Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move away from ex..

113 replies

tinseltoes1982 · 01/01/2023 22:11

I am struggling with the cost of living and have the opportunity to move an hour and forty minutes away from my current location. I live in an expensive area and work full time, plus work in the evenings freelance to pay bills/survive. I have an opportunity to rent a much, much cheaper property from family. Which would mean I could work part time and spend more time with my daughter and be better off financially.

At the moment I pay nearly £2k for nursery, rent, bills, food etc! I get £350 from my ex. I am only entitled to tax free childcare and am a middle earner, so once I have paid all bills I am left with very little and some months go into debt.

I have decided that the move would be the most sensible decision. My ex only sees our LG at the weekends (or when he has holidays) and occasionally pops round in the week, but this is the exception rather than the rule. I have mentioned the idea before and the first time he was really reasonable and the second time he said 'you can't just move, I have rights too.' Having done some research, I'm worried he would get a prohibitive steps order and have read it's better to move without telling him (though this makes me feel really uncomfortable)!

I do the majority of childcare, pay for all nursery costs and take my daughter to all doctors appointments. I would also meet him half way for pick ups and drops off and would encourage him to have her for whole weekends if I moved (we currently share weekends as we both work full time)! Has anyone got experience of moving away or the legalities? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

OP posts:
Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 02/01/2023 10:13

Is all that travelling fair on your daughter?

Probably not.

Is it fair that the OP is doing all the grunt work of parenting? Is her ex suggesting he wants to take on some of the burden - both practically and financially? Or is he doing what he’s always done and expecting his ex to pick up their child when he can’t? Is it fair that childcare costs £1.7k a month and the ex is contributing only £300 to cover everything? That’s £1.7k the OP is shelling out before she’s made any actual money to house, feed and clothe a child who has 2 parents. The current climate is tough for families, but doubly tough for those of us in one-income households - I work 3 jobs whilst my ex makes no contribution whatsoever. It seems utterly unreasonable that he can have ‘rights’ when it comes to seeing his children regularly but the courts, society, the Government can’t get a penny out of him and expect me to work those 3 jobs to cover our costs! I don’t see him working around childcare or school holidays.

It is absolutely right that children are not removed from one of their parents lives for spurious reasons. But there needs to be some recognition that one parent cannot do everything alone without some reasonable adjustments to life management.

Lkydfju · 02/01/2023 10:12

My DSDs mum did this and it was really hard on DSD and us plus her mum no longer had the flexibility from us that she previously had which she wasn’t expecting. It was okish when DSD was in primary school but as a teen it’s been difficult for her as she then missed out on stuff with her friends when she came to us and she resented her mum for that move.
However in your shoes I can see the benefits for you and your DD in the move; I would think about how it will work out long term. Ideally your ex would contribute more to help manage until you get 30 hours childcare at least

Harliegh · 02/01/2023 10:12

I would want to do the same in your shoes. I'd just be thinking ahead though, when she is school age. Do you really only ever want to see her midweek and not any of the fun family time at weekends? I wouldn't like never having my kids at the weekend for this reason. Every other weekend and sometimes midweek on the opposite week would be fairer. But is that possible with distance....probably not! You shouldn't have to keep struggling though to accommodate the ex.

Ncgirlseriously · 02/01/2023 10:08

I’m saving for a move myself, which will put me and my son much further away from my ex- also for the same reasons, I simply can’t afford to live here, and I have no family here.

My ex flip flopped between being supportive and threatening to take me to court (which, while I understand the emotional turmoil he was going through, does nothing with the actual issue of I Cannot Afford To Live Here). I called citizens advice to ask what the pathway was if he DID try and block me moving. I was told he’d need to prove that I didn’t have a support network where I was moving to and that I was moving to alienate him from our son/that I wasn’t willing to help him maintain the relationship.

Right now my ex is back to understanding, but I’m aware that up until I move he could change his mind again. Overall it’s best if you can get him to understand why you need to move, and avoid court if possible- but calling Citizens Advice and being prepared for the worst outcome made me feel more confident in my decision.

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 10:05

Thanks for your comment. I do get your point but the move would offer my daughter more stability and longer periods with her father.

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 02/01/2023 10:04

For context, I moved some 4 hours away following a very bitter struggle through court with my ex but it was over 10 years ago now. He did move too in the end. Our CAFCASS report was very much focused on the financial side of things - our move was South East to the North East, and mentioned the unmentionable - child maintenance (or lack of).

Also, just out of interest, do you think it's in the best interests of a child to have a mother working two jobs, getting into debt and stressed or a mother who will have more money and time to spend with their child?

There is much made of being ‘child centred’ when it comes to the courts and you absolutely need to focus on the benefits to your child, not you. It just takes a bit of rethinking. Your child will benefit from a stable home, your child will benefit from improved finances, from having a full time parent focused on her, not work etc etc.

His job is unpredictable and he works around the country and long hours. On the few occasions he has meant to be pick her up from nursery he has asked me to pick her up as he is running over an hour late

this is helpful - her other parent has made no adjustments to his working pattern to be able to ensure he can parent appropriately and regularly. Many single parents have to make adjustments - including moving to where the work is, or for cheaper housing, or changing jobs when shift patterns are incompatible with available childcare. You are bearing the brunt of parenting and it’s reasonable adjustments are made - like moving - for the sake of your child.

I'm not sure he would even take me to court, as I assume it costs?

It costs to use a solicitor and barrister in court, yes. But the experts say there isn’t actually a lot of law involved in child access arrangements and plenty of people go through the family courts without legal support. Don’t assume he won’t use the courts to try and get whatever it is he wants.

You don’t say what you do for work. Will it be easy to find work in the new location? Eg. Are you a teacher, nurse, accountant….do you work in a job where there is an obvious demand for your skills? If you’re specialism is such that you are moving away from the one organisation in the country where you can work, it makes things more difficult.

is the area you are moving to comparable to where you are now in terms of schools? Would you be moving within catchment of a school that is rated ‘good’ or better? Is it a downgrade on your current catchment?

How will family support you? What difference will that make to your child’s life?

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 10:04

@whataboutsecondbreakfast I have friends in two parent families that travel the length and breadth of the country to see friends and family
Every other weekend. I'm not concerned about the travel Time as she will have stability Mon-Friday.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 02/01/2023 10:01

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 09:59

@Cherrysoup he sees her
Most weekends and I'd like to continue that but would suggest full weekend every other weekend and one night every other weekend, if that makes sense x

Is all that travelling fair on your daughter?

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 09:59

@Cherrysoup he sees her
Most weekends and I'd like to continue that but would suggest full weekend every other weekend and one night every other weekend, if that makes sense x

Cherrysoup · 02/01/2023 09:57

Ultimately, he sees her eow now and you propose continuing this. He can’t have her 50/50 due to his job.

Were I in your position, I’d do the same.

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 09:48

@whumpthereitis but my ex does not want 50/50. Also, I hear the judges increasingly give 50/50 statement used on here, but when I spoke to a solicitor when we first split they disagreed and said it is rarely offered to parents of very young children.

whumpthereitis · 02/01/2023 09:38

Bear in mind it’s not based on what you consider to be reasonable or unreasonable, it’s what the judge does. Your expectations as to what is fair for you to suck up can be quite different to theirs.

Courts increasingly look for 50/50 to be the ideal. Every other weekend is unlikely to be considered good enough, unless of course your ex agrees with it. Do not move without telling him, that wouldn’t work in your favour.

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 09:31

@gogohmm thank you for your reply. I'm not sure I could move without telling him. I have also broached the subject before and he went from 'you have to do with you need to do' to being really angry about it.

I do try and see things from his point of view, and would happily facilitate a midweek meeting if it didn't interfere with my work or his. However, he choose to move 40 mins away when he first moved out. Such a tough one, am going to speak to a solicitor and then talk to him in a few weeks.

gogohmm · 02/01/2023 09:21

Another thought is that you could meet him half way midweek sometimes giving them 2-3 hours to eat, do an activity etc if there's a suitable location. My friend has become an expert at entertaining herself at her half way point on the midweek contact day. None ideal but you have to make it work. You can also offer to facilitate her to FaceTime regularly.

Whilst he is obviously interfering with your plans a bit, take heart that he actually wants to see his daughter!

poefaced · 02/01/2023 09:14

Definitely move without telling him.

returnofthemacandcheese · 02/01/2023 09:10

@GaryLurcher19 thanks so much for your comment! I should have known from previous experience that there are always a few that believe a mother who does 90% of the childcare and mental load, pays for the majority of costs should still go out of the way to accommodate the father, who expects me to flexible when it suits him and then is controlling if he doesn't get his own way. Reading back I'm being perfectly fair and accommodating, but I can't financially afford to be here anymore and if he won't provide more financial support there is nothing else I can do.

GaryLurcher19 · 02/01/2023 01:27

I think some pp being very unfair to you, OP. Ultimately financial constraints affect our life choices and a co-parent's convenience doesn't override that. It may be better for his relationship with his daughter if you're closer, but it may be necessary for him to bear at least some of the cost to make that doable.

tinseltoes1982 · 02/01/2023 00:51

Totally agree @HeddaGarbled thanks for your measured reply. I really want them to have a relationship but my current situation is not sustainable.

OP posts:
tinseltoes1982 · 02/01/2023 00:48

Thanks for all the replies. Some really good advice. Will discuss in detail with ex and hopefully come up with a plan. Whilst I will accommodate my daughter maintaining a regular relationship with her father, I cannot to afford to get further and further into debt to facilitate this. As others have suggested, he could also look to move and change jobs too.

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 02/01/2023 00:42

The best chance of father and daughter maintaining a close relationship through the teenage years and into adulthood, is if they live close by, so they can have frequent, short, and spontaneous contact, rather than set weekends and holidays, which will naturally dwindle.

I understand and sympathise with your motivation, but don’t minimise the consequences for them both. Acknowledge the downside, as well as the advantages, and then make your decision.

DelphiniumBlue · 02/01/2023 00:37

So he can’t take any weekday responsibilities for your DC because he works unpredictable long hours travelling all over the country. Maybe he needs to think about getting a different job, if despite all this he can’t afford to pay more than £300 pm for his DD.
Yet you, OP are being expected to get a second job whilst taking on the bulk of the childcare and financial burden.
Maybe he should consider moving to a cheaper area as well.

Maya678 · 02/01/2023 00:29

But yes I think I’d sit him down and tell him you need to talk things through and your main priority is your daughter.

Maya678 · 02/01/2023 00:27

@tinseltoes1982 not been in this exact situation but just wanted to say my ex took me to court and though it was stressful, all professionals were incredibly nice and fair. I represented myself as I couldn’t afford a solicitor (it really was fine) my ex had a Mackenzie friend (someone to support him-often volunteers). Myself and my children were seen by cafcass who were very supportive. So long as they can see you are trying to do what is best for the child, they are great. My ex took me to court to try and scare me. I made it quite clear I wanted my children to see their dad and to have a relationship with him. If it does go to court, just be honest with all the facts. Good luck x

FloydPepper · 02/01/2023 00:25

You’re very defensive. People are only offering advice but you’ve very quickly getting snippy, and trying to defend yourself.

im not up on the legals, but I’d be devastated if my ex moved my kids away from me. I’d likely try legal routes, and it’d thoroughly fuck up tje co parenting relationship we had.

think long and hard before blowing things up.

Ponderingwindow · 02/01/2023 00:25

Your plan might work for now. How is it going to work when your daughter has activities on the weekends? When she wants to attend a friends birthday party? What about if she decides to play a sport and has games every weekend for 12 weeks in a row? What if she needs to meet up with other kids from school to work on a project? What if she just wants to spend time with her friends? What if she has a part-time job?

children develop their own lives surprisingly soon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread