Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask how long the NHS has left?

207 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 01/01/2023 20:41

Genuinely now have the mindset that's it's not 'will' the NHS go under but 'when'. I'm not in the NHS though so I guess I'm asking 2 questions here....

  1. YABU the NHS will survive somehow or YANBU the NHS is going to go 100%
  1. If IANBU when? How much longer do you think we have?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fliptopbin · 06/02/2024 17:13

Zombie thread alert!

MorrisZapp · 06/02/2024 16:31

This pish again. The NHS has been 'on the brink of collapse' since I've been on MN, and my son is a teenager now. It's under huge pressure and there are many patients being let down but broadly, hospitals are still open and fully functioning. My mum had a superlative experience when she needed emergency gall bladder surgery two months ago. I'm so sorry others haven't had that experience but the NHS will not close this year or next, what nonsense.

Muddle200 · 06/02/2024 16:24

All political EVEN WITH Labour it will take 10 years

irene90 · 08/01/2023 18:18

It will last as long as the people are willing to have a 3rd world country healthcare system.

for me it was already not fit for purpose 10 years ago , so I hope it officially goes asap . It’s scary not having medical care .

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/01/2023 09:04

t's because too many people are using it, and not enough people are contributing. I can see the NHS becoming a very basic service, closing down non life threatening departments. E.g. cosmetic surgery, allergies and skin complaints. If people want access to better health care, then they'll buy insurance and see a private consultant

Do you have allergies or skin complaints? I have both. One of my allergies is dangerous. I also have bad skin complaints. What about quality of life?

fajitaaaa · 04/01/2023 07:39

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/01/2023 07:39

Allergies can be life threatening. No-one gets cosmetic surgery on the NHS with the exception or reconstruction after trauma or surgery.

Skin complaints can also be life destroying

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 04/01/2023 07:39

Beautiful3 · 03/01/2023 22:20

It's because too many people are using it, and not enough people are contributing. I can see the NHS becoming a very basic service, closing down non life threatening departments. E.g. cosmetic surgery, allergies and skin complaints. If people want access to better health care, then they'll buy insurance and see a private consultant.

Allergies can be life threatening. No-one gets cosmetic surgery on the NHS with the exception or reconstruction after trauma or surgery.

HRTQueen · 04/01/2023 00:26

its not going to suddenly collapse

money will be thrown at it and it will improve for a bit then once again we shall have this discussion in a few years time

we need to move over to systems like France and Germany many will be paying much more but the NHS simply can not provide the service we deserve and should expect in a country as wealthy as the UK

but it’s not a vote winner for parties to dismantle the NHS so they won’t

swg1 · 04/01/2023 00:16

Grumpybutfunny · 02/01/2023 10:47

But it's not really fair to ask everyone else or the next generation to pay for it either. It's a catch 22 as someone is going to have to pay to increase socialcare as even if you privatise the NHS the companies aren't then going to tolerate bed blocking like the NHS does.

If you say increase tax by X percentage which cost the average person say 2k a year (likely to need to be much higher). Over a 50 year working life that's 100k at least as higher earners will once again be hit harder.

Now say you go down the family funding it, social care is usually a maximum of four visits a day. Say they cost £15 per visit, granny is moved near us so we do a morning visit to get her up at 6am before work (wifey as the husband is not a morning person I'm up at the crack of dawn).

We pay someone to come in at lunch time £15, husband can call in on his way home to make sure she okay then one of us can pop round at bed time to put her to bed. Cleaning is what an hour a week so can add that to our cleaners bill or do it on a weekend and the laundry can join my pile which is apply for its own postcode. She better have enough clothes as I wash once a week and it all goes through the dryer!

So say £15 a day x 7 that's £105 a week or £5460 a year some of which will be funded from their private pensions so we will say that includes cover for holidays etc. We could also make it tax free like childcare which makes it £4364 a year by the time my gran needed more than shopping picking up or the high dusting doing she lived a future two years so by having a busy few years we have saved 90k but most importantly we have done it which made her feel more comfortable which to me is priceless.

Your first problem is moving granny near you.

OK, how? How do you finance this? I'm in the North East, we have enormous brain drain of younger folks to more expensive parts of the country. Granny might well have a council house or she might have a house but that house might fetch £80000 - no, I am not missing a zero. How do you afford her moving somewhere more expensive.

Then there's the assumption younger folks are healthier. My nan had two daughters. She's 96. My mum died several years ago from cancer. My aunt is nearly seventy and a pensioner herself, struggling with arthritis. So, there's me - but I'm a widow with two kids and severe medical issues who has required overnight hospitalisation myself half a dozen times in 2022. Can I check on Nan? No, for a large percentage of that I wasn't even legal to drive.

Blossomtoes · 03/01/2023 23:51

KateofGhent · 03/01/2023 23:45

Do you think it could be possible that cottage hospitals will be brought back? I think they started closing in the 80's, but with older people staying in hospitals for longer as care packages at home are like gold dust now, maybe they could be re-introduced for slow recovery wards? Considering millions were spent on the Nightingale hospitals to accommodate Covid 19 and they were not used.

It would be the sensible thing to do. We never had the annual winter pressures fiasco before they were closed. It really annoys me that just about every measure that alleviated the impact of an ageing population on the NHS was removed just as the biggest generation started to reach old age. It’s the most ridiculously short sighted thing imaginable.

