Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what can be done immediately to take the pressure off the NHS?

756 replies

Twinklenoseblows · 02/01/2023 22:46

I've been reading stories about people waiting 4 days in A&E, people being taken into A&E in the back of a van with a broken hip as there are no ambulances ,and doctors and nurses pleading for something to be done right now as lives are at risk. But what can be done that would make a difference within the next week or two?

Promises of more money and more staff will presumably take years to filter through and make a difference.

I guess what is worrying me beyond the immediate crisis is that some bright spark in government is going to say we need a circuit breaker lockdown to reduce flu and covid admissions for the next few months to take some immediate pressure off. The thought fills me with horror so I'm hoping there is something else.

E.g. as a very short term measure could some people be diverted to make use of any spare private GP capacity to try to reduce the number of people going to A&E who could instead be dealt with by a GP if only they could get an appointment. Or is that madness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
RethinkingLife · 03/01/2023 18:36

So the short term steps needed now are
a) Evusheld for the immune compromised
b) masks in all healthcare settings

I'd be pleased to be wrong but I thought most of the clinical evidence shows that Evusheld isn't effective as either a treatment for COVID-19 nor as a preventative. I'd be grateful for a link that shows otherwise (CEV family members).

Can I ask how you're defining "immune compromised," please? The Evusheld campaign refers to the #Forgotten500K. The McInnis report back in July 2022 (? - I think I gave the link upthread) identified a CEV group of @ 150K (e.g., people undergoing current systemic chemotherapy, people who've had a solid organ transplant and are on anti-rejection drugs, people with particular cancers). Some people class everyone above a certain age as "immune compromised" or vulnerable.

The PANORAMIC trial for Paxlovid (an antiviral oral drug combination) defines people as vulnerable if they're more than 50 years old or are younger and have one of a list of conditions. This definition would mean that more than 26million people in England (I think) might be eligible, looking at ONS data. I don't think you could get that many drugs in the short term, even if it were affordable.

EmmaEmerald · 03/01/2023 18:31

Leccy "It’s not nonsense, it’s common sense. Your forebears built this country and probably also fought and died for it in a couple of world wars. You have a claim. Mine didn’t, I’m only 2nd gen and would be happy to pay more into the NHS to reflect my family’s lack of heritage and input to this nation. Let’s not forget what the NHS was started for."

so, you want a system where we have to prove details of ancestry in order to prove how much we should pay to the NHS.

there's, I dunno, 67Million people in the UK.....aside from the warped thinking, how big a job do you think that is? Might as well empty the Pacific with a ladle.

LeccyBillShill · 03/01/2023 18:25

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 03/01/2023 16:56

Why should I be more entitled to care because my forebears lived here? What nonsense.

And yes I have been in A&E and maternity wards in recent years and in both cases immigrants and the children of immigrants were the ones providing the care not receiving it.

It’s not nonsense, it’s common sense. Your forebears built this country and probably also fought and died for it in a couple of world wars. You have a claim. Mine didn’t, I’m only 2nd gen and would be happy to pay more into the NHS to reflect my family’s lack of heritage and input to this nation. Let’s not forget what the NHS was started for.

I’ve had lots of great care from immigrant NHS workers, but you must be deliberately obtuse not to recognise the heaving strain that those who aren’t “doctors and engineers” put on the system. Your view seems to suggest that there are more immigrants working in the NHS than live in the UK in total.

And let’s not forget all “immigrants” aren’t equal in terms of being “useful” or “productive” citizens. For every doctor or nurse from overseas how many do we have from places where 50% of the population don’t contribute because the culture is for women not to work but to raise large families? Not a lot of taxes coming from those types to prop up the NHS.

There are those who bring gains and those who are drains and they can’t all be lumped into one group. The NHS is under many pressures and this is just part of the picture, but one that can’t be addressed in polite society.

Lilibert456 · 03/01/2023 18:24

Not an immediate solution but the country is overwhelmed with people. Stop immigration. Don't care what colour or creed or where they come from. This is not racist just that we can't cope with anymore people needing the service. Quite prepared to be shot down and told about all the immigrant nurses, doctors and so on but these are in the minority. Just too many people to look after already. Also get rid of middle managers who contribute nothing but just take the salary.

Rewis · 03/01/2023 18:23

@BradfordGirl
Online portals won't work with everyone. Same back home. My grandmother still gets her invites via mail. But significant portion of population has the access and ability to use the Internet and has opted to use that. But this obviously requires investment in computer system

RoseAndRose · 03/01/2023 18:20

I've just has a pop up from SKY who are reporting the Health Secretary as blaming flu, Strep A and covid for NHS pressures.

This was entirely predictable, and indeed predicted.

So the short term steps needed now are
a) Evusheld for the immune compromised
b) masks in all healthcare settings
c) consider masks in other enclosed spaces (eg public transport)

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 18:10

@Rewis I remember a consultant on MN saying most of their patients were of retirement age and did not even have an email address.

Rewis · 03/01/2023 18:00

Maybe the 10million wasted unattended GP appointments would be a good start, followed by a similar amount of hospital out-patient appointments missed.

This. However the system needs an update. I'm pretty sure I'm some sort of blacklist for missing appointments. I got invited for a pap. Let them know I already had one in private sector so no need and person on the phone cancelled it. Got a threatening letter about missed appointment later. My dermatologist told me that she'll sent me an invite for check up. Never got another invite. Probably the new people at my flat got them. My nhs dentist sends the invites via email. I was also really surprised that my doctor sent me my paperwork (diagnosis papers, referrals) in paper form. Back in my home country all of these are through online portals.

DeadlyDragon · 03/01/2023 17:59

NotAnotherBathBomb · 03/01/2023 17:52

Ah yes, if only people just did what they were supposed to do, what a perfect world that would be.

Next on the list I think you should suggest people not committing crime and people not being poor.

In a world like that we wouldn’t even need traffic lights.😃

Figgypudding123 · 03/01/2023 17:58

@BradfordGirl I take your point, but well-staffed 24 hour mental health referral services would, in many cases, be a more appropriate place of referral. It's painful just how broken the welfare state is....

NotAnotherBathBomb · 03/01/2023 17:52

scotnurse · 02/01/2023 22:56

People need to take more responsibility for their own health as well as blaming the government. People being obese with cardiac conditions or being T2DM, still smoking, drinking (and getting into a accidents as a result of being drunk) all use beds both in A&E and in the wards.

People not bothering with their own health is a main issue, even with all the education in the world about healthy eating and stopping smoking doesn't seem to make a difference.

Ah yes, if only people just did what they were supposed to do, what a perfect world that would be.

Next on the list I think you should suggest people not committing crime and people not being poor.

ClangingBell · 03/01/2023 17:44

The NHS is not available for use by random people from overseas. I had to use it twice for emergency care while visiting when living abroad, once for me and once for my then baby daughter. Both times I needed to fill in full details for them to reclaim costs from my home health care system. Both times the money was reclaimed, as I got letters confirming the charges had been paid.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 17:42

@Figgypudding123 People under psychiatric care are told to go to A and E if they have a mental health crisis. Many more people are taken there by the police. If someone is suicidal or has lost touch with reality, they need to go somewhere. At its most basic, where do the police take people they have talked out of jumping from a bridge? Or people they have been called to deal with who are shouting and trying to hit passer-by's in a City Centre street? When people are ill a jail cell is not appropriate.

Years ago London had a mental health A and E. Jo Brand worked there as a nurse. That seemed a brilliant idea to me. It was staffed by psychiatric nurses who could give treatment and get order assessments for sectioning if necessary. It is a shame it was closed.

DeadlyDragon · 03/01/2023 17:42

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:54

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain I am totally against an insurance scheme. The idea of spending billions to introduce a whole new layer of bureaucracy is nuts and will only benefit those who make money out of it.

@DeadlyDragon People are always keen to talk about how people should take responsibility for their health, but they ignore dangerous activities like horse riding and motorbike riding. I think either people should be coherent, or they should stop blaming individuals.

I agree that we shouldn’t blame individuals. Shit happens. We can’t police people’s lives and blame them for a broken system.

JenniferBooth · 03/01/2023 17:36

YY @SirMingeALot The vaccine mandate for care workers was absolute insanity. And anyone who supported this move...........well this is at least partly on them.

lljkk · 03/01/2023 17:31

Whole article here about Moroccan-born people living in UK.
51% (n=6058) in 2001 were age 30-44, so yes the exact age when their child count at home would likely maximise. Those people are still even now too young to be at the age where they are a major drain on the NHS (their median age is still << median age of indigenous born population).

Estimated total M-born living in UK = 16k-30k in 2008.
UK residents, 25k Moroccan-born in 2020 & 50k of Moroccan heritage.
Online says the Grenfell Tower building housed 600 people, so maybe that means 1000 residents in the building PP mentioned.

kistanbul · 03/01/2023 17:30

We don’t need a new system, we need to spend money. If we spent as much money on healthcare as France and Germany, we might get a healthcare system as good as France and Germany.

