Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this charity deserve prosecution for being so bloody stupid?

298 replies

Fucklechuck · 02/01/2023 21:48

Just seen this in the news and went down a rabbit hole reading the whole story plus comments on their FB.

They took a bunch of young kids on a frozen lake (apparently without parental consent) and tried to justify it as a safety lesson despite clearly having no understanding themselves of the actual dangers. For example they're claiming the entire lake was frozen over with 2ft thick ice - no, it definitely wasn't, not in the south west of the UK, it's just not that cold in this country even in the recent cold snap. That's just impossible.

Their comments on their FB page are shockingly blasé and they've even been liking other people's comments saying that vaccines are a bigger danger to children than this was Hmm

Just can't believe anyone would be so stupid less than a week after the tragedy in Solihull Sad and then to take to social media calling it a knee jerk overreaction to suspend their license until an investigation is complete shows a total lack of regard for the most basic H&S or risk assessment processes. I actually hope their registration to look after children is revoked by whoever has such powers!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TheMightyOak · 03/01/2023 00:14

GhostBridezilla · 02/01/2023 22:23

They were supervised and teaching them what safe ice felt like. I don’t see the problem.

No such thing as 'safe ice'.

Ffs how are people not getting it? It is not safe to walk on a frozen lake. Ever.

I agree about bringing back the public information films - those thing were terrifying. I still remember the firework one..."Arghhh Juuulie" 😱

Whydidimarrythis · 03/01/2023 00:12

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 00:03

Agreed.
I have no idea if this particular activity was safe or not. But in many very cold countries people walk and skate on frozen ponds and lakes. And they do teach children how to tell if it is safe to walk on it.

You’ve got to be joking, right? In places where it might be safe they teach whether or not it’s safe. But they’re not taught by absolutely numpties who don’t know what they’re talking about and they don’t learn by venturing out onto unsafe lakes to find out. In the UK, it’s not safe, so we don’t risk our children pretending it might be.

Tulipvase · 03/01/2023 00:08

You have just said “in very many COLD countries”

It was an unusually cold period for England but we aren’t a cold country and 2 feet of frozen water would be unusual.

TangledWebOfDeception · 03/01/2023 00:08

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 00:03

Agreed.
I have no idea if this particular activity was safe or not. But in many very cold countries people walk and skate on frozen ponds and lakes. And they do teach children how to tell if it is safe to walk on it.

That is perfectly fine in those very cold countries.

This is not sensible nor safe in this country where it isn’t ever very cold for very long.

Butchyrestingface · 03/01/2023 00:07

Yes, I saw this post too and it disappeared pretty quickly. People were questioning if the op was.telling the truth it seemed so outrageous that anyone would do this so soon after the Solihull tragedy.

Never underestimate stoopid.

ClareBlue · 03/01/2023 00:06

Whydidimarrythis · 02/01/2023 23:18

To the PP who think that it’s safe because it’s only 3ft deep, Babbs Mill Park Lake is only 2-3ft deep according to the people who fish in it.

Exactly. This wasn't even a theoretical risk, assessment, it was a known risk that resulted in multiple deaths a few days before. None of those deaths were drowning so drowning was not the only very significant risk and the depth of the water becomes irrelevant.
This is into the territory of negligance and will have to be treated as such. The doubling down is not helping them. And if the two adults were trained leaders they need to review their training ASAP.

Butchyrestingface · 03/01/2023 00:03

There is no need for anyone - child or adult - to learn what "safe ice" feels like. Because there is no need for anyone to be ON the ice in the first place. That's what should be taught - stay off the ice. No ifs, buts or maybes.

BradfordGirl · 03/01/2023 00:03

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:44

If the parents gave permission then I don’t see an issue.

The lake was shallow and the ice was 2ft deep, and they were with trained staff. This would be normal in Norway.

Agreed.
I have no idea if this particular activity was safe or not. But in many very cold countries people walk and skate on frozen ponds and lakes. And they do teach children how to tell if it is safe to walk on it.

Whydidimarrythis · 02/01/2023 23:57

SnowlayRoundabout · 02/01/2023 23:53

You've missed off the highly significant first three words from that quote, namely "Staff said the lake was frozen solid". That doesn't make it true. These are staff trying to defend their extremely stupid action given that it is likely to have very serious consequences for their employers.

Spot on. Absolutely baffling that adults don’t realise that sometimes people lie or are incorrect about things. The ice was not 2ft thick and the article doesn’t say that it was, it says that someone said it was 2ft thick - that’s not the same.

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 02/01/2023 23:56

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:44

If the parents gave permission then I don’t see an issue.

The lake was shallow and the ice was 2ft deep, and they were with trained staff. This would be normal in Norway.

Its parents who have complained

One of the reasons complaints have been made is several of the children are neuro diverse, and, in the parent opinions, lack the capacity to understand that just because one iced over lake is safe to walk on another might not be

Which makes the decision even more concerning.

Invisimamma · 02/01/2023 23:55

HumourReplacementTherapy · 02/01/2023 23:01

One of the parents (or a family member of one of the children, can't quite recall) posted on mn at the time, I'm sure it must have been this she was talking about. The poster was asking who to report it to etc.
I can't see it now on TIO so must have been deleted for privacy.

Yes, I saw this post too and it disappeared pretty quickly. People were questioning if the op was.telling the truth it seemed so outrageous that anyone would do this so soon after the Solihull tragedy.

SnowlayRoundabout · 02/01/2023 23:53

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:49

I’m just going by what the article in the OP says

lake was frozen solid - the lake is 3ft deep right across to the island, and had at least 2ft / 60cm of ice on it

You've missed off the highly significant first three words from that quote, namely "Staff said the lake was frozen solid". That doesn't make it true. These are staff trying to defend their extremely stupid action given that it is likely to have very serious consequences for their employers.

Usernameisunavailable · 02/01/2023 23:52

Absolute stupidity. Well done to Forestry England for taking quick and decisive action in suspending these idiots.

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:49

TangledWebOfDeception · 02/01/2023 23:47

The ice absolutely was NOT two feet thick.

This isn’t Norway.

I’m just going by what the article in the OP says

lake was frozen solid - the lake is 3ft deep right across to the island, and had at least 2ft / 60cm of ice on it

SnowlayRoundabout · 02/01/2023 23:49

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:44

If the parents gave permission then I don’t see an issue.

The lake was shallow and the ice was 2ft deep, and they were with trained staff. This would be normal in Norway.

The charity claim it was 2 foot deep - it's a virtual certainty that it was not. It simply was not consistently cold enough for long enough. And in what way were the staff trained in assessing the thickness of ice on natural ponds and lakes? We get virtually zero experience of it in the UK.

Given that a parent complained, it doesn't look like they gave permission, either.

SusanPerbCallMeSue · 02/01/2023 23:48

Norway is completely different, weather wise, to the UK!

As a Scout leader who has to a risk assessment for every tiny thing we do I just can't see how they even thought stepping one foot onto ice was a good idea!

Risks - ice breaking, children falling in, other children panicking, shock, injuries, hypothermia, adults getting injured and not being able to help children, deaths!

How to avoid these risks - don't do it!

Jeez, how can people not see a problem?

Don't go on fucking icy ponds in this country! Ever.

TangledWebOfDeception · 02/01/2023 23:47

The ice absolutely was NOT two feet thick.

This isn’t Norway.

AlanThePig · 02/01/2023 23:46

TangledWebOfDeception · 02/01/2023 23:42

👋 to @AlanThePig how are things at the pond?

Evening @TangledWebOfDeception
Good thanks, Egwina and Duncan have returned along with a couple of other stray males.
DH and I have been discussing after the Solihull tragedy whether we should invest in a life ring and put some signs up. Not many people know the pond is here really but still, shook me a bit that did.

Whydidimarrythis · 02/01/2023 23:44

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:44

If the parents gave permission then I don’t see an issue.

The lake was shallow and the ice was 2ft deep, and they were with trained staff. This would be normal in Norway.

In Norway it’s possible to have ice that’s two foot thick. 🙄

Fraine · 02/01/2023 23:44

If the parents gave permission then I don’t see an issue.

The lake was shallow and the ice was 2ft deep, and they were with trained staff. This would be normal in Norway.

TangledWebOfDeception · 02/01/2023 23:42

👋 to @AlanThePig how are things at the pond?

AlanThePig · 02/01/2023 23:39

I’m the owner of a large pond /small lake. It’s a natural one not man made. You’d be forgiven for thinking it’s not too deep, after all around the sides you can wade in the knee deep water and feel quite secure.
Then it drops. At its deepest we’ve measured around 35ft.

The thing with ponds and lakes is you really can’t be sure of their depth because they don’t usually have flat bottoms. They can drop off like the edge of a cliff.

Bodies of water are always dangerous. To take kids on there is just negligence.

ButterBastardBeans · 02/01/2023 23:34

People are genuinely becoming thicker and thicker with every passing year.

If there is only a 0.01% percent risk why would you risk it, especially with other people's kids.

SnowlayRoundabout · 02/01/2023 23:28

GhostBridezilla · 02/01/2023 22:23

They were supervised and teaching them what safe ice felt like. I don’t see the problem.

It wasn't safe ice. As OP has said, in the South West bodies of water were not freezing to two foot thickness during that relatively short cold spell, and it's incredibly blasé to claim that they would have been fine if they had fallen through. People notoriously have drowned in water 3 foot deep or less, and the shock of falling into freezing water can cause the heart to stop or go into dangerous arrhythmia.

If children need to learn what safe ice feels like, they can do that at an ice rink. Taking them out onto a frozen lake simply makes them think it's safe to walk on ice - and the next time they may not in fact be safe and there may be no adults around to save them.

Tulipvase · 02/01/2023 23:27

So you step onto ice to see if it’s safe and surprise, it isn’t….. then what?

Also as previously said, what happens when you disappear under the ice you just fell through?

Unbelievable. No wonder there are so many unfortunate deaths/drownings in this country.

Swipe left for the next trending thread