Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how long the NHS has left?

207 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 01/01/2023 20:41

Genuinely now have the mindset that's it's not 'will' the NHS go under but 'when'. I'm not in the NHS though so I guess I'm asking 2 questions here....

  1. YABU the NHS will survive somehow or YANBU the NHS is going to go 100%
  1. If IANBU when? How much longer do you think we have?
OP posts:
MoscowMules · 01/01/2023 21:29

NHS Wales run by labour isn't fairing much better. In our city A and E is overflowing, ambulance wait times for anything below a heart attack/stroke is hours.

We recently had a lad with a dislocated hip, broken tibia/fibi wait 8 hour in excruciating pain for an ambulance, the family had resorted to crushing up codine tablets and putting it on teaspoons mixed with water and forcing it down his throat in an effort to give him some relief. But it didn't touch it really.

The NHS is now a dying duck in the water. It's just like you say OP how long till they fish the dead duck out.

I do however believe, a small and very small part of the problem is abuse of the NHS by the general public. Stop booking GP appointments for a cold, or booking appointments and not turning up. Stop calling an ambulance for a broken wrist or tonsillitis. Stop going to the pharmacy and getting a pharmacist to prescribe things like Calpol under the common ailment scheme. It's £1 for off brand paracetamol suspension for children.

I think the only way the NHS can save itself is to cut back pretty much on every service except life threatening, and truly A and E (broken bones/Trauma) cancer diagnosis and care, cardiac, crisis mental health intervention, children's health and so on. Basically, only treatment to keep you alive.

There will be no more things like infertility, psychology, weight management surgery, cosmetic, physiotherapy, dermatology. All this will get outsourced to private of which if you want it you pay for it.

GP's will become a 7 day 24/7 service across the board, but not anytime soon, as understandably strike action will delay this. All you have to see is the general publics reliance on GP OOH to know it's needed but it needs to be done right and not at the detriment of the poor GP's having to run it.

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 21:24

Bundlebuns · 01/01/2023 21:16

I'm going to buck the trend and say that I took my 5 yr old ds to A&E on Thurs evening after a fall playing football. We were in hospital a total of 1hr and 15 minutes. He was triaged, x-rayed and diagnosed/treated in this time. He has a broken collarbone. I had a call the following day from the fracture clinic and his x-ray had already been reviewed by an orthopaedic consultant. He was brought back into hospital for the optimum sling to be fitted. I was blown away by the service! I am in no way diminishing the poor experience of anyone else. Simply describing the incredible care we received, and my gratitude for our wonderful NHS

I'm glad for you but genuinely amazed. My friend's teen waited 11 hours with a broken bone. Mum's done two 18 hour waits this year - stroke and suspected heart attack.

thecats can't figure out that one at all!

DeathMetalMum · 01/01/2023 21:22

I hope, while this winter has so far been pretty much a shit storm things will improve over the next year.

In my area there seems to be a number of prescribing pharmacist's (I know of 5 locally) that have in the past few months qualified and are able to prescribe for most types of acute infection. Hopefully this happens across the country, it should free up some GP appointments and also some of the load on 111/OOH.

While it's not a fix on waiting times and secondary care timescales. Relieving pressure on hospitals at least a little should trickle down and make some services feel more accessible.

thecatsthecats · 01/01/2023 21:17

One of the issues generally is that I've been hearing that the NHS is on its knees for the past two years.

If you don't work directly in the organisation, use it much, or know people who do, and you get used to hearing that it's on its knees, then the statement ends up as white noise.

(I'm not saying that it isn't true, I just think that it's part of the problem - people don't know/believe it until it actually breaks)

Spendonsend · 01/01/2023 21:16

I think they will just carry on letting private companies deliver 'nhs' services, fof orifit, paid by the tax payer and have less services available.

Then alongside it more and more people will buy additional cover

Bundlebuns · 01/01/2023 21:16

I'm going to buck the trend and say that I took my 5 yr old ds to A&E on Thurs evening after a fall playing football. We were in hospital a total of 1hr and 15 minutes. He was triaged, x-rayed and diagnosed/treated in this time. He has a broken collarbone. I had a call the following day from the fracture clinic and his x-ray had already been reviewed by an orthopaedic consultant. He was brought back into hospital for the optimum sling to be fitted. I was blown away by the service! I am in no way diminishing the poor experience of anyone else. Simply describing the incredible care we received, and my gratitude for our wonderful NHS

Snowmoab · 01/01/2023 21:14

NotAnotherBathBomb · 01/01/2023 21:11

Well for all the 'NHS is falling' fetishists, the privatisation of the rail and Royal Mail have gone splendidly, so I hope you'll be happy 😇

Realists is the term I'd use. It's absolutely terrible at the moment with no signs of improving. I love the ethos of the NHS and that's part of the reason why I've stayed despite how terrible it is, I think we should all be fighting to keep universal healthcare, but it doesn't mean that in its current form, how things are at the moment is good or sustainable.

