Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what can be done immediately to take the pressure off the NHS?

756 replies

Twinklenoseblows · 02/01/2023 22:46

I've been reading stories about people waiting 4 days in A&E, people being taken into A&E in the back of a van with a broken hip as there are no ambulances ,and doctors and nurses pleading for something to be done right now as lives are at risk. But what can be done that would make a difference within the next week or two?

Promises of more money and more staff will presumably take years to filter through and make a difference.

I guess what is worrying me beyond the immediate crisis is that some bright spark in government is going to say we need a circuit breaker lockdown to reduce flu and covid admissions for the next few months to take some immediate pressure off. The thought fills me with horror so I'm hoping there is something else.

E.g. as a very short term measure could some people be diverted to make use of any spare private GP capacity to try to reduce the number of people going to A&E who could instead be dealt with by a GP if only they could get an appointment. Or is that madness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SantaOnFanta · 03/01/2023 09:07

It doesn't help that so many people are coming to live here... More houses built, but where are the hospitals being built?

Where I live the town has increased by 4 times in last decade. Yet the local hospital the same.

I used to work in A&E about 15 years ago, it was hell then, I seem to think what it's like now.

MrsPutnamNaomiDarling · 03/01/2023 09:01

Reinstate the NI hike that Truss cancelled?

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 03/01/2023 08:55

Stunningscreamer · 03/01/2023 08:23

I don't know why it's worse but I'm pretty sure the Welsh Government don't decide the number of medical student places or the rates of income tax which determines the NHS budgets.

It’s worse because the welsh government are not managing the workforce crisis. I’m a labour supporter but the welsh government are dire.
In a population of 3 million 3/4 of a million are awaiting NHS treatment.
A quarter of the population!
44% of welsh gp’s are due to retire in the next 10 years.

Ravenclawess · 03/01/2023 08:55

(Name changed)

My most recent experience of NHS emergency services was on Boxing Day. My 13 year old had sever stomach pain to the point she couldn't stand up straight. So, off we went to the closest Minor Injuries Unit just to be on the safe side. I checked online and it said they were open. Got there at 2pm to discover a printout on the door saying they had closed at 1pm because it's Boxing day and to go to A&E at RD&E. This left the entirety of Mid Devon without any out of hours care from 1pm on boxing day with the reccomendation to go to A&E...

The 2 other minor injury units in Mid Devon closed in the last 5 years and there are no WIC facilities.

So I checked the NHS Quicker App which says its an 9 hour wait in A&E RD&E but a 2 hour wait at a walk in centre 5 mins walk from the A&E. I called ahead and they saw us at the WIC in and out in under 2 hours. However had I not had the app I would have never known this place even existed.

During our wait at the walk in centre 6 parents with small (under 4) children turned up after being sent over from A&E (not including those already waiting) because they were told they were not an emergency (higher temps but kids running around still). One woman was even ranting to everyone who would listen that they refused to prescribe antibiotics for her son and she wasn't leaving until she got them because he had had a temp or over 38 for 5 days now. Another parent, upon hearing this, got up and left after realising they weren't just handing out penicillin willy nilly. It is madness.

From our time of arriving at the WIC at 2:45 to our leaving 2 hours later the wait time for being seen went from 2hrs to 4 hrs (The WIC is open 8-8). The A&E wait on the app was now 26 hours.

The Gov needs to fund more non emergent care. The NHS needs to make people aware of MIUs and WICs.

Hoppinggreen · 03/01/2023 08:54

motherhubbard12 · 02/01/2023 23:06

The immediate thing is that every single person can consider their need for A&E very carefully. That would make an immediate difference.

I used to be on the board of our local NHS Trust and saw some stats around how many people who attended A&E over 1 weekend actually should have been there - it was 20%.
The rest were drunks, drug addicts, homeless, people with MH issues, entitled idiots and people who couldn’t get a GP appointment, as well as some who were genuinely worried (usually parents) but didn’t really need emergency care.
A&E is massively overused and abused
The obvious answer is to increase services and access to them in Primary care but how that can be done quickly I don’t know

Itstoocoldoutthere · 03/01/2023 08:48

Immediate

Immediate significant pay increases across the NHS for front line staff.

Immediate significant increase in minimum wage for care workers.

Special tax reliefs for anyone working in the medical profession.

Tax relief/more benefits for stay-at-home carers but a requirement to take some basic training in care in order to qualify.

Free Visa entry scheme for foreign medical staff – we should be welcoming foreign doctors and nurses and before anyone complains about taking medical staff from other nations, a few years in UK is good for their careers, it doesn’t need to be for life.

