Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are some people on here so horrible?

285 replies

Wheeesht3 · 02/01/2023 22:58

has anyone else noticed an increase in certain posters who consistently comment with horrible, insulting and deliberately unhelpful things?

im not talking about posts where the OP can’t accept the truth, or where they don’t like to be told they are being unreasonable. I’m talking about certain commenters consistently posting horrible comments. You can recognise it by their username in some cases.

does MN deal with them? There’s several posters I can think of off the top of my head who are horrible everytime they comment, and half the time their comments end up being deleted for being horrible. Maybe it’s just me but I’ve definitely noticed an increase in it recently.

OP posts:
verystablegenius · 03/01/2023 05:52

Downunderduchess · 03/01/2023 02:17

The thing I loathe most on here is when posters hijack a thread to argue a specific point & they go back & forth with a couple of other posters. It ruins what is often an interesting discussion. It’s like they MUST be right and won’t stop trying to make others agree with them. Craziness & quite selfish.

You're right - there'll be a throwaway comment on page 6 of a thread and it will generate a poster constantly coming back to this one point, like a dog with a bone.

PrincessConstance · 03/01/2023 05:49

Ayeaken · 03/01/2023 01:14

"we don't have to 'be nice' as women are often expected to be".

Being nice isn't an expectation of women, it's an expectation of decent human beings living and interacting in a civilised society. Don't try and use that as a poor excuse to justify being rude/nasty. Anyone with a modicum of intelligence can respectfully disagree/state their case without resorting to sarcasm, name calling, taunting, etc.

Mumsnet is full of abrasive replies such as just tell them to f off. No one speaks like that in real life without being either called out or disowned. It's certainly not how 'Telling them how it is', is defined.
It's embarrassing.
Being pleasant and polite is better received than being vulgar and sweary.

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 05:27

SugarplumFairyyy · 03/01/2023 02:09

I was just so aghast that MN allowed users to use the word "cunt" that it felt like a weird novelty for me at first on here. So many places don't allow it, I felt like I was given permission to use it. I dont even normally use the word cunt but by week two I'm replying to the OP like:

Tell your cunt-face SIL to stop being such a cunty bitch by spreading rumours and then cunting around. The cunt.

Grin
Tomatobear · 03/01/2023 05:13

I agree there are some horribly arrogant, contrarian and small minded people on here. Without them it would be a lovely, supportive place where more women would reach out for support

HappinessAlley · 03/01/2023 04:51

I see it quite a lot too. Some people seem to find pleasure in escalating the tone of a conversation. They often take comments out of context and twist the meaning to get a reaction. I can only guess it's because they find it fun.

As for reporting it, it's difficult. It's not normally a direct personal attack (shut up you poopy head) but more subtle but still often as hurtful due to the snarkiness, passive aggression and condescension.

SugarplumFairyyy · 03/01/2023 02:23

Downunderduchess · 03/01/2023 02:17

The thing I loathe most on here is when posters hijack a thread to argue a specific point & they go back & forth with a couple of other posters. It ruins what is often an interesting discussion. It’s like they MUST be right and won’t stop trying to make others agree with them. Craziness & quite selfish.

Yes you are right!!!

And this literally happens
EVERY👏SINGLE👏TIME👏

Downunderduchess · 03/01/2023 02:17

The thing I loathe most on here is when posters hijack a thread to argue a specific point & they go back & forth with a couple of other posters. It ruins what is often an interesting discussion. It’s like they MUST be right and won’t stop trying to make others agree with them. Craziness & quite selfish.

SugarplumFairyyy · 03/01/2023 02:09

I was just so aghast that MN allowed users to use the word "cunt" that it felt like a weird novelty for me at first on here. So many places don't allow it, I felt like I was given permission to use it. I dont even normally use the word cunt but by week two I'm replying to the OP like:

Tell your cunt-face SIL to stop being such a cunty bitch by spreading rumours and then cunting around. The cunt.

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 02:03

Now's the time @PrincessNakatomi Grin

PrincessNakatomi · 03/01/2023 01:46

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 00:54

Because you seem to think it’s of some relevance that I’ve NC, and other posters have suggested that the fact there’s been lots of these threads recently means this thread isn’t genuine. Hence why I said feel free to report if you have any concerns. Otherwise, I’ve no idea why you’re concerned that I’ve NC, which is perfectly acceptable and allowed

I think it's because you've posted saying someone is horrible and calls you names, including cunt. Well I post a LOT and don't think I've been called a cunt recently (awaits MN humorous cunt-calling). Don't get me wrong lots of people don't like me and tell me off, that's fine. To be called a cunt, well, there is the smallest chance you said something that maybe some people might believe was a little cuntish. Maybe not though. NCing means you can object to the name calling giving the history of the conversation as you see it, but no one can actually assess it.

I like a good primary source!

Well said, MrsTP. I’ve never seen anyone call you a cunt either!

SugarplumFairyyy · 03/01/2023 01:46

nalabae · 03/01/2023 01:42

Sometimes people post annoying things like “we said we won’t get each other presents and he got me one”
why is this type of question postable on AIBU? Who the hell cares! It’s such a non issue or people say “should I go A&E” cause they have cough.

some people lack common sense on here or need friends to say these irrelevant questions to.

