Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of people who stuck to one DC?

233 replies

WerkinMum · 01/01/2023 23:48

There's obviously nothing I can do about my reality so just venting and wondering if anyone else shares my thoughts.

I have two much loved children, 6 and 3. They are amazing. However I look at people with one and think they have the best of both worlds. They're a parent but also have time for themselves, can focus on a career, more money etc.

DH and I found our first child hard in the beginning, the sleep was atrocious, and just as we got back to normal we had another. I was happy with one but felt a lot of pressure and guilt over not having another and so took the plunge. I adore DC2 of course but my life is now all about being a parent with no space left for me and my interests. I used to have a great career which I have now been out of for so long I'll never properly get back.

DC1 never expressed interest in a sibling, they don't play together that much they're usually bickering or doing their own thing, vying for my attention.

I wish everything was a bit calmer! Does anyone else ever feel the same?

OP posts:
BrownEyedGhoul · 02/01/2023 14:33

WerkinMum · 01/01/2023 23:48

There's obviously nothing I can do about my reality so just venting and wondering if anyone else shares my thoughts.

I have two much loved children, 6 and 3. They are amazing. However I look at people with one and think they have the best of both worlds. They're a parent but also have time for themselves, can focus on a career, more money etc.

DH and I found our first child hard in the beginning, the sleep was atrocious, and just as we got back to normal we had another. I was happy with one but felt a lot of pressure and guilt over not having another and so took the plunge. I adore DC2 of course but my life is now all about being a parent with no space left for me and my interests. I used to have a great career which I have now been out of for so long I'll never properly get back.

DC1 never expressed interest in a sibling, they don't play together that much they're usually bickering or doing their own thing, vying for my attention.

I wish everything was a bit calmer! Does anyone else ever feel the same?

This is just your classic grass is greener nonsense. You could have one that causes chaos and noise all day every day or 6 well behaved quiet little introverts.

You made your choice, you got what you got. IF your life isn't working the way youve made it, make the changes you need to, don't sit around pining for some imaginary impossible other life.

47times11 · 02/01/2023 14:32

I am pleased with our decision to have one. as i said upthread he has SEN and needs alot of input and attention to keep him on any sort of even keel and able to be vaguely productive. If we had 2 i simply could not have given that time and the second would have been shortchanged. I know my personality and know DH's and we could not have successfully parented two IMO.

One means we can meet his needs more readily. I really worked for us and I do not regret it for a minute.

Glitterblue · 02/01/2023 14:27

Pyvadanya · 02/01/2023 00:08

I was an only child and there was no way I was going to replicate that situation for my kids (if I could help it!). I have 3 and would probably have more if my husband wanted to (he doesnt). 1 child would be easier for me but it's not what I wanted for my kids. I understand I've been very blessed with my circumstances and not everyone had the same Lonely experience that I had growing up.

This is what really worries me about only having one child. We always wanted two, but DD was born so prematurely and we both almost lost our lives so we couldn't risk another. She's 12 now and I'm still so sad about not having another one, and I really really worry in case she's lonely. My mum was an only child and always wished she had a sibling.

kikisparks · 02/01/2023 14:22

RunLolaRun102 · 02/01/2023 13:47

Ask your 7 year old again in 10 years. Parents always think they’re giving enough 1-2-1 time but with 3 kids it’s impossible for you to have as much quality time or as deep a relationship as only parents do.

I’m one and done and whilst one reason is that I think, for me, I’ll be able to have a better connection with DD because I’m not having more, I don’t think your comment is very fair or true, there are lots of reasons besides family size that contribute to how much quality time or how deep a relationship someone has with their parents.

theholidaymum · 02/01/2023 14:17

DisneyChops · 02/01/2023 13:51

Nothing wrong with having an only child, and I completely understand how you feel OP.
There are lots of benefits to having one.

Problem is everyone's pros and cons lists will be differently weighted because it depends on your circumstances.

However, what annoys me is some of the 'cons' (apparently) to having an only child are completely ridiculous, which results in many families feeling like they have to have more than one. Let's see, like:

  • only children are spoilt (research suggests otherwise. Old fashioned outdated opinion)
  • only children have no social skills (again, false and depends on the experiences you provide for them or encourage )
  • they'll have someone to play with if they have a sibling (I hated playing with my two brothers, so not a given)
  • they'll have the whole burden of looking after elderly parents (actually, often this makes it more frustrating as usually one sibling does more than another and resents the other for it)

And so, because of these reasons, I bet there are lots of families out there who probably would have been happier staying at one, but don't want to admit it.

this!
The 3 people I know are only one - my husband and the two of his cousins. They are all amazing adults, and much more mature than my spoilt sister tbh. My husband and I only have energy for one (although he would love to have more than one, just so that he can give more love and cuddles, not for all the reasons people mentioning). One of his cousin (a teacher) also chooses to have one. The other (a nurse) is having a second close in age.
I never understand why anyone will feel the need to give any excuses/reasons/regrets why you will only have one? We are happy with one child, by choice, and just don't feel the need to change our dynamics. And we are happy with our choice, so all the "pity" from one of the posters can keep to themselves.
Same with family with 2,3,4 or more kids, why would you choose to have them then feel regrets and unhappy with your choice or someone else choices? And feel the need to criticise the others for their choices? Tbh I have no respect for these parents. If you cant cope with that many kids then don't have them. Will just make life harder for yourself and the kid(s).

DisneyChops · 02/01/2023 13:51

Nothing wrong with having an only child, and I completely understand how you feel OP.
There are lots of benefits to having one.

Problem is everyone's pros and cons lists will be differently weighted because it depends on your circumstances.

However, what annoys me is some of the 'cons' (apparently) to having an only child are completely ridiculous, which results in many families feeling like they have to have more than one. Let's see, like:

  • only children are spoilt (research suggests otherwise. Old fashioned outdated opinion)
  • only children have no social skills (again, false and depends on the experiences you provide for them or encourage )
  • they'll have someone to play with if they have a sibling (I hated playing with my two brothers, so not a given)
  • they'll have the whole burden of looking after elderly parents (actually, often this makes it more frustrating as usually one sibling does more than another and resents the other for it)

And so, because of these reasons, I bet there are lots of families out there who probably would have been happier staying at one, but don't want to admit it.

RunLolaRun102 · 02/01/2023 13:47

SleepingStandingUp · 02/01/2023 13:25

Obv doesn't work if you're a single parent, but I still have 121 time with my 7 yo despite having 3 yo twins. We do stuff they're too small for so DH has them. He does stuff with Dad they're too small for so I have them. The twins don't get 121 time as such cos twin toddlers.... but wil Las they're older.

I find 3 hard work (we planned two, the egg split) but the idea that only singleton parents get quality time is nonsense

Ask your 7 year old again in 10 years. Parents always think they’re giving enough 1-2-1 time but with 3 kids it’s impossible for you to have as much quality time or as deep a relationship as only parents do.

mamabear715 · 02/01/2023 13:30

I have seven, (2 ASD but ok) & I adore them all.
It's a very personal choice & I am sorry for all parents who have had snidey comments. Sometimes I get asked 'did you not have a telly?' but I can laugh at that one! :-)

Iamnotausername · 02/01/2023 13:30

I have one child and don't regret it at all.

I sometimes look at 2+ children families and there are advantages eg it's often easier for them to play when they are younger because they don't rely on the adult as much and larger families often look like fun.

But, we have fun and there are definately things we can do with one child that we couldn't with more eg next summer we are going interrailing for 6 weeks. There is no way we could afford that if we had more than one.

My daughter has never mentioned having a sibling.

The only person who has given me any grief about having one child is my mum. She thought it was selfish and would make the child lonely. Ironically she had me and my sister. As kids we HATED each other and adults we don't even have each other's telephone numbers so where she has this fluffy sibling image from I don't know. My sister only has one child as well so I'm guessing
she didn't see the benefit of having a sibling either. :D

A few months after I had mine, I bumped into my midwife. She asked if I planned anymore and I said probably not. She said "I'll see you in an ante-natel class soon" and winked. I was furious. I still am. I need to get over that! :D

Anyway, there are advantages and disadvantages of families of all sizes.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/01/2023 13:25

Obv doesn't work if you're a single parent, but I still have 121 time with my 7 yo despite having 3 yo twins. We do stuff they're too small for so DH has them. He does stuff with Dad they're too small for so I have them. The twins don't get 121 time as such cos twin toddlers.... but wil Las they're older.

I find 3 hard work (we planned two, the egg split) but the idea that only singleton parents get quality time is nonsense

biscoffonasunday · 02/01/2023 13:18

@stargirl1701

'No. DD1 is autistic and if I had only had her I would have regarded myself as an failed and inadequate parent, DD2 is NT. Parenting her gives me a sense of normalcy. I am not a failure. I am actually quite good at being a mum.'

This ^ although just in process of trying to get some help for dc1. For ages I thought I'd failed as a parent, delayed movement, delayed speech, what ever I did didn't get a reaction as I'd imagined, or seen with other people's dc; i really couldnt win and would sit and cry. I almost didn't have another due to how difficult it was, thank goodness I did. Dc2 gives me all of the things I feel I didn't get with dc1 how I'd imagined it would be. Dc1 gives me the lovely unique quirks dc2 doesn't. I have the best of both worlds.

Whydidimarrythis · 02/01/2023 13:11

Orangepolentacake · 02/01/2023 10:28

@Whydidimarrythis People are allowed to talk about the things they want to talk about, as long as in a respectful manner. People also have the option not to read threads and not to comment. I don't understand why people feel the need to go onto threads to tell posters that they should keep their mouth shut. Everyone has their own experience and not one or the other is more valid or worthy. Why do you feel the need to come on here to criticise the op for having her own experience? Just walk on when you see threads you don't like. It's easy not to click on something and read it and post something unpleasant.

🙄almost none of what you’ve written is a response to what I’ve said. No one has said OP isn’t entitled to her experience but encouraging people to say nasty and hurtful things is a horrible thing to do.

kikisparks · 02/01/2023 12:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This. There’s nothing wrong with someone saying that they prefer having 2 children but no need to say something negative about those with a different family size. DH, DD and I are absolutely a full family.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/01/2023 12:37

No the opposite in facr. I wanted a big family. I would have absolutely hated dc not to have a sibling.

nc824 · 02/01/2023 12:33

@Namechangingx100 you sound like an amazing mum. Plenty of mums, with 1 or more children, probably don't invest that level of energy to engage with their kids. Whilst you're tired I have no doubt it will be in your and your daughter's benefit in the long run Flowers she will remember it.

hexanine · 02/01/2023 12:22

I have 2 DDs with a 3.5 year gap and it's worked out well for us. I had planned to just have one and I did enjoy the early years with DD1 when there were just three of us, so I'm glad we didn't rush into having another. DD1 was at nursery and then school when I had DD2 so I had plenty of time to enjoy baby classes with DD2 the second time around, and DD1 was independent enough to dress herself, use the toilet and eat without help.

DH also wfh part of the week and is very hands on (and has a generous leave policy, he had 7 months of paid time off for paternity). I run my own business which is mostly passive now, so I'm not stressing about my career or worrying about money (we have no concerns about paying for both to go to private school, uni or funding house deposits). I don't have much time for myself right now but that's because DD2 is so young - she will go to preschool in a year and then full days at school, when I will be able to focus on myself a bit more. I don't think I would have had another without all that extra support and security.

suzyscat · 02/01/2023 12:19

You're coming out of a hard bit where you have been needed a lot. As youngest turns 4/ 5 and becomes more independent and they can play together it gets easier. I do actively encourage loyalty and team work between them, there was a period where they'd wind each other up but we worked on it and it's lovely now. (Though messy.)

I know that feeling of how organised and doting parents of 1 seem, it's hard to balance multiple lives, needs and attention. I was an only child and although had a happy childhood and can't complain at all, I wouldn't have wanted it for my kids and they really appreciate having a chum.

ItWasTheBestOfTimes · 02/01/2023 12:06

I have 2 DDs and no regrets. They are best friends and play nicely together 90% of the time. I wouldn't have any more though as I think I have a good of balance of time with them together, 1:1 with each child whilst the other is at an activity and on our own. Luckily DH earns well so we can still afford all the extras and have very hands on parents who help out a lot.

kikisparks · 02/01/2023 12:02

Velda · 02/01/2023 01:04

You make your choice. Free time and career, or another child. What you prefer depends on you as a person. I imagine it’s a lot easier to die and leave two children together than one alone. And it’s certainly easier for two to look after you, it’s a burden for one.

Not necessarily, a lot of the time siblings fight over looking after their parents/ inheritance and the burden falls on one anyway who ends up resentful. I think the best would be if people planned for old age so that their children don’t have to look after them. Plus I know lots of adult siblings who don’t talk at all and lots who are on friendly terms but not super close. When my parents go it will be my DH I lean on, not my sibling, much as we get on ok and care about each other we’re not close.

47times11 · 02/01/2023 11:52

stargirl1701 · 01/01/2023 23:52

No. DD1 is autistic and if I had only had her I would have regarded myself as an failed and inadequate parent, DD2 is NT. Parenting her gives me a sense of normalcy. I am not a failure. I am actually quite good at being a mum.

My Ds12 is autism. We decided we would have to make a choice when he turned 3 about another and decided it was so hard we would stick with one. I am very pleased about it tbh. We have been able to give huge amount of time, financial and emotional respurces to him that we simply could not have done with another. He is in a fee paying school which we would never have been able to afford otherwise. We can do massive amounts of enrichment stuff- like days out, and trips away- last year he was able to go on a school trip with his mainstream school and I was able to go and prop nearby the vicinity to be on hand of required. (Only the teachers knew this, DS did not). It was not needed but if I had to go and pick him up or just be around I could have done so.

I don't think I am a rubbish parent at all. We have had loads of family therapy and sometimes work within support groups and what shouts out to me is that most parents of children with any special needs are really really instinctive, responsive and just plain GREAT at parenting. So don't do yourself down. parenting a child with SN and autism is hard. Usuaully, despite what we judge ourselves to be, we are bloody brilliant at it.

NegroniLover · 02/01/2023 11:46

We have 1 dc, not by choice, secondary infertility Inc multiple failed ivf cycles & miscarriage etc made that decision for us.
I mourned it a LOT when dc was younger but have now come to terms with it & we've poured all our energy into making the best life we can for all 3 of us.
Our dc has had amazing opportunities & travelled the world etc. She has wonderful friends & a very active social life.
I have no regrets now.
I used to envy friends with multiple children but I don't any longer at all. We got incredibly lucky with the one we did get & she's absolutely amazing. We love spending time with her.
Other stupid people have been the main issue in our experience. In particular when she was small - other mothers saying stupid shit without engaging their brains at all. Usually the ones churning out multiple kids they could barely cope with.
I could never understand why it was 'ok' for them to say 'oh she needs a brother it sister, she'll be spoiled' and it wouldn't be ok for me to have commented oh what a pity you've had 3 and are on yout 4th when you can clearly barely afford the cost or energy to deal with 2...they're all going to suffer in the long run...

MousyMcMouse · 02/01/2023 11:44

uncomplicatedish · 02/01/2023 08:45

I have one child and he's lonely. No cousins locally and those he does have are older and not interested anywayS

I really struggle as I have to arrange play dates etc with other parents who have more than one kid and don't need play dates in the same way. I feel like a shit parents.

I don't like saying it, but I recognize this.

Beforehand we made the very conscious choice to have only one child because it suits us: older parents, both introvert, don't enjoy having a full calendar and having struggled finding jobs and supporting ourselves in the past. We were absolutely sure there'd be no more kids after I had an extremely rough pregnancy that took me a year and multiple surgeries to recover from, and while that was a case of terrible luck and a new pregnancy might be as easy as they come, it was a bit of a trauma.

I thought it would be the easy, healthy and happy choice.

But for the past years we've been getting lots of remarks - kindly meant, not necessarily negative, but signaling we are unusual: people seem to assume something is wrong with us (like secondary infertility). Everyone around us seems to have at least two. We try to arrange play-dates for our four year old, but generally people aren't open to it: too busy with multiple kids, and they don't need it. I very much feel like an island, and sometimes do consider having a second just because of social pressure and giving my kid the same experience all her peers get to have. But the thought of having another baby and going through it all again fills me with terror and anxiety. I really don't want another. And that makes me feel like a shit mum.

I had no idea having an only was still so much the exception and how much society is geared towards families of four (2 parents, 2 kids). You read everywhere that one-child families are on the rise, and that more and more people adopt the "one and done" approach, but my daughter is the only only in her class. She is constantly asking for a sibling. I might have made different choices had I known.

Copasetic · 02/01/2023 11:42

I've never regretted and of my 3 for even a second. First two conceived with fertility treatment and then a surprise 3rd. I do have big age gaps between each though so that makes life easier. I love what they bring to my life. I might be busy picking them up and taking them places but their hobbies have become my interest too so I don't want time to do my own thing. I work part time and always busy but happy with that.

Wombatbum · 02/01/2023 11:34

No, I’ve got 3, it’s hard sometimes but wouldn’t change it.

I’m an only child and I wish I wasn’t. I have no cousins either so it’s very lonely… I worry about when my mum is elderly and I have to deal with it on my own.

Namechangingx100 · 02/01/2023 11:30

Just want to add. I have one child. I am a parent, we are a family and I am very grateful to have her. She is meant to be and I can’t imagine the world without her.

I grew up with a friend (back in my school days) who was an only child and she is a great person with loads of friends and a really decent life. There is nothing wrong with being an only child.