Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To try to remain the same size throughout life?

62 replies

JollieJullie · 01/01/2023 19:33

I used to be a size 8 from puberty until a couple of years ago. Now I am in my early-mid 30s and I am a size 10, but I am trying to go back to an 8.

However, I wonder if my efforts are pointless as maybe my body is maybe just not meant to stay the same size as I get older?

Do you think it is reasonable to remain roughly the same size throughout life? Or should we accept the fact that later in life we will get a bit softer?

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 01/01/2023 19:46

I've changed my mind about this over the course of my life. Ever since I left my mother's household, I have steadily put on weight. She used to reassure me that some people do just get heavier over time.

As part of the zoe health project I wore a continuous blood glucose monitor this year and saw in real time how bad my body's response to auger is these days. I've been low carbing (as many green veg as I can swallow with good quality meat and fats to make them taste good) and feel well on it.

Blood sugar is now stable and I have been (very very) slowly shedding the weight. I am now confident that in another six months or so I will be back to my teen age weight. I feel more energetic and am much more inclined to be active than I have for ages.

So many of the lifestyle related illnesses are directly linked to obesity that I think this is an important step to ensure that I continue to have a good quailing of life as I age.

I spent a week at a multi sport centre in September where it was very unusual to see anyone even slightly overweight. It was noticeably different to what I see out and about in the UK.

eurochick · 01/01/2023 19:46

It can be hard work to stay the same size throughout life as many people get less active as they get older and at the same time their calorie requirements reduce. I stayed within half a stone of 9 and a half stone from about 20 to mid-40s. Now I'm perimenopausal my weight is creeping up and it is a lot of effort to stay within a healthy bmi (I am managing it so far but it is hard work). I'm working at it because it is healthier to maintain a steady healthy weight though life if you can.

AllOfThemWitches · 01/01/2023 19:46

I'm a size 8, I don't overeat, I do exercise and I still feel fat. I think you're right though, I'd have to eat way too little to lose weight!

Newusernameaug · 01/01/2023 19:45

i do think it’s possible for most people to stay approx the same size, maybe 1 size / 1 stone more but any more than that isn’t going to be healthy or good generally.

I’m 42 and slimmer now than I was in my 30’s and about the same as my teenage years.

Jourdain11 · 01/01/2023 19:45

MolesOnPoles · 01/01/2023 19:40

I’m late 30s and exactly the same size I was at 20 (when not pregnant).

I kid myself that it’s diet and exercise, but I suspect there’s a dose of luck there too.

I don’t know if menopause might clobber me? But in general I don’t seem to have weight ‘creep up’.

Same here - mid-30s. In my case I think it's just luck and genetics, plus not having any taste for biscuits, crisps etc.

Cherryblossoms85 · 01/01/2023 19:44

You dont have to change size. It's usually. Change of lifestyle and eventually menopause but I know some super fit skinny 50s. I'm thinner than before kids and I'm 45. Must admit it does get harder though, you have to want it quite a lot.

BackBeatTheWord · 01/01/2023 19:44

Most people's bodies tend to naturally exist within a certain range of weights (set point range). What this range is varies massively between individuals. If you eat a balanced diet (including all the food groups and some deserts etc) and lead even a moderately active life you should be able to listen to your hunger cues and remain within your set point range. Trying to reduce your weight below that range will cause problems (increase chance of dementia and osteoperosis, fertility issues etc) and will also often lead to weight gain long term as your body responds by increasing hunger cues and you tend to overshoot your original weight. If you have a genetic predisposition it can also lead to an eating disorder.

For that reason aiming for a particular weight or size isn't helpful and is pointless (will your life really be particularly different at a size 8 than 10). Aim to live a healthy lifestyle and accept the weight that puts your body at. If this is challenging aim to combat the negative thought patterns that lead you to have a disordered attitude to weight.

thunderstruckk · 01/01/2023 19:43

Maybe if you're basing it on measurements / weight or something similar, but they've shown clothes sizes changing over the years so I wouldn't pick an arbitrary clothing size over measurements. I am similar measurements to post puberty, but obviously bigger than pre puberty! I have stayed the same height the whole time which helps too I think.

MolesOnPoles · 01/01/2023 19:40

I’m late 30s and exactly the same size I was at 20 (when not pregnant).

I kid myself that it’s diet and exercise, but I suspect there’s a dose of luck there too.

I don’t know if menopause might clobber me? But in general I don’t seem to have weight ‘creep up’.

something2say · 01/01/2023 19:40

I was a size 10 for over 25 years. I'm 12 now, but that's changing back.

Stay slim OP. It helps with health. What changes is your body's ability to metabolise everything you eat and we need less calories as we age. That might be why you're seeing the 10 from the 8.

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 01/01/2023 19:39

Everyone's different I was always a size 10/12 hit 28 and been a size 6/8 ever since.

Zippedydoo123 · 01/01/2023 19:35

Everybody is different. I was a size 10 at 20 then crept up to size 14 from age 30.

Am now 59 and still size 14 with a post menopause belly.lol.