Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why Rishi Sunak shelving the 'childcare reform plans' as a bad thing

135 replies

Mummyof287 · 03/01/2023 21:54

Firstly because increasing the ratios would be unsafe and unkind for children, and and unfair for childcare practitioners.
(I used to be one)

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

So why is it being seen as a bad move? Or is that just the media's viewpoint 🤨

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 08/01/2023 21:03

Bogasphodel · 08/01/2023 18:56

That’s fab for you but not for those on average let alone low wages etc. I mean £30k pa works out at about £16ph before tax and that’s above the average income in the UK. This logic does not help everyone or even the majority.

Also it’s completely irrelevant. Professional charge out rates bear little relationship to hourly rates of pay. I doubt daisymade is being paid 10% of her charge out rate. Yet her salary is the money is the thing that will need to pay the childcare fees

PinkPink1 · 08/01/2023 20:57

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

It would be great if mums who work full time were entitled to 20 funded hours of childcare a week! This means that women wouldn’t have to stay home and sacrifice their career whilst their male colleagues continue to progress (also struggle financially from not working). The alternative is working full time, but struggling financially to pay for expensive childcare on top of increasing bills.

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 20:57

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 20:55

@BungleandGeorge We aren't arguing about the ratios though. We're telling you how ridiculous you are in saying that £6.50 per hour (when in reality its £65 per day as you have to cover 8 hours of work plus 2 hours commute) is in practice incredibly expensive and unaffordable for even higher earners.

You've clearly not experienced it, so have no knowledge of the realities of putting children into childcare.

Sorry, that should day "were telling you how ridiculous you are when you're saying £6.50 per hour ISNT expensive, when in fact its utterly unaffordable for most when taking into account the rest of the expenditure you have to just cover basic necessities

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 20:55

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 20:45

£190 a week on those incomes with 2 children on £6.50 an hour child care.

increasing ratios to reduce cost of care would of course also benefit high earners. I’m not sure there’s any evidence it would significantly reduce costs to the end user though. Especially due to likely staffing issues with asking those on poor pay to look after more children for the same amount of money

@BungleandGeorge We aren't arguing about the ratios though. We're telling you how ridiculous you are in saying that £6.50 per hour (when in reality its £65 per day as you have to cover 8 hours of work plus 2 hours commute) is in practice incredibly expensive and unaffordable for even higher earners.

You've clearly not experienced it, so have no knowledge of the realities of putting children into childcare.

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 20:45

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:39

And 2k tax free childcare is all you get. Because let's face it, your partner or husband is working full time so even if they're on min wage you've a 40k ish joint income.... Wonder how much UC you'd get. Not a great deal I imagine. Not enough to fund a second child going to nursery that is for certain.

All these bold claims and clearly no actual experience.

£190 a week on those incomes with 2 children on £6.50 an hour child care.

increasing ratios to reduce cost of care would of course also benefit high earners. I’m not sure there’s any evidence it would significantly reduce costs to the end user though. Especially due to likely staffing issues with asking those on poor pay to look after more children for the same amount of money

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 20:27

It baffles me how someone can be so utterly confident of something they clearly do not understand. Yes, per hour it's not 80%, but you don't pay per hour. And you definitely don't get 85% of it paid.

If someone like you can't wrap their head around it it's no wonder rishi doesn't have a fucking clue. Blinded by privilege.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 20:24

You can do the calculator yourself if you like. Maybe read up on universal credit whilst you're there.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 20:22

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 20:06

Yes I have, I presume you haven’t?
nmw post tax and NI is £9 per hour (40 hour week) or £9.15 per hour (37.5 hour week). £6.50 is 80% of £8.13.
so maybe explain how it’s more than 80%?

at that income level you’d be getting 80% of childcare through UC. If you have a high earning partner no you wouldn’t but limits aren’t that low.

£6.50 per hour really isn’t expensive for the service provided.

Because you don't pay for 37.5 hour a week of nursery you pay for 50 at full time.

And no, you wouldn't. Two adults on min wage with a childcare bill of £65 a day full time job get just over £100 a month. I did the calculator.

Check again.

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 20:06

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:37

Have you done the maths on it being nothing like 80%? ....... I don't think you have. Minimum wage is less than 20k gross. Just over £1400 per month and that's not taking into account any pension payments. £65 a day, full time works out to be about £1408 a month. No it's nothing like 80% it's more Biscuit

Yes I have, I presume you haven’t?
nmw post tax and NI is £9 per hour (40 hour week) or £9.15 per hour (37.5 hour week). £6.50 is 80% of £8.13.
so maybe explain how it’s more than 80%?

at that income level you’d be getting 80% of childcare through UC. If you have a high earning partner no you wouldn’t but limits aren’t that low.

£6.50 per hour really isn’t expensive for the service provided.

Margarita45 · 08/01/2023 19:17

Pinkbananas01 · 04/01/2023 10:00

In Scotland all children aged 3 get 30hours funded childcare so this is correct. Although funded payments appear better up here they still do not cover actual costs of care, which is a huge issue re sustainability of any childcare business.
Re ratios they are actually much stricter here - childminders can only look after 3 children below school aged whereas in England they can look after more already & can vary this themselves which is not allowed here. There are no plans to increase ratios here so d9nt know where this has come from.

Worth noting that the increase in hours in Scotland led to council nurseries doing mass recruitment, which in turn led to so many experienced childcare staff moving out of private sector for the better holidays and hours etc.

Result has been private nurseries closing due to lack of staff, or those that have survived are doing so by relying on trainees/junior staff.

I was relieved when my kids went to school, as they difference one their nursery in the couple of years since the increase was really concerning. They even changed the opening hours which scuppered a lot of working parents as the early opening was scrapped.

Bogasphodel · 08/01/2023 18:56

daisymade · 03/01/2023 22:12

My childcare works out around £5 an hour. Comparatively the firm I work as a fee earner charge me out at £235/hour…
childcare is cheap if you actually consider what you’re paying people to look after, the most precious thing in any of our lives.

That’s fab for you but not for those on average let alone low wages etc. I mean £30k pa works out at about £16ph before tax and that’s above the average income in the UK. This logic does not help everyone or even the majority.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:45

Oh and, you can't claim universal credit and use tax free childcare. It's one or the other.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:39

And 2k tax free childcare is all you get. Because let's face it, your partner or husband is working full time so even if they're on min wage you've a 40k ish joint income.... Wonder how much UC you'd get. Not a great deal I imagine. Not enough to fund a second child going to nursery that is for certain.

All these bold claims and clearly no actual experience.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:37

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:35

@onesadmama @Ineverwannabelikeyou

how is £6.50 an hour expensive to look after a young child? It is really not a lot of money for the service provided at all. If they’re on a 1:3 ratio that’s a total of less than £20 per hour, I can’t even see how that is covering costs tbh! It’s nowhere near 80% of nmw and you’d be able to get tax free childcare and UC childcare help (the cut off is much higher than nmw and you’d be getting child elements and child benefit as well). Free hours at 3.
yes having children invariably costs money. I don’t think childcare should be made less safe to save money. And nursery workers are already poorly paid, I don’t think it’s right to make their job even harder

Have you done the maths on it being nothing like 80%? ....... I don't think you have. Minimum wage is less than 20k gross. Just over £1400 per month and that's not taking into account any pension payments. £65 a day, full time works out to be about £1408 a month. No it's nothing like 80% it's more Biscuit

Throwncrumbs · 08/01/2023 18:34

Far worse in hospitals where nurses are allocated 7 patients, often more and they just have to get on with it for no extra pay.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:32

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 16:23

I do work...never said I didn't 🤔 And I certainly wouldn't say we are 'privileged' financially by any means, we are on a fairly low income, live month to month and can't afford luxurious extras.

I'm not saying everyone should be stay at home parents, but a child being in childcare whilst a parent working part time afew days a week is very different to them being there 8-6 four or five days a week, which does happen more than it should.

If you're able to live on one salary you are privileged.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:31

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:35

@onesadmama @Ineverwannabelikeyou

how is £6.50 an hour expensive to look after a young child? It is really not a lot of money for the service provided at all. If they’re on a 1:3 ratio that’s a total of less than £20 per hour, I can’t even see how that is covering costs tbh! It’s nowhere near 80% of nmw and you’d be able to get tax free childcare and UC childcare help (the cut off is much higher than nmw and you’d be getting child elements and child benefit as well). Free hours at 3.
yes having children invariably costs money. I don’t think childcare should be made less safe to save money. And nursery workers are already poorly paid, I don’t think it’s right to make their job even harder

Oh dear. You've no a clue have you?

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:30

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:38

And financial support for childcare has already increased substantially recently. A few years ago you got 15 hours free term time only and it used to be nothing!

Yes and back when it was nothing, the cost of living was not as it was. Houses were not as expensive as they are. You could run a household on one average salary. Can you do that now? No.

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 18:22

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:38

And financial support for childcare has already increased substantially recently. A few years ago you got 15 hours free term time only and it used to be nothing!

You are completely oblivious to the needs of the majority.
It. Is. Not. Enough.

If we want safe, high quality childcare with well paid staff AND a productive workforce AND a strong economy we NEED state funded childcare for ALL working parents.
And unfortunately that only comes from increasing taxes or reducing expenditure elsewhere.

The middle age torys need to start investing in the babies who will be their nurses and carers when they're elderly 🙄, otherwise they won't have anyone as noone will be able to afford to live and have children

AbreathofFrenchair · 08/01/2023 18:19

Mummyof287 · 03/01/2023 21:54

Firstly because increasing the ratios would be unsafe and unkind for children, and and unfair for childcare practitioners.
(I used to be one)

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

So why is it being seen as a bad move? Or is that just the media's viewpoint 🤨

The problem is the funding doesnt match the hourly rate of the nurseries either so private day nurseries would be forced to shut down.

People already hold disgusting views of nurseries, extra 20 hours funding would be the final nail in the coffin of an already struggling sector.

onesadmama · 08/01/2023 18:16

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:35

@onesadmama @Ineverwannabelikeyou

how is £6.50 an hour expensive to look after a young child? It is really not a lot of money for the service provided at all. If they’re on a 1:3 ratio that’s a total of less than £20 per hour, I can’t even see how that is covering costs tbh! It’s nowhere near 80% of nmw and you’d be able to get tax free childcare and UC childcare help (the cut off is much higher than nmw and you’d be getting child elements and child benefit as well). Free hours at 3.
yes having children invariably costs money. I don’t think childcare should be made less safe to save money. And nursery workers are already poorly paid, I don’t think it’s right to make their job even harder

Did you not read our replies to you.

I literally costed out the price of having 2 children in childcare for a household with no debt and barely any non essential spend. And it came to over £4300 per month.

£6.50 pee hour doesn't seem alot but most family's spend well over 50% of their income on it, which makes it expensive.

Are only the rich (and I mean super rich because its even a stretch for £70k+ households) allowed children?

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:38

And financial support for childcare has already increased substantially recently. A few years ago you got 15 hours free term time only and it used to be nothing!

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 16:38

rightsforunderfives · 07/01/2023 19:08

Thats because it was supposed to be pre-school education. Some bright spark re-named it childcare and managed to upset all the really highly qualified staff. Loads have left now. Fed up of being treated like babysitters. All the Montessori teachers, EY teachers and educators. Called 'childcare workers' and paid peanuts. If the UK continues to call it childcare it will end up as a babysitting service run by those who didn't do well at school. That's the demographic at the moment. Mostly girls who are doing poorly at school are told to do hair or childcare. It's a desperate situation. Especially for children with SEN. We should be recruiting the brightest and best who understand brain development in the u5s. Instead we're asking for stack it high, sell it cheap, low quality. Tragic for our children.

You've got it spot on! I witnessed many great practitioners move onto better paid jobs with better career progression and t's & c's and it was such a loss to the children.Some of the people working in nurseries are amazing but others have no idea of how to help a child develop and learn, don't care for them in an emotionally sensitive way or understand how to manage their behaviour appropriately because their heart isn't in it or they have been pushed/fallen into it without the correct skillset for the job

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 16:35

@onesadmama @Ineverwannabelikeyou

how is £6.50 an hour expensive to look after a young child? It is really not a lot of money for the service provided at all. If they’re on a 1:3 ratio that’s a total of less than £20 per hour, I can’t even see how that is covering costs tbh! It’s nowhere near 80% of nmw and you’d be able to get tax free childcare and UC childcare help (the cut off is much higher than nmw and you’d be getting child elements and child benefit as well). Free hours at 3.
yes having children invariably costs money. I don’t think childcare should be made less safe to save money. And nursery workers are already poorly paid, I don’t think it’s right to make their job even harder

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 16:23

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 07/01/2023 18:50

Yes, and we also need to be able to feed and clothe them, and many of us aren't as privileged as you and need to return to work to be able to do that. Can you fathom that it's not actually a choice for a lot of us?

I do work...never said I didn't 🤔 And I certainly wouldn't say we are 'privileged' financially by any means, we are on a fairly low income, live month to month and can't afford luxurious extras.

I'm not saying everyone should be stay at home parents, but a child being in childcare whilst a parent working part time afew days a week is very different to them being there 8-6 four or five days a week, which does happen more than it should.

OP posts: