Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stick to designated day off?

235 replies

HandbagsnGladrags · 03/01/2023 06:54

Am early 50's and work in a mid senior high pressure role in financial services. I've just dropped to a 4 day working week and taken a 20% pay cut. There was initially some resistance to me dropping my hours but I eventually got agreement. I've asked for the same day off each week and that was agreed.

Here's the dilemma - on only my second week of the new working pattern, one of my colleagues who was resistant to my drop in hours has put in an overnight stay which would mean me either travelling back home on my day off, or swapping my day off that week.

I don't want to start agreeing to swap days all the time as the whole point of me dropping my hours was to give me a better work life balance and be able to plan things for my non working day. WIBU to say that my day off is my day off and not be chopping and changing all of the time?

OP posts:
funnelfan · 03/01/2023 11:28

I’ve done compressed hours working, and I agree with the advice of previous posters. Use the terminology “non-working day”, set up a recurring appointment in your calendar to block it as out of office, put your working hours in your email signature. I also set an out of office auto reply on my non-working days to say I won't be picking up the email until Monday, but if it is an urgent matter then contact …

In some ways, it is good that this situation has come up now. You can use it to really think about your boundaries and communicate with your colleagues about them, under the guise of everyone is still getting used to your new hours and the situation is still bedding in.

Eg, as part of the discussion with management for my flexible working, I agreed that if two specific important situations arise then I will consider working on my non-working day/swapping it for another day that week. That actually happened within a month of me starting the new hours, and meant I spent an hour on email on my NWD on one day. I didn’t mind because it was part of the mitigation proposed for some management to get them on board for the flexible working arrangement in the first place, and I’d clearly defined up front the situations in which I would make myself available. It actually reassured management that the business would not suffer for my new working hours, and took some of the pressure off!

KnickerlessParsons · 03/01/2023 11:25

I think it depends on whether you'd ever want work to be flexible with you. If you foresee a time when you might want to switch your day off so you can do something without taking a holiday day, then it might be best to accommodate the request from work.
I work a "10 days in 9" pattern - I do 10 days' worth of hours over 9 days, so I have a day off every fortnight, and no loss of pay. Whilst I was asked to specify a day, I have switched the day off several times, either for my convenience, or to attend something important for work.

It works both ways.

bridgetreilly · 03/01/2023 11:23

The meeting/jolly whatever is a thing you absolutely say no to. Part of working 4 days is that there will be some things that you’re not at. You are not there to do 100% of the job in 80% of the time. You need to remember that and help your colleagues get used to it as well.

rookiemere · 03/01/2023 11:12

This is excellent advice :

"One thing I would say is when you aren't in, don't be in. Don't start to respond to emails on occassion, or reply to messages (unless truly urgent). Otherwise people think you are working, even if you are not. ^"

I got myself into trouble in lockdown by picking up the odd thing on a Friday. At first I didn't mind - genuinely wasn't doing much and people were appreciative- but then my workload started ramping up as if I was working 5 days and people put stuff in routinely. As the main reason I work reduced hours is for good mental health and work life balance, this caused me serious stress.

Now I'm pretty hardline. I will pop into Teams occasionally as I can log on from my i-pad, but only if it's a genuine emergency or like recently a team member's DD w^as ill, and I wanted to see how she was.

MRex · 03/01/2023 11:08

I'm always flexible for things booked long in advance when they are time critical, or for business emergencies. I am entirely inflexible to other people's lack of planning. It isn't business critical, nor time critical, so I'd decline.

"Happy New Year! I will be able to attend this event until 6pm on Thursday, due to Friday being a non-working day for me. If you needed my attendance for the evening session, then please adjust the date. My calendar is always up to date, so please do check it before booking future meetings, or get in touch with me in advance if a session is time sensitive but falls in non-working time, so that it can be scheduled."

rookiemere · 03/01/2023 11:07

I put my working hours on my outlook signature, along with upcoming holidays.
Also in this case it does seem to be malicious intent, but I try to work on the assumption people don't know or have forgotten and respond accordingly. Embarrassingly someone I work with doesn't work a Wednesday and sometimes I forget and schedule meetings in then, probably because she hasn't blocked it out.