It would cost so much more to go through a massive restructure.

VladmirsPoutine · 03/01/2023 17:28

Pay them more!!!

Figgypudding123 · 03/01/2023 17:27

It's hard to think of any effective short-term solutions beyond the following: consider your A&E needs carefully. Get your vaccines - if eligible. Wear masks in public places and don't go out and about if sick.

I know someone who works as a A&E triage nurse who says mental health issues take up a huge amount of A&E time - that definitely needs addressing. Unless someone is bleeding out or OD-ing, then A&E really isn't the best place for mental health crises.
More funding for mental health support needed to divert people away from A&E.

More minor injury centres needed.

It might seem controversial but personally I would consider charging people for care if the injury was very obviously alcohol-related. If someone drinks 10 pints and breaks their leg falling off a kerb, why should the NHS foot the bill for that?

And pay the poor nurses a living salary. Have nothing but empathy for them atm.

MargaretMead · 03/01/2023 17:16

To answer the original question, increase staffing in

  • primary care
  • social care
  • mental health
  • ambulance services
  • Ensure support services such as labs are running 7 days per week

And the only way to attract experienced staff to make an immediate difference is to offer attractive rates of pay and conditions, and to fast track visas for overseas candidates.

I’m basing my answer on what a close relative who works for the NHS has been telling us.

JenniferBooth · 03/01/2023 17:08

@Legallypinkish so if they went home as opposed to sleeping on the floor for four days that would prove they needed A&E right.

Except i suspect you would have come to the same conclusion for both scenarios.

Anotherusernameanotheday · 03/01/2023 17:05

@MarshaBradyo thanks for answering. I think Starmer is trying to tread a fine line between wooing the City and big business and not winding up some more left wing elements of the party. It's a tricky one I agree !
www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/nov/03/labour-mps-press-keir-starmer-to-set-out-wealth-tax-plans This is a good article if you are interested. I agree that he will frighten off many a floating voter if he follows rhetoric from Richard Burgon who was a Corbyn acolyte. Lets hope he continues to be mindful of that !
Saying that not everyone is necessarily opposed to the super rich paying more
www.theguardian.com/news/2021/oct/25/millionaires-petition-rishi-sunak-to-introduce-wealth-tax

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 03/01/2023 16:56

LeccyBillShill · 03/01/2023 16:51

A two-tier system would be totally fair if you redefine the “have nots” as those who have no heritage in this nation and who’ve never paid in a penny (or had any forebears who did). Why should they receive a level of care that the “affluent” - i.e. people who’ve paid NI contributions all their lives as have their forebears. Why shouldn’t they reap what they’ve sown.

Anyone with eyes who has been in an A&E or maternity ward in the last 10 years knows what’s up.

The world has been raping the NHS for decades. In the 1980s my mum’s Australian friend used to come here to get a new pair of glasses and teeth on the good old NHS every few years. I can’t imagine she’s the only one…

Why should I be more entitled to care because my forebears lived here? What nonsense.

And yes I have been in A&E and maternity wards in recent years and in both cases immigrants and the children of immigrants were the ones providing the care not receiving it.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 16:54

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain I am totally against an insurance scheme. The idea of spending billions to introduce a whole new layer of bureaucracy is nuts and will only benefit those who make money out of it.

@DeadlyDragon People are always keen to talk about how people should take responsibility for their health, but they ignore dangerous activities like horse riding and motorbike riding. I think either people should be coherent, or they should stop blaming individuals.

LeccyBillShill · 03/01/2023 16:54

LeccyBillShill · 03/01/2023 16:51

A two-tier system would be totally fair if you redefine the “have nots” as those who have no heritage in this nation and who’ve never paid in a penny (or had any forebears who did). Why should they receive a level of care that the “affluent” - i.e. people who’ve paid NI contributions all their lives as have their forebears. Why shouldn’t they reap what they’ve sown.

Anyone with eyes who has been in an A&E or maternity ward in the last 10 years knows what’s up.

The world has been raping the NHS for decades. In the 1980s my mum’s Australian friend used to come here to get a new pair of glasses and teeth on the good old NHS every few years. I can’t imagine she’s the only one…

I will add that I place no blame whatsoever on those who’ve used the NHS without contributing.
The government - Labour not Tory - did not protect it adequately.
It’s only human nature to take what’s on offer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread