Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel bad even writing this - do they get it

313 replies

Bigcrane · 03/01/2023 07:08

I feel awful even writing this but it makes me so low

I try and be a good daughter, and a sister to my only brother, and their families

I pick up the financial brunt - just paid the bulk (75% I think) of a 5k family trip away, hosted Xmas, paid for the panto trip for all, paid for the Santa day out at a theme park, paid for the kids activities etc whilst away on trip.

We do earn more then my brother and his wife, and my parents are retired with savings but less income (obviously) .

I do this because I love them. But I just don't think they make the connection between my effort and that cash. I work massively hard to get promotion, do hours of unpaid work, juggle all this with 2 under 6. My husband does the same. Both full time and it's tough.

All the time we were away my mother kept saying "you really need to work less hard", with my sister in law nodding away. Whilst sat in the cottage I had paid for. No one really acknowledged the financial cost to me of all these lovely things we did. All the time mum saying " I hope your resolution is to work less"

I know I'm an idiot just not to stop doing it - and I'll be told that here. I just don't seem to be able to do it, as I want us to be able to do these nice things together and my parents genuinely can't afford it. I do however want them to get the link between my effort and our good times and just say thankyou. Am I an idiot?

OP posts:
BMW6 · 03/01/2023 08:42

Why are you "Lady Bountiful" and also resentful about having to work so hard to fund it?

Be honest - are you trying to buy love, or the accolades? Could you be showing off rather?

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 03/01/2023 08:42

whynotwhatknot · 03/01/2023 07:40

youre paying tousands of pounds for a trip -theres jsut no need

maybe them saying slow downis a way of saying you dont have to do this all the time

To me... It could be any of these explanations....

But just think OP...

If you continue to work... And divert thr income into your own family... How much extra would you have? Another holiday for you /more savings for your future.

You could reduce your hours and your family has you back...

It soubds as if you're working extra time to facilitate other people your age. (s&BIL) .... What are they doing to help? OK I understand they may be only on minimum wage.... But a couple of pub shifts soon amasses extra in the pot. Locally 100£net per shift is on low end..

JoyPeaceSleep · 03/01/2023 08:36

A cottage jus for yourselves next year! enjoy it!

JoyPeaceSleep · 03/01/2023 08:36

I think it's all been spelled out already, but may suggest somethingthey could afford to pay their share on?

SilverPeacock · 03/01/2023 08:34

Is it the money or is it that you don’t feel appreciated generally for your achievements?

If money you should take suggestions above on board. Receiving of expensive gifts or money can cause complex feelings and using money to express love may be your own issue that you should think about. You should start doing things where everyone is paying their share, unless maybe some special occasion or something it might be appropriate to treat.

If you want appreciation for your achievements it hard if you don’t get it. We all want approval from our parents. Your mother obviously cares about you or she wouldn’t be saying she worries about you working too hard and it does sound like a way of saying they appreciate you for you and don’t need expensive things. You could maybe use the opportunity to talk to them about it?

Sparkletastic · 03/01/2023 08:34

Analyse your motives. Are you doing this selflessly or in the expectation of admiration and gratitude?

RosesAndHellebores · 03/01/2023 08:31

You should be working hard for your own family unit. If your ils want more they can work harder ime.

Ultimately, do you want to and do you enjoy working hard? DH and I always did. There was a time, 20 years ago, when I wanted to host and treat SIL and her family. Sadly, the sense of entitlement was overwhelming.

It stopped after a paid treat to Centre Parks when she said yes to everything, neither she nor her dc appeared to know the words please and thank you and after a day when dh and I supervised the children, organised everything, cooked dinner, including organising a birthday cake for her three year old, as the table was cleared, she laid down on the sofa and read whilst we washed up. We had a 4 year old and a 1 year old. She had one totally unboundaried 3 year old.

At that point I withdrew from any encouragement for her to spend time with us.

Do your family appreciate how hard people actually do work? MIL was a teacher and could never wrap her head around the fact that if you weren't a teacher you didn't get two weeks off at Christmas and Easter. I'm not saying teachers don't work hard but the lack of understanding was sometimes overwhelming.

Mummadeze · 03/01/2023 08:29

I think they probably don’t get it. I am sure they are appreciative of the lovely experiences you have given them - who wouldn’t be? But they probably think you have the option to work less and still earn as well as you do. They are making these comments out of love and care for your well-being I expect. If treating them makes you happy, usually, and you can afford it, I would just continue on and if they ask why you work so hard, just spell it out a bit more.

Prettyreindeer · 03/01/2023 08:25

Can't you say in response: "Well yes, I could work less hard but then the upside is that we can afford to live somewhere nice and be able to afford nice things, have some financial security, and treat family...."

It is a fair and true response and if as a PP has suggested, they are meaning that they don't need treating as such then it would pave the way to a dialogue about how they would rather see you not work so hard just to do that.

Treetrim · 03/01/2023 08:25

I’ve been in a similar position in my family, the one who did well and could afford to pay for treats for others. However once my DC came along and started to get older, my disposable income declined and I also realised that I had to be more financially responsible and not spend so much of my discretionary money on family activities or trips.

You likely feel slightly guilty that you have a nicer lifestyle than your family, I can understand that, I felt the same.

Over the years I’ve taken my DM on numerous domestic city breaks (london Edinburgh etc) to New York twice, Paris, Rome, Venice, France, Spain several times. When money was tighter and time was at a premium there was an expectation that I would still just do this, which I found hurtful.

I don’t think there is any ‘fault’ here. You’ve decided to treat them and they are happy to go along with it but it needs to change if you are feeling this way. My advice is next time a family event comes up, work out a more equitable division of cost, if they aren’t willing to pay their share then simply do it as just your family. I would be inclined to still sometimes treat your parents and nieces and nephews but I on a less frequent and expensive basis.

Unlike lots of MN, I do believe in the importance of extended family and not the ‘just us’ approach so I would be subtle about this. If anyone asks say ‘look I just can’t afford the extra cost at the moment’ That is entirely reasonable and important to do. Unless you are a really big earner, discontent will set in.

Fuckthatguy · 03/01/2023 08:25

They sound completely unappreciative OP and I will bet that once the lovely experiences you so generously provide for them stop, they will be singing a different tune.

Experiences are invaluable as far as I’m concerned, if I were in your position instead of funding them this year, use the money to take your family somewhere amazing without the rest of them. Do not feel guilty either.

Lobelia123 · 03/01/2023 08:24

In my experience, when one person contributes so much, it leads to an imbalance in the family dynamics, and (perhaps even subconciously) it leads to resentment. Then people start subtly denigrating you to make up for their feelings that theyre not doing as well as you for whatever reason (which may all be due to a valid choice). Its their way to say, well I cant afford all this but BigCrane can only do it because shes doing X which is wrong, and I can be smug and superior about it because at heart my way is better. Its a way to neg you and say 'POOR BigCrane' and make themselves feel better.

So I would stop with these lavish treats - I know you mean them lovingly and selflessly, but I think the worm is turning and its starting to generate some resentment and entitlement. Scale it right back - if it gets questioned, you can say youve taken all that great advice about relaxing and scaling back and the result is that financially you cant treat anyone anymore, you can only afford to concentrate on your kids. Youll be happier, and maybe they will all learn a little something about happiness and gratitiude. And youll be freed from the burden of being the benevolent rich provider of all good things. Stop now, before things really get out of hand. An occasional treat of a meal out, or tickets to a theatre show are all lovely and generous, but stop with the flood of subsidised holidays, extravagant treats and days out etc. They are not appreciated. It will all backfire specatacularly unless you step back....sad but true that this is base human nature/

LetsDoThis2023 · 03/01/2023 08:24

I personally think yes, I'd also want to hear..."thanks for treating us to all these lovely things. We really enjoy them and we recognise how hard you work to make them happen". Then by all means they might go on go say "...but we'd be just as happy to do hot chocolate in auntie Jane's garden so don't run yourself into the ground for us". That's just self awareness surely.

Who would actually say this in reality?

HettyMeg · 03/01/2023 08:23

You are not an idiot as you just want to share nice experiences with your family. However, you cannot control how they behave, or how grateful or otherwise they seem. I agree you should find cheaper ways to spend time with them - family isn't about expensive trips away. If you don't want to work less, spend the extra cash on yourself / you and your dh. If you do want to cut down hours then do it but only if you want to.

NewYearNewSeeds · 03/01/2023 08:22

OP, I was a bit like this in the past. I had very senior job and no children so had cash to spare. That job also brought me in contact with fine things in life and I used to spoil my family because I wanted them to have access to those nice things also. Including holidays and days out and experiences.

That job almost broke me. I now earn half as much (maybe less than half!) and am a lot less stressed. My family get a lot less spoiling from me but I cannot honestly say we were happier before and are less happy now.

Everyone is just as happy now. Maybe even more so, because I am not tired and stressed regularly.

If you are someone who shows their love via gifts, it can be a hard lesson to learn that not everyone prioritises or values those gifts in the same way. Your family may wel be genuinely far happier with knowing you are happy and not over worked, even if it means they have to swap a 5k family trip away for a weekend all together in someone's home.

