Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu or him: Car broke down

112 replies

Snorkers · 03/01/2023 18:46

Husband hit a pot hole near his work about 45 mine away from home and burst a tyre. No harm beyond that and he pulled into a large, safe stopping place to ait for recovery. e doesn't have a spare - been meaning to get one but never got around to it.
The breakdown peopel are really busy and 1hr15mins later still haven't got someone out.
He wants me to go and pick him up so he doesn't have to wait and let the recovery peoek bring the car bac when they have time, but that will mean a 2 x 50 min trip for me to get him, I have made arrangements to be somewhere soon and I have also already done a full day at work plus 2 hours of house chores and pet care for us.
AIBU to tell him to just hang on and wait rather than us both have to spend hours dealing with this?

OP posts:
Snorkers · 03/01/2023 20:40

He gave up waiting and found a mobile tyre place willing to come out for a few hundred quid. All sorted on on his way home.

We have recovery to home so not a problem bringing the car home but I think it would hae been a risk leaving the key. What if someone nicked it, or the company that got allocated the job decided not to take the car without him too?

But let's get one thing straight though! He was NOT in danger. He was NOT a damsel in distress in the fucking pissing rain - he ONLY HAD A FLAT TYRE. He sat there parked up in a layby bored on his iphone in the warm dry car with the engine on, nice and dry and SAFE.

No - I would not give up my evening to go and sit there so we both waste a night - today I have already cleaned our clothes, hung them up, dried them, taken our dogs out, cleaned the kitchen, put the washing up away, done a 9 hour work day, taken the dogs out again.

All the man has to do it sit there for a few hours, why should I jack my evening plans in so we both waste hours.? What if I got there and they'd just arrived? I would not have left him there all night, of course not - but waiting litle over an hour before asking your wife gives up her evening to alleviate your boredom? No thank you.

OP posts:
laurenlodge · 03/01/2023 20:39

He's likely to be waiting hours - what a miserable evening/night. I'm pretty hard-hearted generally but I would go and get my partner in this situation or at least take him some things to be more comfy. Couldn't enjoy my evening knowing he was just stuck waiting endlessly.

Dibbydoos · 03/01/2023 20:32

And if the boot was on the other foot, what would you expect?!

pocketvenuss · 03/01/2023 20:22

I wonder if everyone saying to leave him would say the same if the roles were reversed.

I'd hate to be waiting what could be many many hours in the dark in the side of the road. I'm sure he is hating it too.

Lockheart · 03/01/2023 20:22

rwalker · 03/01/2023 20:18

As a male in a safe place he’ll be the lowest of the low priority
I was 5.5 hours the other months cancelled technician on way twice to send to higher priority
they outsourced it in the end

Last summer some visiting family members were stuck at my parents house for over 24 hours!

Lockheart · 03/01/2023 20:21

Most cars are no longer sold / made with spares, and this has been going on for almost a decade, so it's probably more common to not have one than to have one nowadays. I wouldn't say someone is an idiot for not having one.

rwalker · 03/01/2023 20:18

As a male in a safe place he’ll be the lowest of the low priority
I was 5.5 hours the other months cancelled technician on way twice to send to higher priority
they outsourced it in the end

LostInSpaceRaiders · 03/01/2023 20:14

I would go and collect my husband, and then let him have the use of my car while I went out if I was desperate to continue with my plans, or stay home with him if I thought that I would need to drop him back at the car and then bring mine home.

At best they’ll be able to put a space saver on his car so it can go back to a garage for repair, but most likely they’ll just put it onto a flat loader to their garage for new tyre fitment in the morning and he’ll probably be left without a means of getting home at that point anyway. As an able bodied male he’ll be so far down the priority list it could be tomorrow before they get to him.

I certainly wouldn’t leave him in his car in the pissing rain and the freezing cold so I could go out to fulfil my plans, nor have I done that in the past when he’s needed me to collect him for similar reasons. But, then my husband has and would do the same for me without question. Likewise my closest friends.

OnlyFannys · 03/01/2023 20:11

I'd be worried about the insurance being invalidated as well, I would want to call my insurance first and check rather than rely on a random call centre workers advice. Can he not head to a local fast food place or something or get public transport if he is desperate to go home

HikingforScenery · 03/01/2023 20:09

Astralitzia · 03/01/2023 18:51

I can't imagine leaving my partner stranded for an unknown period of time (which could be hours and hours based on my most recent experience of a breakdown) on a dark rainy evening when I could bring him home, nor could I imagine my partner leaving me stranded! Surely this is the sort of thing you do for each other in a caring relationship?

I cannot imagine thinking twice about this request tbh. I’d suggest picking him up
in the first place.

ChigedyJigHeeHawHeeHawItsDominicTheDonkey · 03/01/2023 20:03

Brefugee · 03/01/2023 18:50

I wouldn't fetch him either. And now he has learned why you should carry a spare ready to put on when you need it.

Not all cars have a spare tire! My Mazda didn't it just had a can of foam that pretty much rendered any tire useless that it was sprayed into.

ChigedyJigHeeHawHeeHawItsDominicTheDonkey · 03/01/2023 20:00

SharksInTheTea · 03/01/2023 18:53

It's not the effort of going to get him that would bother me - I'd do that in a heartbeat. It's that the recovery people will not handle an abandoned car within the owner present, I don't think.

When I accidentally locked my keys inside the boot of my car and had to get the AA out to get into my car. I left my car in the carpark where it was and went for a wonder around. I already knew there would be a good 2 hour wait. AA guy rang me to say he was nearly there. Told him I was on my way back and I would meet him back at the car. When I got there he was already making a start on trying to open the lock back up. In the end though we had to wait for another AA guy to come with a drill to drill the lock out. I was massively grateful to the travel lodge that who let me use their toilet and gave me a free coffee to get warmed up again.

bellac11 · 03/01/2023 20:00

I wonder if this is one of those test threads about how much hostility there is toward men on this site

Because if some of these posts were written about women by their male partners it would be almost hate speak

'Shes an idiot for not getting a spare sorted out. That alone would make me not want to get her'

reallyhatewinter · 03/01/2023 19:56

If it was me, I'd collect my DH in a heartbeat if the company have said they'll take the car.
Even if the company wouldn't take the car and DH had to stay with it, I'd be driving out to give him extra warm clothing, some food and a flask.
But then I know my DH would do the same for me, the only difference being, he'd probably wait with the car and tell me to drive straight back home.

CalistoNoSolo · 03/01/2023 19:55

He's an idiot for not getting a spare sorted out. That alone would make me not want to go get him.

GreenManalishi · 03/01/2023 19:50

With no spare there's not going to be anything they can do with a blow out when they arrive other than tow, where to will depend on your cover.

Whether you should go and get him depends on your relationship, and whether you'd appreciate the same from him if the roles were reversed.

toocold54 · 03/01/2023 19:48

Unless he’s in the middle of no where with no where to go to the toilet then YANBU.

It’s just a part of breaking down isn’t it.

I’ve broken down many times before and often they’ll say it’ll be like 6 hours to wait and then a couple hours in to it I get a phone call saying they’re 10mins away.

If that was to happen I can imagine him being put on the bottom of the list as they’re not going to wait 50minutes for him to come back.

minionsrule · 03/01/2023 19:41

LumpyandBumps · 03/01/2023 19:13

If the breakdown service is expecting to deal with a tyre which needs replacing they are unlikely to arrive prepared to tow his vehicle home.
They work on the vehicle at the roadside, or if it cannot be fixed tow it home or to a local garage. I have never known them offer a delivery service for fixable problems just because the car driver doesn’t want to wait.

Depends on the breakdown company.
OP already said there is no spare tyre and if they are anything like mine they rarely fix at the roadside and generally won't be equipped with spare parts (unlike the AA/RAC which is why they charge a fortune). Most likely the service is breakdown recovery only, so will just tow you home.
Mine did once change my tyre at the roadside but I had a spare

NewYearNewSeeds · 03/01/2023 19:35

Each to their own but if the recovery people have confirmed they will deal with the car without him, I'd go.

I don't think a 90 mins journey is such a big deal, but appreciate not everyone thinks that way about car drives.

bellac11 · 03/01/2023 19:32

I would drive a mcdonalds and a hot drink to my OH if this happened. I wouldnt allow him to leave the car and the key hidden (he wouldnt do that anyway, too risk averse)

WeAllHaveWings · 03/01/2023 19:31

Last 2 times we had RAC out they took over 5 hours, have they given him an ETA?. First time dh's car (about 5 years ago), second time for mine (last year). Both times we didnt hesitate to change our plans and picked each other up/dropped back off when recovery said they were nearly there.

KendrickLamaze · 03/01/2023 19:30

They recovery person will be taking the van to the nearest or recommended garage with the keys hidden so no hassle to them.

KendrickLamaze · 03/01/2023 19:29

Recoveries are taking so long at the minute they are now used to people leaving the cars with keys hidden. I wouldn't expect him to be recovered any time soon and would be thinking about ringing recovery agents separately.

Lindy2 · 03/01/2023 19:26

I agree with other posters, he can't just leave the vehicle. I'd not expect a recovery driver to do any work on a vehicle with no driver there.

He needs to wait or find a garage that can help him sooner.

When DH was in a similar situation, I did drive out to him with a bag of snacks and a hot water bottle. He was only about 20 minutes away though and he didn't expect me to wait with him. I just made his wait a bit more comfortable.

Is there perhaps a pub or shop nearby that your DH could wait in? A 50 minute drive each way, when you can't do much to help, is quite a faff. Also only waiting 1 hour so far isn't really very long.

RewildingAmbridge · 03/01/2023 19:25

Surely abandoning it roadside with the key would invalidate the insurance if it's stolen?