Wrinklydinkly · 01/01/2023 21:13

The Tories will sell it off to the lowest bidder, it's been chronically underfunded for so long, they will cite it's being not fit for purpose as the reason. I believe the Americans will be given first refusal, they have been eyeing the NHS up for years. A few rich people will become very much richer, and we will all have to pay for private health insurance. I really hope im wrong though.

ofwarren · 01/01/2023 21:12

roarfeckingroarr · 01/01/2023 21:10

@ofwarren that's not how it works. He wouldn't have been left to die. Do neither of you work?

Not at the moment. I'm a carer for him and my DH is currently on sick for mental health and has been since October.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 01/01/2023 21:11

Well for all the 'NHS is falling' fetishists, the privatisation of the rail and Royal Mail have gone splendidly, so I hope you'll be happy 😇

roarfeckingroarr · 01/01/2023 21:10

@ofwarren that's not how it works. He wouldn't have been left to die. Do neither of you work?

bibbif · 01/01/2023 21:10

We'd all have to get insurance like the states?

There are plenty of other options as opposed to the States.
We will need to pay more tax though & the burden needs to be far more equal but that won't go down well

Orangesare · 01/01/2023 21:10

The problem isn’t the same across the whole country. Most parts of the nhs are working really well where I live and I live in an area that has experienced population growth. You can see a gp urgently, minor injuries has very short wait times, hell you can even get an nhs dentist!
A & E and some wards have issues but mainly down to social care problems. Not sure how they will solve the social care problem in my area as even if they put the wages up significantly there just aren’t the women (because it’s mainly women) who will want to do the work. Many women still don’t work or work in family businesses, of the women left who do go out to work many have professional jobs and of there are plenty of easier jobs than caring for the remaining to choose from.

The nhs was worse before 1997 imo and I’ve had plenty of use out of it over the years!

Realistically what is going to be replaced with. Families can’t afford to pay. Frequently on MN you get people posting who have high household incomes unable to manage as fuel, energy, mortgages and food go up. Businesses won’t be able to pay for employees health care they can’t even pay the increased energy costs in many cases.

Snowmoab · 01/01/2023 21:09

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:02

Can people stop with these threads it's really hurtful for the staff trying to keep going through this crisis. The NHS isn't finished it's just going through one of the hardest times in its history. Hopefully once summer comes and respiratory virus die back for a few months things will improve.

Changes are going to have to be made it's a question of where. Giving the NHS more money isn't an option (if anything it needs to go to education) it's time top ups, ceiling of care and the criteria for safe discharge we're discussed on a National scale.

Difficult decisions need to be made about what level of staffing we are going to provide is it going to be PA and nurses doing 99% of the work or do we want to keep a Dr led front of house service. (HCPs that a discussion for another thread 😉)

I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward. I can also see no essential services like prenatal classes, support groups etc being moved to the charity sector

I'd rather a doctor thanks. PAs aren't under a regulatory board, their role isn't even overly clear. But what is clear is that a 2 year postgrad is not comparable to a degree in medicine and the subsequent hoops doctors have to then jump through as a junior doctor. Although nurses are also well qualified professionals, some of who have a mountain of experience, it's a different role to that of a doctor and I think the only scenario where doctors are replaced is one where they cannot be recruited so someone else is better than nothing. I say this as a nurse who is proud of my job and understands the value they bring! I just think that doctors do a role that shouldn't be replaced by something inferior just as we do.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/01/2023 21:09

It's the national religion, the sacred cow. It's not going anywhere.