Natty83 · 03/01/2023 08:20

Have you read about love languages? It sounds very much like you love your family and want them to be happy and your family love you and want you to be happy - perhaps your love language is gift giving and theirs is quality time? And they want you to have more quality time not understanding this is how you are showing your love. I may be completely wrong but might be worth a chat. Good luck x

MeinKraft · 03/01/2023 08:16

Curiosity101 · 03/01/2023 07:15

How do you imagine they would react if you stop doing it?

Maybe they go along with all the expensive stuff to keep you happy. Maybe "you really need to work less hard" really means "stop spending all this money. I'd rather you had an easier time of life than that we had all these fancy things"

This is exactly what I think. It's a roundabout way of telling you to calm down with the spending.

mommatoone · 03/01/2023 08:15

My friend was like this OP. At the risk of sounding ungrateful, it was claustrophobic. Just too much. People didnt want to say anything or refuse to go to places as she would have been offended / upset.
She was very much motivated by money.

It seems that you come from a good place with your genorosity but please consider that not everyone feels comfortable with this.

EasterIsland · 03/01/2023 08:14

You’re not an idiot and YANBU to feel a little upset about your generosity being taken for granted.

But.. people get stuck in certain roles in families and this comes to seem “natural.”

Also, they may all be aware of what you’ve spent but a) don’t want constantly to feel beholden? or b) aren’t hugely fussed about doing all the things you pay for so just let you do them?

Your actions come from kindness and generosity but maybe they feel burdensome to your family?

But to reiterate- you’re not an idiot nor unreasonable to feel a little upset.

I think you’re going to have to cut back a bit, or suggest something- for example to your brother - about going halves in something for your parents, for example.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 03/01/2023 08:13

Is it possible that your family would actually have just as much joy or possibly even more if you stepped down your high-powered money-earning and stepped down the luxury and spent quality time with them in more basic circumstances - skiing holidays are lovely obviously but are spectacularly expensive at the popular resorts, you can enjoy the sport just as much at a more basic location without the huge markups, or can have non-skiing holidays with other activities. If you are splashing around the cash to upgrade from something that they could afford and would enjoy happily, to something that is no more enjoyable but they feel pressured into, then that's not being nice to them, and no they shouldn't feel obliged to stroke your ego for it. You might be more fun to be with if you worked less? I don't know how true this is, but it's possible that this could be their take on it.

Breakingpoint1961 · 03/01/2023 08:13

Coming from a mature mum, if one (or both) of my adult DC were to do stuff like this, I'd probably accept it the first time, albeit not comfortable with it. If say, they were a very high flyer (talking footballer etc) then I think that's very different from a regular job with a good salary.

I am not even comfortable with expensive presents from my 'kids' so I'd find this uncomfortable, even more so if my other DC was ok accepting itBlush.

I am very much a giver, and believe me people will take, in fact I find myself gravitating towards takers it seemsConfused

OP we don't give for gratification, we give because we want to, so no expectation should be sought (unrealistic I know) however, there comes a point whereby we maybe look at what we are giving, and just scale it back somewhat. It doesn't need to be confrontational either, just a reduction in your generosity.

unkownone · 03/01/2023 08:11

I would put a hold on paying for all their stuff. We had similar with my in laws all of them! Except they expected us to pay for everything and would laugh walking away saying we’d pay like always. After another time when it got back to me what they said about us we no longer pay for anything for them. Id say cut back if they want those experiences all chip in.

goldismything · 03/01/2023 08:11

You sound lovely but stop paying for them. Concentrate on your own family and maybe go for walks or picnics with extended family. Paying top dollar for experiences doesn’t equate good times.

Guavafish1 · 03/01/2023 08:10

I agree with all the above.

Expensive trips doesn't mean quality time. I agree with others... you need to rethink about cutting back the costs.

Consider doing things on a lower budgets... your family won't care as long as you're spending time together as a family

Gloschick · 03/01/2023 08:03
  1. You may be working too hard. Have a think about why they were saying that. Were you frazzled, taking work calls etc?
  1. I think you should have an honest conversation with them all. What do they want? If I could afford £1k for my half of a Christmas cottage, but my sister insisted on paying £3k into the pot for a really fancy cottage, then I'd find that quite difficult. I would much prefer us to stay at a more modest £2k cottage and pay my way.
  1. In these times of cost of living crisis they might find it hard to play along with the indulgence. If they are worried about paying the heating bill next month then it might feel tough to pay so much on holiday treats.