Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what can be done immediately to take the pressure off the NHS?

756 replies

Twinklenoseblows · 02/01/2023 22:46

I've been reading stories about people waiting 4 days in A&E, people being taken into A&E in the back of a van with a broken hip as there are no ambulances ,and doctors and nurses pleading for something to be done right now as lives are at risk. But what can be done that would make a difference within the next week or two?

Promises of more money and more staff will presumably take years to filter through and make a difference.

I guess what is worrying me beyond the immediate crisis is that some bright spark in government is going to say we need a circuit breaker lockdown to reduce flu and covid admissions for the next few months to take some immediate pressure off. The thought fills me with horror so I'm hoping there is something else.

E.g. as a very short term measure could some people be diverted to make use of any spare private GP capacity to try to reduce the number of people going to A&E who could instead be dealt with by a GP if only they could get an appointment. Or is that madness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
LeccyBillShill · 03/01/2023 16:51

Anotherusernameanotheday · 03/01/2023 15:40

@LeccyBillShill ok so what happens when your private health care doesn't cover things like A/E care because it's just not lucrative enough ? What happens when there then becomes a two tier A/E system, basic care for the have-nots, far superior for the affluent ?
And at what point are people deemed too poor to pay insurance ? A joint house hold income of £30k ? 60k ? People are basically saying they are quite happy to pay more into a profit making business than a national free for all one....oh no we can't keep putting money into the NHS bottomless pit but desperate to line the murky coffers of Kaiser Permanente 🙄

A two-tier system would be totally fair if you redefine the “have nots” as those who have no heritage in this nation and who’ve never paid in a penny (or had any forebears who did). Why should they receive a level of care that the “affluent” - i.e. people who’ve paid NI contributions all their lives as have their forebears. Why shouldn’t they reap what they’ve sown.

Anyone with eyes who has been in an A&E or maternity ward in the last 10 years knows what’s up.

The world has been raping the NHS for decades. In the 1980s my mum’s Australian friend used to come here to get a new pair of glasses and teeth on the good old NHS every few years. I can’t imagine she’s the only one…

DeadlyDragon · 03/01/2023 16:49

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 03/01/2023 16:44

I did (or didn't do) all of those. That didn't stop me developing a condition that means I'm what you so charmingly call 'a burden' on the NHS (three monthly checkups and lifetime medication).

And at @BradfordGirl ’s comment I take my leave. This thread has turned toxic. 😂 No horse back riding or rough sports? Guess we will open up a lot of jobs as grown adults will now need nanny’s to watch them and make sure they aren’t doing anything too fun.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 03/01/2023 16:48

Insurance type schemes - Pregnant women, parents with babies, disabled people, people with chronic health problems, the poorest, and elderly people pay more

And presumably you'd be happy with pensions and long term benefits being increased so people on already limited incomes or who are unable to work could afford this?

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 16:48

Anotherusernameanotheday · 03/01/2023 16:40

@MarshaBradyo inequality has been stable for a decade ? So no longer improving ? Isn't life expectancy declining for the first time in years ?
I guess I'd like to know why you think Sunak is inherently a better bet than
Starmer ? What policies are the Conservatives promising that will improve the situation ? How are they proving that they are capable of the job on the basis of their past performance ?
The last elected tory PM was sacked because of his ineptitude, the last tory PM was close to destroying the economy, but Labour are still worse ? Mind boggles.
I suspect you and your family are doing well and you cannot see beyond that. That's fine but why post on threads like this if you are not open to changing your mind.

You were doing well with questions then bottomed out with you shouldn’t be posting 😬

I think Labour has bandwidth to do more, and I’d love to see that. I’m concerned about the direction they seem to be taking but if they drop some of those and the manifesto is something else than we’ll see.

I’m afraid many posts from Labour supporters reinforce some concerns but no not totally fixed.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:46

NHS staff often give way more of themselves than they would to a private provider. I have worked for charities and worked far harder than I now do for a private company. That kind of feeling is common amongst people/ It is why I moved to the private sector, because I wanted an easier job. I get more money and it is much easier. I see nurses who talk about moving to private healthcare in the UK moving jobs out of the NHS for more money and less work.

The NHS relies on staff. Without there co-operation any major changes will fail anyway.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 03/01/2023 16:44

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 01:42

@RobertaFirmino Interestingly if you want to not be a burden on the NHS then my advice would be-

  • keep a healthy weight
  • do not smoke
  • exercise
  • moderate alcohol consumption
  • do not take illegal drugs
  • do not ride motorbikes
  • do not go horse riding or skiing
  • do not take part in dangerous sports like rock climbing or rugby
  • do not get in between dogs fighting
  • finish your antibiotics
  • do not live in cold or damp housing

I did (or didn't do) all of those. That didn't stop me developing a condition that means I'm what you so charmingly call 'a burden' on the NHS (three monthly checkups and lifetime medication).

RethinkingLife · 03/01/2023 16:41

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:02

@RethinkingLife It would lead to more staff walking away. In Nottingham this happened when the very specialist eyecare service was privatised. The specialist Drs had warned they would walk if it happened, and they did.
In the UK most staff in the NHS do not go into it to make money. If they had to start not being able to treat some patients properly because they did not have the money to pay, some would just walk.
Imagine not being able to put a premature baby in an incubator because the parents could not afford the co pay. Lots of staff would find that hard to stomach.

From the look of that piece, it seems the author (Nigel Edwards) agrees with you that it's likely that such a drastic shift would be "unpopular among staff" (never mind the necessary level of disruption and reorganisation).

Edwards discusses more about competition, competitive markets, and social insurance systems in various countries in the next installment.

www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/news-item/myth-4-there-is-not-enough-competition-and-choice-in-the-nhs

Edwards N (2022) ‘Myth #4: “There is not enough competition and choice in the NHS”’. Nuffield Trust blog, 2 December.

Anotherusernameanotheday · 03/01/2023 16:40

@MarshaBradyo inequality has been stable for a decade ? So no longer improving ? Isn't life expectancy declining for the first time in years ?
I guess I'd like to know why you think Sunak is inherently a better bet than
Starmer ? What policies are the Conservatives promising that will improve the situation ? How are they proving that they are capable of the job on the basis of their past performance ?
The last elected tory PM was sacked because of his ineptitude, the last tory PM was close to destroying the economy, but Labour are still worse ? Mind boggles.
I suspect you and your family are doing well and you cannot see beyond that. That's fine but why post on threads like this if you are not open to changing your mind.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 03/01/2023 16:38

why not open up the nightingales

Because the Nightingales were handed back to the companies that owned them some time ago. They aren't just sitting around empty waiting for an emergency, and even if they were they'd have to be equipped and staffed.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 16:37

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:33

@MarshaBradyo I am totally against spending the billions it would require to introduce a totally different bureaucratic system.
Sort out social care and that will mean hospitals can run fine again. An insurance system for healthcare does nothing to tackle the real issues.

I completely agree here.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:37

@MarshaBradyo In terms of productivity that is when I would like Ministers to listen to Civil Servants for a change. Some Ministers appear to think productivity refers to how hard staff work!! They do not even appear to properly understand the concept. It is laughable.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:35

@scaredoff I have heard of someone with dementia living alone going to A and E for something very minor. But it was ultimately because of a lack of good social care.
But all systems have this. US has people turning up inappropriately to their private A and E as well. Some of this will happen in any system.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 16:34

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:31

@MarshaBradyo There has been massive corruption in this country in the last few years, blatantly so.

An easy fix is proper inheritance tax. But we also need to grow the economy. The government handling of the economy has been negligent. Our productivity is very low. Look at other countries like Singapore that understand the role high quality manufacturing plays in the economies productivity. Instead all we get in the UK is the idea that if workers rights are reduced that will boost the economy. They are totally fucking clueless.

What level of inheritance tax would you like?

Our productivity is low, not convinced Labour is the answer to the problem though. They seem to just say pay more, tax more, target ‘the rich’. Like I say they have more bandwidth for NHS reform (and the SM too while I’m at it) but they aren’t suggesting much to give me hope it’ll improve.

trampoline123 · 03/01/2023 16:34

People taking responsibility for their own health, don't just go to AnE, the system is being misused

Better GP service, appt availability etc

Better working conditions for NHS staff

Better mental health and care for the elderly

Govmnt to pay private health hospitals to help with back log of operations etc

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:33

@MarshaBradyo I am totally against spending the billions it would require to introduce a totally different bureaucratic system.
Sort out social care and that will mean hospitals can run fine again. An insurance system for healthcare does nothing to tackle the real issues.

DeadlyDragon · 03/01/2023 16:32

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:28

DNRs are a good thing. People do need to know it is not the same as on the telly.

Yes and it’s not a mystery who has one and who doesn’t. In my mothers facility they put a big red DO NOT RESUSCITATE sign above their heads. There’s not going to be any confusion who needs to be saved. There was one patient who kept going back and forth and the facility changed their policy that you can only change your mind 3 times in six months though because it was a lawsuit waiting to happen. This is in the US though so things are a bit different there.

scaredoff · 03/01/2023 16:32

I've never met a single person who has gone to A&E to get a bandaid put on their cut finger or paracetemol for a headache, let alone been willing to wait 12 hours for an ambulance and 2 days in A&E to do so. Nor have I seen a single piece of evidence indicating that abuse of the service has increased since the time when it used to work properly, and is therefore the reason why it no longer does . . .

Can anyone point to anything from the NHS itself - and I don't mean randoms on some internet forum claiming that they are "on the frontline" - indicating that increasingly wasteful abuse of the system is the reason for its problems and the key to solving them?

So nothing then?

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:31

@MarshaBradyo There has been massive corruption in this country in the last few years, blatantly so.

An easy fix is proper inheritance tax. But we also need to grow the economy. The government handling of the economy has been negligent. Our productivity is very low. Look at other countries like Singapore that understand the role high quality manufacturing plays in the economies productivity. Instead all we get in the UK is the idea that if workers rights are reduced that will boost the economy. They are totally fucking clueless.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 16:28

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:19

And nominal charging would not work. It would cost more to administer and would prevent those who most need it from accessing healthcare.

In terms of privatisation look at dentistry. Dentistry has been de facto privatised in the UK. It is very difficult to get an NHS dentist and if you can, often all but basic services are excluded. Most around my way will only take on children as NHS patients. And as a result you have the blossoming of cosmetic dentistry for well off people, and dreadful teeth in a significant part of the population.

This is what happens. It encourages services that make money in this case cosmetic dentistry, with those with a social conscience focusing on the most needy - usually children. Everyone else gets no service except emergency dentistry or only a partial service. Is that really what we want for healthcare generally?

It works in other countries. Aus is the one I know well. People are used to it though and we are not.

Are we too different?

Culturally quite similar, similar inequality levels but maybe it would cause worse outcomes.

However in so many posts people list models that use it and say they want that, I’m open to either argument but it seems posts are just it’s better in x country but not the detail.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:28

DNRs are a good thing. People do need to know it is not the same as on the telly.

Anotherusernameanotheday · 03/01/2023 16:27

This is a good thread about it
www.reddit.com/r/germany/comments/s2uiwi/introducing_the_german_health_care_system_to/

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/01/2023 16:26

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:22

If we encouraged personal responsibility we would tell people not to ride motorbikes or go horse riding. Both have frighteningly high odds of requiring hospital treatment.

Theyre not 1% of the issue that obesity is.

DeadlyDragon · 03/01/2023 16:25

Beexo · 03/01/2023 06:49

Ffs educate yourself putting a young healthy fit adult through CPR is a massive strain and outside of hospital setting is very very unlikely to work. The chances of a 75+ year old surviving and regaining a good quality of life no brain damage , 100 percent mobility is very very low. I do not want CPR when I become elderly because I've seen it and it's fucking brutal. You want your nan having her ribs broken and assaulted instead of being comforted in their final moments? Is that kind?

I’m not trying to be unkind but you might change your mind later. My mother is a nurse for the elderly and she has witnessed very sick old people getting resuscitated several times. She came home crying because she once witnessed an elderly man have his ribs broken three times in the same month because he kept having heart attacks because his bones were so fragile. The third time we woke up he started crying and sobbed “Won’t you people just let this old man die already?” Sometimes DNRs are the kind thing to do. His children finally signed a DNR and he passed away peacefully in his sleep a week later with his daughter at his side. DNRs don’t exist just because people can’t be bothered. Death is natural. It’s not all about “giving up” sometimes it’s because there is a time that our spirit must rest.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 16:23

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:15

@MarshaBradyo We need to pay more but most of all the government need to stop being corrupt with taxpayers money and allowing extensive fraud and misuse of public funds. This government has acted like a corrupt banana republic.

I agree the bounce back loan situation / and mini budget which were upsetting and frustrating other than that I’m ok mostly.

We’re still paying for PFI now, stuff goes wrong and it costs.

We’re high on list for non corrupt countries though and also inequality has been stable for last decade.

I get some have the perception you do and Labour could be braver with changes for NHS due to that. But unless Streeting has said something recently as mentioned below then I’m not hearing it.

So moving away from funds will be there when Labour get in - they won’t - I’d be interested to hear who pays more with any changes.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:22

If we encouraged personal responsibility we would tell people not to ride motorbikes or go horse riding. Both have frighteningly high odds of requiring hospital treatment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread