Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry that my family banned me from Christmas for having covid

768 replies

tantrumingcoldchild · 02/01/2023 02:42

I flew 4000 miles to see my parents for Christmas. I unfortunately have to live in a different country from them.

I am asymptomatic but had to test due to being exposed to someone with COVID.

My parent was supposed to pick me up from the airport but decided not to after the positive test.

I see my parent once a year at most. They don't travel to see me. My parent and the rest of their family went ahead with the celebration but I was uninvited.

Fortunately, my other parent picked me up and let me stay with them (my parents are divorced)

They have agreed to meet me in a park tomorrow for an hour, which will be the extent of my time with them for the next year.

AIBU to consider this relationship basically over?

OP posts:
lljkk · 03/01/2023 16:50

I accidentally immigrated as a young person.

I flew > 4000 miles to see old friends & family this year. It was grueling & expensive to get there. That's the lens I hear this story thru. My aunts/cousins possibly didn't care if I tested + but my dad+stepmom would have refused to see me if I got a +covid.

Sounds like OP has a load of other issues to aggravate this situation, my folks would have been very sad & unhappy at least, to miss seeing me.

I hope OP makes up with her relatives.

Ihavedogs · 03/01/2023 15:46

there are at least 2 issues going on here, you testing positive for covid and how you were subsequently treated.

You can’t blame anyone, especially older people not to willingly want to come into contact with someone who has covid. It is totally disrespectful to take away anyone’s autonomy over their own body. You have every right to be upset and disappointed that your plans didn’t come to fruition and so does your family.

The lack of support you feel you experienced is slightly different. Whilst it is not unreasonable for anyone not to want to transport you hundred’s of miles due to you having covid, you do have a right to feel justifiably upset that little care or concern was shown by one of your parents.

I am a little younger than your parents, but my husband is older than them. Our DD would never have put us in the position where we had to say that we didn’t want to have close contact with her if she had covid (regardless of her symptoms or lack of them) and we showed her the same respect. We’ve been through it twice with her having tested positive followed by other members of her household and then when my DH and myself had it months later. We had to cancel a number of previously made plans, but managed to muddle through and support each other without any falling out or bad feelings.

Not one of us sailed through our covid experience(s) and the side effects lasted for a number of weeks for a couple of us and majorly impacted on our day to day activities even when we were no longer positive.

FrownedUpon · 03/01/2023 13:14

They don’t want covid, which is completely understandable & normal. I can’t believe you think everyone should risk catching it, just to make you happy.

MzHz · 03/01/2023 13:12

@tantrumingcoldchild so your uninterested parent has a spouse who works with small children- so are we right to assume that this is your dad we’re talking about?

for those who think op is being dumb about this, it was arranged that the uninterested parent was collecting op from the airport and having decided unilaterally that op was persona non grata, she was not only left to make her own way hundreds of miles, there was nowhere for her to go. Added to this the uninterested parent didn’t even phone to check on where the op was, what had happened to her or anything. They simply acted as if she didn’t exist or even matter to her.

They basically shit on her from a massive height and left her to it.

I don’t blame you for being angry @tantrumingcoldchild you absolutely have that right. Heal, process and see what you want to do going forward.

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 12:19

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 12:03

They definitely left some stuff out.

Yes. If it were a complete fake, the story would probably be more consistent. They do seem to be in a different time zone as well.

autienotnaughty · 03/01/2023 12:18

They don't want to be ill. Why do you not care if you make them ill? YABU

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 12:03

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 11:48

It’s the inconsistency of claiming not to have flown with Covid but needing a lift from the airport that doesn’t make sense - plus the story was always going to arouse strong feelings.
I wasn’t on MumsNet or any social media in 2020 so I don’t know what you’re talking about there.

They definitely left some stuff out.

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 11:48

ichundich · 03/01/2023 11:18

Just because someone takes a different stance to you, doesn't mean they're fake. Not everyone is as hysterical about Covid. It's funny that it's essentially still the same users as in March 2020; I guess you'd just love to have lockdowns forever, regardless of all the collateral damage they did.

It’s the inconsistency of claiming not to have flown with Covid but needing a lift from the airport that doesn’t make sense - plus the story was always going to arouse strong feelings.
I wasn’t on MumsNet or any social media in 2020 so I don’t know what you’re talking about there.

IneedanewTV · 03/01/2023 11:34

I’ve had flu for the last two weeks. More people die from flu than Covid. We don’t test for flu but we rely on people being sensible and staying in ( to be fair if you are that ill you don’t want to go out).

majority of people in real life are not testing for Covid everytime they get a cold. Most employees don’t get adequate sick pay so are really not going to start calling in sick.

where are people getting the Covid tests from? Mine from 2021 are dried up now so complete waste of time and I’m not buying new ones unless I need to visit a care home or hospital.

PlasticFries · 03/01/2023 11:29

Harry12345 · 03/01/2023 11:00

I would never ever turn any of my children away if I’d not seen them for a year and they had traveled. Even if I had to due to being high risk it would have been handled in a more loving and warmer manner than the ops parent did. I would have opened windows and worn masks. There’s no rules anymore, we are probably in contact with hundreds every day with it in work, shops and public transport. I’d never turn my child away if they were ill and vulnerable. I voted differently but after reading the way it was handled and that there was no phone calls etc to OP I think the parent is UR

I completely agree with you @Harry12345 .

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 11:27

ichundich · 03/01/2023 11:18

Just because someone takes a different stance to you, doesn't mean they're fake. Not everyone is as hysterical about Covid. It's funny that it's essentially still the same users as in March 2020; I guess you'd just love to have lockdowns forever, regardless of all the collateral damage they did.

Don't be daft. Sensible precautions when you actually have a positive test are a world away from compulsory lockdowns. Respecting other people's decisions about their health is not being hysterical.

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 11:25

ichundich · 03/01/2023 11:15

The issue that people are taking with your original post is that you're making wild assumptions about the OP's personality and family situation; absolutely nothing to do with Covid.

Except for the massive clue about them not only feeling angry and entitled about a supposedly loved family member taking precautions against covid, but ranting about them on mumsnet too. Not a single post from OP acknowledging the parent's point of view. It's not a leap to read that and think maybe they're not the most caring and considerate of people.

ichundich · 03/01/2023 11:18

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 10:41

I did report it early on, but they said the poster has been posting consistently for several years.

Just because someone takes a different stance to you, doesn't mean they're fake. Not everyone is as hysterical about Covid. It's funny that it's essentially still the same users as in March 2020; I guess you'd just love to have lockdowns forever, regardless of all the collateral damage they did.

ichundich · 03/01/2023 11:15

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 10:41

Tbf it does sound as though OP's parents are not in the UK but my comments were about the increased risk to anyone of becoming seriously unwell at the moment. So many horror stories about lack of care. I wouldn't want to deliberately pass on a virus anyway which it amounts to given how contagious covid is, but particularly not if there is a real chance of serious illness (which there still is) and totally inadequate or nonexistent healthcare in that event. If they're not in the UK it's probably not as bad from that point of view but I fundamentally can't understand the mentality of wanting to visit someone and stay in their home knowing I had covid. Fair enough if the parent didn't care I guess but they did and they have every right to protect their health. Is OP going to be there looking after them if they have months of complications? It's all up to the individuals concerned of course but especially the ones potentially being put at risk.

The issue that people are taking with your original post is that you're making wild assumptions about the OP's personality and family situation; absolutely nothing to do with Covid.

Harry12345 · 03/01/2023 11:00

I would never ever turn any of my children away if I’d not seen them for a year and they had traveled. Even if I had to due to being high risk it would have been handled in a more loving and warmer manner than the ops parent did. I would have opened windows and worn masks. There’s no rules anymore, we are probably in contact with hundreds every day with it in work, shops and public transport. I’d never turn my child away if they were ill and vulnerable. I voted differently but after reading the way it was handled and that there was no phone calls etc to OP I think the parent is UR

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 10:41

echt · 03/01/2023 10:33

Having engaged on this thread in sincerity, I now call bullshit.

Utter utter wank.

I did report it early on, but they said the poster has been posting consistently for several years.

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 10:41

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 10:26

No I’m all for personal responsibility when it comes to health but that’s because it’s a good idea. People using the you must care about the NHS in your decision making.. no I don’t need to consider it at all. Others can if they want to, up to them.

But that line just reminds me if the pandemic and I’ve moved on mentally. It was over used and worn out.

And now when it’s likely the parents aren’t even in the U.K. posters are telling the op to think about the NHS, it’s so engrained for some.

Tbf it does sound as though OP's parents are not in the UK but my comments were about the increased risk to anyone of becoming seriously unwell at the moment. So many horror stories about lack of care. I wouldn't want to deliberately pass on a virus anyway which it amounts to given how contagious covid is, but particularly not if there is a real chance of serious illness (which there still is) and totally inadequate or nonexistent healthcare in that event. If they're not in the UK it's probably not as bad from that point of view but I fundamentally can't understand the mentality of wanting to visit someone and stay in their home knowing I had covid. Fair enough if the parent didn't care I guess but they did and they have every right to protect their health. Is OP going to be there looking after them if they have months of complications? It's all up to the individuals concerned of course but especially the ones potentially being put at risk.

echt · 03/01/2023 10:33

Having engaged on this thread in sincerity, I now call bullshit.

Utter utter wank.

NoNameNowAgain · 03/01/2023 10:30

I would be more sympathetic if I could understand how you can need a lift from the airport, which was denied because of a positive test, and yet deny having flown with Covid. It may only have been an internal flight but it still implies that plans could have been changed at an earlier stage.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 10:26

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/01/2023 10:09

No, they don't. Family relationships are very important, but they don't trump matters of life and death, which the NHS is.

Of course it's neither the OP's nor her parents' fault that the NHS is in such a precarious state. We can blame successive governments for that. But given that it is, why risk lives more than we need to?

No I’m all for personal responsibility when it comes to health but that’s because it’s a good idea. People using the you must care about the NHS in your decision making.. no I don’t need to consider it at all. Others can if they want to, up to them.

But that line just reminds me if the pandemic and I’ve moved on mentally. It was over used and worn out.

And now when it’s likely the parents aren’t even in the U.K. posters are telling the op to think about the NHS, it’s so engrained for some.

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 10:22

SaySomethingMan · 03/01/2023 09:50

That’s not an ´opinion’. That’s full on fiction 😝

Which bit? That the OP, who made it clear on here and to her parents that she felt entitled to knowlingly give them covid so her Christmas plans werent disrupted, might have been shirty on the phone and unlikely to be keen to just sit out on the porch? Or me mentioning my own family situation?

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/01/2023 10:09

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2023 08:58

Family relationships trump caring about the NHS.

I hope the op can stay in touch and repair the hurt

No, they don't. Family relationships are very important, but they don't trump matters of life and death, which the NHS is.

Of course it's neither the OP's nor her parents' fault that the NHS is in such a precarious state. We can blame successive governments for that. But given that it is, why risk lives more than we need to?

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/01/2023 09:52

I wouldn’t dream of meeting my parents if I had Covid because I care about them and their well-being.
YABU.

SaySomethingMan · 03/01/2023 09:50

Aspiringmatriarch · 03/01/2023 08:56

If I'm wrong I'm wrong, but I have every right to give my opinion. It's pretty obvious the OP is being selective about their own behaviour and reactions but even the bare facts show a very entitled attitude. It's not her parents fault she lives abroad nor that she tested positive for covid but apparently they should just suck it up and get unwell. I couldn't imagine wanting to put my parents in that position, any more than I'd go over with a nasty gastric bug or the flu, especially with the NHS in a state of crisis. It wouldn't even occur to me to put them in that position because, you know, I care about them and want them to be well.

And we had a very similar situation with our extended family over Christmas, of course it was disappointing but there was no suggestion of them just coming anyway. We had a second 'alternative' Christmas meal for them a few days later. Nobody fell out because nobody was a selfish dick about it.

That’s not an ´opinion’. That’s full on fiction 😝

FullOfoxit · 03/01/2023 09:42

That divisions and infighting is the thing that we should really pay attention to.