Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a stretcher and keep it at home in case of emergency?

287 replies

Summersoon8 · 03/01/2023 14:54

I had the thought of doing this and then a few days later I read the story of an elderly man with a broken hip with no ambulances available (not even given a long wait time, just told none available at all) and his family took him to hospital strapped to a plank of wood in the back of a van.

AIBU to consider buying some sort of emergency/folding stretcher online and storing it at home in case we're ever in the same sort of situation?

OP posts:
JustWhattheDoctorOrdered · 04/01/2023 21:27

Look at the homepage of BBC website right now. A story about a man who had to carry his father to hospital because he was having a heart attack and there were no ambulances. If he had not carried him he would have died.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-64168805

Mentalpiece · 04/01/2023 16:05

CriticalAlert · 04/01/2023 14:21

Hahaha. Who is pulling your strings? What a silly comment.

Whooooosh.

CriticalAlert · 04/01/2023 14:21

XenoBitch · 04/01/2023 01:51

I thought people not wearing masks were to blame...Wink

Hahaha. Who is pulling your strings? What a silly comment.

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 13:58

@curiousierandcouriser i dont disagree with you. probably why in part i have still not bought anything yet. i was just joining the thread to point out that it is not always best to leave a patient if there is no ambulance and explain our situation and how we injured ourselves and would like to have had something to use, maybe a carry chair, i have no idea.

i agree training would be the most useful but i expect all advice would be to wait for an ambulance so it is petrifying when you are told there isnt one and a very fit active person who could have treatment to reverse the stroke would miss out on it. Plenty of 40 year olds on the stroke ward, we are not just talking about older people.

curiousierandcouriser · 04/01/2023 13:44

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 10:36

curiousier
how would you get them to your car after a stroke then? We carried my parent and caused back injury. Hence my vow to get a lifting chair or stretcher or anything that would make it easier to carry someone paralyzed from the neck down or any other effect from stroke if it happened again as getting to hospital quickly is so important.

This all depends on the home layout and terrain we are talking about and what was on hand. Honestly, if I was alone, I would probably either put them in a rolling chair / sled or carry them (fireman carry if they were small enough or grab them under their arms and pull them). If I had someone with me, we would carry them or use a duvet cover/coats as a sling if necessary.

I just don't see how a stretcher would be faster really (especially when alone) when taking stairs, distance, narrow corridors, etc into account over say a rolling chair or carrying. If there is a spine injury or bone injury, I wouldn't be comfortable moving them onto a stretcher by myself in any event.

I'm not intending to belittle anyone's experience or opinion - if you have the space and money for it, go ahead and get one. IMO, there's equipment and training I would spend the money on before getting a stretcher myself.

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 12:48

@Summersoon8 I remember that from guides too ... now! Hard to think straight when you have been woken in the night with news that a parent who seemed very fit has had a stroke and is totally paralyzed and there are no ambulances. I thought strokes would be category one not two. They live near a hospital so never expected over 2 hour delay (and this was November so before all the outcry). Thats why I recommend preparing

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 04/01/2023 12:28

@Summersoon8 - when I was in the Guides, we learned how to improvise a stretcher out of two coats and two long poles. If I recall correctly, you do the coats up inside out, then put the poles through the sleeves (that are inside the buttoned up coats, if you see what I mean).

It might be easier to buy and store two long poles than a whole stretcher.

I used to be a nurse, and I do understand what people are saying about the risks of moving an injured person, and in general I wouldn't try it - but the current circumstances are not normal, and I can see that there could be situations in which moving the injured person might be the lesser of two evils. It would have to be a dire circumstance, but maybe such dire circumstances are happening now.

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 12:22

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe I think you are misunderstanding - we injured ourselves carrying the parent with a stroke (we didnt injure the patient). Had we had a carrying chair/stretcher/training in carrying we might not have done so.

However absolutely no regrets as we got them to hospital in time to have clot treatment (just). We just carried them in our arms into the car - anything that had helped over the longer distances between bedroom and car would have helped. There would have been no issue lifting into a carry chair or stretcher it was the distance we had to carry that was the issue. I think a deck chair or duvet cover could have been a better option than our method. Maybe government could do some adverts for us all on how to safely transport our relatives to hospital!!!

