Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how long the NHS has left?

207 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 01/01/2023 20:41

Genuinely now have the mindset that's it's not 'will' the NHS go under but 'when'. I'm not in the NHS though so I guess I'm asking 2 questions here....

  1. YABU the NHS will survive somehow or YANBU the NHS is going to go 100%
  1. If IANBU when? How much longer do you think we have?
OP posts:
DrunkenSailor · 01/01/2023 22:15

refuge123 · 01/01/2023 22:13

Why dont they just have a phone line for NHS non emergencies.
It would clear up the line?

111 is the number for non-emergencies.

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 22:14

DrunkenSailor · 01/01/2023 22:12

Experience from yesterday. I had severe midcycle bleeding for several hours, felt faint, was alone at home and called 111 for advice. They "booked an appointment" for me to go to the local hospital (a major London hospital) - to see a doctor there (i was told).

When i reached there, i was told there was no appointment system and that i should join the A&E queue - minimum wait of 5 hours and nowhere to sit except the floor. The admission staff complained 111 were misadvising patients and promising them appointments while all the hospital had was A&E (and apparently no facilities for an ultrasound scan).

I didn't need A&E! I would not have gone had I known that was the option offered. It baffles me why 111 is directing patients to A&E when all many of us need is an urgent care centre. Oh - and it took 45 mins on the phone in a queue to even reach 111 (up from the 8 mins i remember it took me 3 years ago). All that time spent was a waste.

But have you got an urgent care centre?

are you okay now, I do hope so.

refuge123 · 01/01/2023 22:13

Why dont they just have a phone line for NHS non emergencies.
It would clear up the line?

DrunkenSailor · 01/01/2023 22:12

Experience from yesterday. I had severe midcycle bleeding for several hours, felt faint, was alone at home and called 111 for advice. They "booked an appointment" for me to go to the local hospital (a major London hospital) - to see a doctor there (i was told).

When i reached there, i was told there was no appointment system and that i should join the A&E queue - minimum wait of 5 hours and nowhere to sit except the floor. The admission staff complained 111 were misadvising patients and promising them appointments while all the hospital had was A&E (and apparently no facilities for an ultrasound scan).

I didn't need A&E! I would not have gone had I known that was the option offered. It baffles me why 111 is directing patients to A&E when all many of us need is an urgent care centre. Oh - and it took 45 mins on the phone in a queue to even reach 111 (up from the 8 mins i remember it took me 3 years ago). All that time spent was a waste.

IWannaBeInTheRoomWhereItHappens · 01/01/2023 22:12

As someone with a long term degenerative condition this completely terrifies me because I can't see the Tories going with a sane system like parts of Europe - its all going to be about making their rich mates richer, let's face it.

In all honesty if something like the US system is brought in I am screwed and so are millions of others. My friend in the US with my condition died because she did not have enough insurance to get hospital treatment. I might as well give up now and stop my meds if that really does happen. I tell myself it won't, I'm being daft, the NHS will survive, it always does, but I don't know that it will this time. My local hospital has queues of ambulances waiting 30 hours at the moment and the government want to close down our A and E to 'consolidate resources and efficiency'. It's a complete nightmare.

ColdHandsHotHead · 01/01/2023 22:04

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 21:05

Grumpy "I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward"

how so, like paying for particular treatments? I have an NHS dentist but just go for check ups.

Indeed. I have an NHS dentist but need treatment not available on the NHS. I will have to go private for it and it's going to cost thousands. Upwards of £5K.

Busybody2022 · 01/01/2023 22:00

Our area have merged hospitals to one across two sites and split what the different sites provide. As part of it they created a UTC at one. Recently my son broke his collar bone and we used the UTC and were in and out in 90 minutes. The system worked really well as we weren't in the A&E queue. I was really impressed.

Trying to get care for his chronic disabilities is a whole other shitshow though and I'm devastated for him. Private options don't even exist as an alternative.

Coasterfan · 01/01/2023 21:54

We have experienced the issues facing the NHS first hand over Christmas. MIL was taken to a and e from her care home with pneumonia 7am Thursday morning, she has dementia and severe asthma and had had nothing to eat or drink for days. She was in a makeshift bay in a and e until today and has finally been moved to a ward. She has had fantastic care however despite a and e being in utter chaos. Social care is utterly broken as well which is leading to the issues in the hospitals, people are fit for discharge but there is no care in place for them. Social care should be nationalised and run alongside the NHS.

Bigbadfish · 01/01/2023 21:53

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:02

Can people stop with these threads it's really hurtful for the staff trying to keep going through this crisis. The NHS isn't finished it's just going through one of the hardest times in its history. Hopefully once summer comes and respiratory virus die back for a few months things will improve.

Changes are going to have to be made it's a question of where. Giving the NHS more money isn't an option (if anything it needs to go to education) it's time top ups, ceiling of care and the criteria for safe discharge we're discussed on a National scale.

Difficult decisions need to be made about what level of staffing we are going to provide is it going to be PA and nurses doing 99% of the work or do we want to keep a Dr led front of house service. (HCPs that a discussion for another thread 😉)

I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward. I can also see no essential services like prenatal classes, support groups etc being moved to the charity sector

I'm sick to the back teeth of some Staff taking any criticism of the NHS personally.
It's fucked! The "care" system we have at the moment is actually murdering people! We are angry and it's not about you so get over it!

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 01/01/2023 21:52

MoscowMules · 01/01/2023 21:49

I don't think you'll get a US style, what you'll end up with is a Canada, Sweden, French, Australia similar model

How? What process will get us to a half sane, albeit more expensive system, when all the government has to do is completely ignore the problem and let the NHS wither and profit-making US style private healthcare boom?

MoscowMules · 01/01/2023 21:49

I don't think you'll get a US style, what you'll end up with is a Canada, Sweden, French, Australia similar model

MarshaBradyo · 01/01/2023 21:48

I think it would be sad for it to go but it’s obviously straining atm. Although apparently some headway was being made on lists

I don’t know that people would vote for changes to pay at point of service so who knows what will happen

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 01/01/2023 21:47

bibbif · 01/01/2023 21:10

We'd all have to get insurance like the states?

There are plenty of other options as opposed to the States.
We will need to pay more tax though & the burden needs to be far more equal but that won't go down well

There are other options, but none of them is on the table. It's been obvious for some time that the Tories' intention is to create a U.S. system that happens on its own without any discussion needed. The NHS will limp on in name, kind of like Medicaid, and employers will increasingly offer private healthcare as a perk. People who don't get covered through work and aren't rich will suffer.

Adviceneeded200 · 01/01/2023 21:46

I've a mate who has had a private operation cancelled for lack of a bed and is struggling for a new date. I wonder if NHS have taken over more of the private provision?

Speedweed · 01/01/2023 21:45

If it goes, the cost of gas and electric will be nothing compared to real US-style health insurance, not the low level stuff you get through work to provide physio and deal with ingrown toenails quickly.

Forget free at the point of need, and hello to excesses, co-pays and deductibles, oh my! There's nothing like having to work out whether you've been billed correctly when you're recuperating.

Oh, and it's normally capped too, so if you're not well by the time you hit the cap, you have to pay out of pocket or stop treatment. Pre-existing conditions can make it completely unaffordable unless you get the condition excluded from cover.

If the NHS goes, times will be so much tougher for so many.

NoodleDoodleDo · 01/01/2023 21:45

Some areas of the country seem to be fairing better than others.

My DH and I have both seperately needed A&E in the last 2 months and we've been seen, had tests and images, received medication and left within 4/5 hours.

A&E did me a physio referal with first appointment within 4 weeks, after a few weeks physio did referal to spinal unit which I had on 23 December. Theywho arranged an MRI for mid Jan and follow up appointment in place.

My DH went on 23 December and was sent for a more detailed ultrasound on christmas eve. All clear thankfully.

I've also had great treatment from GP for MH reasons, and an urgent referal for suspicious lump (thankfully all clear)

My Mum who lives an hour away from us has elective op planned for mid Jan after only waiting 4 months.

As a family we have needed NHS a lot this year and they have been fantastic and reliable.

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 21:43

Moscow "I think the only way the NHS can save itself is to cut back pretty much on every service except life threatening, and truly A and E (broken bones/Trauma) cancer diagnosis and care, cardiac, crisis mental health intervention, children's health and so on. Basically, only treatment to keep you alive.
There will be no more things like infertility, psychology, weight management surgery, cosmetic, physiotherapy, dermatology. All this will get outsourced to private of which if you want it you pay for it."

Half agree. Physio is important - could save someone from disability. get them back to work.

Dermatology - sepsis and other life threatening infections can and do enter from broken skin.

cancer - sad to say, my father was one to refuse to give up - if he'd been shown a bill for what it cost to keep him clinging on, I'm not sure what he'd have said. The amount of chemo to buy him a few more weeks in a hospital bed, unable to move....I sometimes wonder if people understand those costs. I only know because I overheard the MDT arguing over it.

I suppose we are on the same page though - a real cost benefit analysis. And some things are just too pricey. I'm fat, I have thought about weight loss surgery but I don't think the taxpayer should fund it.

ohfourfoxache · 01/01/2023 21:43

Pre covid, I reckoned a decade

6 months into covid, I thought 5 years

And now, that’s it. I don’t think there’s any way back from this situation. It’s field medicine with extreme triage

in the last 6 months A&E delays have contributed to 15k extra deaths. If that’s not the sign of a failed system I don’t know what is

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 01/01/2023 21:42

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:02

Can people stop with these threads it's really hurtful for the staff trying to keep going through this crisis. The NHS isn't finished it's just going through one of the hardest times in its history. Hopefully once summer comes and respiratory virus die back for a few months things will improve.

Changes are going to have to be made it's a question of where. Giving the NHS more money isn't an option (if anything it needs to go to education) it's time top ups, ceiling of care and the criteria for safe discharge we're discussed on a National scale.

