Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my evenings back…at least sometimes

263 replies

Kneepillowfan · 02/01/2023 19:33

I have a 5 month old DS. Every evening is the same and it’s really getting to me. I wait all day for my husband to come home at 5:30. He cooks and cleans and we have to take turns eating as baby needs constant entertainment, then we all have to just go to bed before 7pm as the baby won’t settle downstairs. Will not settle without me upstairs either. I’m breastfeeding and the only thing that makes baby happy after 6pmish is breastfeeding in bed with me on and off for an hour or so. I guess DH doesn’t need to come to bed with me as it’s me the baby wants but DH does come too so I don’t feel lonely.

I love DS to pieces but am missing the times when DH and I used to watch a film in the evening, have dinner with a glass of wine. DH is currently out walking baby round the block to calm him down as I can’t eat when he’s screaming. Dinner was a bit later tonight as we went out for a food shop.

We very much wanted to be parents and love our DS so much. We knew it would be difficult and I wouldn’t change anything (except maybe having a happy DS in the evenings). I don’t know what I need from MN right now but please be kind! I’m just exhausted and deflated. DS is the kind of baby that needs a lot of entertainment during the day too. He has 2 naps per day but they are only 30 mins. He wakes every 2 hours at night. I never get a break and I’m feeling drained 😞

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 03/01/2023 10:53

Suprima · 03/01/2023 10:50

i don’t know if you are talking about a NICU nursery nurse or someone generally poorly babies, but yes- of course breastfed babies would struggle to settle in those instances.

babies want to comfort suckle and cluster feed and if poorly or literally brand new, they will obviously want their mums if BF has been introduced as the food source

the fact that your mate or acquaintance is painting this like it is the gospel true that FF babies are better sleepers is terrifying

the science taken from studies (that don’t include anecdotal evidence from ill or premature babies) does not express a link between sleep and method of feeding

trust me, if it did- the formula companies would find a way to publish the information in a completely
legal way

This is the reply I wanted to see! 👏🏻

Suprima · 03/01/2023 10:50

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/01/2023 10:17

A nursery nurse who works night shifts on a hospital ward told me, ‘It’s always the breastfed babies that won’t settle and are poor sleepers, but we’re not allowed to tell the patients that for obvious reasons’ this is somebody who has settled literally thousands of babies in her time.

i don’t know if you are talking about a NICU nursery nurse or someone generally poorly babies, but yes- of course breastfed babies would struggle to settle in those instances.

babies want to comfort suckle and cluster feed and if poorly or literally brand new, they will obviously want their mums if BF has been introduced as the food source

the fact that your mate or acquaintance is painting this like it is the gospel true that FF babies are better sleepers is terrifying

the science taken from studies (that don’t include anecdotal evidence from ill or premature babies) does not express a link between sleep and method of feeding

trust me, if it did- the formula companies would find a way to publish the information in a completely
legal way

peanutbuttertoasty · 03/01/2023 10:49

Also RE gear - you can buy blackout blinds with suckers on for windows, and a rockit rocker might help extend pram naps when you park him back at home so you don't need to be out as long. Check marketplace/Vinted for second hand?

You're doing a great job op and giving your baby what he needs now will be setting him up so well for the future.

All the tough love sleep training advice on here makes me so sad. Babies cannot and are not meant to self soothe. Many adults cannot emotionally self soothe! It's a complex and sophisticated thing for a brain to do that takes self awareness that babies do not have. Learning to not cry, and self soothing, are not the same thing at all. You soothing him is what will model it for him to learn later. I don't think there are shortcuts to raising emotionally healthy and securely attached adults, as inconvenient as that may be for parents! I think there are ways for you to continue to be responsive and get better baby sleep/your evenings back though.

LouisLitt · 03/01/2023 10:47

musttryharder84 · 03/01/2023 10:08

What's the big difference between giving formula and solids?

I have a nightmare sleeper. Have never co-slept and moved her onto formula at night at 6 months in the hope it would make some sort of difference to her abysmal sleep. It didn't, she still woke every 40 minutes until she was 15 months.

Among the people I know, the ones with the nightmare sleepers have never co-slept and actually were mainly formula fed or combination fed.

Obviously this isn't proof of anything, just like your anecdotal evidence isn't. Scientifically, though, there is much less difference between formula fed and breastfed babies than most people seem to think.

I meant there is a big difference between advocating formula and early weaning to solids.

MollyRover · 03/01/2023 10:29

Agree @Imthegingerbreadwoman but there's no indication that this is a feeding problem. It's more than possible to ebf and have a baby that sleeps fine. 4 - 5 months is when sleep regression happens, this is well known, and the OP still won't get her evenings back by weaning on to formula.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 03/01/2023 10:23

And I agree with @Cuppasoupmonster I just accepted if I'm breastfeeding then they will want to be on me. Its hard but part of the parcel in my opinion. You could try weaning from the breast at night times, so a bottle at night but breast in the day if you don't want to stop

@MollyRover I breastfed all 4 for 2 to 3 years each non stop for 9 years. But if mother isn't happy then it won't harm baby to wean from the breast. Or partial wean

24petlegs · 03/01/2023 10:21

When DC was that age, we were convinced they needed silence for sleep. They didn't!
They needed noise to fall asleep to; it was a sanity saving revelation!
We put the TV on, we talked, we played music...it was reassuring for them that we were still there. Absolute silence for a baby would be quite unnerving.
We never solved the 30min map issue but night times improved which then had a knock on effect for daytime. Weaning also helped.
For DC2, putting them in their own room at 4 months really helped them sleep better- less disturbed by DH's snoring!

MollyRover · 03/01/2023 10:17

I'm going through this aswell OP, just wanted to offer a hand hold. One day we'll be out the other side of it! Definitely would recommend expressing a stash of milk so DH can give him the odd bottle, definitely helps boost your morale and MH to get out and do something for yourself every so often.

I'm really shocked at the amount of people shouting "wean!", sleep regression is completely normal at this stage and has nothing to do with hunger. A reminder that the WHO recommends breastfeeding until 2 years. Do people think that ebf babies are wasting away with malnutrition right left and centre? Or that mothers who breastfeed happily let their babies go hungry in order to avoid formula feeding? Breast feed, bottle feed, whatever you want. Just don't give advice that's patently incorrect thinly veiled judgement.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 03/01/2023 10:17

I breast fed and co slept 4 dc. 2 years between each. And it's hard! And many an evening where I was stuck upstairs but more when they where a bit older.

Don't stay silent is my advice. He has to be used to noise at all times. Even at night. How many naps is he having? It could also be sleep regression.

Have you tried baby wearing with a sling in the day so he can sleep on you whilst you do your bits and bobs?

Mine had a swing chair and they loved that for the evenings before bed. Not a vibrating one but a swing.

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/01/2023 10:17

musttryharder84 · 03/01/2023 10:08

What's the big difference between giving formula and solids?

I have a nightmare sleeper. Have never co-slept and moved her onto formula at night at 6 months in the hope it would make some sort of difference to her abysmal sleep. It didn't, she still woke every 40 minutes until she was 15 months.

Among the people I know, the ones with the nightmare sleepers have never co-slept and actually were mainly formula fed or combination fed.

Obviously this isn't proof of anything, just like your anecdotal evidence isn't. Scientifically, though, there is much less difference between formula fed and breastfed babies than most people seem to think.

A nursery nurse who works night shifts on a hospital ward told me, ‘It’s always the breastfed babies that won’t settle and are poor sleepers, but we’re not allowed to tell the patients that for obvious reasons’ this is somebody who has settled literally thousands of babies in her time.

Cuppasoupmonster · 03/01/2023 10:15

LouisLitt · 03/01/2023 08:27

There’s a big difference between formula and solids. OP should try it. Out of everyone I know, all the mums with nightmare sleepers are the breastfeeding, Co-sleeping brigade. So it’s OP’s choice to carry on like this or try and get some life back

I agree, much as that is sacrilege on here. All the breastfeeding/cosleeping babies I know have been screamy and tired.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 03/01/2023 10:10

Cliff1975 · 03/01/2023 09:54

It only gets harder! Seriously the problems change as they get older but it doesn't get any easier and mine are 14, 17 and 20!

OP is saying she wants some time to herself in the evening. I can pretty much guarantee that with teenagers, she will get that!
There are different problems with older dc (which I have) but the grinding intensity of life with an infant is not one of them.

musttryharder84 · 03/01/2023 10:08

LouisLitt · 03/01/2023 08:27

There’s a big difference between formula and solids. OP should try it. Out of everyone I know, all the mums with nightmare sleepers are the breastfeeding, Co-sleeping brigade. So it’s OP’s choice to carry on like this or try and get some life back

What's the big difference between giving formula and solids?

I have a nightmare sleeper. Have never co-slept and moved her onto formula at night at 6 months in the hope it would make some sort of difference to her abysmal sleep. It didn't, she still woke every 40 minutes until she was 15 months.

Among the people I know, the ones with the nightmare sleepers have never co-slept and actually were mainly formula fed or combination fed.

Obviously this isn't proof of anything, just like your anecdotal evidence isn't. Scientifically, though, there is much less difference between formula fed and breastfed babies than most people seem to think.

peanutbuttertoasty · 03/01/2023 10:06

Another vote for Lyndsay Hookway on instagram

peanutbuttertoasty · 03/01/2023 10:03

@Pumpkinspicemadre completely agree

peanutbuttertoasty · 03/01/2023 10:01

He sounds overtired to me too OP

I have an 8 month old and I struggle with this too on and off. Hitting the wake windows can be tricky! I think for a 5 month old they should only be awake for 2-2.5 hours at a time. In practice getting them to sleep on time can be tricky!

