Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I'd gone into nursing instead of teaching

63 replies

Cantbebothered31 · 01/01/2023 19:05

I did a languages degree then a PGCE. Full-time teaching is absolutely not for me, the ridiculous workload, horrendous behaviour and constant fear of Ofsted to name a few. I'd be happy to do it otherwise but not prepared to work 7 days per week.
I am doing language tutoring part-time, which pays about £15 an hour. I do enjoy it but it's only part-time and not paid during holidays so it's not stable. I also do some supply teaching, but again it's not stable.
The rest of the time I do care work, for £10 an hour. I do enjoy it, but of course it's very poorly paid for hard work.
People don't really understand why I do this when I have qualifications, and I do see what they mean. However it's incredibly rewarding, I love caring for people and helping them, it's a very important role and it's a shame society doesn't value it.
I'm completing an NVQ to become a Senior carer so that's a start, however I keep wishing I'd gone into nursing instead. I'd be on a much better salary, I know nurses have been striking but I'm only on 22-23k. I'm in my early 30s and feel like I need to progress in life.
Would you recommend going into nursing? Or even becoming a nursing associate?
I can't afford to take on any more student debt nor to go without a full time income so I feel a bit limited.
Not sure if there are fast track schemes, what would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
NotRainingToday · 01/01/2023 22:12

endofthelinefinally · 01/01/2023 19:17

Consider going into research with pharmaceutical company. You would be an ideal candidate.

Except that the OP has literally none of the qualifications for what you suggest

Lapland123 · 01/01/2023 22:10

I second OT, a few posters have mentioned.
(I’m not an OT, but that’s what I would pick now if I was going into healthcare)

Silvercatowner · 01/01/2023 22:07

Do some supply in a SEN school. I bet you'd love it.

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 01/01/2023 21:58

Just to add that although speech and language therapy is often suggested on threads like this, it's highly competitive to get onto and is normally via an accelerated (ie relentless) 2 year taught MSc for graduates, or involves starting again with the undergraduate degree, so it is not a free, easy or low stress option. Once qualified it's paid on the same AFC scale as nurses in the NHS, although many now choose to work privately. As everywhere in the NHS there's a shortage in the profession at the moment so I wouldn't discourage anyone from applying, but it wouldn't be quick or cheap. As you're already a qualified teacher it would be worth looking at SEN teaching (or even SALT assistant jobs in the NHS) if you 're interested in working in that area but can't afford to retrain.

countdowntonap · 01/01/2023 21:30

There is a HUGE demand for MFL teachers. Give it a try

countdowntonap · 01/01/2023 21:29

Move schools! There’s no need to be working 7 days a week. I’m bottom of the SLT scale on £61343 and refuse to work a weekend - not even open an email. Granted, I stay until 4.30pm on a Friday but then that IS IT. Any emails have to wait until Monday morning. I work two days in the holiday - internal results day and student results day.
We’re not paid CEO salary, so refuse to work CEO hours. A different school that values its staff is most likely the change you need.

timetogetlost · 01/01/2023 21:20

I would also suggest SEN teaching or Speech and Language Therapy with your qualifications, though the latter might cost to train. You should be able to swap straight into SEN and it sounds like you would find that much more rewarding, same pay.

Resembleflower · 01/01/2023 21:10

Honestly I don’t recommend nursing, I said that as a qualified nurse of 20yrs. Workload is horrendous, it’s incredibly stressful. Add in unsocial hours. Paying for your pin (licence), you have on going training and will become very skilled for very little pay. That’s just a small part of nursing.

Cantbebothered31 · 01/01/2023 21:03

Thanks everyone, this has really given me food for thought. I knew it would be stressful but thought it would be in a different kind of way. I really need to think about it..
I did have an interview for the Civil Service border force and I've been put onto the reserve list until December 2023.. I'll keep trying.

OP posts:
x2boys · 01/01/2023 20:47

I was a nurse,my sister was a teacher ,both are incredibly stressful jobs wouldn't recommend either tbh.

Isahlo · 01/01/2023 20:47

I went from teaching, to being a HCA (I earned more money as a HCA working shifts with enhancements, than on MPS 3. I was also a senior HCA, and then assistant practitioner very quickly due to having a masters level qual.) then onto occupational therapy/OT. Best choice I could’ve made.

OT is everything about teaching (I was a SEN Specialist) and HCA I loved 🥰

Namechxnge · 01/01/2023 20:30

I left teaching and joined the civil service, I would never go back.

Look for executive and high executive officer roles. Either policy or project support roles are an easyish way to get it!

Marshmellow123 · 01/01/2023 20:30

I'm also a nurse, and if I was go back in time I would have studied something else. It is incredibly stressful and pay is so poor. My hourly pay rate is very close to yours and i am working as a practice nurse. Its very difficult to get hours that work around bringing up a family. I have been qualified for 10 years now and worked in different areas. Working in a ward in a hospital is another level of stress physically and emotionally.

OneWildNightWithJBJ · 01/01/2023 20:26

Have you considered teaching in an SEN school? I work with physically and neurologically impaired children. Although we have carers in class, there is still a fair bit of care I do as a teacher. Certainly not much of the behavioural issues you get in mainstream.

I’ve never thought about becoming a nurse and would imagine it’s highly stressful. As said above, you still have the paperwork and the alternative to Ofsted. Having said that, as a pp said, I do think people should follow their dreams as far as possible. If you feel nursing is what you want to do, then go for it.

sapphiremoonlight · 01/01/2023 20:09

I disagree with most of the comments. If nursing is what you want to do then go ahead & train to be a nurse. I wouldn’t bother doing senior caring- just apply to nurse degree course instead. For goodness sake though don’t do it for the money !! For the job the money is poor. Quite literally peoples lives are in your hands. Not everyone can cope with the stress & responsibility that comes with that. If you can then it can be a truly be a worthwhile & rewarding career. Good luck with whatever you decide.

MatildaTheCat · 01/01/2023 19:57

I know someone who made a similar change and did the two year course. She’s been qualified less than five years and now just got a band 7 research post. Quite a specialised field.

Another is starting out on a post grad mental health nursing course. Loves it. But I don’t know if avoiding debt is possible. Can you get translation work? Might be flexible around your other work.

willstarttomorrow · 01/01/2023 19:55

I trained as a nurse many years ago- stayed until a band f in old money so only a few years. I then retrained as a social worker and have been in child protection ever since. Nursing and teaching are very different things, both are stressful, however academically- whilst nurses are professionals, teaching is demanding in very different ways. I totally expect lots of nurses to jump on this post but the intellectual demands as a social worker and the autonomy as a professional is very different, the same with teaching. I worked as an CP social worker in a hospital for a while and it was like being back in the 1970s- the accepted hierarchy is bloody astounding. There is also a huge difference in personal accountability- and autonomy. Grass is always greener etc......

Sliversands · 01/01/2023 19:50

If you already have a degree you can apply to do a fast track degree in nursing which only takes 2 years. However, not sure it will be the less stressful career you are hoping for.

User20232023 · 01/01/2023 19:49

P.s. if you do decide to re-train then there is the PGDip in nursing. Post grad and only 2 years.

User20232023 · 01/01/2023 19:47

Name change for this. I trained as a nurse before quitting after a year and doing a PGCE. I found it gruelling. I worked in London- all 12 hour shifts but often 13 by the time you've handed over and left. It drained me emotionally, burned me out physically and left me a little bit broken. Pay was poor, hours long, patients often rude and sometimes consultants too. The responsibility was too much too. I would never switch off when my shift finished because I would be thinking about drug charts and doses and double checking myself all the time. It is an incredible vocation but one I couldn't do and I certainly wouldn't go into it thinking it is less pressured. I feel much less pressured as a teacher (and that is saying something!).

Hangupsrus · 01/01/2023 19:47

Having been a nurse and carer, I think you would find nursing a different ball game from caring. It's a high pressured job and you still have lots and lots of paper work and targets, with various agencies breathing down your neck. When you are a carer it's very hard work granted, but ultimately the responsibilities of running the ward etc, fall onto the nurses shoulders, and they have a pin to protect too. I've seen several nurses dragged through the courts by the NMC for various misdemeanors, often unintended, and that must be incredibly stressful. It's not exactly well paid and it's long/unsociable hours. Hence I'm no longer a nurse and never will be again. I wouldn't jump from the fat into the fire personally.

Phos · 01/01/2023 19:46

I left languages teaching after a couple of horrendous years. I realised I could earn more money and not spend my days trying to teach rude, badly behaved kids Spanish or German they had no interest in learning. I went into finance though. I don't blame you for wanting to get out but nursing is brutal. You might not face the same behaviour problems but you will face difficult patients, difficult relatives of patients, high workload and constant fear of litigation if you put a foot wrong.

eloquentsilence · 01/01/2023 19:45

How about speech and language therapy? Or occupational therapy as a PP suggested.

Shiningstarr · 01/01/2023 19:43

Definitely don't do it. It's really tough. And shite. On our ward the nurses never go on time, they are really stressed and rarely take their breaks doing 12.5 hour shifts. The workload is immense, with too many patients to nurses.

If the night staff don't turn up for whatever reason, they have to stay, even if they have childcare to get home for, or other reasons.

Many of the nurses I work with say if they could go back they would not have gone into nursing.

pompomdaisy · 01/01/2023 19:41

You want to swap one over monitored public service job for another? I'm both. Qualified nurse but am also a qualified teacher. Believe you me the grass is not greener.