Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of people who stuck to one DC?

233 replies

WerkinMum · 01/01/2023 23:48

There's obviously nothing I can do about my reality so just venting and wondering if anyone else shares my thoughts.

I have two much loved children, 6 and 3. They are amazing. However I look at people with one and think they have the best of both worlds. They're a parent but also have time for themselves, can focus on a career, more money etc.

DH and I found our first child hard in the beginning, the sleep was atrocious, and just as we got back to normal we had another. I was happy with one but felt a lot of pressure and guilt over not having another and so took the plunge. I adore DC2 of course but my life is now all about being a parent with no space left for me and my interests. I used to have a great career which I have now been out of for so long I'll never properly get back.

DC1 never expressed interest in a sibling, they don't play together that much they're usually bickering or doing their own thing, vying for my attention.

I wish everything was a bit calmer! Does anyone else ever feel the same?

OP posts:
QualityStreetGreen · 02/01/2023 11:29

Certainly don’t need pity here!

Because of the multiple challenges we’ve faced with DS, you wouldn’t feel pity for throwing another DC into the mix. They wouldn’t have had the attention I would have wanted to give them.

I’m certainly not saying that this is the case with other families, but in our case, having a ND dc with little or no outside family support, both trying to hold down FT jobs, our age etc, I’d laugh at anyone throwing pity at me for not adding another DC to the mix, seriously!

ridemesideway · 02/01/2023 11:29

Oh I certainly don’t need pity! We’re a very happy family of three. Many reasons for not having another, all valid in my mind which is the only mind that matters.

Having one isn’t something all parents can do. There’s no other kid to entertain them so you need to be more involved. Luckily for us, both DH and I have rediscovered our ‘fun’ selves and love hanging out with our son. Both of us have taken up new hobbies because he loves them and we’ve all made lots of new friends. We wouldn’t have had the time to do that with more kids. DS is financially set up and we’re certainly not expecting him to take care of us in old age.

Namechangingx100 · 02/01/2023 11:26

I’m envious of parents who have more than one. I wanted at least 2 but really wanted 3 children.

It just didn’t work out that way and I was only able to have one. I love her so much. She tells me that she wishes she had a sister.

Before she started school I took her to playgrounds every single day so that she would have other children to play with. And that was tiring.

I never had any downtime. Even at night because she had trouble sleeping and ended up sleeping with me.

I try to compensate for her lack of siblings and be her playmate as well as her mum or facilitate activities where she could have playmates.

I grew up with siblings. My mum didn’t have to be our playmate or take us to playgrounds every day. We played with each other. Though we had some terrible fights that if they became too bad she would have to intervene.

I am so over role playing games. I would rather do craft or board games. But she loves role playing games. And they are important. I remember loving role play as a kid too.

Also, I have had people who have asked me if I have other children respond very negatively about me only having one. One woman told me in front of my daughter that I was selfish. It is cruel to not give my child siblings etc. And she said this in front of my daughter. What sort of message did that send to my daughter!

I still get told how much easier I have it having only one. I still have people comparing me to them and telling me that I don’t really know what it’s like to be a real parent until I have more children. It’s not nice to deal with.

GladiatorSandals · 02/01/2023 11:26

Fleabigg · 02/01/2023 10:56

Heartily endorse your response. And another pp mentioned “pitying” one-child families. People can shove their “pity” (they really mean judgement anyway, because they desperately need their own acquiescence with societal expectations to be completely validated) up their arses.

Oh, they absolutely can shove it, but I got it a lot from strangers or randomers at neighbours’ parties* *and the like, and found it wildly irritating, especially as, until I had DS when I was 40, the same type of person would say the same type of thing about me being childless.

And yes, if I ever needed proof that a particular type desperately needs their own life choices validated (and is deeply suspicious of something that looks ‘easier’), I got it in spades.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 02/01/2023 11:26

greenteafiend · 02/01/2023 11:06

I'll also add that if you only have one DC, you can't go anywhere without somebody who barely knows you asking why you only have one.

I literally never had this experience. Not once. And my oldest was an only child for eight years! The closest was that I occasionally was asked by a good friend if I was stopping at one or considering another, which is a completely fine question to ask.

I constantly got asked by people if /when I'm having another .

"Oh ,God no!" Stopped them from asking more than once.

Just a few months again DD's HT asked if I'm having another because DD is off to secondary soon. Grin

bookworm14 · 02/01/2023 11:15

Fleabigg · 02/01/2023 10:56

Heartily endorse your response. And another pp mentioned “pitying” one-child families. People can shove their “pity” (they really mean judgement anyway, because they desperately need their own acquiescence with societal expectations to be completely validated) up their arses.

Yes, exactly. Why on earth would we need pity?

sanityisamyth · 02/01/2023 11:14

leccybill · 01/01/2023 23:59

We had just the 1 DD but not by choice and I was sad about that for a long time. But now she is 13, I'm over it, life is easy and quiet, we have lots of money for fun and leisure and we have Ddog who is like a second child but loved so much by us all. Would I have liked another child? Yes, for me. Is life good now? Yes, for us all.

This, but swap dog for pony!

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/01/2023 11:13

I regret not having more. I loved being a mum of small children (although I’m not denying it was tough some days) but we worried about affording more. With hindsight we could easily have manage another two and I wish we had taken the plunge.

Keha · 02/01/2023 11:09

I'm not posting here to be smug at all, just for people reading this and worrying about having more children. I've got two a dd3 and baby and I'm really enjoying it. I like seeing them interacting, I like the business and noise, I don't feel massively like I've lost myself, just that I'm doing something else for a few years, plenty of time in future for hobbies, career etc. I guess that easiness of the DC, age, finances all affect this and I imagine there will be harder stages too! I guess it's all horses for courses.

greenteafiend · 02/01/2023 11:06

I'll also add that if you only have one DC, you can't go anywhere without somebody who barely knows you asking why you only have one.

I literally never had this experience. Not once. And my oldest was an only child for eight years! The closest was that I occasionally was asked by a good friend if I was stopping at one or considering another, which is a completely fine question to ask.

Fleabigg · 02/01/2023 10:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Heartily endorse your response. And another pp mentioned “pitying” one-child families. People can shove their “pity” (they really mean judgement anyway, because they desperately need their own acquiescence with societal expectations to be completely validated) up their arses.

Dancingdragonhiddentiger · 02/01/2023 10:43

stargirl1701 · 01/01/2023 23:52

No. DD1 is autistic and if I had only had her I would have regarded myself as an failed and inadequate parent, DD2 is NT. Parenting her gives me a sense of normalcy. I am not a failure. I am actually quite good at being a mum.

Ditto! I mean I adore my first child but every single bit of parenting them is an uphill struggle- working very hard to ‘fail’ in society’s eyes at least. My NT child is honestly such a tonic. People praise me about them all the time and I tell them “he is great all by himself”. Now I take no blame and no credit - just love them and advocate for them as best I can. Sooooo much of parenting (& life frankly) is the luck of the draw.

MontyK · 02/01/2023 10:38

We have one and it's enough for us.

Basically I'm knackered most of the time and I'm massively introverted. I can just about manage the organisation of one child, school, clubs, activities, socialisation, homework etc but I would massively struggle with two. I NEED downtime and opportunities to indulge myself in hobbies and 'me time' - this is much easier to do with one child. In a sense I'm selfish and I think that's ok, I didn't want to spend all of my 30s and 40s parenting young children.

We can also afford private school, I never have to worry about money and whether we can afford to do something, a day out etc, we just do it.

Luckily most of my friends also have one child for similar reasons so that has helped to validate the decision in a way, as you inevitably feel a sense of guilt about them being lonely.

Unlike me, my son is an extrovert and would probably have loved a sibling. I do feel pangs of guilt at times but I know I would have been miserable and really struggled with the daily grind of parenting.

I make a lot of effort to ensure that he has plenty of opportunities to meet up with friends and he also has several cousins who we see regularly. We also holiday with friends and their only children so that's a huge bonus.

Basically there's no wrong or right, but I do feel strongly that people should only have another if it's something that they want 100% and are not doing it out of misplaced guilt.

BigMadAdrian · 02/01/2023 10:33

I have three and genuinely enjoy having a bigger family - one is homeschooled too, so I am hardly ever alone (but we do many share interests and are able to do a lot together). My dc have reached the age where we spend time together, rather than me having to physically look after them - I enjoy their company.

Orangepolentacake · 02/01/2023 10:28

Whydidimarrythis · 02/01/2023 00:02

No, not in a million years. I fought like hell for my DD and I wouldn't be happier in any sense of the word without her.

This thread is awful though - asking people to say how much they regret their DCs or, the alternative, gloat about them on a site full of people potentially struggling to conceive. What are you hoping to gain OP?

@Whydidimarrythis People are allowed to talk about the things they want to talk about, as long as in a respectful manner. People also have the option not to read threads and not to comment. I don't understand why people feel the need to go onto threads to tell posters that they should keep their mouth shut. Everyone has their own experience and not one or the other is more valid or worthy. Why do you feel the need to come on here to criticise the op for having her own experience? Just walk on when you see threads you don't like. It's easy not to click on something and read it and post something unpleasant.

LaBaDeeLaBaDa · 02/01/2023 10:26

6 and 3 is a tough age. My older two are now 7 and 4.5 and it is all much much easier than it was a year ago. Hang in there @WerkinMum

I find the absolutism of some parents about family size a bit odd. It's such a personal choice and there's no right answer for everyone, just trade offs to consider. It's really interesting to read how parents feel about their choices and why, though. I could write a long post about why I find 3 perfect OR why it's really hard, equally if we'd stopped at 1 I'm sure I could have written reams about how good that is, or bad. It's both, lots of things can be true at the same time. As with most things, it's not what you end up with but what you make of it.

(Yes thanks, I AM enjoying the view from up here on the fence Grin )

Sarahcoggles · 02/01/2023 10:23

TeddyisMydog · 02/01/2023 08:14

I have 4, I often long to go back to the days when I was childless (I was only 19 then) and make the decision to never have children. But nobody in real life seems to understand

@TeddyisMydog why did you have 4? Did you not realise after 1 that it was hard work? Or maybe after 2, or 3? Why keep on having kids if it wasn't what you wanted ?

WatchoRulo · 02/01/2023 10:18

Grass is always greener - we'd have liked another but plummeting fertility put paid to that.

Choconut · 02/01/2023 10:18

I only have one as me and my brother fought like cat and dog growing up and I knew I didn't want to risk a repeat of that! Seeing my friends kids arguing and fighting just confirmed my decision. He's a teen now but I couldn't be happier with an only (and he's really glad to be an only too).

nc824 · 02/01/2023 10:15

@reddwarfgeek please don't feel guilty. The reason I reply to these threads is out of repentance for my pre-child belief people must have 2 but now realising how short sighted that was and that 1 is a lovely family too with a lot of "pros"- a lifestyle I think would have suited my parenting style and personality. I wouldn't change my situation because I love my youngest, but I do believe my eldest would have been happier as an only (they are chalk and cheese, the hardest part of our family life is their incessant arguing, it's torture). I will never know, but I really admire you for knowing what works best for you and not just doing what you think you are "supposed" to do. I honestly think some of the comments are made by people who are either consciously or unconsciously jealous wanting you to be as burdened as them. How dare you make life easier for yourself Grin

reddwarfgeek · 02/01/2023 10:10

Great thread. Interesting to read different perspectives. I have one DD who has just turned 5. Severe mental health issues for mr, lack of support, and wanting to keep some sort of life for myself means plus my age she will almost certainly be an only.
Everywhere I go people ask me when I'm having another. One colleague puts a lot of pressure on me to do so. It makes me feel dreadful.
My close friends don't as they know my relationship is poor. DP is lazy (he's still in bed after being there since 9pm last night 🙄 this is not unusual) not at all a hands on dad, does no housework and drinks too much-but that's a story for another thread.
I feel so guilty that DD will be alone, and that I am not a 'complete mother' and have fallen into the trap of thinking everything would be better if I had two children.
However I just can't do it again without big changes, which I don't think would happen. I chose the wrong person to settle down with.
It's a shame but I'm sure everyone has things they regret in life. I am able to work, go running and try to be the best mum I can be to DD. It often feels like I may aswell be a lone parent.
I take my hat off to people who have more than one, they are made of strong stuff!

Robostripes · 02/01/2023 10:10

Well for many one child families it’s not really a choice, so no I don’t think you should feel envious of the extremely traumatic TFMR and miscarriage I went through before deciding I couldn’t face any more heartbreak and would just stick at one.

I also get lots of comments about poor DS being an only, oh haven’t you thought about another one? From the insensitive thoughtless types, who range from other school mums to colleagues to friends.

However trying to take a step back and look at it more objectively, yes it is easier just having one. DS gets all of our time and attention and money. He’s very easy going and we have lots of lovely days out, never having to referee or sort out fights. He never complains about being lonely or wishing he had a sibling. On the other hand, there is no one else at home to entertain him and he is incapable of keeping himself occupied other than with a screen - so DH and I do have to play with him a lot in a way I expect many parents of two or more don’t.

GreenDanglyearrings · 02/01/2023 10:07

One child would be easier but it's only because I have 3. Someone one who has 6 children would think that 3 is easy.

My children are now teens and a million times easier than toddlers. I had 3 under 5 so had a busy few years.

Do I regret 3? No I absolutely do not. They all get on well, have great sense of humour and are generally great people to have around. I love watching the interaction they have together. They all have their own social lives but also like doing stuff together too.

Symphony87 · 02/01/2023 10:07

I am an only child and currently have 1 child myself, I am constantly asked when I am having another (MIL asked when she was 5 weeks old and barely out of hospital!)

I’m torn, I wasn’t lonely growing up and had a great life, close with my parents. My partner is one of 3 so he’d like another. I don’t think there’s a right answer, there will always be that ‘what if?’

3partypics · 02/01/2023 09:56

This is a useful thread. We have one DS and I feel I'm done, but DH would ideally like another.

My reasons for sticking at 1) DH &I both have older siblings, and we were brought up very much knowing we were mistakes and our parents wished they'd stuck at 1. 2) we're not particularly close to our siblings, DH not at all and for me only since we became adults, but we can't reminisce much about childhood etc as we both experienced it very differently. 3) DH is 'hands on' but our relationship is definitely not 50/50 in terms of parenting and housework etc. He does a lot, but still not 50/50, in a more equal world then I might consider another.

All of our parents had many siblings around but that made life much harder when it came to sorting elderly parents, in some cases siblings taking legal action against one another. One sibling in every case was also landed with looking out for the elderly parents before they passed, and definitely added resentment to the relationships.

DH thinks our DS is wonderful (he is!) So why not try make another? But no two siblings are the same and whilst I'm sure DC2 would also be wonderful, it's so hard trying to be good parents and not replicate our own upbringing, that I fear 2 would make that much too hard!

Swipe left for the next trending thread