Separate A &E from walk-in minor injuries/sickness.
Separate doors – Separate staff etc. This happens in some places but needs to be much clearer.Vulnerable patients with life-threatening conditions such as heart attacks and strokes should not be sat in an A&E waiting room alongside someone’s kid with flu/covid/strep - this has happened to me recently as the ambulance service left me in a chair (no beds available) to wait my turn as they had another call.

Significant tax increases on alcohol, cigarettes, processed junk food etc.
Ban the sale of the worst offenders completely – force a reduction in alcoholic content or the strength of tobacco etc.

During this crisis, the NHS should only provide life-preserving essential services (no electives). Doctors from other departments should be re-deployed to help where possible.

Entitlement to time off (similar to maternity leave) for all staff to enable them look after sick relatives at home. This could alleviate a lot of the issues of getting patients out of hospital.

Paid GP appointments for those that can afford it through more private (but reasonably priced) GPs to relieve the burden on the NHS.
Paid minor injuries/walk-in clinics too. The NHS should remain free but limited to emergencies only. There needs to be more choice for those that can afford to pay – stop the requirement to see your GP for a referral. Allow direct access to specialists for paying patients.

For the future

Full bursaries/free training for all medical staff (probably via write off of student loan after 5 years employment in NHS.

Train more medics through the armed forces.
Increase recruitment of medical staff in the forces through schools etc and provide incentives for them to move to the NHS on completion of training.
If the NHS was run more like the forces, I am sure it would be more efficient.
Maybe the NHS should be a fourth ‘service’.
In future, any threat to our country is likely to come through disease, gun warfare, gas or poisons etc. A better trained and funded medical provision would be an essential provision.

More encouragement for home care, multi-generational living etc. to help with care of the elderly as we cannot as a nation expect to house and care for them all.

Mothers need to be taught how to look after their children when they are sick etc. A compulsory GCSE in child and elderly care or equivalent training would go a long way to helping this happen.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 08:48

Spendonsend · 03/01/2023 08:32

I know this sounds silly, but i dont actually know what the problem is? I hear a lot of flu/covid/rsv patients are in hospital. Every year of my life the hospitals get stretched with flu. Maybe we need to reopen cottage hospitals for respiratory viruses.

I think housing is a big issue too. My mum has moved into a retirement flat. The service charge is enourmous and grows each year and doesnt cover much. If we want more people to downsize we need to build the type of housing they want.

Extra flu / strep A and some Covid apparently

HelloDaisy · 03/01/2023 08:47

Supernormative · 03/01/2023 07:53

Allow elderly people with no capacity and complex comorbidities to die with dignity. I saw an interview recently with a doctor who said the main problem was the families, insisting on resuscitations and invasive treatments for their relatives with dementia and other issues. He has no option but to comply but could not believe the numbers of people who were wanting to put their relatives through hideous treatments for a few months more of existence. I have two aunts in care homes, neither of which know who they are or what they are doing. They live their lives in considerable distress. I hope for everyone's sake, including theirs, that they are allowed to die soon but no doubt the care homes and their children will continue to rush them into A&E every time there is an issue, to be patched up and sent back to hell.

We also need to immediately sort out the elderly care system and relieve the blocking of beds (which is not the patient's fault). Reopen the Nightingale hospitals and staff with the army to get people into these half way houses while long term care is being sorted.

More education for people about self-treatment. I work in health (private, functional, not medicine) and am amazed how much my seemingly educated clients rush off to the doctor to get something 'checked out'. You see it on Mumsnet all the time. Rushing kids off to A&E 'because you can never be too careful with a child and they will always see children'. Or the recent thread about someone who went to A&E a day or two after they thought their drink had been spiked and they were already feeling better. A total waste of resources. 111 also need to stop sending ambulances for everything under the sun because they are afraid of getting sued. Ambulances are not a taxi service, they are for people who can't be moved after an accident or where it is a genuine emergency, e.g. stopped breathing.

Better access to GPs and allowing pharmacists to prescribe basic things like antibiotics. They are allowed to do this in Scotland but not England. Total madness.

Well said, far better than I could have written it.

I used to run a nursing home and we hardly ever sent residents to hospital, only for falls resulting in broken bones, but it seems that we are now so afraid of death that we fight against it all the time, trying to prolong somebody’s life only for them to live in this half way hell for another few months.

My dad died at home and even though he was only 45 we would not have rushed him off to hospital at the end just to give him another few hours/days but allowed him to die at home with all of us, with dignity.

RoseMadderAsHell · 03/01/2023 08:47

MintJulia · 03/01/2023 08:04

And, yes, I would charge for missed appointments.

I recently went for a mammogram. I got there early, expecting to wait and was see immediately. The previous SEVEN patients hadn't shown up. None had bothered to cancel their slots. I was told this is not unusual.

Stupid, selfish, wasteful and hideously expensive

It might be the NHS system at fault here, not the patient.
Routine mammogram appointments (with time and date) are sent out in our area.
As these appointments haven't been requested and for many are unexpected (they might not even bother to open the envelope assuming junk mail) the onus shouldn't be on women to cancel if not convenient/not wanted.
Perhaps the idea is that more women will attend if they don't have to phone and make an appointment, but it's bound to result in loads of missed appointments.

ButterBastardBeans · 03/01/2023 08:47

Staff in the NHS could do their jobs properly int he first place. My last eight trips to A & E and my Dh's last four have all been as a result of staff in the NHS failing to do their job correctly in the first place.

I haven't worked since 2017 because I had botched surgery. My DH has been let down even worse by the NHS. They are, root and branch, a shoddy joke.

Greatly · 03/01/2023 08:36

Shame on the posters who think it’s the fault of the service users!

Don't be so dramatic. Of course there are people at A and E that shouldn't be there or are just hugely pissed.

olympicsrock · 03/01/2023 08:36

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 03/01/2023 06:41

If the country stopped paying for every old frail person to be kept going til they are in their 90s we might have better health care for younger people.

My grandmother is in her early 90s and still completely sound of mind. Still cooks, goes shopping, etc. Has always led a healthy lifestyle and never been overweight in her entire life.

By contrast, I look at some of the unrepentant fatties that comprise our young and don't really feel they should be automatically prioritised based on their age.

Obviously, keeping a barely sentient person alive with expensive treatments doesn't seem a great use of resources, but where do you draw the line? If somebody is experiencing lots of health problems at a young age you could also argue that we just nip it in the bud rather than allow a whole life of expensive treatments. Unlike most elderly people they may not ever pay into the system if they're too fat/ill to work.

@FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine i don’t mean those like your grandmother who would score reasonably on the clinical frailty score. She clearly has good health and quality of life . I mean those who are dependent on others for all care.

sjxoxo · 03/01/2023 08:34

They need more money and more staff; now.
This has entirely been orchestrated by the Conservative government.. money was available very quickly during covid so no I don’t think it will take years to trickle down. It’s a choice from the government to let the NHS rot. Shame on the posters who think it’s the fault of the service users! Even if there are some people who go to A&E etc for inappropriate reasons, the system should be equipped to deal with some extra. It’s an entirely political choice- ten years in the making. x

Spendonsend · 03/01/2023 08:32

I know this sounds silly, but i dont actually know what the problem is? I hear a lot of flu/covid/rsv patients are in hospital. Every year of my life the hospitals get stretched with flu. Maybe we need to reopen cottage hospitals for respiratory viruses.

I think housing is a big issue too. My mum has moved into a retirement flat. The service charge is enourmous and grows each year and doesnt cover much. If we want more people to downsize we need to build the type of housing they want.

FrizzledFrazzle · 03/01/2023 08:25

I don't think the problem is the NHS. I think it's the lack of social care facilities, so that people who have received NHS treatment but who need ongoing support are able to leave hospital with an at home package of care (support with washing/dressing/food prep etc).

A lot of the NHS issues at A&E / hospital are because people can't be discharged so there are no beds.

A fix for that would be massively increasing the social care budget for local authorities and training new support workers to meet demand. It's hard to recruit for care work so a pay increase might help. It might also help to make care workers a shortage occupation to allow international recruitment.

On the NHS front, I think the issues Cary regionally, but timely access to a GP would be a good start!

Cm078 · 03/01/2023 08:25

1 thing I know through working in a hospital would help. Pay carers more money so there are more carers out there for those medically fit to be discharged able to go home quicker. Some can wait weeks for a care package therefore holding a bed no longer needed. Sad, but that's the reality now.

Hongkongsuey · 03/01/2023 08:24

MintJulia · 03/01/2023 08:04

And, yes, I would charge for missed appointments.

I recently went for a mammogram. I got there early, expecting to wait and was see immediately. The previous SEVEN patients hadn't shown up. None had bothered to cancel their slots. I was told this is not unusual.

Stupid, selfish, wasteful and hideously expensive

I can see the point of charging for missed appointments made by the patient but screening letters are just sent out inviting women to attend. They also overbook, knowing a certain percentage of patients won’t turn up. So it doesn’t seem fair to charge for missing something not requested in the first place.

Stunningscreamer · 03/01/2023 08:24

Also when we had a national Labour Government public services were not falling apart in the way they are now.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 08:24

Stunningscreamer · 03/01/2023 08:23

I don't know why it's worse but I'm pretty sure the Welsh Government don't decide the number of medical student places or the rates of income tax which determines the NHS budgets.

Devolved systems can decide income tax. Scotland has increased theirs and Wales probably can too.

Stunningscreamer · 03/01/2023 08:23

Freysimo · 03/01/2023 08:16

'Don't vote Tory'. I live in Wales where NHS is managed by Welsh Labour. It's in a worse state than England's.

I don't know why it's worse but I'm pretty sure the Welsh Government don't decide the number of medical student places or the rates of income tax which determines the NHS budgets.

Stunningscreamer · 03/01/2023 08:20

Glittertrauma · 02/01/2023 23:09

Well to put it quite blunty, the NHS was never designed for the world we have now, where more people than ever live into their 80s and 90s with complex health issues that require long term support. We have an ageing population. No one wants to pay the level of tax that it would take to truly support the NHS. 10 years plus of a Conservative government that are actively committed to bringing state health care to its knees. Scientific breakthroughs creating the possibility of more complex treatments and surgeries that people expect to receive. Comprehensive financial mismanagement but a lot of NHS trusts. People having children later or through IVf leading to complex pregnancies and births with a lot more intervention. There are some very hard truths we just aren't prepared to face. Even an NHS that was properly funded and politically supported would be struggling. The simple truth is we all need to pay a lot more. And get a lot more strict on what is treated and what is not. But I don't think people want to hear that. They want low taxes and a bottomless pit of treatment.

This is a massive issue. People want functioning public services but don't want to pay higher income taxes. They want to be able to pass on all their inheritance to their children (much of which will have come from increase in property prices, not from savings from work) and not pay income tax on it while at the same time have top notch, free social care.

There is no government fund that comes from magic land. They only have money from our taxes. If we want decent public services, we have to pay for them through taxes. There aren't enough billionaires paying taxes in this country to fund our entire public services (most of those that are here are non doms anyway and probably pay less tax than us!). We all have to contribute.

And we all have to make the effort by not making frivolous demands on the NHS. Don't take up an appointment unless you really need it. Try and look after your own health. Cancel an appointment if you can't attend. Eat more healthily and do moderate excercise. It requires a collective effort.

Freysimo · 03/01/2023 08:16

RobertaFirmino · 02/01/2023 23:22

There are plenty of things people can do to help. I'm sure most people could do at least one of these things:
Don't vote Tory
Consider the need for A&E
Maintain a healthy weight
Quit the cigs
Reduce alcohol consumption
Take regular exercise
Do the exercises that the physio/specialist recommended
Have fewer children
Treat at home if you can
Buy your own meds if available OTC and affordable
Don't miss appointments
Campaign for change
Treat NHS staff with courtesy

People might say 'Well why should we have to do anything, it's up to the government to sort it out'. To that, I would reply that they are doing sweet FA to improve things so it's down to us.

'Don't vote Tory'. I live in Wales where NHS is managed by Welsh Labour. It's in a worse state than England's.

Flammkuchen · 03/01/2023 08:07

Charge £10 per visit for GP appointments, £20 for A&E and £50 per day for stay in a hospital for anyone who is medically fit to leave. No exceptions, apart from halving costs for those on out of work benefits (not pensions).

It would reduce unnecessary appointments and give people a very strong incentive to get out of hospital quicker, or allow more funding if it is too inconvenient for them to look after their relatives.

MintJulia · 03/01/2023 08:04

And, yes, I would charge for missed appointments.

I recently went for a mammogram. I got there early, expecting to wait and was see immediately. The previous SEVEN patients hadn't shown up. None had bothered to cancel their slots. I was told this is not unusual.

Stupid, selfish, wasteful and hideously expensive

MintJulia · 03/01/2023 08:01

SellFridges · 03/01/2023 07:29

The key to sorting out the NHS, is sorting out social care. Too many old people think they can stay in their unsuitable accommodation for too long and don’t make plans for the future. They end up bed blocking as a result.

Their children cannot care for them as they are geographically dispersed, have their own young children, and have jobs to pay their bills.

  1. Normalise downsizing
  2. Incentivise saving for care (similar to health insurance or life policies)
  3. Don’t vote Tory.

I'll be 60 this year. I'm trying to downsize. Single storey two bed homes are almost impossible to find.

I refuse to move to an over-priced retirement apartment with no outside space and rocketing service charges. I will not be exploited. To the point I've bought a tiny piece of land and applied to build a bungalow - my five year plan.

Housing policy !!