Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why Rishi Sunak shelving the 'childcare reform plans' as a bad thing

135 replies

Mummyof287 · 03/01/2023 21:54

Firstly because increasing the ratios would be unsafe and unkind for children, and and unfair for childcare practitioners.
(I used to be one)

Secondly because '20 more hours free childcare' would basically be the government pushing/encouraging parents to prioritise working before their children, and to be more likely to send them to daycare for longer than is emotionally healthy to be apart from their families at such a young age.

So why is it being seen as a bad move? Or is that just the media's viewpoint 🤨

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fairywhale · 15/03/2023 20:31

To keep women in their place - just

whatkatydid2013 · 14/03/2023 17:36

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 16:23

I do work...never said I didn't 🤔 And I certainly wouldn't say we are 'privileged' financially by any means, we are on a fairly low income, live month to month and can't afford luxurious extras.

I'm not saying everyone should be stay at home parents, but a child being in childcare whilst a parent working part time afew days a week is very different to them being there 8-6 four or five days a week, which does happen more than it should.

Like many things it’s not optimal but it’s unlikely to cause any actual harm particularly if time with kids is prioritised when parents are with them. The idea if someone is a SAHP they will always be spending all their day engaged with their kids is also a bit unrealistic. Certainly my kids who went to nursery for 4 10.5 hour days were screen free for massively longer than a lot of their peers and things like their communication, numeracy, fine motor skills, problem solving, ability to share, dress themselves, manage toileting independently and to follow instructions in a group were all ahead of those who didn’t go to nursery when they started school. On the other hand I do think my eldest sometimes struggles with confidence and she can need lots of reassurance. All these things might be to do with having been in childcare or then again they might be coincidence. It’s definitely not as straightforward as SAHP = good and nursery = bad though

rightsforunderfives · 10/01/2023 21:29

Or actually maybe you weren't replying to me, now I've read it back!!

rightsforunderfives · 10/01/2023 21:27

Lili132 · 10/01/2023 21:21

Surely parents who believe that longer hours in nursery are unhealthy for their child do not have to use extra funding?
Lots of children all over the world are at nursery full time and they are absolutely fine and happy.
You must also speak from either very privileged position or be a little narrow minded. I personally believe that me not being able to afford days out, visit our family or buy healthy food because I don't have enough money due to childcare cost is not good for my child.
I also strongly believe that my inability to work full time will impact my future earnings and chance of saving for my child's future education or eventually buying own house etc.
Being underemployed is a huge risk for stability and financial safety. I have been in this situation before as a single parent and never want me or my children to experience that again.

So as you see it's not as black and white and everyone's priorities are different depending on their own life situations. It does not make them right or wrong and its important people (women) have choices!

I think I've not been clear. Sorry. I'm not saying that children don't do well in nursery at all. I'm saying that children need to be in AMAZING nurseries! They proof is there that nurseries can be future-changing (in a good way) for a lot of children. The caveat is that they MUST be good. So the government not subsidising them with an amount to make them affordable is really wrong. I'm very pro early years education. I'm very anti the term 'childcare' because it's derogatory to those that teach small children (a very particular skill), and actually to the children themselves. They're capable of so much at that age, and a lot more competent than they're given credit for! They need to be with well-qualified and knowledgeable staff.

Lili132 · 10/01/2023 21:21

Surely parents who believe that longer hours in nursery are unhealthy for their child do not have to use extra funding?
Lots of children all over the world are at nursery full time and they are absolutely fine and happy.
You must also speak from either very privileged position or be a little narrow minded. I personally believe that me not being able to afford days out, visit our family or buy healthy food because I don't have enough money due to childcare cost is not good for my child.
I also strongly believe that my inability to work full time will impact my future earnings and chance of saving for my child's future education or eventually buying own house etc.
Being underemployed is a huge risk for stability and financial safety. I have been in this situation before as a single parent and never want me or my children to experience that again.

So as you see it's not as black and white and everyone's priorities are different depending on their own life situations. It does not make them right or wrong and its important people (women) have choices!

rightsforunderfives · 09/01/2023 10:04

This is what children’s centres were for. Sadly, while early education is considered ‘childcare’ a job that most people consider to be something anyone can do, there won’t be the funding to pay for the highly skilled people we actually need. You said you found it hard to look after your twins. That’s because being with young children is an extremely hard job. It needs a genuine skill to do well. To understand attachment, brain development, sensitive periods and so on. Done well we could genuinely change society. The word childcare needs to be banned from EY education. It’s ruinous for the sector. No one wants to be called a ‘childcare worker’. Especially not highly trained EY teachers, Montessori teachers etc who are the people we need. From birth.

onesadmama · 09/01/2023 00:21

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 22:09

I certainly don't think alot of couples nowadays can afford for one parent not to work at all...I think most can afford for one parent to work part time, if they are willing to cut out 'extras' to prioritise working less and being at home with the DCs more.

Please tell me how, because we certainly can't.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 22:20

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 22:09

I certainly don't think alot of couples nowadays can afford for one parent not to work at all...I think most can afford for one parent to work part time, if they are willing to cut out 'extras' to prioritise working less and being at home with the DCs more.

Based on?

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 22:09

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 22:01

Well then surely you can understand that not everyone can afford to work part time or not at all? I'm not sure many of us actually want to work full time and use full time childcare, you know?

I certainly don't think alot of couples nowadays can afford for one parent not to work at all...I think most can afford for one parent to work part time, if they are willing to cut out 'extras' to prioritise working less and being at home with the DCs more.

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 08/01/2023 22:05

YABU because perhaps the childcare reforms need to be more than just about ratios or hours but accessibility and affordability. And it may shine a greater light on inflexible work and low paid hours.

the UK is far far behind what could be done about childcare.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 22:01

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 21:58

Well as i say we don't live on one salary now, but if you are referring to my response to the PP upthread where I said I used to be a SAHM- it wasn't because we could actually really afford for me to be by any means (although it did save money on childcare fees and not having to run 2 cars) it was because I had bad postnatal anxiety around DD1's welfare, and literally felt like I could barely trust myself to meet my high expectations of how she should be cared for, not alone anyone else!

I WANTED to return to work part time, but in the mindset I was in back then I could never have brought myself to do so as I would have felt like i would have been failing my child if I did.
We claimed UC alongside DH's relatively low wage to help get us by, but still ended up in debt especially when larger/unexpected expenditures came along such as car bills or Christmas.

Luckily I got CBT when DD1 was a toddler and slowly learnt how to let go and to trust others, so things have been very different with DD2.
(Not that I regret all the lovely times DD1 and I got to spend together)

But we certainly have never been 'financially privileged'...

Well then surely you can understand that not everyone can afford to work part time or not at all? I'm not sure many of us actually want to work full time and use full time childcare, you know?

rightsforunderfives · 08/01/2023 22:00

No. The nursery premises will be a LOT more than a village hall!

Mummyof287 · 08/01/2023 21:58

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 18:32

If you're able to live on one salary you are privileged.

Well as i say we don't live on one salary now, but if you are referring to my response to the PP upthread where I said I used to be a SAHM- it wasn't because we could actually really afford for me to be by any means (although it did save money on childcare fees and not having to run 2 cars) it was because I had bad postnatal anxiety around DD1's welfare, and literally felt like I could barely trust myself to meet my high expectations of how she should be cared for, not alone anyone else!

I WANTED to return to work part time, but in the mindset I was in back then I could never have brought myself to do so as I would have felt like i would have been failing my child if I did.
We claimed UC alongside DH's relatively low wage to help get us by, but still ended up in debt especially when larger/unexpected expenditures came along such as car bills or Christmas.

Luckily I got CBT when DD1 was a toddler and slowly learnt how to let go and to trust others, so things have been very different with DD2.
(Not that I regret all the lovely times DD1 and I got to spend together)

But we certainly have never been 'financially privileged'...

OP posts:
Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:55

Did you do it as renting? I did it as mortgage. Since housing benefits not got anything to do with childcare....

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:50

And no @BungleandGeorge I can't work it out so please can you tell us all? It'll be really helpful. There's such obvious solutions and none of us can see them....

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:49

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:35

No it was based on 2 people. Your original message mentioned one person which I replied to and then you gave an example of 2 people for UC.

ive Paid for childcare as most people probably have. Having kids isn’t free. I don’t quite see your point about ‘privilege’ and I’d say you have no clue about anybody else’s circumstances. My costs were higher because there were not 30 hours free. I’m sure everyone can work out ways to reduce nursery fees between 2 parents it’s not rocket science.

you both said £6.50 was expensive, for the service you get it’s really cheap. And the average cost is actually more like £5.20 an hour

Post a screenshot then because it's very, very different to the results I got and I know I got it right.

Presumably your mortgage and cost of living was lower If your children are older now. Swings and roundabouts. Don't bleet about how you had it so much harder when you've no real idea of how hard it is now.

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2023 21:42

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:41

Compare it to a kids activity class that you have to stay and supervise them at then! Music with mummy is £5 for half an hour..

But that’s not a relevant comparison is it. The nursery won’t be paying to hire a hall for 30 minutes. They won’t have to traipse their guitar and giant parachute around from place to place.

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:41

Bogasphodel · 08/01/2023 21:31

I agree! It’s still an unhelpful comparison though!

Compare it to a kids activity class that you have to stay and supervise them at then! Music with mummy is £5 for half an hour..

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2023 21:39

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:35

No it was based on 2 people. Your original message mentioned one person which I replied to and then you gave an example of 2 people for UC.

ive Paid for childcare as most people probably have. Having kids isn’t free. I don’t quite see your point about ‘privilege’ and I’d say you have no clue about anybody else’s circumstances. My costs were higher because there were not 30 hours free. I’m sure everyone can work out ways to reduce nursery fees between 2 parents it’s not rocket science.

you both said £6.50 was expensive, for the service you get it’s really cheap. And the average cost is actually more like £5.20 an hour

How much did you pay?

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:35

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:05

I quite clearly said two full time on minimum wage. Your results are based on one person?

Ah. Yes, as I said. Not a fucking clue.

What are those options for reducing childcare costs? I'm sure most of Mumsnet would like to know.

What a joke.

No it was based on 2 people. Your original message mentioned one person which I replied to and then you gave an example of 2 people for UC.

ive Paid for childcare as most people probably have. Having kids isn’t free. I don’t quite see your point about ‘privilege’ and I’d say you have no clue about anybody else’s circumstances. My costs were higher because there were not 30 hours free. I’m sure everyone can work out ways to reduce nursery fees between 2 parents it’s not rocket science.

you both said £6.50 was expensive, for the service you get it’s really cheap. And the average cost is actually more like £5.20 an hour

Bogasphodel · 08/01/2023 21:31

I agree! It’s still an unhelpful comparison though!

LittleBearPad · 08/01/2023 21:20

@BungleandGeorge do you pay for childcare at present? If yes, how much for how many hours?

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:05

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:04

You didn’t mention you had a partner earning money and contributing. You spoke about one wage.
there are multiple options to reduce childcare costs, especially if there are 2 parents. i don’t think reducing safety for children should be an option

I quite clearly said two full time on minimum wage. Your results are based on one person?

Ah. Yes, as I said. Not a fucking clue.

What are those options for reducing childcare costs? I'm sure most of Mumsnet would like to know.

What a joke.

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 21:04

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 20:45

£190 a week on those incomes with 2 children on £6.50 an hour child care.

increasing ratios to reduce cost of care would of course also benefit high earners. I’m not sure there’s any evidence it would significantly reduce costs to the end user though. Especially due to likely staffing issues with asking those on poor pay to look after more children for the same amount of money

Do you want to show us those results? Because that's not what I got. It's wildly different.

Nobody is arguing you about the ratios, just the affordability which you cannot seem to accept you have got wrong.

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 21:04

Ineverwannabelikeyou · 08/01/2023 20:27

It baffles me how someone can be so utterly confident of something they clearly do not understand. Yes, per hour it's not 80%, but you don't pay per hour. And you definitely don't get 85% of it paid.

If someone like you can't wrap their head around it it's no wonder rishi doesn't have a fucking clue. Blinded by privilege.

You didn’t mention you had a partner earning money and contributing. You spoke about one wage.
there are multiple options to reduce childcare costs, especially if there are 2 parents. i don’t think reducing safety for children should be an option

Swipe left for the next trending thread