I've found that if I get the first nap in on time the rest of the day goes better. He tends to nap for longest in the morning so I sometimes submit myself to a long contact nap, then it doesn't seem to matter if the other naps are shorter or in the pram (where he naps for less time).

I actually set a timer when he wakes up that goes off 2 hrs 15 mins later, giving me a 15 minute wind down warning for the nap. If I can stick to this then all the sleeps go better. It went a bit chaotic over Christmas though!

I hope this helps? It's been trial and error for me and far from perfect but we have managed to get our evenings back.

I would say it did go to pot a bit around 6 months when he refused to be put down at all but moving from snuzpod to big cot helped with that.

Good luck! Keep experimenting and I'd look at wake windows and also follow gentle sleep advice - Instagram is helpful. Sarah ockwell smith is good. I don't think you need to do sleep training or weaning. Your baby needs you but it also sounds like he needs a bit more sleep xx

Didimum · 03/01/2023 10:00

Cliff1975 · 03/01/2023 09:54

It only gets harder! Seriously the problems change as they get older but it doesn't get any easier and mine are 14, 17 and 20!

Alright, harbinger of doom.

Cliff1975 · 03/01/2023 09:54

It only gets harder! Seriously the problems change as they get older but it doesn't get any easier and mine are 14, 17 and 20!

haggisbreath · 03/01/2023 09:46

@Kneepillowfan unsure if you will return to the thread OP, and I also stopped reading the comments as they do feel somewhat harsh.

Have you read about the 4th trimester (which I know is usually seen as up to 3 months) and velcro babies? My eldest was most definitely a velcro baby and it was a massive shock to the system to have a baby that didn't want to be put down, needed to be touching me to sleep, didn't like to be in the pram/buggy and much preferred the sling. For me, accepting that what seemed to work best for them was the thing that worked - I was too tired for the battle really! And while it means that you may not have the same time together with your DH in the evenings, it won't be forever.

If you've not already read up on it, you may also find it interesting to look in to attachment and gentle parenting.

bobbyew · 03/01/2023 09:44

harrassedmumto3 · 03/01/2023 01:15

Your husband cooks and cleans when he gets home from work?

Sorry, but I think you need to up your game a bit.

Maybe you haven't experienced having a baby like OP's. Sometimes there are days when babies like this won't be put down ANYWHERE for more than 5 minutes. You have a choice, do I pee? Shower? Attempt to eat a piece of toast? Cleaning the house or spending 30 mins plus cooking a healthy family meal feels impossible on those fussy days.

Didimum · 03/01/2023 09:36

Get a sleep consultant.

bobbyew · 03/01/2023 09:32

Wow, I could have written everything you've written OP! My 5mo dd is the exact same, will only have 30 min cat naps in the day, no matter what I do. By 6pm is exhausted and will only settle breastfeeding in bed. She falls asleep by 7pm but wakes whenever I put her down until around 9.30pm, by which time I'm shattered and go to sleep myself, so there's no winding down time. Won't take a dummy or a bottle. It's absolutely exhausting. And hard when you see other babies the same age being put down 'drowsy but awake 🙄' at 7pm and not waking till 7am. But comparison is the their of joy, and hopefully we'll be past this stage soon.

aSofaNearYou · 03/01/2023 09:25

OP absolutely does not have to not have a life until toddler stage. That is so depressing. I had my baby in lockdown and was so fed up living like a prisoner.

That' not what I said, I'm not saying she doesn't get to have a life, I'm saying the no evenings stage goes away when they start having a bed time and staying asleep at night. My DD was at that point around 1 but there is no set time, hence I said "toddler". But my point is the "no evenings" experience is an early parenting thing that does go away while the children are still small.

Calphurnia88 · 03/01/2023 09:22

LouisLitt · 03/01/2023 09:03

It’s worth a try though, this is an extreme case, this isn’t a newborn and OP is on her knees so was just trying to help but forgot how anti formula mumsnet is.

Where have I said I am anti-formula? 🤔

As I said, I have tried giving DD a bottle of formula before bed. He will also have a bottle of formula from DP if I'm not around, or if I'm wiped out. He's not EBF.

As a mum of a bad sleeper I have tried almost every trick in the book to improve my baby's sleep. I know how disappointing it can be when they don't work, and how it can lead you to question yourself. So when I read threads like this where posters are suggesting something that will fix their babies sleep I think it's important to provide balance (and scientific studies where available).

LouisLitt · 03/01/2023 09:14

aSofaNearYou · 03/01/2023 09:08

It totally get how you're feeling but it does come back as they become toddlers, you're through a lot of the part with no evenings!

In your position I would consider switching to formula, though.

OP absolutely does not have to not have a life until toddler stage. That is so depressing. I had my baby in lockdown and was so fed up living like a prisoner. As soon as things opened up I was out having a life again. Baby was around six months so similar to OP and I wouldn’t have coped with this set up she is living through every evening. OP, how do you feel in yourself generally? For me I found the early months brutal but once I was able to have short breaks from the baby I was so much happier in myself. 💐