Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what can be done immediately to take the pressure off the NHS?

756 replies

Twinklenoseblows · 02/01/2023 22:46

I've been reading stories about people waiting 4 days in A&E, people being taken into A&E in the back of a van with a broken hip as there are no ambulances ,and doctors and nurses pleading for something to be done right now as lives are at risk. But what can be done that would make a difference within the next week or two?

Promises of more money and more staff will presumably take years to filter through and make a difference.

I guess what is worrying me beyond the immediate crisis is that some bright spark in government is going to say we need a circuit breaker lockdown to reduce flu and covid admissions for the next few months to take some immediate pressure off. The thought fills me with horror so I'm hoping there is something else.

E.g. as a very short term measure could some people be diverted to make use of any spare private GP capacity to try to reduce the number of people going to A&E who could instead be dealt with by a GP if only they could get an appointment. Or is that madness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SoShallINever · 04/01/2023 23:59

mrsnoodle55
I absolutely agree that we have lost all sense of rationality trying to save 94 year olds with dementia. You just can't save everyone all the time and whilst beds are occupied by 90yr olds they will be turning away 40yr olds at the front door.
My gorgeous mum died recently at 88. We had to plead with the (wonderful) paramedics, not to take her into hospital as she wanted to die at home. She had full capacity and as an ex nurse was fully aware of how awful being on a chaotic ward would be.
The GP was another matter and practically accused us of trying to murder her.

FriedasCarLoad · 04/01/2023 23:59

If you are a smoker/ heavy drinker/ obese then you have to start paying into an insurance scheme to gain full access to NHS services.

I'm obese. I put on weight because of poorly treated medical issues. I've managed not to gain more, but it's extremely difficult to lose any, in spite of exercise, teetotalism and lots of fruit and veg.

On the other hand, I've saved the country a fortune by giving up five years of my life to care for my terminally ill and very disabled mother, and I now give several hours a week to carrying for elderly relatives, friends and neighbours.

To afford insurance I'd have to give up those hours to earn extra money, which would actually cost the country more money.

JenniferBooth · 04/01/2023 23:58

Looks like some people are under the impression that misogyny will save the NHS

MintyFreshOne · 04/01/2023 23:51

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 13:44

@Snowmoab I have seen that argument before about rising at a faster rate. But I understand arithmetic so I know that argument is bollocks.

Little lesson - if for ease 1% of a population is obese in country A but increases to 3% being obese and
10% of a population in country B is obese but rises to 22%
Obesity in country A is rising at a much faster rate than in country B. Even though the level of obesity in country B is far higher than in country A - 3% compared to 22%.

The US is a clear example of how paying for healthcare has no impact on peoples personal responsibility. That is because the reasons for peoples lifestyle behaviour is complex and not as easily changed as the mantra of personal responsibility suggests. All that happens is that people die younger. The US has a much lower life expectancy than Britain.

Individuals don’t pay the full costs of obesity in the US; insurers do, which is spread among their entire client base.

The poor don’t pay at all so they have few constraints in that sense.

The larger issue (ahem) is that it’s really too late to do anything anyway by the time it affects your health so badly you have to see doctors and be on medication

mrsnoodle55 · 04/01/2023 23:23

Coming back to this thread raises some interesting ideas- wouldn’t it be great if Rishi read it 🙄

I had to come back to offer a glimpse into one of the big issues ; today I went, on 999 calls/blue lights, to 6 patients. 5 in care homes, one in sheltered accommodation. Ages of 90, 93, 94, 2 patients of 88 yrs old and finally a 95 year old lady.

All 6 people ended up going in. This is pretty rare tbh. This isn’t intended to be an agist post, merely an insight. 2 of these patients had complex and life threatening problems (very rapid heart rate and sepsis), quite rightly required treatment in hospital. The other 4 patients invoked lengthy phone calls to GP’s, OOH’s…. The result being that the tunnel visioned risk averse culture we exist in removed all common sense. In they went. Not necessarily the fault of the other HCP’s/GP’s I spoke too- more that short term risk trumps the long term risks that we all know about, but no-one can quantify those so in they go.

The risk to the individual patient at that exact time trumped the huge extended risk to them in terms of a lengthy hospital stay, the inevitable 15 hr wait on the corridor, the huge slump in mobility once in hospital, the risk of acquiring HAP, covid, you name it, the big risk of not making it out. So the 94 year old with dementia who may have had a stroke at some point in the night, so way out of any treatment window, was sent in by the GP, from a comfy bed, in her care home, with carers who maybe even have time to feed/toilet her, to a hospital corridor for an 18 hour wait, to (fingers crossed) end up on a stroke ward, to be eventually discharged a shell of her former self.

We- families, partners, children of the elderly, HCP’s, need to wise up to the fact that sending our elderly relatives to hospital ‘to be checked on’ is sometimes the worst possible decision. We need a huge education campaign. Sending people to hospital should have a definite aim- not just be the default position to shift risk to someone else. The vision of distressed elderly people, languishing on the corridors of my A and E, is an imagine that chills me to my soul.

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/01/2023 22:49

Rowthe

“It's easy blaming people for getting ill when the blame lies in one place.“

No it doesn’t. Our Government is a shambolic, incompetent, self-interested embarrassment.
The great British public does itself no favours whatsoever, though. Too many people eat too much, drink too much alcohol, don’t exercise enough and, still, smoke. Personal responsibility seems to be a thing of the past.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 04/01/2023 22:44

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/01/2023 22:22

What’s the moral of this story?

Save the NHS by not spiking drinks?

I think it's more their inconsiderate refusal to provide strobe lights and a DJ.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/01/2023 22:22

JenniferBooth · 04/01/2023 20:49

There was a young woman on the news recently who had been spiked on a night out and she felt as if they treated her like she was just drunk

What’s the moral of this story?

Save the NHS by not spiking drinks?

JenniferBooth · 04/01/2023 20:49

There was a young woman on the news recently who had been spiked on a night out and she felt as if they treated her like she was just drunk

SirMingeALot · 04/01/2023 19:52

Provision to charge patients in the NHS already exists. It's just that it requires staff, doesn't come for free and in order to be profitable, needs to actually recoup all those costs and more. Given that some people who present at A and E for treatment while under the influence are homeless or otherwise transient, and therefore not going to pay, that's a considerable hurdle. This is even before we start considering how to administer the inevitable exemptions for people who've been the victims of a crime, which obviously is fairly common on nights out.

Kazzyhoward · 04/01/2023 19:47

Lordofmyflies · 04/01/2023 19:29

Every patient that enters the NHS system is given a patient number. Can it be that difficult to allocate a 'fee' to a patient number payable on discharge or within 28 days? Private hospitals already use this system. Something has to change. People vastly underestimate the cost of healthcare and over estimate how far their NI contributions go.
Our A&E department now has 3 side rooms padded with gym mats for inebriated patients to recover in. The amount of time clerking, monitoring, cleaning up vomit and bodily fluids every night people who have had 'one too many' is ridiculous. Its like herding cats most nights rather than dealing with medical emergencies.

There is already something similar in place which could be extended, being the internal "business" market. Different trusts already "charge" other trusts and the national funding body for the services they provide. It wouldn't be re-inventing the wheel to "add on" to that system direct patient charges. There's already a small army of pen pushers paying money to each other in the highly fragmented NHS system.

SirMingeALot · 04/01/2023 19:39

Lordofmyflies · 04/01/2023 19:29

Every patient that enters the NHS system is given a patient number. Can it be that difficult to allocate a 'fee' to a patient number payable on discharge or within 28 days? Private hospitals already use this system. Something has to change. People vastly underestimate the cost of healthcare and over estimate how far their NI contributions go.
Our A&E department now has 3 side rooms padded with gym mats for inebriated patients to recover in. The amount of time clerking, monitoring, cleaning up vomit and bodily fluids every night people who have had 'one too many' is ridiculous. Its like herding cats most nights rather than dealing with medical emergencies.

Private hospitals aren't usually using this system for people who are on drugs, for starters.

You don't get anywhere near a private hospital unless you have a policy and a paper trail. It's a condition of entry, whereas it isn't for an NHS facility. Private healthcare companies already have established, well resourced financial and administrative systems, as well as legal processes. So they already have both a clientele who can and do pay, insurance companies to chase and the systems in place to facilitate these things. That's why they're profitable. You don't graft that same system onto the NHS by doling out invoices to drunk homeless people who have about as much chance of paying them as they do of getting angels to fly out of their arseholes.

It's a completely unworkable idea.

