Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what people did before antidepressants?

146 replies

dottypotter · 02/01/2023 21:33

Don't know how long anti depressants have been around for depression and anxiety etc, but what happened before they were invented does anyone wonder?
Did people go mad?
Put up with it, but never get better.
Did their depression etc just go away. Intrigued.

OP posts:
Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:30

Suicide rates have increased despite SSRI use being more common and less stigmatised:

www.bmj.com/content/370/bmj.m3431

"Data published by the Office for National Statistics on 1 September showed that in 2019 the suicide rate among men and boys was 16.9 deaths per 100 000, the highest since 2000 and slightly above the 2018 rate of 16.2 per 100 000. The suicide rate among women and girls was 5.3 deaths per 100 000 in 2019, up from 5.0 per 100 000 in 2018 and the highest since 2004."

Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:25

My problem with this thread is it heavily suggests that SSRIs are a magic fix. Other than the fact there are various psychiatric illnesses that don't benefit from SSRIs, studies indicate they don't work for a significant number of people who take them.

Plenty of people on SSRIs or other mental health treatments go on to die from suicide.

CaptainMyCaptain · 03/01/2023 07:24

My mother (born 1925) was prescribed a cocktail of drugs in the 70s but it didn't do her much good and she would go from being a zombie to an aggressive screaming monster and made several sucide attenpts. I dont think these were 100% serious as she tended to do it in front of people. It made my teens very difficult and, as I had no-one sensible for advice, I ended up making bad decisions myself.

She eventually came off the drugs although always had a difficult personality so that years later her decline into dementia went unnoticed for a while.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 03/01/2023 07:23

Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:07

If SSRIs worked as well as this thread suggests, the suicide rate wouldn't be so high.

Suicide rates aren't that high, historically.

Graph from: academic.oup.com/ije/article/39/6/1464/736597
showing rates in England and Wales from 1863 to 2007.

To wonder what people did before antidepressants?
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 03/01/2023 07:15

Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:07

If SSRIs worked as well as this thread suggests, the suicide rate wouldn't be so high.

I don't think there's really any basis for that claim. For a start, there will be a large proportion of suicide victims who are not and never have been taking SSRI's, another proportion who have not received any form of mental health treatment whatsoever, those who haven't engaged because they simply haven't realised they have a mental health condition, those who have conditions with suicidal ideation that SSRI's are not prescribed for in any case, and a few with conditions where the illness is actually exacerbated by the prescription of SSRI type drugs.

It really isn't anywhere near as simple or straightforward as people committing suicide because their medication fails. It's often the case that people aren't even at their lowest point when they commit the act, as it usually takes some form of wherewithal and functional ability to actually carry it out, so it's often people who have recovered somewhat and outwardly appear calm and in control.

Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:07

If SSRIs worked as well as this thread suggests, the suicide rate wouldn't be so high.

Puffin87 · 03/01/2023 07:02

I think they might work for some people - my siblings who had milder depression and anxiety benefited from them whereas I didn't at all.

Also, a large proportion of people on long term sickness benefits take SSRIs. Again, suggesting they don't radically work for everyone.

My depression was really bad as a teen and in my 20s. By my 30s I'd learnt how to work full time in a demanding job despite episodes and almost never take a sick day. I've been unmedicated for years. Being self-employed helps since I have targets to meet regardless of how tired or low I am. It's also a good distraction.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 03/01/2023 07:02

Obv I'm talking about depression as per the OP, not things like schizophrenia and disassociative disorders.

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 03/01/2023 07:00

I'm not so sure most would've ended up hidden away in an asylum or hospital. I think many would've just trudged on but never realised their potential. Intelligent people scraping by in 'manageable' but dreary jobs with little positive outlook. Much like in today's society.

I actually think in some cases necessity might help (whilst also understanding that in others it might be crippling to have no safety net). I used to really struggle with motivation but when I had to pick myself up for risk of losing my job etc (and by extension my ability to house and feed myself) I always seemed to manage by hook or crook. I think people in generations past often didn't have the luxury of reflection that we do.

Cantbebotheredwithausername · 03/01/2023 06:58

Most mild-moderate depressions will eventually resolve automatically. It takes a while, though, so I suspect that most people were simply miserable until the problem resolved by itself.

Those with severe mental problems were often institutionalized under horrible conditions, mostly to keep them away from society. Their conditions were considered to be either contagious or caused be devillish possession. Wasn't pretty.

You can agree or disagree with today's use of antidepressants, but the alternative "back in the day" certainly wasn't better and led to unnecessary suffering, isolation in asylums, self medication with alcohol, poverty, and violence.

Zuve · 03/01/2023 06:45

They were outside much more. If it was mild depression then they used lavender, and other natural herbals. If it was clinical depression then they were hidden away at home or put into an institution.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 03/01/2023 06:42

Much the same as now, mostly, I think.

Modern antidepressants like SSRIs (e.g. sertraline, citalopram, fluoxetine etc.) have an NNT or "number needed to treat" in depression of about 7, which means that you need to give the antidepressants to 7 depressed people in order for one person to benefit. The other six, some of them will get better through the placebo effect, some will get better on their own, and some won't get better at all. Other classes of antidepressants (SNRIs, TCAs, MAOIs, others) have similar NNTs. Antidepressants just aren't that effective, even though they're on a par with many drugs for physical conditions.

So I suppose that like now, many people got on with life despite feeling like shit if they were able to, relied on family to support them, turned to alcohol or recreational drugs, killed themselves, made life or lifestyle changes (radical or otherwise), were unable to cope and sank under the pressure becoming homeless or otherwise failing to function, tried traditional remedies, tried remedies that had a placebo effect, tried religious rituals, or tried to change the way they felt by talking to someone — a therapist, a religious mentor, a friend, someone with claimed magical powers, or whoever might fill that role in the society they lived in.

Depending on the period in history there were also different medical or other socially-approved treatments, with different levels of success based either on medical effects, psychosocial mechanisms or placebo effect. Psychiatric hospitals, asylums and institutions for those with severe enough problems or who could pay, physical treatments with electricity and insulin and cold water to try and shock the brain into changing, traditional herbal or other folk remedies (some of which are effective antidepressants), drugs that aren't strictly antidepressants but can help some people with depression, brain surgery, traditional social interventions that work on a family or village level, various things really.

But I suspect mostly it was fairly similar — a lot of people with depression eventually felt better through natural recovery or recovery assisted by non-antidepressant factors, a lot of people just pushed on through their ongoing or recurrent depression, and a few people weren't able to function or ended up dying from it.

TerfOnATrain · 03/01/2023 06:21

They locked my bipolar grandmother up in an asylum and gave her electric shock treatment.

my father, a little boy at the time, was able to visit her, kept in those conditions. He never got over it, and takes about how horrific it was in his eighties.

Shesasuperfreak · 03/01/2023 06:18

Alcohol was consumed

borntobequiet · 03/01/2023 06:16

ECT was wonderfully effective in curing my PND (which was so severe that I was barely able to function at all).

Oblomov22 · 03/01/2023 06:07

Watching tv show Vienna Blood. Freud devotee Jewish Max Liebermann, 1900, other doctors use electric therapy on patients.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/01/2023 05:38

I haven't heard of depression being the main malady of inmates at Bethlem etc. They tended to be more "violent" / "delusions" - bipolar disorders etc but I could be wrong. It's been a while since I read the source material at uni

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/01/2023 05:37

I think there is historical evidence that many mental health conditions as we know them existed. There's a long record of "melancholy" - to do with the four humour theory. When out of sync the person would become ill. Women were cold and wet so more likely to suffer with it than men who were hot and dry.

NameIsBryceQuinlan · 03/01/2023 05:32

I think it would depend on your social class.

Though across all levels of society alcoholism would be rife, and drug use would be high if you were affluent. There were plenty of opium and laudenum addicts.

Life expectancy was much lower.

Startwithamimosa · 03/01/2023 05:29

Heard of a lobotomy?

ivykaty44 · 03/01/2023 05:28

They’d walk into the canal, sadly that was commonly reported in the newspaper but rarely depression was mentioned. There’d be other recordings of suicide in the coroners records.

asylum records don’t seem to mention depression, other afflictions but not that one. I’ve read a fair few over the years

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 03/01/2023 05:26

It is a shame that we don't do away with them given they do nothing. Waste of time and money.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 03/01/2023 05:25

LivingOnAPrayerYes · 02/01/2023 21:48

Just talking about a great aunt over Christmas who would go for electric shock 'therapy' for her depression. (40 to 50ish years ago)

They still use this.

GingerScallop · 03/01/2023 05:05

CuteBear · 02/01/2023 23:31

I had severe depression, anxiety and PTSD as a teen because of something horrific that happened to me. Many women and girls will have, sadly, gone through what I endured. Nothing to do with social media and the media.

People would’ve become addicts, self-harm, or commit suicide without medication and therapy.

This.

OP There are still many many countries where people hardly have access to anti-depressants and no access to counselling (my country is one such). Yes some commit suicide others become drunkards but the rates if those are not automatically higher than in countries like us or UK where antidepressants and therapies are more readily available. Some cope muddling through on their own. Others cope with community support whether relatives, friends, cultural ostriching or church. Obviously depression and mental health are a broad spectrum and range from mild to severe so solutions that work differ n r dependent on context. That is why there is the paradox of happiness or contentedness. Some people that are very very happy and contented with little to no depression/anxiety etc are people who have gone through the most horrific experiences. Others have severe anxiety and depression despite having the most perfect lives imaginable. Chemical (im)balances also play a part of course

FlorenceAndTheVendingMachine · 03/01/2023 04:54

Onnabugeisha · 03/01/2023 00:09

These all play a part and I agree with you that tablets are not a magic pill or a one size fits all treatment. It’s the same for exercise and sleep too. Exercise generates your own feel good medication of endorphins- so endorphins obviously worked better for you than say Prozac or whatever SSRI you were given.

But the main thing I think was getting used to the idea that life can be shit sometimes and working up from there.

For me it was overcoming a shit start to life and then suffering life changing injuries that took away my entire built from nothing life in seconds. (Also took away my physical ability to exercise and gave me chronic pain so sleep is always a struggle) I’d always known life can be shit, but I’d wrongly thought I’d put that behind me and had done well for myself. Having it all snatched away with no hope of getting it back put me into a deep depression with hallucinations and imaginary beings. I was diagnosed with MDD with psychotic features aka Psychotic Depression (among other things like PTSD) Medication and therapy saved my life. I still take medications and honestly, it helps me hold on to my marbles and accept I’m living a different life.

My approach wasn't a magic bullet but it got me into a better place where I could start chipping away at life, even if everything seemed much harder to me than to many of my friends

This is so true, the chipping away. It is hard work to dig out of depression and progress is not linear. I would often be two steps forward and then slide one step back. I don’t think I will ever not be working to keep treading water. So, giving you a high five for having pulled yourself out of it too.

Thanks. You definitely sound like a fighter. It's so easy when suffering from mental issues to take the physical side for granted, even when logically we know we shouldn't.