Or when people clearly need to take their children to A&E as they have sky high temp, vomiting, rash etc etc and they are like
" so basically I'm just getting teensy wee bit worried cos little one has collapsed now" and people have to tell the OP go to the hospital😳

nalabae · 03/01/2023 01:42

Sometimes people post annoying things like “we said we won’t get each other presents and he got me one”
why is this type of question postable on AIBU? Who the hell cares! It’s such a non issue or people say “should I go A&E” cause they have cough.

some people lack common sense on here or need friends to say these irrelevant questions to.

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 01:42

nalabae · 03/01/2023 01:40

It’s this section

It's true. Sporner Corner is utterly delightful. Supportive, kind and funny. And covered in pus.

Summer2424 · 03/01/2023 01:42

Hi @Wheeesht3 yes i've noticed too!
Some of them comment on my comment in such a horrible way 😔

nalabae · 03/01/2023 01:40

It’s this section

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 01:39

Being nice isn't an expectation of women, it's an expectation of decent human beings

Men don't get told off half as much for twice as much awful behaviour. I assume OP isn't on Reddit or Twatter or any of the utterly vile cesspits men frequent telling them off.

The phrase, "isn't this place supposed to be..." is constant. This place is often supportive and lovely but I think people think it HAS to be because it's mums. And mums are supposed to be primarily nice. Well the mums here are sometimes nice. But also funny and intelligent and cutting and no nonsense and brave and strong. And sometimes that means you get what you need, not what you want.

There is always Netsmums for 'you go girl' hunning.

ruo · 03/01/2023 01:38

BIWI
@worraliberty hello! I was wondering where you'd got to - haven't seen you posting in ages!

Good old namechange

Definitely ^

mathanxiety · 03/01/2023 01:36

@Cuppasoupmonster yes, goadiness as a term can be used that way.

However, I've been on this site for many years now, and I know it when I see it used in a personal way, with the aim of getting under someone's skin.

I've seen many examples in the past week or two which were not a simple, forthright disagreement. They were more 'Can't you google, stupid?' Or 'When I was in this situation I had a termination, because unlike you who are clearly an inadequate mother and self indulgent woman, I prioritized my older child'. Just nasty, and doubling down on the nastiness when challenged - take an emotive topic, identify a potential doubt or insecurity on the part of another poster, hit them hard below the belt, and then keep at it.

It's the sort of communication style that leads others to very unwisely tell them to fuck off, which is something MN won't tolerate.

SugarplumFairyyy · 03/01/2023 01:32

Ayeaken · 03/01/2023 01:14

"we don't have to 'be nice' as women are often expected to be".

Being nice isn't an expectation of women, it's an expectation of decent human beings living and interacting in a civilised society. Don't try and use that as a poor excuse to justify being rude/nasty. Anyone with a modicum of intelligence can respectfully disagree/state their case without resorting to sarcasm, name calling, taunting, etc.

Yes I do see this side of things too and think that not being overly "nice" does not mean a pendulum swing into the opposite direction.

Perhaps women may feel more pressures for a less direct approach and more people pleasing mentality.
But I agree, it is human decency to be generally kind.
Having an opinion or perhaps some constructive criticism, when asked, is something some people view as being mean, however.

For me unkindness is being indignantly rude and abrasive and simply trying to belittle someone and insisting only your view is the right view.

But having a healthy debate, respecting others opinions, whilst clarifying your stance , whilst being open and willing to listen to others is fair.

I think the word "nice" has those connotations and perceptions that can be different. It can be viewed in different ways.

The way I ultimately see it is: don't say something to someone you wouldn't appreciate being said to you. Don't be an arsehole. Speak openly and honestly but refrain from extreme judgment. And finally, allow for a dose of humour... life is too serious.

Peckhaminn · 03/01/2023 01:23

Yes. I've been watching MN for a good 4 years and only recently started posting as a way to express similar interests and I've had many a nasty comments. Think some people just feel a certain way and express it's rudely via the internet. Personally, I could never be this way towards someone on the internet as I am fully aware of the repercussions it can have on someone's life xx

Ayeaken · 03/01/2023 01:14

"we don't have to 'be nice' as women are often expected to be".

Being nice isn't an expectation of women, it's an expectation of decent human beings living and interacting in a civilised society. Don't try and use that as a poor excuse to justify being rude/nasty. Anyone with a modicum of intelligence can respectfully disagree/state their case without resorting to sarcasm, name calling, taunting, etc.

LanceandBecky · 03/01/2023 01:00

I've been around for a few years, it's always been like this.

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/01/2023 00:54

Because you seem to think it’s of some relevance that I’ve NC, and other posters have suggested that the fact there’s been lots of these threads recently means this thread isn’t genuine. Hence why I said feel free to report if you have any concerns. Otherwise, I’ve no idea why you’re concerned that I’ve NC, which is perfectly acceptable and allowed

I think it's because you've posted saying someone is horrible and calls you names, including cunt. Well I post a LOT and don't think I've been called a cunt recently (awaits MN humorous cunt-calling). Don't get me wrong lots of people don't like me and tell me off, that's fine. To be called a cunt, well, there is the smallest chance you said something that maybe some people might believe was a little cuntish. Maybe not though. NCing means you can object to the name calling giving the history of the conversation as you see it, but no one can actually assess it.

I like a good primary source!

CallieQ · 03/01/2023 00:49

What are the talk guidelines? Sometimes posts get deleted because they disagree with the OP

LadySweetPea · 03/01/2023 00:47

Presumably a sign of disordered personality... maybe they have no-one else to abuse so they come online? I mean, if you think about it, it's pretty sad. Very boring how certain posters completely derail threads with their abusive posts, though (including one in this thread lol)