Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move away from ex..

113 replies

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:11

I am struggling with the cost of living and have the opportunity to move an hour and forty minutes away from my current location. I live in an expensive area and work full time, plus work in the evenings freelance to pay bills/survive. I have an opportunity to rent a much, much cheaper property from family. Which would mean I could work part time and spend more time with my daughter and be better off financially.

At the moment I pay nearly £2k for nursery, rent, bills, food etc! I get £350 from my ex. I am only entitled to tax free childcare and am a middle earner, so once I have paid all bills I am left with very little and some months go into debt.

I have decided that the move would be the most sensible decision. My ex only sees our LG at the weekends (or when he has holidays) and occasionally pops round in the week, but this is the exception rather than the rule. I have mentioned the idea before and the first time he was really reasonable and the second time he said 'you can't just move, I have rights too.' Having done some research, I'm worried he would get a prohibitive steps order and have read it's better to move without telling him (though this makes me feel really uncomfortable)!

I do the majority of childcare, pay for all nursery costs and take my daughter to all doctors appointments. I would also meet him half way for pick ups and drops off and would encourage him to have her for whole weekends if I moved (we currently share weekends as we both work full time)! Has anyone got experience of moving away or the legalities? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
MissSmiley · 02/01/2023 00:22

If he's hard up too and works around the country would he move to be near you on your new cheaper location? I'd discuss it with him and see if you can reach an agreement, you can't just bugger off and let him find out after you have moved

FleasNavidad · 02/01/2023 00:19

I have read all posts. They're very telling. You only want answers that suit your plans but if you intend to truly put your daughter first then you'd be best speaking with her Dad and making an arrangement that enables her to develop proper meaningful relationships with both of you.

tinseltoes1982 · 02/01/2023 00:09

@Mumuser124 can I ask who recommends this?

OP posts:
Mumuser124 · 02/01/2023 00:01

I don’t think your proposal is unreasonable given your finances and the fact he only sees her at the weekends now. But it is sad dad and child don’t get to see each other during the week. Many children have to travel distances to get to school/nursary. At your daughters age it is recommended that a child does not spend more than a couple of days away from each parent.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:48

@FleasNavidad I replied to another poster who said EOW worked best and I agreed. I didn't say that is what I was going to do. Please read all posts.

OP posts:
FleasNavidad · 01/01/2023 23:46

Yeah and then you said every other weekend is best. It's not if you want her to know her dad properly.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:44

@FleasNavidad I think you'll find in the earlier posts I've said I would like him to see her most weekends.

OP posts:
tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:42

Hi @PumpkinDart thanks this is all really helpful. We don't have a court order in place, at the moment as we both work full time we share weekends (he has her either Friday or Saturday night and sometimes for the whole weekend). My ex partner is heavily in debt, so can only afford the CMS payments he needs to, which are £300. He also has a job which sees him going all over the country, which is why he would never be able to offer our daughter 50/50.

I'm not sure he would even take me to court, as I assume it costs?

All I want is a less financially strained and stressful life. I don't want my daughter to not see her father and would go out of my way to facilitate their relationship. I really appreciate your reply. Thank you so much. Do you mind me asking once a PSO has been applied for, does this mean I wouldn't be able to move until the court hearing?

OP posts:
FleasNavidad · 01/01/2023 23:38

He's seeing her every weekend @PumpkinDart and occasionally through the week. The OP wants to change that to every other weekend Friday night to Sunday afternoon.

OP - is that what you truly feel is best for their relationship?

@Bigbadfish is right, you need to work on looking at what is best for your daughter alone. Reacting with emotion and getting defensive and affronted won't help.

PumpkinDart · 01/01/2023 23:31

Hi OP, my background is the Family Court. If he's only seeing her every other weekend now I'm perplexed at why others think the mags would be unhappy with that continuing. You're offering an increase in contact as well and to do the bulk of transport plus talking under 2 hours. I've known children travel further for contact.

If it does go to Court you'd have to outline what you'd do to promote the relationship, face time, phone calls etc. If he does apply for Prohibited Steps it will be listed quicker than a standard Child Arrangement Order but the backlog is still quite significant.

Do you have an amicable relationship? Can you sit down with him and discuss? Potentially even go to mediation and come up with a plan?

Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 23:26

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:24

@Bigbadfish not emotion. Just nothing I have proposed is unreasonable and you keep saying it is. Many, many people have EOW. I am not even proposing that I am proposing every weekend with some weekends being for the full weekend. Again, can I ask how you know so much?

No, I'm working on keeping my online life more private. Especially with MN history.

I would advise you see more advise from a solicitor or if finances are tight a
mckenzie friend

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:24

@Bigbadfish not emotion. Just nothing I have proposed is unreasonable and you keep saying it is. Many, many people have EOW. I am not even proposing that I am proposing every weekend with some weekends being for the full weekend. Again, can I ask how you know so much?

OP posts:
Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 23:20

I never said you're unreasonable and you need to start taking the emotion out of it. Because if he has gone the legal route you will be asked a lot harder questions than this.

Every other week would be seen as to long. So you'd need to come up with an answer for that.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:18

@Bigbadfish all my proposals include meaningful relationship with both parents and would infact include her seeing him more (whole weekends instead of shared). If you read the other posts you will see where I have put I would drive to his some of the month and meet half way other times. Would love to hear your suggestions how ex can provide more for his daughter?

Not sure where I'm being unreasonable or trying to stop contact. As mentioned, are you a lawyer or do you work for family courts?

OP posts:
Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 23:13

Child focused would also include the rights of the child to have a meaningful realtionship with both parents. Your current proposal does not future proof and also involves less access.

Your finances could be an argument but you would be better to plan ahead for how you will assist in travel. Also he will likely get 50/50 holidays so you could enter that as an argument to increase time over the academic year.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:09

@Bigbadfish and why a shared care order? He still won't be able to afford half the nursery costs? His job is unpredictable and he works around the country and long hours. On the few occasions he has meant to be pick her up from nursery he has asked me to pick her up as he is running over an hour late.

OP posts:
tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 23:07

@Bigbadfish not sure how I'm not being child focused? A child needs stability, money and a secure home. My ex also see her at the weekends and nothing would change, the only thing that would change is the distance between our homes.

Out of Interest are you a lawyer? Do you work in the family courts? Where have you seen the account of someone not been granted to move less than two hours away because it would benefit them financially and stop them getting into debt?

OP posts:
Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 23:02

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:51

@Bigbadfish why wouldn't the court be thrilled at every other weekend? Also, just out of interest, do you think it's in the best interests of a child to have a mother working two jobs, getting into debt and stressed or a mother who will have more money and time to spend with their child?

Out of interest, what is your opinion on a father who can't step up financially to pay for half childcare costs for his daughter, even though he also works full time? Or a father who has never taken time off work to look after his Ill daughter?

As my original post states I want my daughter to have a relationship with her father, but I can't be expected to work two jobs and go into debt to appease a man who isn't providing his fair share!

They tend to like more frequent contact.
50/50 Is even rising in popularity.

That is what you would have to put forward but it would not be seen as the NRPs responsibility to fund care on the RPs time.
Maybe a shared care order would work better for you so he can then take the burden.

But do prepare yourself.
I have seen someone have a PSO granted even with the financial difficulties listed and the point made was that it did not preserve the NRP and child relationship.

You need to really push child focused and leave you out of it.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:53

@YetMoreNewBeginnings thanks for pointing this out. I didn't think of this

OP posts:
tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:52

@Fireflygal thanks this is all really helpful information.

OP posts:
tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:51

@Bigbadfish why wouldn't the court be thrilled at every other weekend? Also, just out of interest, do you think it's in the best interests of a child to have a mother working two jobs, getting into debt and stressed or a mother who will have more money and time to spend with their child?

Out of interest, what is your opinion on a father who can't step up financially to pay for half childcare costs for his daughter, even though he also works full time? Or a father who has never taken time off work to look after his Ill daughter?

As my original post states I want my daughter to have a relationship with her father, but I can't be expected to work two jobs and go into debt to appease a man who isn't providing his fair share!

OP posts:
Fireflygal · 01/01/2023 22:44

A court could take a dim view of you moving without consulting him.

He could apply for a court order to have regular contact which would make a move difficult or even residency of his daughter.

Outline a proposal for moving, give him options to discuss what works for him and also when you propose moving. If he mentions court suggest mediation.

Some mothers have had to return or risk residency of child being transferred as a judge could view you as acting unilaterally.
An emergency pos could have you in court quickly

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 01/01/2023 22:44

If you set the precedent of him having her every weekend then he could argue you changing that when she goes to school.

I have a friend who gave her ex 3 weekends out of 4 and her doing all the drop offs and pick ups to persuade him to let her move 2 hours away. When the child started school he insisted it was kept to and the court agreed on the status quo when she tried to change it.

She’s only 2 now but she’ll be 4 before you know it!

Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 22:42

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:38

@Bigbadfish she isn't school age and he doesn't see her midweek. He does occasionally pop round if he hasn't seen her at the weekend.

I'm assuming you don't plan to move back in the next few years? And she will continue to age?

And a court wouldn't be thrilled at a proposal of every other weekend.
So if you were to go to court it would be on you to show how you would maintain the realtionship going forward.

This would inculde some form of mid week contact.

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:38

@Bigbadfish she isn't school age and he doesn't see her midweek. He does occasionally pop round if he hasn't seen her at the weekend.

OP posts: