nursery for some of the time (or especially in the case of infants, a good childminder) is bad for them by any means...if they are settled in properly and are happy there then it can be a very beneficial experience for them.I was a SAHM with my first, have worked 2.5 days a week with my 2nd (she has been with a lovely CM since 10mths) and both have thrived.Many people can't afford to be SAHM's all the time either.But children ARE often spending too much time in daycare nowadays and not enough time with their mummies/families, and like you say the psychological affects (especially if it's a nursery which is not a 'home from home' environment ) can be damaging for attachments and mental health.

OP posts:
Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 15:11

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 13:37

Personally I don’t think preschool childcare is expensive at all when you consider what you get. There’s already help in the form of tax breaks, free hours and universal credit. It is also for a fairly limited time period. I think there should be more emphasis on state run school based childcare for older children. Take out the profit element and require before and after school care and holiday clubs in schools. The buildings are already available, it’s much more difficult to source that care than full time nursery and it’s expensive given the ability to safely look after much larger numbers of children.

Of course it's expensive. When my son went to nursery it was like 80% of my wage if not more. You don't get free hours until the term after they turn 3. And even then it's 30 hours term time, my bill probably halved but it wasn't completely free. Tax free childcare is a max of 2k a year which isn't really that much comparably. The limit of earnings for UC is low.

I agree after school and holiday care is needed, but I don't think it's needed instead of help for early years.

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 14:35

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 13:37

Personally I don’t think preschool childcare is expensive at all when you consider what you get. There’s already help in the form of tax breaks, free hours and universal credit. It is also for a fairly limited time period. I think there should be more emphasis on state run school based childcare for older children. Take out the profit element and require before and after school care and holiday clubs in schools. The buildings are already available, it’s much more difficult to source that care than full time nursery and it’s expensive given the ability to safely look after much larger numbers of children.

Its super expensive, locally its averaging about £65 per day.

£65 * 5 = £325 per week
£325 * 51 weeks (minus christmas week) = £16,575 per year
£16,575 - £2000 cap = £14,575
£14, 575 / 12 = £1215 per month..

for 1 child.

Plus rent/mortgage (£600-£800),
plus energy (£200-£400),
plus other utilities, council tax etc. (£300-£500)

even taking the middle values thats £2615 per month

then add transportation/commute costs, food, general living costs, clothing and other essentials (£300 - £500)

again take the middle cost, thats £3015 per month.

then what about the nice to haves, holidays, christmas, birthdays, days out (£200-£400)

or an important one.. another child (£1000 with discounts)

thats £4315 per month.

I'm in a £65K income household, we bring in £4000 including our child benefit. Even if you remove the nice to haves, that leaves us with literally nothing left..

How is that not expensive?

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 14:22

Mummyof287 · 07/01/2023 10:43

You seem to be very focused on the needs of the 'women' but what about the needs of the child?!

I agree that things are often imbalanced in that the women are expected to be the ones to work less, sacrafice more career wise, and men are rarely given the affordable option to be the ones to work part time and be home more.

But ultimately, we as parents need to be 'present' with our young children for a decent amount of time, for their emotional health, and attachment/relationship building and to not do so is doing them an injustice.And the government should not be encouraging/making it easier or more expected for parents to spend increasingly less time with their children.

@Mummyof287

"But ultimately, we as parents need to be 'present' with our young children for a decent amount of time, for their emotional health, and attachment/relationship building and to not do so is doing them an injustice"

It's fine to have that opinion, and most families will agree to an extent. I'd love to go part time with my DS to be able to be there for their emotional health.

But not many families can afford it, it costs 2 decent wages to afford to run a house now, unless you want every family on UC struggling on the poverty line? Or does emotional health trump a roof over their head, heat in their rooms and food on the table?

Affordable childcare should be state funded like primary/secondary education. And the ENTIRE system needs reforming.

Additionally, what happens to workforce productivity when all (women) leave to do this childcare? Who picks up the slack?

Also, birth rates are already low, guilting parents into staying at home, or forcing them to will reduce them further.

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 13:37

Personally I don’t think preschool childcare is expensive at all when you consider what you get. There’s already help in the form of tax breaks, free hours and universal credit. It is also for a fairly limited time period. I think there should be more emphasis on state run school based childcare for older children. Take out the profit element and require before and after school care and holiday clubs in schools. The buildings are already available, it’s much more difficult to source that care than full time nursery and it’s expensive given the ability to safely look after much larger numbers of children.

BabyOnBoard90 · 08/01/2023 12:55

The UK is one of the most expensive and hardest places to have a child. Especially in London &South East

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 08/01/2023 12:52

30 hours a week spread over 52 weeks a year is a drop in the ocean for childcare for people working full time
Childcare should be funded depending on people's working hours

Yet if our claim benefits you get 15 hours at 2 and they don't even need it the current system is unfair

NurseryNurse10 · 08/01/2023 12:20

Many parents of the babies that I know of have dropped their children's hours in nursery as they cannot afford it.
I think what people fail to understand is that it isn't just about getting a staff member to work in a nursery, there are certain qualifications needed. For example, in a baby room, you would need one level 3 and at least half the other staff need to be level 2. You can be unqualified and work in a nursery but you can't have 4 unqualified members of staff in a room with no qualified as it's a breach of ofsted.
As was said upthread, if the ratio of kids are increased then it puts more pressure on staff who are already stretched to the limit.
On another note, I speak to colleagues who are level 2 qualified and a lot of them say that there's no point progressing to level 3 as the pay increase is so small, it just isn't worth it.
It really is a dire situation all around for parents and staff.

FortSalem86 · 08/01/2023 09:58

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:49

Old enough to have done enough research to know it’s not ideal for children to be away from their parents and shoved into nursery for 45 hours a week. It’s why when I have children I’ll be the one looking after them. I have to be a certain age to care about the psychological effects of children being shoved into nursery all day?

I am curious to know what percentage of children are in nursery for that long? I imagine a very small minority.

Ricardothesnowman · 08/01/2023 09:53

Changing ratios would lead to less childcare places, not more.

Staff who are paid minimum wage now look after 4 toddlers each.

This is hard, it's not the same as looking after your own child at home, as you need to educate them according to the EYFS. This means activities, planning, recording, reporting, supporting SEN, tons of paperwork etc.
Most staff are trained to at least level 3, many to degree level but all get minimum wage, or just above.

If you increase ratios, to 1:5 you are asking then to do 25% more work for no more money.
Would you stay in a job that asked that of you?

So staff will leave and not be able to be replaced.

There is already a recruitment crisis. Where I work we are already limitng the number of children we take because we can't get enough staff to care for them.
If more leave, we will have to limit it even further.

Nurseries are closing at an alarming rate, making the job harder will only increase this rate.

schratching · 08/01/2023 09:27

I found it difficult to be a stay at home mum to twins. We couldn't afford childcare and we barely scraped by. I found it difficult because it was so undervalued. Nobody says wow you're a stay at home mum. I hated being apart from my kids as well though. It's strange. I would have liked more support to stay with them. Could we support parents that want to look after their own children in anyway? In addition to funding childcare.

LittleBearPad · 07/01/2023 20:40

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:49

Old enough to have done enough research to know it’s not ideal for children to be away from their parents and shoved into nursery for 45 hours a week. It’s why when I have children I’ll be the one looking after them. I have to be a certain age to care about the psychological effects of children being shoved into nursery all day?

Yes, like so many other people, I was the perfect parent before I had children.

PS check your tenses next time.

lieselotte · 07/01/2023 20:38

I don't agree with changing the ratios, at least for the under 3s. 3 babies or 4 toddlers is enough for anyone to look after!

But I do think childcare for the first child/twins should be tax deductible.

lieselotte · 07/01/2023 20:37

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:49

Old enough to have done enough research to know it’s not ideal for children to be away from their parents and shoved into nursery for 45 hours a week. It’s why when I have children I’ll be the one looking after them. I have to be a certain age to care about the psychological effects of children being shoved into nursery all day?

I assume you have, or will, found/find a rich husband then. Otherwise you'll be working to pay the mortgage/rent and feed your child.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 07/01/2023 19:23

rightsforunderfives · 07/01/2023 19:11

@Ineverwannabelikeyou it shouldn't be a choice. If the govt subsidised Early years education properly then it would be a win/win/win. Children, parents AND thé EY sector.

Yes, I agree, what I'm saying is a lot of us don't have a choice but to use childcare. It should be a choice really, as in you shouldn't need two fill time incomes to pay the bills but here we are. But yes, since that won't change proper funding is what we need, however I daresay that won't happen either.

Zombiemum1946 · 07/01/2023 19:22

Being emotionally present doesn't feed, cloth nor house the child. Do you think the tories are going to pay, mostly women, to stay home in order to be emotionally present ? Given they're currently screaming lazy benefits scroungers get back to work, I doubt they're in the emotionally present mind set.

rightsforunderfives · 07/01/2023 19:13

NurseryNurse10 · 07/01/2023 18:49

As a nursery nurse the idea of raising ratios is a ridiculous one. Staff are already on their knees and massively overworked. This would just force even more out of the profession. I've also seen an increase in special needs and behavioural difficulties which is yet another reason to keep ratios the same.
There are so many issues to unpick. Childcare is completely unaffordable, qualified level 3 staff barely exist anymore and nurseries need them to operate safely, staff are paid peanuts for an incredibly stressful job and to be honest I see it getting a lot worse before it gets better.

It shouldn't be called childcare either. As a qualified nursery nurse you do a lot more than that.

rightsforunderfives · 07/01/2023 19:11

@Ineverwannabelikeyou it shouldn't be a choice. If the govt subsidised Early years education properly then it would be a win/win/win. Children, parents AND thé EY sector.

rightsforunderfives · 07/01/2023 19:08

Littlebluedinosaur · 07/01/2023 19:02

Reform is needed but Truss’ plan was bonkers. More help is needed BEFORE the age of three rather than an extra 20 hours at 3. Let’s see funded hours for all children when maternity or shared parental leave needs.

Ratios for two year olds need to stay the same.

Thats because it was supposed to be pre-school education. Some bright spark re-named it childcare and managed to upset all the really highly qualified staff. Loads have left now. Fed up of being treated like babysitters. All the Montessori teachers, EY teachers and educators. Called 'childcare workers' and paid peanuts. If the UK continues to call it childcare it will end up as a babysitting service run by those who didn't do well at school. That's the demographic at the moment. Mostly girls who are doing poorly at school are told to do hair or childcare. It's a desperate situation. Especially for children with SEN. We should be recruiting the brightest and best who understand brain development in the u5s. Instead we're asking for stack it high, sell it cheap, low quality. Tragic for our children.

SausageMonkey2 · 07/01/2023 19:05

Because spending £1400 on childcare each month is quite frankly a nightmare. Reform is due given there isn’t even enough childcare places in the city for everyone who wants one despite the high costs involved.

Littlebluedinosaur · 07/01/2023 19:02

Reform is needed but Truss’ plan was bonkers. More help is needed BEFORE the age of three rather than an extra 20 hours at 3. Let’s see funded hours for all children when maternity or shared parental leave needs.

Ratios for two year olds need to stay the same.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 07/01/2023 18:50

Mummyof287 · 07/01/2023 10:43

You seem to be very focused on the needs of the 'women' but what about the needs of the child?!

I agree that things are often imbalanced in that the women are expected to be the ones to work less, sacrafice more career wise, and men are rarely given the affordable option to be the ones to work part time and be home more.

But ultimately, we as parents need to be 'present' with our young children for a decent amount of time, for their emotional health, and attachment/relationship building and to not do so is doing them an injustice.And the government should not be encouraging/making it easier or more expected for parents to spend increasingly less time with their children.

Yes, and we also need to be able to feed and clothe them, and many of us aren't as privileged as you and need to return to work to be able to do that. Can you fathom that it's not actually a choice for a lot of us?

NurseryNurse10 · 07/01/2023 18:49

As a nursery nurse the idea of raising ratios is a ridiculous one. Staff are already on their knees and massively overworked. This would just force even more out of the profession. I've also seen an increase in special needs and behavioural difficulties which is yet another reason to keep ratios the same.
There are so many issues to unpick. Childcare is completely unaffordable, qualified level 3 staff barely exist anymore and nurseries need them to operate safely, staff are paid peanuts for an incredibly stressful job and to be honest I see it getting a lot worse before it gets better.

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:49

LittleBearPad · 07/01/2023 18:45

Goodness - how old are you?

Old enough to have done enough research to know it’s not ideal for children to be away from their parents and shoved into nursery for 45 hours a week. It’s why when I have children I’ll be the one looking after them. I have to be a certain age to care about the psychological effects of children being shoved into nursery all day?

LittleBearPad · 07/01/2023 18:45

ily0 · 07/01/2023 18:43

God imagine prioritising putting food on your table over spending leisurely afternoons with your children playing in the park and drinking hot chocs.

What a nasty comment. I’m so glad I have a lovely stay at home mum and wasn’t shoved into a nursery for 45 hours a week

Goodness - how old are you?