Lordofmyflies · 04/01/2023 19:29

Every patient that enters the NHS system is given a patient number. Can it be that difficult to allocate a 'fee' to a patient number payable on discharge or within 28 days? Private hospitals already use this system. Something has to change. People vastly underestimate the cost of healthcare and over estimate how far their NI contributions go.
Our A&E department now has 3 side rooms padded with gym mats for inebriated patients to recover in. The amount of time clerking, monitoring, cleaning up vomit and bodily fluids every night people who have had 'one too many' is ridiculous. Its like herding cats most nights rather than dealing with medical emergencies.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 04/01/2023 19:16

Lordofmyflies · 04/01/2023 18:47

Its difficult isn't it? Perhaps a set fee for those that get wasted on a night out and end up passing out / taking up a room in A/E. Maybe a sharp, short shock of self responsibility in the form of a fine may even deter repeat offenders. It would be good if money from this could go into addiction services.

This would only be a good idea if running admin for this kind of system was free. It's not!

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 19:09

@JangolinaPitt Read the thread. There are a lot of knowledgeable people who recognise a major issue is social care. If you don't fix that, nothing will change.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 19:08

That is sad. The food in my local hospital is usually very good.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/01/2023 19:07

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 18:51

@Lordofmyflies Charge people for food in hospital? Would just lead to some patients not eating the meals and surviving on cheap snacks like crisps. Which for some will delay their discharge.

In some hospitals the food is not much better than crisps, if you are lucky enough to actually get any.
(York Hospital I am looking at you.) The option to pay for nutritious food would be an improvement.

JangolinaPitt · 04/01/2023 19:07

What's clear from all this is that there isn't a quick fix or it would be fixed.
Unfortunately there is a misplaced sentimentality about the NHS with people treating it as something sacred. It is (or should be) a public service like Street lighting and tax collection. Tax funds public services so why don't we clap for tax collectors?
The NHS is a badly run anachronism and need totally overhauling and treating like the German system. Simply chucking money at it as all governents have done and continue to do -despite the predictable kneejerk sqwarks about 'the tories' is making it even worse.

JenniferBooth · 04/01/2023 18:58

MN The NHS is not a hotel
Also MN Charge people for food in hospital

SirMingeALot · 04/01/2023 18:56

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 18:50

Or more likely just lead to deaths. People will not take their alcoholic relative to hospital who has passed out again.

Or, even worse from a purely costs angle, people who are under the influence or drugs or alcohol when they get injured don't die, but they wait until they become more critical and therefore expensive to treat. The larger the bill, the less likely a person is to be able to pay it obviously. The NHS therefore ends up on the hook for both the more expensive treatment caused by this policy and for trying to enforce a debt that the person may be simply unable to pay.

Charging pissed up people is one of those ideas that gets floated sometimes but quite obviously doesn't survive any degree of scrutiny.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 18:51

@Lordofmyflies Charge people for food in hospital? Would just lead to some patients not eating the meals and surviving on cheap snacks like crisps. Which for some will delay their discharge.

BradfordGirl · 04/01/2023 18:50

Or more likely just lead to deaths. People will not take their alcoholic relative to hospital who has passed out again.

Lordofmyflies · 04/01/2023 18:47

NotAnotherBathBomb · 04/01/2023 18:29

Charge patients a with alcohol induced, drug induced injuries / medical issues a set fee.

How do we differentiate between those going too far on a night out and those battling addiction, which is an illness? Or do you not differentiate?

Its difficult isn't it? Perhaps a set fee for those that get wasted on a night out and end up passing out / taking up a room in A/E. Maybe a sharp, short shock of self responsibility in the form of a fine may even deter repeat offenders. It would be good if money from this could go into addiction services.

SirMingeALot · 04/01/2023 18:45

Charge patients a with alcohol induced, drug induced injuries / medical issues a set fee

This is a terrible idea, even when considered purely on practicalities.

These are people who are disproportionately likely to be chaotic and not pay, so the NHS would be left with the cost of billing, administering and chasing people for money they're not going to get back. They'd have to recruit people to do the work, which would pose all the usual problems that NHS admin recruitment is going through at the moment. There'd also have to be some method of scrutiny, judicial review if nothing else, so the NHS would also end up paying for involvement in that too when the more capable of the cohort who had been charged challenged it.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 04/01/2023 18:29

Charge patients a with alcohol induced, drug induced injuries / medical issues a set fee.

How do we differentiate between those going too far on a night out and those battling addiction, which is an illness? Or do you not differentiate?

Swipe left for the next trending thread