Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how long the NHS has left?

207 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 01/01/2023 20:41

Genuinely now have the mindset that's it's not 'will' the NHS go under but 'when'. I'm not in the NHS though so I guess I'm asking 2 questions here....

  1. YABU the NHS will survive somehow or YANBU the NHS is going to go 100%
  1. If IANBU when? How much longer do you think we have?
OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 02/01/2023 16:50

"I think you are confusing the NHS with a hotel- why on earth would there be fruit or a choice of yoghurts?"

Not the first time ive heard this "the NHS is not a taxi service" was the other one ive heard. This is why people go abroad. A local taxi driver went to Turkey to have his teeth done. Just under £800 included the hotel AND transport to and from the clinic. He was quoted £1500 here just for the procedure.

And why the fuck shouldnt fruit be available from the organisation with HEALTH in its title plus its champions who are always whining about obesity. Fucking obfuscation as usual.

EmmaEmerald · 02/01/2023 11:25

Grumpybutfunny · 02/01/2023 08:12

You make it a law punishable by the costs being removed at source from your pay. No doubt countless private care companies will pop up claiming a top up off the family on top of the funded hours so DS doesn't have to look after DM or DDad which in turn will make it a better paid more attractive job.

I don't get it

so when the hospital wanted to discharge mum to me, too dizzy to get from bed to chair, you think that's okay and it should be my legal responsibility?

how can anyone genuinely think you are responsible for parental care?
how many suicides would you consider an okay sacrifice for this?

Bard6817 · 02/01/2023 11:20

JenniferBooth · 01/01/2023 23:46

And how would that legal requirement work with the employment rights in this country of which there is fuck all

If you think we are bad, have a peek at the US.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/01/2023 11:17

‘They came round and offered bread and butter or weetabix/cornflakes. There was no yoghurts, fruit, no option for toast.’

no option for toast….well, that just sums up the problem with the NHS, doesn’t it.

Bard6817 · 02/01/2023 11:13

Grumpybutfunny · 01/01/2023 21:02

Can people stop with these threads it's really hurtful for the staff trying to keep going through this crisis. The NHS isn't finished it's just going through one of the hardest times in its history. Hopefully once summer comes and respiratory virus die back for a few months things will improve.

Changes are going to have to be made it's a question of where. Giving the NHS more money isn't an option (if anything it needs to go to education) it's time top ups, ceiling of care and the criteria for safe discharge we're discussed on a National scale.

Difficult decisions need to be made about what level of staffing we are going to provide is it going to be PA and nurses doing 99% of the work or do we want to keep a Dr led front of house service. (HCPs that a discussion for another thread 😉)

I can see GPs moving towards a more dentist like model going forward. I can also see no essential services like prenatal classes, support groups etc being moved to the charity sector

No.

This isn’t a tory or labour caused problem.

I gave up on the Nhs when Labour were in office after a series of medical nightmares, that i still have nerve damage from.

The Nhs can be good at the point of emergency. Beyond that it’s bust.

But it’s over. There are so many great people working in it, but it’s despite the system, the waste, the poor mgmt, the negligence, the poor wages, the hygene and clenliness, the facilities. For every plus, there’s at least 5 negs.

I knew this in the mid 2000’s when i had months off work for two seperate medical issues that i was repeatedly assured ‘rest’ was the solution, by a rotating group of GP’s, never seeing the same one twice, each denying me access to anything other than anti inflamatories and cocodamol to manage the pain or steroid inhalers to aid breathing.

I recently had to dip back into it, pre covid for some Chest Pain issues. The ambulance guys were amazing…. Beyond that, I paid privately for the Holtzman monitor tests (had to wait a week for the letter from my gp) so i didn’t have to wait 8 weeks for it, but i still had to wait a year to see a cardiologist according to its results…. Saw one a week later privately, with same results, diagnosed properly, back to work after an op a month later.

I won’t go into what friends and family have been put through. Although i have seen Cancer care is very good, once diagnosed.

The Nhs is bust. Pretending it isn’t is just doing a disservice to the great people in it, who are being held back by a fear of change, politics and narrative. I don’t want the American model, but the British model sure as shit don’t work now and as far as i can see, hasnt for a very long time.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 02/01/2023 11:04

But it's not really fair to ask everyone else or the next generation to pay for it either

What about those of us who’ve been paying for gemerationd above us for 40 years?

Id be mighty pissed off if suddenly we had to pay after paying in for everyone else for 40 years

Thr NHS will stay. It’s too complex to disassemble for lots of reasons including the one I’ve stated here

Grumpybutfunny · 02/01/2023 10:55

MichelleScarn · 02/01/2023 10:53

Problem is @Grumpybutfunny a significant portion will refuse to even pay out that £15, despite having it in private income or benefits because 'its their right' to get it for free. Attendance allowance is currently £60 week low £90 high at present and as far as I know that's on top of other benefits.

I would take it at source like child maintenance if they didn't pay.

Ilovemycatalot · 02/01/2023 10:55

I think the way forward is health insurance. No one wants to pay more I get that but we don’t have the money in this country to provide a functioning NHS service. Plus a reform in care work. Pay care workers the wage they deserve to attract people back into the profession. Cheap labour from abroad has gone now we need to look to paying people a living wage ( not nmw which is not liveable) lots of elderly taking up beds because their is no where for them to go.

MichelleScarn · 02/01/2023 10:53

Problem is @Grumpybutfunny a significant portion will refuse to even pay out that £15, despite having it in private income or benefits because 'its their right' to get it for free. Attendance allowance is currently £60 week low £90 high at present and as far as I know that's on top of other benefits.

Grumpybutfunny · 02/01/2023 10:47

shinynewapple22 · 02/01/2023 10:13

"I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement."

We are supposed to have this in the UK - at a society level. Younger people work and pay taxes which then go to fund pensions and health care for the elderly. Or at least that is what is meant to happen - the impact of this not working at the moment is the reason for this thread. What is needed is a way to get back to where this does work . Expecting young people in an individual family - who are already struggling with high housing costs and poor wages - to support their own elderly family members is ridiculous .

But it's not really fair to ask everyone else or the next generation to pay for it either. It's a catch 22 as someone is going to have to pay to increase socialcare as even if you privatise the NHS the companies aren't then going to tolerate bed blocking like the NHS does.

If you say increase tax by X percentage which cost the average person say 2k a year (likely to need to be much higher). Over a 50 year working life that's 100k at least as higher earners will once again be hit harder.

Now say you go down the family funding it, social care is usually a maximum of four visits a day. Say they cost £15 per visit, granny is moved near us so we do a morning visit to get her up at 6am before work (wifey as the husband is not a morning person I'm up at the crack of dawn).

We pay someone to come in at lunch time £15, husband can call in on his way home to make sure she okay then one of us can pop round at bed time to put her to bed. Cleaning is what an hour a week so can add that to our cleaners bill or do it on a weekend and the laundry can join my pile which is apply for its own postcode. She better have enough clothes as I wash once a week and it all goes through the dryer!

So say £15 a day x 7 that's £105 a week or £5460 a year some of which will be funded from their private pensions so we will say that includes cover for holidays etc. We could also make it tax free like childcare which makes it £4364 a year by the time my gran needed more than shopping picking up or the high dusting doing she lived a future two years so by having a busy few years we have saved 90k but most importantly we have done it which made her feel more comfortable which to me is priceless.

shinynewapple22 · 02/01/2023 10:13

"I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement."

We are supposed to have this in the UK - at a society level. Younger people work and pay taxes which then go to fund pensions and health care for the elderly. Or at least that is what is meant to happen - the impact of this not working at the moment is the reason for this thread. What is needed is a way to get back to where this does work . Expecting young people in an individual family - who are already struggling with high housing costs and poor wages - to support their own elderly family members is ridiculous .

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 02/01/2023 09:32

I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement.

You come from a culture where women are responsible for the elders.

You make it a law punishable by the costs being removed at source from your pay.

You're taking blinkered authoritarianism to extraordinary levels here.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 02/01/2023 09:26

Not that any of this is wrong - but there seems to be far less tolerance of 'human error' now

And rightly so, because "human error" is never a root cause - it's just a category of failure. However, if we're now blaming individuals for system failures (poor training, poor processes, poor management, poor culture, lack of capacity...) then we're going in the wrong direction.

LakieLady · 02/01/2023 09:23

EmmaEmerald · 01/01/2023 23:42

Grumpy "I would also say that we need to discharge people who are medically fit regardless of the home situation. Choices of care home locations shouldn't exist if it holds up discharge. I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement."

how are you defining "medically fit"? Who are the "young"? Mum would only have me or cousin with medical conditions, or my sister two counties away.

There's no way my brother or I would have been in a position to provide care for my parents had it been necessary.

We both live a 3-hour drive from where they were living, I was working full-time and he has pretty severe MH problems. Many of my friends are in a similar position, living a long way away and/or working f/t.

And the notion that young people should care for older family members rather presupposes that they have the necessary skills and aptitude. Anyone dependent on me for care would be signing a DNR asap, I'd be utter shit at it.

Zebedee55 · 02/01/2023 09:18

If these reports, out today, are correct, the NHS is just falling apart. It needs urgent root and branch reform or there will be nothing left soon:

www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/01/up-to-500-deaths-a-week-due-to-ae-delays-says-senior-medic

LakieLady · 02/01/2023 09:11

Fifi00 · 01/01/2023 23:18

Instead of burying our heads in the sand , we need to talk about the future. People say I've paid my stamp but it's not enough to expect the state to fund our care needs in old age.

That's tough on those of us who've worked for 50 years or more and funded care for the generations that went before us, only to be told that we now have to pay for our own.

I could sell my house to fund mine, but people who are renting don't have that option.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 02/01/2023 09:08

The NHS gives us all of this for free. I cannot imagine having to even try and navigate a life for him without that.

Right now the NHS does not give many who need it anything at all, and "free" is its blessing and its curse.

Nothing in life is free. Someone somewhere is paying for that.

LakieLady · 02/01/2023 09:05

JenniferBooth · 01/01/2023 22:49

@Grumpybutfunny and it shouldnt be ok to slag off patients either but patient blaming is off the charts on MN Its the lack of social care causing these issues.

Delay in pre-discharge social care assessments is a massive issue where I live. The wait is sometimes several weeks. A friend's elderly mother was fit for discharge for 10-12 weeks before her care plan was in place.

There needs to be better integration between ASC and the NHS, and more resources for ASC so that they can recruit and retain staff to get assessments done and care plans in place more quickly.

The NHS seems to be getting all the blame when a good proportion of the problem is down to local government.

MarshaBradyo · 02/01/2023 08:57

I’d concentrate on social care too and overall population health.

With those two the NHS could be ok. On one hand I would miss it if it disappeared (not that I use it that much atm) but I appreciate the idea, oth meeting quite an unhealthy population’s healthcare needs in such an encompassing way does feel like it’s getting more onerous.

SleeplessInEngland · 02/01/2023 08:52

Let’s see if/when Labour wins the next election. Maybe having a government that doesn’t ideologically hate the nhs will help somewhat. Probably can’t hurt.

LakieLady · 02/01/2023 08:51

Adviceneeded200 · 01/01/2023 21:46

I've a mate who has had a private operation cancelled for lack of a bed and is struggling for a new date. I wonder if NHS have taken over more of the private provision?

My local trust is using a Nuffield private hospital for some elective surgery. They started doing it in the noughties, when Blair's government was prepared to spend to reduce waiting lists.

I had a partial knee replacement on the NHS done in the Nuffield just over a year ago, and a nurse told me that it was 50% NHS patients in there at the time.

lovemelovemesaythatyouloveme · 02/01/2023 08:41

I think the main problem is social care.
We need more...

  • NH beds
  • Rehab/Intermediate care/ step down units in nursing homes
  • care in the community
  • Senior and entry level care staff in both NHs and the community (seniors can do meds/further education)
  • Mental health provision

That way, the people who don't need to be in hospital beds, wouldn't be there and nursing staff would have more time/ resources to look after people who really needed it.

Grumpybutfunny · 02/01/2023 08:12

greenteafiend · 02/01/2023 07:49

I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement."

How on earth would you enforce this, especially in a world where people don't always live near elderly parents?

In cultures where there is a strong social pressure to look after your parents in old age, women are increasingly going on marriage strike because they don't want the burden of aging inlaws.

You make it a law punishable by the costs being removed at source from your pay. No doubt countless private care companies will pop up claiming a top up off the family on top of the funded hours so DS doesn't have to look after DM or DDad which in turn will make it a better paid more attractive job.

greenteafiend · 02/01/2023 07:49

I come from a culture were the young are responsible for the elders which I think should become a legal requirement."

How on earth would you enforce this, especially in a world where people don't always live near elderly parents?

In cultures where there is a strong social pressure to look after your parents in old age, women are increasingly going on marriage strike because they don't want the burden of aging inlaws.

connie26 · 02/01/2023 07:31

I spent a night on the corridor of A&E recently. The care from the doctors and nurses was amazing but it was obvious just how stretched they were.
Behind me was a bloke who'd been drinking a litre of vodka a day, to the side was someone who'd overdosed on cocaine and in front of me was a drunk who's girlfriend had ended their relationship and he'd no where to stay.
Society is breaking down and the NHS takes the hit massively. Think of all the stabbings, injuries from fights and many accidents caused by dangerous drivers. This puts huge pressures on the NHS.
Having worked in the NHS most of my 30 years working life, I have also seen mismanagement, wasted money and staff taking the piss in my field of work.
I can only think that eventually it will become like the US and people will need to have health insurance with a core service for those who cannot afford.

Swipe left for the next trending thread