Fedupofdiets · 01/01/2023 21:09

I work as a Nurse Practitioner for the NHS in an Urgent Care Response team in a major city. We take lower category 999 and 111 calls and see patients at home so ambulances can concentrate on higher cat calls and relieve the pressure on them. The past few weeks have been absolutely gruelling, to the point I just want to go off long term sick. The things people call the emergency services for is staggering but most of that problem is lack of GP appointments and walk in centres. 99% of the people I have been seeing have been for coughs / colds / flu but do not feel they have anywhere to turn. We are taking more calls than we have staff to cover and so I spend my shift lurching from one patient to the next - it is the worst I have ever seen it in my 28 year career. I had an elderly patient die a couple of weeks ago who I suspected had sepsis but had to wait over 16 hours for an ambulance, I don't know if he would have survived had he been treated sooner, I have been so upset about it.

I wonder everyday when they will say it is broken. How will they go about doing that though?

bibbif · 01/01/2023 21:08

It's not sustainable.

Ageing population & impact on social care
Not enough workers, why work in a stressful job paying more tax & struggling to avoid a house when you can go to Oz or similar?

StupidStupidStupidStupidStupid · 01/01/2023 21:07

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 01/01/2023 20:53

It's collapsing right now. EDs are full and overflowing. Many hospitals have declared a major incident in the last couple of days.

Yep. Our local one had waits of over 25 hrs in A&E the other day and more than 100 people waiting for beds so they could be admitted.

Its terrifying.

Snowmoab · 01/01/2023 21:05

Personally I think that very soon elective operations will be cancelled as they were during covid, staff will be redeployed with a focus solely on emergency and life saving areas. I can't imagine they will then be stood back up, certainly not to the same extent. Many people will live in pain and suffer on, private healthcare will flourish though and if you can afford it I think wait lists will quieten down as it expands. Basically I do think it will carry on delivering life saving and emergency care, but everything else that contributes to a healthy society will be scrapped.

It used to be that there would always be 20% leeway in the system, ie you wouldn't often see hospitals go over 80% capacity/capability, but it could handle it for short periods if needed. Of course over the past decade or so the fact has been cut away so there is no longer a safety net or any give in the system. It runs at 100% all of the time and then just starts to crumble when things are paritcularly bad.

I find it startling that the government aren't even acknowledging this at all.

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 21:05

Grumpy "I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward"

how so, like paying for particular treatments? I have an NHS dentist but just go for check ups.

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:02

Can people stop with these threads it's really hurtful for the staff trying to keep going through this crisis. The NHS isn't finished it's just going through one of the hardest times in its history. Hopefully once summer comes and respiratory virus die back for a few months things will improve.

Changes are going to have to be made it's a question of where. Giving the NHS more money isn't an option (if anything it needs to go to education) it's time top ups, ceiling of care and the criteria for safe discharge we're discussed on a National scale.

Difficult decisions need to be made about what level of staffing we are going to provide is it going to be PA and nurses doing 99% of the work or do we want to keep a Dr led front of house service. (HCPs that a discussion for another thread 😉)

I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward. I can also see no essential services like prenatal classes, support groups etc being moved to the charity sector

ofwarren · 01/01/2023 21:00

Flossiemoss · 01/01/2023 20:56

Agree. It’ll be a shitshow January to March. I suspect( pure speculation) there will be an announcement in spring.

this government is nearing its end game with nhs- they aren’t going to get this opportunity to dismantle it again so they aren’t going to waste the opportunity.

Terrifying
What would that mean? We'd all have to get insurance like the states?
My DS is only 8 and he's been so ill since birth. By 6 months old, we worked it out with one of the doctors that if we were American he would have had over a million dollars worth of treatment.
So upsetting to think if we'd have lived there, he would have died because there is no way we could have afforded that or insurance that would cover that amount of care.

KateBalesCardi · 01/01/2023 21:00

Fathercrossmas · 01/01/2023 20:52

It's already gone but what is most worrying is there is no provision to replace it, I've tried to go private for something recently and there is no private provision for what I need either. What exactly was the Tories plan here when they decided to drive it into the ground?

There was no plan, there never is! None of them think past their 5 year term and haven't for a long, long time, that's why we're in this mess.

ScandiNoirNuit · 01/01/2023 20:58

DF currently in A&E for 12 hours and counting following suspected stroke this morning. NHS is not fit for purpose imo. It is just falling apart at the seams, I feel for those working in it, it must feel like pushing water uphill.

Flossiemoss · 01/01/2023 20:56

midnightfirework · 01/01/2023 20:54

6 months

Agree. It’ll be a shitshow January to March. I suspect( pure speculation) there will be an announcement in spring.

this government is nearing its end game with nhs- they aren’t going to get this opportunity to dismantle it again so they aren’t going to waste the opportunity.