In fact the only people who annoy me are those who do the school run or whatever but don't block the time out in their calendar, then expect me to know when I schedule a meeting then, or message me and tell me they will try to attend - which is pretty useless. Lack of ambiguity works for me, so if you're not going to be available fine - make sure your diary reflects that.

FortyFacedFuckers · 03/01/2023 11:05

I worked part time for 15 years and came across these situations all the time expecting me to come in on my day off or even work past my finish time, i found it easier to say sorry I can't I have made an appointment for that day when I am off or I have made an appointment for when I finish work so need to finish at my actual finish time.

EndlessRain1 · 03/01/2023 11:04

I have about 10 years experience in this predicament. And issues still arise.

I have found as I have become more senior it's been more difficutl in some ways. While I have more autonomy I also have more responsibility and things can't always wait for me to have a working day.

The way I play it is I assess things for (1) urgency and (2) importance. If it's both urgent and important I make an exception, if it's neither then I don't. It's incredibly important to me to make the arrangement work, which is why I do it this way. I don't want to miss out on promotions or do a bad job, but eqaully I don't want to give away my free time. Once in a while I get someone who makes it difficult, but actually people most of the time are really considerate of my time, and value the fact that they know I will be avvailable if important.

One thing I would say is when you aren't in, don't be in. Don't start to respond to emails on occassion, or reply to messages (unless truly urgent). Otherwise people think you are working, even if you are not.

In your predicament here, I would assess the importance of you attending this event and the inconvenience caused to the client by rearranging.

poetryandwine · 03/01/2023 10:57

Well, what’s done is done. OP, you know best how reneging on this arse will go down in your workplace. FGS when - not if - he tries to land you in it again, make up your mind what to do and stick with it.

On a happier note, I also love the NWD terminology and think it would be very helpful to add your working days to your email signature as a PP suggested

Mirabai · 03/01/2023 10:52

HandbagsnGladrags · 03/01/2023 08:18

@rookiemere oh I have no desire to get promoted beyond where I am now. But I don't want to end up in the next round of redundancies because I'm labelled as inflexible. That's my only concern.

But equally they don’t want to end up with a case for constructive dismissal (or they shouldn’t).

AlisonDonut · 03/01/2023 10:43

I used to work 4 days a week until I retired, and yes you have to take it.

I'd respond in this instance that I would be flexible on this one occasion but then I'd block out any meetings from 5pm on the Thursday to 9pm on Monday as 'do not book' so that if anyone does a search on your diary it will come up with booked. I'd take the Wednesday that week or 2 days the next week to make up for it.

I'd email the person that did the booking and say 'Unfortunately, you have forgotten that I am now on a 4 day week and finish work at 5pm on Thursdays. I'll change my non working day this one time but please note that you have now had notice and I'll not be changing it again. Please do not book any evening meetings or events for me on a Thursday night, or at any time on a Friday.'

If anyone does book anything on those days, decline the meeting/event etc. And leave them to deal with it. And take back control of your diary so that other people can't keep booking you when you are not there.

Aftersevens · 03/01/2023 10:40

Also what has pissed me off is that it's literally the second week of my new working arrangement (it starts this week).

I’m going against the consensus here in that, on this occasion, I’d agree to swap. The fact that it’s only week two is the reason I would, rather than wouldn’t. I’d be very clear and say, I will do it this week as I understand new arrangements can take a while to get used to. But ongoing, I will be sticking to my designated day off.

rookiemere · 03/01/2023 10:38

I wouldn't routinely block out Thursday evening, as if there is an expectation in your role that you do attend evening events and they are within commuting distance of your home, then I'd say it is reasonable to expect you to attend those.

But Fridays- absolutely.

Fraaahnces · 03/01/2023 10:35

Surely if you’re not employed to work that day, or not paid, then you’re not insured either? Could be potentially an issue…

Brefugee · 03/01/2023 10:34

If you're not expected to work, just to travel home, on your day off, I don't think it's that unreasonable an expectation.

haha, fuck that. it is HUGELY unreasonable, especially since OP has said these events would never be on a Friday.

Back in my Army days i did (mad) shifts. But we all still had to do military training and PT, as did all the staff who didn't work shifts, and as a result of it being those people planning the training it was always done on our one day off in a cycle (not every cycle but probably once a month) which meant we worked every day for 16 days. And our complaints fell on deaf ears until our colonel decided to work a shift cycle or two with us to annoy us "keep his hand in". And luckily for us, it was an NBC training day. He finally got what we had been talking about and ever after all military training was done on a Saturday Grin because you can pull stunts like that in the military.

In civilian life? that would be illegal, i think?

DRS1970 · 03/01/2023 10:32

Stick to your day off, or make it explicit that it is a one off due to special circumstances caused by the overnight stay.

YoungForestElephant · 03/01/2023 10:30

May sound like a basic thing but i have found that blocking the entire day - so it shows purple as 'Out of Office' every week helps. In your case I would start the block from say 6pm on the Thursday - which stops these types of events being 'accidentally' put in your calendar on a Thursday night.

I found once I started to religiously block the time out people start to respect it. I think it also takes time for others to adjust but they will adjust.

In cases where you have to be flexible (for genuine emergencies etc.) then be ruthless about taking the time back. In this scenario I also wouldn't apply for the time - I would just take it. Again block it as out of office in your calendar.

2Rebecca · 03/01/2023 10:25

I suspect you are getting this hassle because it's the first few weeks of your new hours and you need to be inflexible the first couple of months so they get used to your new hours and coping without you.
If they need a flexi worker who can work different days each week then they advertise for one. Part timers are not flexi workers.

roarfeckingroarr · 03/01/2023 10:24

Ok if that's your boundary OP. I work 4 days too but take Wednesdays off, so if I applied the same rule I wouldn't be available for evenings with clients on Tuesdays or Wednesdays - or able to be in a meeting that requires travel on a Thursday morning either. I think that would be quite a big ask given the seniority of my role, plus I don't mind travelling, so I'm flexible. It's give and take.

LolaSmiles · 03/01/2023 10:24

I don't think it's unusual to travel in your own time. To travel to a conference on a Sunday evening, for example? It depends if FT staff would be expected to travel in their own time or not.
I would imagine for a one off conference it would be a discussion between the worker and their line manager. That would form part of the give and take required in certain positions. That's how it works for DH.

A different colleague, who isn't more senior than OP, deliberately booking something that requires a newly part time worker to lose a chunk of their non-working day, and also booking things into a part time colleague's non-working day is 100% unreasonable.

Nobody can be directed to work in their non-working hours.

HandbagsnGladrags · 03/01/2023 10:20

Am 100% not travelling back from an event on a non working day. Fuck that - it's not reasonable, as some others have already said.

OP posts:
LittleDisaster · 03/01/2023 10:20

LolaSmiles · 03/01/2023 10:15

If you're not expected to work, just to travel home, on your day off, I don't think it's that unreasonable an expectation.

You're in a fairly senior role. You can't essentially write off your day off AND the ones before and after for travel.

Full time colleagues would not be expected to be at work with clients on a Friday night and then lose a quarter of their weekend travelling home from a work event.

Part time work is no different. The OP is not paid for her time on a non-working day.

If there are regular travel/entertaining client events then this should be factored into which days are granted for non-working days. If OP's work arrangements have been approved then it's been agreed she does not work a particular day.

I don't think it's unusual to travel in your own time. To travel to a conference on a Sunday evening, for example? It depends if FT staff would be expected to travel in their own time or not.

Butchyrestingface · 03/01/2023 10:19

Stick to your guns. Your feet are hardly back through the door and they're taking the piss already.

Some people - you give them an inch and they take a thousand miles. Sounds like your colleague may be one of them.

LolaSmiles · 03/01/2023 10:15

If you're not expected to work, just to travel home, on your day off, I don't think it's that unreasonable an expectation.

You're in a fairly senior role. You can't essentially write off your day off AND the ones before and after for travel.

Full time colleagues would not be expected to be at work with clients on a Friday night and then lose a quarter of their weekend travelling home from a work event.

Part time work is no different. The OP is not paid for her time on a non-working day.

If there are regular travel/entertaining client events then this should be factored into which days are granted for non-working days. If OP's work arrangements have been approved then it's been agreed she does not work a particular day.

WetLettuce2 · 03/01/2023 10:15

100% don’t budge this early on - you can be flexible further down the line if you want to (I wouldn’t).

Swipe left for the next trending thread