Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel bad even writing this - do they get it

313 replies

Bigcrane · 03/01/2023 07:08

I feel awful even writing this but it makes me so low

I try and be a good daughter, and a sister to my only brother, and their families

I pick up the financial brunt - just paid the bulk (75% I think) of a 5k family trip away, hosted Xmas, paid for the panto trip for all, paid for the Santa day out at a theme park, paid for the kids activities etc whilst away on trip.

We do earn more then my brother and his wife, and my parents are retired with savings but less income (obviously) .

I do this because I love them. But I just don't think they make the connection between my effort and that cash. I work massively hard to get promotion, do hours of unpaid work, juggle all this with 2 under 6. My husband does the same. Both full time and it's tough.

All the time we were away my mother kept saying "you really need to work less hard", with my sister in law nodding away. Whilst sat in the cottage I had paid for. No one really acknowledged the financial cost to me of all these lovely things we did. All the time mum saying " I hope your resolution is to work less"

I know I'm an idiot just not to stop doing it - and I'll be told that here. I just don't seem to be able to do it, as I want us to be able to do these nice things together and my parents genuinely can't afford it. I do however want them to get the link between my effort and our good times and just say thankyou. Am I an idiot?

OP posts:
PinkyFlamingo · 03/01/2023 12:27

Your choice of words - trying to be a "good" daughter and sister are very telling, why do do you need to "try"? And is spending money on them your way of showing you're "good"?

BloodAndFire · 03/01/2023 12:22

This is why so many people dislike and are made uncomfortable by being given extravagant gifts.

Because they ALWAYS come with strings attached and a power dynamic.

WinterDeWinter · 03/01/2023 12:17

I don't think the OP is motivated by a desire to be acknowledged as a success at all. She thinks these are lovely things that her family enjoys and she wants to show them her love. She's not saying 'if I didn't have to pay for these things I could stop working so hard' - she works hard and does these things. She's just asking for her family to acknowledge the gift really, and say thanks, it's lovely of you.

Unfortunately, OP, I don't think they will. I think you have to dial it back, although I expect you will continue to work hard (it sounds as though this is your default). You can let them think that the reason for fewer nice things is that you're working less or you can just say nothing and let them work it out.

I do think you should look at whether you are missing out on things with your own immediate family by working so hard as a separate issue - maybe you are, maybe you aren't, maybe it's a bit of both but overall it feels worth it to you for what the extra cash allows you to do for your kids.

Pr1mr0se · 03/01/2023 12:13

It may be hard to do but you really need to have an honest conversation with your family about the cost of trips and stays away. I am in a similar position. I enjoy paying for nice experiences/ trips away for us but sometimes it becomes a burden with the 'why don't you work less' comments. They won't understand unless you talk to them and maybe they have no idea of the costs and would not want to do the same things in future.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 03/01/2023 12:09

It's unreasonable to resent them over the cost of the activities when it appears to be entirely your choice to spend that money. They're not forcing you to book expensive trips etc. - next time you all want to meet up, just suggest something cheap/free to do.

Crumpledstilstkin · 03/01/2023 12:08

I think what you really want to hear is that they'd love to spend more time with you and see you happier, even if it means you can't afford to treat them. That your happiness is more important to them than the gifts. I can't tell from the detail here if they'd say that but what do you think?

BloodAndFire · 03/01/2023 12:03

You can't buy love.

They don't need to grovel to you because you splash the cash.

Charlize43 · 03/01/2023 11:59

I definitely think their pointed comments about 'work less' are their way of saying that they are not comfortable with all this unnecessary extravagance while not wishing to sound ungrateful or to hurt your feelings. They are trying to tell you something.

User359472111111 · 03/01/2023 11:58

Itschristmastimeinthecity · 03/01/2023 10:24

I disagree with your comment.
I'm always one to point out when MN posters are being ridiculous but in this instance I think the majority are actually giving OP great advice and insight.

I wonder how many of the people saying “you don’t need a holiday, or the panto or to spend money to have fun” have had a holiday, gone to the theatre or done a paid activity with their family this year.

Off course many have, WITH THEIR IMMEDIATE FAMILY. You see the difference? you really can't compare the 2 situations.

I’m not talking about the majority of posters, I’m talking about the preachy ones.

starfishmummy · 03/01/2023 11:51

icelollycraving · 03/01/2023 07:22

Have you never replied that the trips and treats would need to stop then?
Sometimes I find that people will happily take without much thought of the implications.
Working hard is fine, shows ambition and is setting you up for a good career. Always good to show children that both parents can work hard.

Exactly this!

Op"'s DM " you need to work less"

Op " Good idea mum, I'm definitely cutting back. By the way, next year everyone will need to pay their own way at Christmas".

Dreamwhisper · 03/01/2023 11:46

I don't think you're an idiot but I would try and reframe your perspective and heed what your family are saying - it sounds like you value family time so much that you're willing to grind yourself to the bone to acquire it, which is lovely.

But do you need to spend so much to do nice things together? Do you think your family would equally be happy on a nice day out in summer to a field/lake with a picnic, rather than in a paid for by you cottage break?

Is there part of you that worries your family wouldn't be around for you if you couldn't provide for them what you currently are?

Quarique · 03/01/2023 11:46

I would tell your family that your New Year's Resolution is to work less. Spend a year not paying for anything, put the money into savings for your children instead as it will have a bigger impact done so early. See if anyone comments on you not spending, see how they react. Next year you will have a much clearer idea.

pattihews · 03/01/2023 11:44

I have a very hard-working professional outlying family member whom I've known for 40 years. She loves going to really up-market hotels and on cruises. They're not my thing. She used to go with her husband and, after they divorced, her mum. They'd share a room together but I don't think I'd want to share with her. I can't afford £2000 for a flashy weekend away or a cruise costing upwards of £5k for a week so I've consistently refused her suggestions that we go away on financial grounds. Saying that I can't afford it seems easier than saying I really don't want to go on a fancy cruise with thousands of other people and get dressed up smartly in cocktail dresses for dinner each evening (which is what she likes doing).

She's presented me with a fait accompli in the shape of a Christmas gift. She's booked a two-bedroom suite for us for a weekend in London in a five-star hotel later in the year, with theatre tickets and an art show included and a booking at a posh restaurant. It's very generous of her and I imagine we'll have a lovely time but I'd hate to think that afterwards she'd be feeling like the OP. I don't expect this level of generosity. In fact it embarrasses me.

I've accepted the gift of this amazing weekend mainly because it's what she wants. She wants company while she does the things she loves doing. At least, that's how I've understood it.

ShimmeringShirts · 03/01/2023 11:34

Not everyone values money and trips and days out the way you seem to. They’ve said yes to spend time with you, sounds like they’d rather you took it easier and they didn’t have to go to all the stuff you plan out. Money isn’t the be all and end all of life and good times, so many people prefer some quality time with their family over money being splashed about.

Notjustabrunette · 03/01/2023 11:32

My MIL does this. She equates spending money = how much you care about someone. It doesn’t. She complained about how much she spent on a family day out, however no one asked her to spend that, or even expected it.
Maybe you do need to work less and also spend less? You don’t need to be paying for a Santa day out for some else’s kids. I don’t even do that with my kids 😂.

Crunchymum · 03/01/2023 11:31

workinmums · 03/01/2023 11:07

But this is where many are getting it wrong on this thread.

DID OP FAMILY ASK FOR ALL OF THIS?

That's the first question. So how can they be CF's?

Anyone who accepts a free holiday cottage, free days trips, the free hosting of Christmas etc is a CF in my opinion. Either say No or offer to contribute.

No way on Earth would I accept this from any family members, no matter how much more than me they earn. This is taking aside the fact the people who accepted all this are then questioning why they OP works so much!

Mariposa123 · 03/01/2023 11:29

My brother in law does this. He seems to equate love with spending money. The problem is he doesn’t really take into account what other people in the family actually want (eg takes parents out for expensive dinners when his father is in a restricted diet for medical reasons, so can’t eat anything on the menu!) so it falls a bit flat. He’s always so busy with work that his parents rarely see him, so I think really would prefer his time than his money.

isittheholidaysyet · 03/01/2023 11:25

I wonder if you are paying for 'nice' things that they would be happy without (and cant afford), but they go along with because they want to be with you and enjoy spending time with you and want you to enjoy it too.

Some examples from my own family:

We often go on holiday together, we all camp and have been brought up camping, but my dad has started to find camping a struggle now he is older. So when my sister suggested a joint family camping holiday, he immediately suggested, and found, a holiday cottage instead. This meant he had to pay for a lot of my and my sister's costs, because it was out of budget. (He has good savings). We are all thankful and really enjoyed it, but would have enjoyed the camping just as much.

My husband and I like to have a coffee in a cafe now and again, my parents see this as a waste of money, so we often buy them coffee, they enjoy it, but would have been happier without as they see it as a pointless spend.

When my sister holds parties, everything has to be perfect, matching decor and balloons, matching printed invites etc. These things are pointless to us, but we know she spends money on them because it really helps her enjoyment.

Is this the kind of thing which is happening here. Would you be happy to do it your families' way? Or do you need the 'nice' things in order to enjoy the events?

DNBU · 03/01/2023 11:21

You’re not an idiot OP.

Why did you pay 75%, were you paying for your parents?
& if so, why do things the others can’t afford?

ridiculoso82 · 03/01/2023 11:21

How does your DH feel about this? Working so hard and then spending it all on your family?
That is a bloody good question

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 03/01/2023 11:19

How does your DH feel about this? Working so hard and then spending it all on your family?

How does it affect your 2 small children? Do they reap the benefit in family time to make up for all your extra hours working rather than with them?

I wouldn’t do anything in reaction to their thoughtless comments. Act only in pursuit of what YOU want for your own life.

You have lots of options.

Carry on as you are if it makes you happy. But address their attitude by saying “I work to make sure we can all have times like this”

Carry on your workload, but talk carefully with your DH about how you use your income. Should you save more for your own futures? Bear in mind that it is unlikely that you will have anyone paying for your hols once you retire. Life could be much tougher for your kids, they might be talented but starving artists etc. Would it be best to focus on things within your own family/ saving for kids Uni, your pensions, etc. Your home, to which you can invite your relatives.

Work fewer hours and have more time together within your nuclear family.

You are so generous because you love them, and yet not close enough to say to them that you work because you want to afford these things. They might be horrified! Can you find a moment to have a mini heart to heart with one of them and say ‘I felt really awkward during the conversation about NYRs, and I couldn’t quite work it out. The thing is, DH and I work as we do to pay for the holidays and the fun times out etc. We couldn’t do it on our basic salaries. We love doing these things but I wasn’t sure if you were saying ‘stop!’ “

bridgetreilly · 03/01/2023 11:16

It’s perfectly reasonable to say that you choose to work hard so that you and your family can enjoy the things you want them to. Or you could listen to them and consider working less hard, but having more time to enjoy things that don’t cost as much.

museumum · 03/01/2023 11:15

Unless your family are very stupid then they will fully realise that working less will mean less money/luxuries but they seem to be telling you that your health - mental and physical is more important to them than these treats you buy them.
I think you should reflect on why they keep saying this to you - are you burnt out or unavailable due to work? I doubt they’d keep saying it if you weren’t working too hard/much.

Charlize43 · 03/01/2023 11:10

I specifically stepped away from seeing a friend who liked to buy expensive gifts and book and pay for expensive restaurants because they always came along with the line, 'I know you'd never be able to afford something like this' and the constant reminders that she was a CEO on a six figure salary. I found it grated after a while and it led me to start questioning her motivation.

There was also an element of control attached as well as she would ring up and say 'I've booked tickets for us to see this theatre show next week' without actually being asked if I had any interest in seeing it in the first place. It made me feel uncomfortable and more like a paid companion than friend.

But much worse was hearing her disparage other friends saying 'after all the things I've paid for.'

workinmums · 03/01/2023 11:07

Crunchymum · 03/01/2023 11:05

All the time we were away my mother kept saying "you really need to work less hard", with my sister in law nodding away. Whilst sat in the cottage I had paid for. No one really acknowledged the financial cost to me of all these lovely things we did. All the time mum saying " I hope your resolution is to work less"

I hope you pointed out to your mum that you working is what funded their whole festive period.

I think you have some CF's on your hands here as surely no-one would expect someone else to pay for 75% of a 5k family trip away / the hosting of Xmas / panto trip for all / Santa day out at a theme park / kids activities etc

You need to stop doing it, and you need to tell them to stop passing comment on your life choices given they are more than happy to accept your bloody money.

But this is where many are getting it wrong on this thread.

DID OP FAMILY ASK FOR ALL OF THIS?

That's the first question. So how can they be CF's?

Swipe left for the next trending thread