It doesn't read like that at all to me.
The vast majority of people being treated with SSRI are people who have are experiencing a mild depressive episode, or suffer recurring episodes. For those SSRI's are reasonably effective at relieving symptoms. People who have more profound depressions and psychiatric illnesses are usually referred on, treated by psychiatry, and SSRI's either supplemented by other drugs, other types of treatment, or the SSRI treatment is discontinued because it's no longer relevant.
The fact that mental health care is insufficient in most respects, and some people who commit suicide have undoubtedly been let down by it, isn't indicative of SSRI's failing at what they are intended to do, it's more indicative of the fact that our healthcare systems do not adequately detect or triage profound illness. When SSRI's are used as intended and in the situations they are designed to tackle, they are more effective than any other type of treatment to date.
Of course plenty of people who are on SSRI's or other forms of treatment still go on to commit suicide, nobody is denying that, but that is for a whole gamut of reasons, only one of which is 'SSRI's aren't as effective as they would be in an ideal world'.
If the thread contains a number of posters extolling the virtues of SSRI's, then I'd suggest that's perfectly in keeping with what we understand about mental illness in the general population, and the role SSRI's play in treating that - the vast majority of instances of poor mental health are one-off mild depressive episodes, which SSRI's are reasonably effective in tackling, especially if they are combined with other forms of therapy and lifestyle/environmental changes. They're not intended to treat more profound conditions, and nobody is pretending they are a guaranteed cure.