Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To regret having children?

257 replies

Cinderellasslipper · 02/01/2023 04:15

Anyone else miss being childfree?

YABU - no way

YANBU - yes I have regrets too

OP posts:
Cam22 · 02/01/2023 15:27

The defensiveness of women who basically envy the childfree parents! Lol At least it seems to be about that. Get over yourselves.

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 02/01/2023 15:18

Yawn

Getinajollymood · 02/01/2023 15:13

I think the problem is that many women seem to think they would be living an alternative life that didn’t involve any drudgery at all without children, which just isn’t true. That’s not intended unsympathetically - I’m absolutely shattered from parenting a toddler at the moment - but children or not, there will be disappointments and not getting that promotion, laundry, bills to pay, most of us can’t just travel to Madrid for a weekend.

Whenever there are threads about finding toddlers hard there’s a ‘just you wait’ gleeful sort of aspect to parents of teens and of course there are challenges but equally there is not the gruelling day to day exhaustion either.

TheGirlWhoTamedTheDragon · 02/01/2023 15:12

It's a tricky question.

I found babies and toddlers overwhelming: the noise and the relentlessness. I expected that though. I have never regretted having them but for me it is definitely getting more enjoyable as they get older and we can talk about interesting things, I see their personalities develop more and it's not an epic mission just to leave the house.

On the other hand, it's harder now they have problems I can't fix for them, which was not the case when they were tiny.

I think the PP who mentioned social structures is spot on. I am a lone parent, and that has made life very different to what I envisaged. I think with a supportive partner and family around, the experience would be very different and there would be a greater level of freedom sometimes therefore motherhood wouldn't feel all consuming, whereas 95% of my time is spent on work and children. It would be nice if there was some space for me as an individual in my own right. And what I wouldn't give for a week in a nice hotel next to a sunny beach, all on my own! That said, I know I'd miss them horribly even for a week.

My life has much more purpose now and I wouldn't change it. I just hope they think I've done a good enough job of raising them when they're older and look back. With two parents to split work and time with DCs I could have been far more "present", not always rushing around, and that makes me sad as I haven't been able to spend as much quality time just being with them while small, as I would have liked to.

But no, no regrets.

I can absolutely see why it's not for everyone though. To do a good job of parenting you have to be prepared to be quite selfless for a long period of time and some people quite understandably don't want to do that, and enjoy the lives they have without children.

Toloveandtowork · 02/01/2023 14:58

@leithreas
You are right, that was too much of a generalisation to say women are so diminished by motherhood that they are submerged by the time the kids are older.

However, I think it's a subject that should be taken very seriously as it does happen to too many women. It can be utterly crushing and overwhelming when there is little or no support.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/01/2023 14:52

leithreas · 02/01/2023 14:40

I think this is really patronising to be honest. So diminished they can't find their voice? I have older children and do pretty much everything I want to do. I can go out with friends or on dates with dh whenever I like. I can pick up at any point in the day and walk out the door. I started my own business which is rather successful doing something that I love and devote many hours a day to it. I practice yoga every day, another thing that I love doing. I know exactly who I am and what I want out of life, we are currently saving to buy a second home in a Meditteranean country when the kids leave in a few years(or they can come if they wish), my business will allow me to work from anywhere and dh can work remotely from anywhere.

Honestly, we have a fantastic life, our kids are awesome, so funny and the best company, we laugh every single day together. I can't take off for six months roaming around Asia but I wouldn't be doing that anyway kids or no kids. I'm sorry you feel diminished and tethered but I feel like I am in my prime. Ambitious and excited for the future with dh and the kids.

This in short is why it's so difficult to have an honest discussion about these things because women feel other women's choices are some sort of insult to them. The insecurities just jump out. If the shoe doesn't fit don't wear it.

leithreas · 02/01/2023 14:40

Toloveandtowork · 02/01/2023 13:34

Mine are a bit older, 11 and 16. I'm still tied to them and deep down I'm screaming to get my independence back.

I sometimes wonder if the reason women with older children don't complain as much (on here at least) is that the whole experience has diminished them so much that they can't even find their own voice.

It gets easier as they get older but I hate being tethered. I think there is a deep human need to be untethered, but societal structures tether and saddle mothers for far too long.

I think this is really patronising to be honest. So diminished they can't find their voice? I have older children and do pretty much everything I want to do. I can go out with friends or on dates with dh whenever I like. I can pick up at any point in the day and walk out the door. I started my own business which is rather successful doing something that I love and devote many hours a day to it. I practice yoga every day, another thing that I love doing. I know exactly who I am and what I want out of life, we are currently saving to buy a second home in a Meditteranean country when the kids leave in a few years(or they can come if they wish), my business will allow me to work from anywhere and dh can work remotely from anywhere.

Honestly, we have a fantastic life, our kids are awesome, so funny and the best company, we laugh every single day together. I can't take off for six months roaming around Asia but I wouldn't be doing that anyway kids or no kids. I'm sorry you feel diminished and tethered but I feel like I am in my prime. Ambitious and excited for the future with dh and the kids.

kikisparks · 02/01/2023 14:31

It took years to have DD, lots of sacrifices and fertility treatment. During that time I thought a lot about what I wanted my life to look like and it was always with a child in it. There have been hard times but mostly it’s been amazing and just gets better and better (she’s 1 year old though, maybe I’ll feel differently in the teen years!)

We are one and done though, as I’m not sure if I would regret having more.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/01/2023 14:30

I also see that women who are child free by choice often have a very accurate insight into the realities of motherhood.

Yup. I had a front and centre insight and was like no thanks! Oddly enough men used to dangle the prospect of eternal singleness to terrify women to essentially settle, they are now rattled that the women are actually okay with that fate.

What I will say is there is very good reason why married men and single childfree women have longer lives with reports of greater satisfaction with their lot.

KimberleyClark · 02/01/2023 14:23

I’m really sorry for all your losses. But your life having a point or not does not depend on whether you have children or not. Things will get better.

Phrenologistsfinger · 02/01/2023 14:19

No, I’ve had 13 miscarriages and looking at a future without any kids makes me wonder what the point of the rest of my life actually is.

KimberleyClark · 02/01/2023 14:19

MrsJBaptiste · 02/01/2023 14:14

Your life changes after you’ve had children. Fact. No more uninterrupted peace, no more spur of the moment trips, no more uninterrupted sleep, no more anything which is relaxing and you are the focus

I guess your children are still quite young? Mine are 15 and 18 and we've had our life 'back' for some time now. We do everything we used to do either with or without the boys. Life is good and we have never regretted having kids for one minute.

If you’d read the rest of the post you’re quoting you’d know she was childfree.

MrsJBaptiste · 02/01/2023 14:14

Your life changes after you’ve had children. Fact. No more uninterrupted peace, no more spur of the moment trips, no more uninterrupted sleep, no more anything which is relaxing and you are the focus

I guess your children are still quite young? Mine are 15 and 18 and we've had our life 'back' for some time now. We do everything we used to do either with or without the boys. Life is good and we have never regretted having kids for one minute.

Fraine · 02/01/2023 14:08

*childfree women

Fraine · 02/01/2023 14:08

I’m bemused by how threatened some mums here by childfree mums, to the point of calling them ‘douches’. It’s almost like they can’t bear the idea that childfree women may want different things.

thermostate · 02/01/2023 14:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

theholidaymum · 02/01/2023 14:01

It's hard work but no regrets here. It's hard work but totally worth it. If I have a choice to be kid free or with kid again, a million time will be with DS again and again. Life isn't rosy all the time of course - either pre-kid or now with kid. Definitely only one for us though. Looking forward to when he gets older so we can enjoy a bit of luxury/travel and a lot more of our time back.

Toloveandtowork · 02/01/2023 13:58

@the worldhas

I had my children late (40s) and before that had a good life, professional job and freedom so I do know what it's like to be child free.

I also see that women who are child free by choice often have a very accurate insight into the realities of motherhood.

theworldhas · 02/01/2023 13:49

I think the concepts of freedom and indivudal independence and autonomy are important. And they are highly emphasised in our individualistic, capitalist society, which partly explains (only partly) the growing number of people choosing not to have families.

At the same time, I think the importance of making strong social connections, community, and establishing a larger purpose to one’s existence are undervalued concepts. Which is not to say that having kids is the only way to fulfill those important human desires - far from it. But having kids is ONE fairly straightforward way to address those natural human instincts, which is why the vast majority of adults continue to do it - even though they understand it will often leave them overworked, with less cash and free time at their disposal!

Interestingly though, people who have kids and people who are child free always assume knowledge of what “ the other side” would be like. But the truth is neither of them know. The child free side largely only see the work involved, and basically nothing of the incomparable strength of positive emotions which the vast majority of parents get to experience raising a child. While the parents can only imagine at what notable things they may have achieved or done (if any) with all the extra hours/dosh they would otherwise have had at their disposal … though perhaps the top 1% with their hired cooks and cleaners get to experience the best of both!

Toloveandtowork · 02/01/2023 13:34

Mine are a bit older, 11 and 16. I'm still tied to them and deep down I'm screaming to get my independence back.

I sometimes wonder if the reason women with older children don't complain as much (on here at least) is that the whole experience has diminished them so much that they can't even find their own voice.

It gets easier as they get older but I hate being tethered. I think there is a deep human need to be untethered, but societal structures tether and saddle mothers for far too long.

merrymelodies · 02/01/2023 13:32

YABU. That ship has sailed for anyone with children. Unless you give them up for adoption.

Fraine · 02/01/2023 13:30

leithreas · 02/01/2023 12:36

Childfree through choice myself, and I've had umpteen women down the years remark that they envy the lifestyle that comes with that, but most add the caveat that they would still have their children if they were given the chance over again.

Who is going to tell you that your life sounds shit though? I have never envied childless women but I'd be like yeah wow that sounds great, I'd never tell them what I really think.

Anyway to answer the OP, nope never regretted it. I have 2 teens now and I have really felt privileged to be part of their lives, it flies by so fast and before you know it you are doing all of those things you couldn't when they were younger but you have amazing young adults in your lives too.

Yes, as Cam says, why substitute that poster’s choice of ‘childfree’ for ‘childless’?

Why would you even need the feel the need to tell childfree women your opinion on their choice? They really don’t need your faux validation.

KimberleyClark · 02/01/2023 13:30

Cam22 · 02/01/2023 13:25

“I have never envied childless women”

In the above, you use “childless” although the poster you quoted used the term “childfree”. I wonder why? 😆

Interesting. Childfree is a positive for those who use that term, childless is generally not…..

Cam22 · 02/01/2023 13:29

…you have lost out

Cam22 · 02/01/2023 13:29

Cam22 · 02/01/2023 13:28

The words have entirely different connotations, as you must realise. If you are childfree it implies choice and YOUR decision. Childless suggests you have list out which is a pretty unpleasant idea in my opinion.

Re. childfree v childless.