Difficult decisions need to be made about what level of staffing we are going to provide is it going to be PA and nurses doing 99% of the work or do we want to keep a Dr led front of house service. (HCPs that a discussion for another thread 😉)

I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward. I can also see no essential services like prenatal classes, support groups etc being moved to the charity sector

What's really hurtful is fucking stupid posts like this.

MoscowMules · 01/01/2023 21:42

earsup · 01/01/2023 21:36

My cousin is a nurse in A and E...says the majority still turning up with colds or flu or want a repeat prescription....all just clogging up the waiting areas....all ignore the signs and notices telling them they should go home and visit a pharmacy etc to buy paracetemol......i think there should be much stricter control to weed out all these timewasters....last time i was in A and E, there was a family chucking chairs about as the mother wanted a prescription and an interpreter....its madness...arrest them and ban them !!

I agree.

The one and only time I attended a and e I had a head laceration caused by a metal road sign swingin off its hinges and hitting me at the exact unfortunate time that I walked under it.

I walked in with blood soaked tea towels wrapped round my head as the cafe nearby had chucked them at me to help me, and the waitress drive me to a and e.

Luckily only sat in the waiting room for all of 10minutes. But in that 10 minutes you could tell some people really didn't need to be there! I distinctly remember one bloke saying "I need to see the Dr, I've had this cough for 2 weeks" mate that's neither an accident or an emergency!!!

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 01/01/2023 21:41

I'm really sad sorry to hear my post could be insulting to anyone in the NHS. Please know this was not at all my intention. The NHS workers are bloody incredible and my gripe was intended at the government. Sorry though if it misfired.

Thanks all for the replies though. I am particularly worried as I have a disabled son. The specialists he needs have never really been available through the NHS, so they have always out sourced through private ones. He's done utterly amazingly. However I can't imagine how we would ever cover the costs of his therapy if things go private.

My grandad died a year ago in pain and scared because an ambulance couldn't get there in time. I am struggling to come to terms with this.

OP posts:
coffeetofunction · 01/01/2023 21:41

Fedupofdiets · 01/01/2023 21:09

I work as a Nurse Practitioner for the NHS in an Urgent Care Response team in a major city. We take lower category 999 and 111 calls and see patients at home so ambulances can concentrate on higher cat calls and relieve the pressure on them. The past few weeks have been absolutely gruelling, to the point I just want to go off long term sick. The things people call the emergency services for is staggering but most of that problem is lack of GP appointments and walk in centres. 99% of the people I have been seeing have been for coughs / colds / flu but do not feel they have anywhere to turn. We are taking more calls than we have staff to cover and so I spend my shift lurching from one patient to the next - it is the worst I have ever seen it in my 28 year career. I had an elderly patient die a couple of weeks ago who I suspected had sepsis but had to wait over 16 hours for an ambulance, I don't know if he would have survived had he been treated sooner, I have been so upset about it.

I wonder everyday when they will say it is broken. How will they go about doing that though?

I suspected I know where you are based and you're doing amazing!!!

This service that is being offered will continue to make sure a difference and saving people's lives

earsup · 01/01/2023 21:36

My cousin is a nurse in A and E...says the majority still turning up with colds or flu or want a repeat prescription....all just clogging up the waiting areas....all ignore the signs and notices telling them they should go home and visit a pharmacy etc to buy paracetemol......i think there should be much stricter control to weed out all these timewasters....last time i was in A and E, there was a family chucking chairs about as the mother wanted a prescription and an interpreter....its madness...arrest them and ban them !!

silentpool · 01/01/2023 21:34

They do need to find a solution for those cases which need a walk in centre, rather than a hospital or a GP (as sometimes you can't wait for an appointment or the available times don't suit working
people ).

I once spent six hours in A&E in the UK waiting to get a cut stitched up - that kind of thing doesn't need a hospital.

In Aus, we do tend to have health insurance now and have to budget for it and it's not cheap but not on the scale of the US.

I pay a gap fee between what the government will pay for the GP and the actual cost. But I get an appointment when I want it so I consider it worthwhile.

Those that can't afford it can still use the public system but it takes some pressure off the system, as a whole.

I'm not sure what % of NI goes towards healthcare but I pay roughly a 2% surcharge on top of my salary for the equivalent in Aus. Plus health insurance.

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:31

@Snowmoab I think it's an interesting role and to be fair it would be easy enough to put them under HCPC. I'm maybe biased as the girl at our GP is excellent, but she comes from a paramedic background. Id much rather it was easy to get nurse and ANP appointments vs the current battle to see a GP. A pharmacist does my Botox but can't give out antibiotics for strep throat without a GP script. Other countries have more responsibility on AHCP. I do think requirements are going to have to fall to keep the NHS.

I'm in the NHS over the years what was a band 5 task has become a band 4, what was a 6 has become a 5 etc etc so can see it happening to clinical staff aswel.