Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of people who stuck to one DC?

233 replies

WerkinMum · 01/01/2023 23:48

There's obviously nothing I can do about my reality so just venting and wondering if anyone else shares my thoughts.

I have two much loved children, 6 and 3. They are amazing. However I look at people with one and think they have the best of both worlds. They're a parent but also have time for themselves, can focus on a career, more money etc.

DH and I found our first child hard in the beginning, the sleep was atrocious, and just as we got back to normal we had another. I was happy with one but felt a lot of pressure and guilt over not having another and so took the plunge. I adore DC2 of course but my life is now all about being a parent with no space left for me and my interests. I used to have a great career which I have now been out of for so long I'll never properly get back.

DC1 never expressed interest in a sibling, they don't play together that much they're usually bickering or doing their own thing, vying for my attention.

I wish everything was a bit calmer! Does anyone else ever feel the same?

OP posts:
Thighlengthboots · 02/01/2023 06:26

No, I am an only child and I hated it, begged my mum for a sibling. I now have two and it was the best thing I ever did- they are like best friends.

Ragwort · 02/01/2023 06:18

We have one DC (by choice) and I have no regrets; our life is calm, (have to say DS was an incredibly easy baby), we can afford to do nice things with DS, he is happy & confident with lots of friends; in fact often says how noisy and chaotic his friends' with siblings homes are!
I do look at some peoples lives - so busy & stressful, financial worries, no time for themselves or their own hobbies, people not getting on etc etc and secretly wonder 'just why did you have more than one DC' of course I never say anything.
And it's only on Mumsnet that I see negative comments about having an only DC .. no one has ever said anything to my face about our choice.

Lordofmyflies · 02/01/2023 05:00

I have 2 and wouldn’t change it. They are good mates now they are in late teens, go out together, the eldest will drive his younger brother to school and sports matches. They are company for each other and security for me knowing they have each other, plus it helps me out! Having only 2 dc has allowed us to travel with them and give them each time. I couldn’t have done that with more than 2. Each to their own, but my DC are glad of each other, as am I.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 02/01/2023 04:48

I have one, and I have only wanted one. I know so many people who don't get along with their siblings so I didn't want to have another purely for the reason of having a sibling.
I have a much older sibling who moved out when I was quite young so I was pretty much like an only child and I loved it.
Each to their own, but I find it very odd how on MN people think one child is mean or selfish. You could say the same about having more than one as well Hmm

alanabennett · 02/01/2023 04:34

Give it time, op. As they grow older they may become the best of friends. I have three and despite the fact that they drive me mental sometimes, they and their relationship with each other is my great joy.

FWIW, and just my opinion of course, but I would never have chosen to have an only child, or to be one. I actually don't get on terribly well with my one sibling but I'm still thankful for him. The only parents I know who were only children themselves have all chosen to have multiple children.

If we stuck with one child, would we be more financially secure, with fewer demands on our time and energy? Of course! I still wouldn't change it for the world.

melcalfe · 02/01/2023 04:29

'Sometimes I think about how my life would be if I had only had one, at a much older age'

@BoxerMam I had one at 35. I am knackered and cry every day. PND or whatever you want to call
It, I am just exhausted and I'm too used to my previous carefree life.

In some way having kids younger is better. More energy and you're not too used to be free all the time etc. Daffodil

Fleabigg · 02/01/2023 04:22

Velda · 02/01/2023 01:04

You make your choice. Free time and career, or another child. What you prefer depends on you as a person. I imagine it’s a lot easier to die and leave two children together than one alone. And it’s certainly easier for two to look after you, it’s a burden for one.

That’s assuming they’ll be together in any way whatsoever when you die. DH will most likely never see his brother again once his parents die. Thank goodness, because his life is objectively worse as a result of his sibling.

My dad is terminally ill and I derive ten times as much comfort and support from my DH and friends as from my siblings. Maybe that’ll magically change when he actually dies, but I suspect not.

Fleabigg · 02/01/2023 04:19

Pyvadanya · 02/01/2023 00:08

I was an only child and there was no way I was going to replicate that situation for my kids (if I could help it!). I have 3 and would probably have more if my husband wanted to (he doesnt). 1 child would be easier for me but it's not what I wanted for my kids. I understand I've been very blessed with my circumstances and not everyone had the same Lonely experience that I had growing up.

Whereas I’m one of 3 and deliberately have 1 because I wouldn’t inflict being the middle one of 3 on any child, it’s a potentially terrible dynamic.

My 1 has a lovely life and I enjoy it too. This is a refreshing thread to read as an antidote to the usual “only is lonely” pressure that is heaped on parents of 1.

Fifi00 · 02/01/2023 04:00

I have 1 who's 9 , I think about having another all the time, I feel sad I will never experience having a baby again , I wish I would have cherished that time more and I'm only 29 ! Then I think about money , my career will take a hit , there will be a huge age gap I will have to do another 10 -11 years of school runs. My DD doesn't want a sibling now she used too she has a cousin who is exactly one year apart and they are very close.

I think at this point having another child would be selfish and purely for me to experience having a baby again at an older more well off age. I don't think it would benefit my existing DD.

WanderWomanWW · 02/01/2023 03:46

I have two and I'm glad they have each other. 4.6 year age gap. Best of both worlds, ime - eldest had a good chunk of solo attention, was a good age when youngest was born allowing youngest to receive a good amount of attention too (though not as much as dc1, obviously.).
I totally agree with Kalasbyxor though re what a state the world is in for our kids now, and it makes me extremely stressed. They both bring me so much joy, but i feel the world is too awful for them. I don't regret having them, but I'd be less stressed, but also less happy.

I'm glad dc2 arrived. I can't imagine dc1 being my only. Dc2 enhances dc1's life for the most part.

I'm really glad dc1 has a sibling. Not least because we don't really have any other family, it's just the three of us.

oakleaffy · 02/01/2023 03:26

@WerkinMum
I felt that I couldn't possibly love another child as much as the first, so didn't yearn for another.
Husband DID want a second.

I asked the single adults I knew at the time how they felt..and one response stuck in my head..One chap said ''I was as happy as a pig in shit as an only child..loved it!''

So many adults are not close to their siblings.

One child is much easier, {No squabbling either!}

Goldsnow · 02/01/2023 03:11

I think 2 is perfect. They will always have a play mate growing up and 2 doesn't make much of a difference financially etc.

Adeckofcards · 02/01/2023 02:56

malificent7 · 02/01/2023 02:19

I am 1 and done. It's great. And better for the planet.

By that reasoning 0 is better for the planet.

Adeckofcards · 02/01/2023 02:54

Workyticket · 02/01/2023 00:09

This is really interesting as I'm on the other side. I have 1 and wished we'd had more - ds has ever expressed interest in a sibling and we realised we could have an easier life with 1 but I do still wish sometimes

Question though- those who have more than 1 and wish you only had 1... do you wish you only had the first and not subsequent or do you wish one of your 2nd / 3rd etc was the only?

To answer your question - neither child is perfect. If I could choose, I’d take both their best bits and merge into one child.

DC1 is academic, bright, serious, takes sports and everything else seriously, occupies themselves very easily, reads a lot, has few good friends. Ideally suited to be an only child.

DC2 is not academic, has little interest in sports, never reads, can’t occupy themselves for more than two minutes, loves company, loads of friends, and is a much happier child. Would be a very unhappy only child.

hilariousnamehere · 02/01/2023 02:42

I don't have children but I am an only, and can honestly say that I've had and am having an easier time than some of my friends with siblings around elderly parents and death of parents. My Dad died several years ago and while it was horrific, on a practical level Mum and I made all decisions together and there was no conflict. We've been able to spend plenty of time together since without her having to worry about if she's being fair with her time between multiple grieving children.

As she ages and isn't in the best of health, I know what she wants and what I can do to help - yes, there's just me, but also there's no resentment or complications of any other people involved. I've seen resentment when one child of several takes on the care of parents because the others are busy/geographically too far away / at different life stages / just crap. I've seen plenty of love laced with resentment when there's a big age gap and the younger child has to care for the parents and then their sibling in quick succession.

And I've also seen some siblings pull together brilliantly and support each other during those times - so I think maybe there is no right answer when it comes specifically to end of life considerations.

For what it's worth, I'd hate to have had siblings - I had a brilliant childhood, have always had lots of close friends, I'm an introvert with ADHD, love people but hate them being in my space and much prefer being able to spend time with Mum (and Dad when he was here) without worrying about another few humans who I may or may not have got on with. Because there's no guarantee your children will like each other, judging from everyone I know!

oof, that was long, thoughts while I can't sleep because I've overdone the indulgent food on new year 😂

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 02/01/2023 02:26

MrsTerryPratchett · 02/01/2023 00:02

Smug singleton mum here. I agree that's it's the best. I wanted two but DH wanted to stick so we did.

My poor colleague with three is very jealous when I talk about DD and I hanging out, pleasing ourselves.

Sorry. If it helps there is a MASSIVE amount of judgement about my lonely child.

Same. We have 6 siblings between us and we have no issues with them and we all get along great, close relationships etc., But we only ever wanted one.

The judgement that we are selfish is ridiculous. DD is 14 now and life is a breeze.

malificent7 · 02/01/2023 02:19

I am 1 and done. It's great. And better for the planet.

MoreSleepPleasee · 02/01/2023 02:07

I've got 1. He has everything he wants, we can go on multiple days out as I just have him to pay for. It's good in that sense but having siblings is wonderful and I do feel sorry for him. He's autistic though and actually doesn't like people much or anyone touching his things and he has had meltdowns over the chaos when his cousins visit so I think all in all being an only child is best for him. I hope!

CheerfulYank · 02/01/2023 01:57

I have three and honestly struggle to think that I’m “done” now, I’d love another in a way…but I’m 40, the ones I’ve got are 15, 9, and 7, there’s no money…I need to be satisfied that I’ve got three and that’s fine.

I have had the odd thought that “what if we just had DS” and certainly things would be easier with just one (mostly) self sufficient teen, but I can’t imagine not having my little crew.

littlelovely · 02/01/2023 01:49

I am conflicted on this. I do have days of regret. We have two DC, who are 4 and 1. It feels very relentless at the moment and it would be SO much easier if we only had one. More freedom, more fun, less expensive, our house wouldn’t feel small like it does right now. I often wonder if we were stupid to have been so relaxed about a possible second. We weren’t actively trying but I went from being infertile in my 30s (DD took 6 years to conceive) to fertile in my 40s and conceiving easily twice although I lost a baby at 16 weeks, which was pretty traumatic.

I love the kids (and DC2 is just wonderful) but I hate the tired, shouty person I’ve become. With two kids there’s no escape. I need to work on being better but I’m too tired. This is the thing that really makes me wish we’d stuck at one. Also our marriage feels dominated by parenting in a way that it didn’t with one DC. I hope we will find our way back to each other as a couple.

A saving grace for me is that I didn’t put my career on the back burner and properly returning to work does give me a much needed balance. Just need a bit more sleep and I might feel differently!

BabyOnBoard90 · 02/01/2023 01:49

Riu · 02/01/2023 00:42

Get your career back on track and you won’t resent your children anymore. It is fine to feel lacking in confidence about work after having kids but it isn’t fine to blame your children for it.

Agreed.

There's something incredibly unfair about bringing children into the world and regretting their existence.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 02/01/2023 01:37

Sorry but u don't know why people only have one. I didn't have one by choice and I would've loved more.

BrokenWing · 02/01/2023 01:31

I am one of 5 siblings, and over the last 10 years have struggled with the practical and emotional commitment of elderly parents with chronic and serious health conditions. Then their funerals and dealing with their estate.

But I had 4 siblings who understood everything and to share the burden with. I feel sad that potentially ds will need to go through that alone, or won't have a close family connection when we are gone.

There have been advantages having only one child (not through choice), but there are disadvantages too. The grass will always seem greener on the other side.

Sarahcoggles · 02/01/2023 01:26

I'm baffled at the people who have 4 kids but wish they had 1. Did you not realise this after the 2nd or 3rd, and decide to stop?

QualityStreetGreen · 02/01/2023 01:25

@Velda when my DM parents died, both within a short period of time, the fall out from DM ‘D’B, who took things from the house, photos, treasured items etc, gives another perspective on siblings ‘being there for each other’ once their parents have died.

It’s not always the cosy ‘Walton’s’ scenario!