All I know is everyone would try anything if they knew there was only a 3 hours window for treatment to possibly reverse the stroke for their husband, child or parent.

verdantverdure · 04/01/2023 12:18

AreOttersJustWetCats · 04/01/2023 09:48

I think some people are seriously underestimating how difficult it is to move an immobile adult.

Yes, my neighbour is not a big lad but it took two men to get him down the stairs even though he could get up onto his feet himself, he was just weak and unsteady and unable to make it to the toilet unassisted but he could put one foot in front of the other if most of his weight was supported. I don't know how they would've carried him as a dead weight.

Mirabai · 04/01/2023 10:54

As I said upthread my relative was advised by 999 to take relative to hospital themselves there were 400 people in the queue for the ambulance.

Mirabai · 04/01/2023 10:52

AreOttersJustWetCats · 04/01/2023 09:48

I think some people are seriously underestimating how difficult it is to move an immobile adult.

Yeah they’ve really no idea. My relative literally just experienced this at the weekend - she and her 6ft rugby playing DH had to get a close elderly relative (who is also 6ft and ex ruby playing) down a sleep flight of stairs - with rigidity of the limbs.

I can tell you a stretcher would have made a big difference.

You can’t move people with injuries like head or back - in that circumstance you’d just have to wait it out.

But with things like heart attacks, strokes, sepsis every minute counts and you need to get them to hospital asap.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 04/01/2023 10:52

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 10:36

curiousier
how would you get them to your car after a stroke then? We carried my parent and caused back injury. Hence my vow to get a lifting chair or stretcher or anything that would make it easier to carry someone paralyzed from the neck down or any other effect from stroke if it happened again as getting to hospital quickly is so important.

How are you going you going to get then safely into a stretcher and then carry the weight of the person + stretcher?

To move someone safetly you should use a rigid board, even the lightweight ones aren't easy to move. The fabric sling ones look no better than using a sheet or duvet cover.

newcovidisolations · 04/01/2023 10:36

curiousier
how would you get them to your car after a stroke then? We carried my parent and caused back injury. Hence my vow to get a lifting chair or stretcher or anything that would make it easier to carry someone paralyzed from the neck down or any other effect from stroke if it happened again as getting to hospital quickly is so important.

curiousierandcouriser · 04/01/2023 10:03

JustWhattheDoctorOrdered · 04/01/2023 08:49

@curiousierandcouriser
I think investing the money into attending emergency medical courses first would be more beneficial. There is no point in buying equipment unless you know how to properly use it. The the next would be a risk assessment of your surroundings and prioritize what you feel the most likely injuries and prep for those first

As several people have now said, first aid courses are specifically designed for people to offer immediate help so they can make someone comfortable and monitor them until medical help arrives but many, many other people (and I am sure you must have been watching/reading the news recently)have said that ambulances very often do not come any more. It’s not just a case of having to wait a bit longer. They just do not come. Very often the call handler will tell the caller to bring the patient to hospital themselves.

Yes I think everyone here is very well aware that moving someone could possible cause harm. But what do you actually do in that situation? Shrugging your shoulders and relying on girl guides advice from the 1980s won’t help you.

Of course a broken spine or hip should not be moved by an untrained person but what about a person with a stroke? Strokes are very common indeed. Most families will know a relative who has had one. My sister and father had stokes in their 30s. If someone is having a stroke seconds count. They have to be got to hospital immediately. Would you really just go through your first aid procedure and wait for an ambulance that never comes ? Without a doubt my sister is only alive today because someone in the street lifted her and got her to hospital in their car after she had a stroke.

Shame on the people laughing at this.

I'm not laughing - I'm just questioning if buying a stretcher is the best use of money. In your example of a stroke, how would having a stretcher (without an appropriately sized vehicle) help? If someone had a stroke in my house and no ambulance was coming, then I would get them into my car and drive them to the ER.

A surprising number of people are not up-to-date regarding first aid (basic and advanced) and this could make a big difference to an outcome. If you are knowledgable on this, there may be more useful things to purchase before the stretcher - crutches / wheelchair / fully stocked first aid / silver blanket / emergency car kit / etc.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 04/01/2023 09:48

I think some people are seriously underestimating how difficult it is to move an immobile adult.

Sparklingbrook · 04/01/2023 09:21

This scenario requires people able to lift the patient onto the stretcher, then lift the stretcher and walk to the car and then what’s happening? How are we getting them into the car? 🤔

EnyoClytemnestra · 04/01/2023 09:18

Summersoon8 · 03/01/2023 17:05

Not to mention, as people have said, it’s as much about the person putting the injured party on to the stretcher correctly that would determine outcome for the patient. You don’t have that training.

No, but several healthcare workers in my family do.

And luckily, they will all be available in the emergency situation you are envisioning...

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 04/01/2023 09:11

Lifting someone after a stroke is very different from moving someone with a suspected hip or pelvis fracture. Especially at home with stairs involved. And in your case a home stretcher wasn't needed.

In a lot of cases moving a patient can cause more injuries and extreme pain.

If the person can be lifted and the risk of needing cpr on route is low then just carry them. If a limb needs immobilising and staying flat then it is best to wait for an ambulance.

If people do want to be prepared then a silver blankets in the car and crutches at home are much more useful than a dodgy stretcher. Plus a fire blanket in the house (always amazed how many people don't have one - small kitchen fires are quite common).

MeinKraft · 04/01/2023 09:07

JanuaryBluehoo · 03/01/2023 21:53

Head

No..

Under the last Labour government after 10 year's, a decade of labour funding our local hospital was failed.

People were terrified of being sent there it was scary.
Your post deeply concerns me because funding really isn't the only issue.
It needs a massive overhaul and the culture behind it.

Well the Tories have had 12 years, why haven't they overhauled it then?

MeinKraft · 04/01/2023 09:02

YANBU
Moving injured people can cause harm, but so can leaving them lying on the floor for hours/days at a time

JustWhattheDoctorOrdered · 04/01/2023 08:49

@curiousierandcouriser
I think investing the money into attending emergency medical courses first would be more beneficial. There is no point in buying equipment unless you know how to properly use it. The the next would be a risk assessment of your surroundings and prioritize what you feel the most likely injuries and prep for those first

As several people have now said, first aid courses are specifically designed for people to offer immediate help so they can make someone comfortable and monitor them until medical help arrives but many, many other people (and I am sure you must have been watching/reading the news recently)have said that ambulances very often do not come any more. It’s not just a case of having to wait a bit longer. They just do not come. Very often the call handler will tell the caller to bring the patient to hospital themselves.

Yes I think everyone here is very well aware that moving someone could possible cause harm. But what do you actually do in that situation? Shrugging your shoulders and relying on girl guides advice from the 1980s won’t help you.

Of course a broken spine or hip should not be moved by an untrained person but what about a person with a stroke? Strokes are very common indeed. Most families will know a relative who has had one. My sister and father had stokes in their 30s. If someone is having a stroke seconds count. They have to be got to hospital immediately. Would you really just go through your first aid procedure and wait for an ambulance that never comes ? Without a doubt my sister is only alive today because someone in the street lifted her and got her to hospital in their car after she had a stroke.

Shame on the people laughing at this.

Dente · 04/01/2023 04:07

i Mean you can get a stretcher, but will it fit safely in your car? Do you have enough manual handling experience not to injure yourself ( or the person going on the stretcher). Are you sure you want to move someone with a head/spinal injury ?

curiousierandcouriser · 04/01/2023 02:17

I think investing the money into attending emergency medical courses first would be more beneficial. There is no point in buying equipment unless you know how to properly use it. The the next would be a risk assessment of your surroundings and prioritize what you feel the most likely injuries and prep for those first.

Mentalpiece · 04/01/2023 02:05

Pushingdaisys · 03/01/2023 21:41

How was your husbands friends after he parachuted down? At least your husband was sensible. I’ve been training doing smaller climbs to build up to it

A fair few broken bones, including his back.
Unfortunately it didn't knock any sense into him because as soon as he was mended, he was back up the mountains.
Maybe the op could be waiting at the bottom next time with her shiny new stretcher.

XenoBitch · 04/01/2023 01:51

CriticalAlert · 03/01/2023 23:26

I'd buy a Sherman tank instead and blast every Tory in this country to smithereens. They've destroyed the NHS. We'll be paying for ambulances very soon, if we can afford one.

I thought people not wearing masks were to blame...Wink