Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you find this odd to say to a 6yo?

157 replies

Goldsnow · 02/01/2023 02:36

A 6 year old female child in her house with her family (twin brother, mum and dad). The daughter is playing wearing her pants (joggers) with no vest or top on. The father then tells her to put a top on as she should not be running around like that. The house was warm so it wasn't that. It was because she is female that is the reason he was telling her she shouldn't do that and to put a top or vest on.

Would you find this strange for a man/father to say to a 6 year old or not? I would have thought a little child of that age is fine in her own home without wearing a top and I wouldn't have given it a second thought. But maybe that is just me.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:51

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:45

But you haven’t read it because OP said : [son] he plays without wearing a top sometimes too and nothing has been said to him

I did read it. Nothing had been said to either child in the past. Both the girl and boy played with no top on. Then on this day, the girl definitely had no top on and was to told you put one on. The boy may or may not have had a top on, OP can’t remember but wasn’t running around where the DH saw him at any rate. The DH saw the girl and said to put a top on.

It’s leap to presume that the only reason he said this was because she was a girl. Could just as likely be because it’s winter. Or they’re both too old to be half naked and she was the first twin to be told because her brother had a top on already or not, but wasn’t where the DH could see him anyway.

Goldsnow · 02/01/2023 16:49

@Onnabugeisha the only deltail I missed out was him saying you're a girl.

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:47

Goldsnow · 02/01/2023 16:45

It was because she is a girl. His exact words '(name) put a top on, you shouldn't running around like that, youre a girl' (in a strict tone of voice). She was playing and got hot so took off her top and carried on playing. It was evening so would have been getting changed into pj's shortly after and did not have any guests nor expecting any.

It’s not a fact his mind went there though. The OP has presumed it is because she’s a girl and then assumed it has to do with sexual reasons. The OPs mind has definitely gone there, and she’s projecting it on this thread

Because it was. What else could it have been?

OP,
You are changing your story….you originally said that
he shouted her name and said you shouldn't be running around like that put a top on.

now you are saying that he said
'(name) put a top on, you shouldn't running around like that, youre a girl'

These are completely different alleged statements.

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:45

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:42

Yes Im a real idiot for actually reading what happened vs swallowing while the OPs conjectures and speculations.

Well, if you dig into OPs updates, that’s not exactly what happened. The OP has assumed he is ok with the boy not wearing the top, but not the girl. At the time, the OP can’t remember if the boy was wearing a top or not:

he shouted her name and said you shouldn't be running around like that put a top on. I can't remember if son had one on at the time or not buy he plays without wearing a top sometimes too and nothing has been said to him.

Presumably, nothing had been said before to either child. Could simply be he thinks they should both have tops on now due to age, winter, whatever and it was a 50/50 chance as to which child would be told first to put a top on.

But you haven’t read it because OP said : [son] he plays without wearing a top sometimes too and nothing has been said to him

Goldsnow · 02/01/2023 16:45

It was because she is a girl. His exact words '(name) put a top on, you shouldn't running around like that, youre a girl' (in a strict tone of voice). She was playing and got hot so took off her top and carried on playing. It was evening so would have been getting changed into pj's shortly after and did not have any guests nor expecting any.

It’s not a fact his mind went there though. The OP has presumed it is because she’s a girl and then assumed it has to do with sexual reasons. The OPs mind has definitely gone there, and she’s projecting it on this thread

Because it was. What else could it have been?

OP posts:
Velda · 02/01/2023 16:44

People who let their kids run around the house partially naked usually come from the type of family where the father (if there is one) also sits around topless. Totally inappropriate and common, regardless of the sex of the child.

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:42

BrownEyedGhoul · 02/01/2023 16:35

ITs idiotic to pretend she has just made it up though. Do englighten is what other possible reasons he could have for being fine with a topless boy but not a topless girl?

Yes Im a real idiot for actually reading what happened vs swallowing while the OPs conjectures and speculations.

Well, if you dig into OPs updates, that’s not exactly what happened. The OP has assumed he is ok with the boy not wearing the top, but not the girl. At the time, the OP can’t remember if the boy was wearing a top or not:

he shouted her name and said you shouldn't be running around like that put a top on. I can't remember if son had one on at the time or not buy he plays without wearing a top sometimes too and nothing has been said to him.

Presumably, nothing had been said before to either child. Could simply be he thinks they should both have tops on now due to age, winter, whatever and it was a 50/50 chance as to which child would be told first to put a top on.

Abouttimemum · 02/01/2023 16:41

BrownEyedGhoul · 02/01/2023 16:02

But thats not the point, is it? The point here is someone who thinks its ok for a boy to have no top on, but not a girl. When they look identical.

What are people not getting here?

I did actually say that directly underneath my original post, so yes I do agree actually.

sheerpurplepetal · 02/01/2023 16:38

I wouldn’t find it odd - but we all get dressed each morning, and they wouldn’t be playing wearing pyjamas either 🤷‍♀️

OP has no idea what the reason was.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 02/01/2023 16:38

I wouldn't have let either of my dc run around topless if we had visitors tbh, I wouldn't let them slob round in pj's either. It's rude.

BrownEyedGhoul · 02/01/2023 16:35

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:27

It’s not a fact his mind went there though. The OP has presumed it is because she’s a girl and then assumed it has to do with sexual reasons. The OPs mind has definitely gone there, and she’s projecting it on this thread.

ITs idiotic to pretend she has just made it up though. Do englighten is what other possible reasons he could have for being fine with a topless boy but not a topless girl?

StaunchMomma · 02/01/2023 16:28

I think these kind of things often come from how you were raised. I wouldn't look too much into it.

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:27

inkworks273 · 02/01/2023 16:22

At 6 I don't think he should be treating her any different than her brother. The fact that his mind even went there is weird to me. The amount of people agreeing with him in this thread is just grim. She's 6. There's nothing sexual or inappropriate about her body.

It’s not a fact his mind went there though. The OP has presumed it is because she’s a girl and then assumed it has to do with sexual reasons. The OPs mind has definitely gone there, and she’s projecting it on this thread.

Sprogonthetyne · 02/01/2023 16:25

In December I tell both my kids (1 boy/ 1 girl) to put/keep cloths on because so I don't have to have the heating on high. In summer both have sat round in just their pants on very hot days, though I do try to encourage vests for both.

wackamole · 02/01/2023 16:25

This is your house and your husband/partner and (both of) your children? Neither of you should be making a rule/demand for the children that (1) shocks the other parent or (2) confuses the other parent so much s/he has to ask about it on line.

I'd raise the issue with him, not in front of the children, and talk it through. If playing shirtless is something the children have done in the past, then demanding that one of them NOT do it is going to need an explanation, or at least a united front from the parents. If he has a good reason why shirts should be worn (and personally I think it's probably a good idea, but not life and death if someone's without one for a short time), it should be the same rule for both children.

Definitely, your daughter should not be told her behaviour is being restricted arbitrarily/unnecessarily because she's a girl AND she should not be treated as if she's done something wrong or should have known better, when shirtless play has been the norm/gone unremarked in the house before.

inkworks273 · 02/01/2023 16:22

At 6 I don't think he should be treating her any different than her brother. The fact that his mind even went there is weird to me. The amount of people agreeing with him in this thread is just grim. She's 6. There's nothing sexual or inappropriate about her body.

BrownEyedGhoul · 02/01/2023 16:18

Amanitacae · 02/01/2023 16:15

I’d probably tell my children (boys) to put a top on. I don’t walk around the house topless. Neither does my husband.

What has that got to do with this issue, at all?

Amanitacae · 02/01/2023 16:15

I’d probably tell my children (boys) to put a top on. I don’t walk around the house topless. Neither does my husband.

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:12

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:07

Ah yes, those poor menz 🙄

Thinking that is straight outta incel/MRA.

Call me bonkers, but trying to comprehend how an incel would manage to even father a child? 😂

And honestly the point is valid, telling a 6yr old to get fully dressed doesn’t automatically mean they’ve been sexualised FFS.

Bookkeys · 02/01/2023 16:11

BradfordGirl · 02/01/2023 16:05

I think it is fine outside as well. But many people do not. I think the British are still generally very prudish.

I don't think it's about being prudish, more about protecting our children

There are a disgustingly high amount of pedophiles who would enjoy seeing semi/fully naked children in public.

They've estimated there's probably around 800,000 in the UK. Imagine how many of those would be sitting on the beach just watching 🤢

ThinWomansBrain · 02/01/2023 16:11

yabu for having the house so hot
would you spend the evening with no top on?

Michiru · 02/01/2023 16:10

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:07

Ah yes, those poor menz 🙄

Thinking that is straight outta incel/MRA.

Okay then... 🤔

RhymeHasAReason · 02/01/2023 16:09

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:07

Ah yes, those poor menz 🙄

Thinking that is straight outta incel/MRA.

Yep.

Onnabugeisha · 02/01/2023 16:08

he shouted her name and said you shouldn't be running around like that put a top on. I can't remember if son had one on at the time or not buy he plays without wearing a top sometimes too and nothing has been said to him. I just thought it was ridiculous and slightly strange.

Personally, I think half naked children playing at home are never acceptable regardless of sex. Not even babies- I hate seeing babies in just nappies it just smacks of neglect and laziness.

Put a shirt on them. They’re not beggar children with nothing to wear. That said, I know I am strict & in the minority by preferring to have even babies fully dress. But every parent I know has a limit for the half naked phase, and most seem end it at when they start primary school, as in Reception/Early Years (age 4), so I think you are also in a minority by allowing 6yr olds to play half naked.

Perhaps you should chat with your DH and come up with an agreement on this.

PrincessNakatomi · 02/01/2023 16:07

Michiru · 02/01/2023 16:04

I hope you're not labelling me a weirdo. This is a chat forum and the question invited different perspectives.

I speak to many people due to the nature of my job. A few men I know either have been faslely accused, even just jokingly, but it sticks with those who take it too far, of being perverted in some way concerning young women and young girls, or they know someone this has happened to. They are now paranoid.

OP sorry if I misread, I thought it was your brother, but the thought still stands.

Ah yes, those poor menz 🙄

Thinking that is straight outta incel/MRA.

Swipe left for the next trending thread