KateofGhent · 03/01/2023 23:45

Do you think it could be possible that cottage hospitals will be brought back? I think they started closing in the 80's, but with older people staying in hospitals for longer as care packages at home are like gold dust now, maybe they could be re-introduced for slow recovery wards? Considering millions were spent on the Nightingale hospitals to accommodate Covid 19 and they were not used.

justasking111 · 03/01/2023 22:53

Blossomtoes · 03/01/2023 22:42

That's nothing new here in Wales, our health board has been farming out orthopaedic surgery for years. Ditto cataract surgery. Orthopedic to Wrexham, cataracts to Cheshire. The shadow health secretary says 40k operations a year. I suspect that's a drop in the ocean.

I believe a new private hospital is being built in Manchester.

The fly in the ointment is that complications from surgery at our private hospital means that you are transferred to the NHS pretty damned quick

Blossomtoes · 03/01/2023 22:42

justasking111 · 03/01/2023 16:07

There's a deafening silence from labour, SNP too. They all know it's unsustainable

Labour is pretty clear what it will do.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/wes-streeting-vows-cut-nhs-28758138

justasking111 · 03/01/2023 22:30

Beautiful3 · 03/01/2023 22:20

It's because too many people are using it, and not enough people are contributing. I can see the NHS becoming a very basic service, closing down non life threatening departments. E.g. cosmetic surgery, allergies and skin complaints. If people want access to better health care, then they'll buy insurance and see a private consultant.

That's very possible. The list of cosmetic procedures are growing. A friend paid for her very bad varicose veins recently. I have scoliosis, pay for my own treatment as and when needed. Waiting list for physio at least six months

yaflouloci · 03/01/2023 22:29

I listened to a radio phone in today and a senior A&E nurse contributed saying that the NHS is also a victim of its own success. So many new treatments attracting many more patients, I'd simply not even considered that.

IAmTheWalrus80 · 03/01/2023 22:27

The NHS costs over £2 billion a week to run (and that’s in its current diabolical state). A few extra million is absolutely nothing.

yaflouloci · 03/01/2023 22:26

When people talk about it surviving what do they actually mean? What will happen otherwise?

IAmTheWalrus80 · 03/01/2023 22:25

I find it infuriating when people cling blindly to the NHS in the belief that the only two ways of funding healthcare are a) the NHS or b) the US system. People are dying unnecessarily at the hands of our health service and you can’t even be arsed to read about different models of healthcare funding.

Beautiful3 · 03/01/2023 22:20

It's because too many people are using it, and not enough people are contributing. I can see the NHS becoming a very basic service, closing down non life threatening departments. E.g. cosmetic surgery, allergies and skin complaints. If people want access to better health care, then they'll buy insurance and see a private consultant.

3luckystars · 03/01/2023 21:55

‘They pay a lot into the system and would normally happily pay more for universal healthcare for everyone.’

do you mind me asking how much?
Is it from your income tax?

In Ireland we pay huge taxes too but we don’t know where it goes.

justasking111 · 03/01/2023 21:48

Zonder · 03/01/2023 21:41

If we chuck more money at the NHS it going to have to come from borrowing

@Grumpybutfunny. It could come from clawing back the millions given to mates for non existent PPA and huge tax breaks for a start.

I'd settle for the £122 million our health board has mislaid in the last financial year

Zonder · 03/01/2023 21:41

If we chuck more money at the NHS it going to have to come from borrowing

@Grumpybutfunny. It could come from clawing back the millions given to mates for non existent PPA and huge tax breaks for a start.

phobiaofsocialmedia · 03/01/2023 21:38

3luckystars · 03/01/2023 19:43

How can people with a lot of disposable income be charged absolutely nothing for medical care. It doesn’t add up.
It must feel like taking a right away to remove it now though? I don’t know how you are all going to navigate this.

in Ireland going to the GP is a service like the hairdresser or mechanic, you just pay the doctor.
this pays for his admin staff and nurses etc.
If you are poor or elderly or vulnerable, you get it free but everyone else pays for the service.

i went to visit my sister in the uk who got an infection, went to the gp for free and got the medicine free. I was totally dumbfounded at this, she can afford to pay.
I would have paid €60 to see the doctor and €10 for the medicine at home and yet this is all free in the UK. Except it’s not.

Someone is paying and it’s the staff.

How can people with a lot of disposable income be charged absolutely nothing for medical care. It doesn’t add up.

They pay a lot into the system and would normally happily pay more for universal healthcare for everyone. Hmm

JanuaryBluehoo · 03/01/2023 19:45

It's under now surly

3luckystars · 03/01/2023 19:43

How can people with a lot of disposable income be charged absolutely nothing for medical care. It doesn’t add up.
It must feel like taking a right away to remove it now though? I don’t know how you are all going to navigate this.

in Ireland going to the GP is a service like the hairdresser or mechanic, you just pay the doctor.
this pays for his admin staff and nurses etc.
If you are poor or elderly or vulnerable, you get it free but everyone else pays for the service.

i went to visit my sister in the uk who got an infection, went to the gp for free and got the medicine free. I was totally dumbfounded at this, she can afford to pay.
I would have paid €60 to see the doctor and €10 for the medicine at home and yet this is all free in the UK. Except it’s not.

Someone is paying and it’s the staff.