Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I'd gone into nursing instead of teaching

63 replies

Cantbebothered31 · 01/01/2023 19:05

I did a languages degree then a PGCE. Full-time teaching is absolutely not for me, the ridiculous workload, horrendous behaviour and constant fear of Ofsted to name a few. I'd be happy to do it otherwise but not prepared to work 7 days per week.
I am doing language tutoring part-time, which pays about £15 an hour. I do enjoy it but it's only part-time and not paid during holidays so it's not stable. I also do some supply teaching, but again it's not stable.
The rest of the time I do care work, for £10 an hour. I do enjoy it, but of course it's very poorly paid for hard work.
People don't really understand why I do this when I have qualifications, and I do see what they mean. However it's incredibly rewarding, I love caring for people and helping them, it's a very important role and it's a shame society doesn't value it.
I'm completing an NVQ to become a Senior carer so that's a start, however I keep wishing I'd gone into nursing instead. I'd be on a much better salary, I know nurses have been striking but I'm only on 22-23k. I'm in my early 30s and feel like I need to progress in life.
Would you recommend going into nursing? Or even becoming a nursing associate?
I can't afford to take on any more student debt nor to go without a full time income so I feel a bit limited.
Not sure if there are fast track schemes, what would you do in my situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EileenAdler · 02/01/2023 03:40

Depends where you work in nursing. I have colleagues who work 9-5 in various days clinics and get paid £40k. On the other hand if you work on a busy ward with barely enough staff then it’s both stressful and exhausting. I specialised in emergency medicine and work in ICU. Personally I wouldn’t do anything else. But it’s something you really want to do, it’s not just a “job”.

Stompythedinosaur · 02/01/2023 03:22

I think this is a case of "the grass is always greener". Nursing is just as hard as teaching, and less well paid. If you have a chance to change career, I would never choose nursing, there is a reason a huge percentage of newly qualified nurses leave in the first two years.

Fifi00 · 02/01/2023 03:14

Whee · 01/01/2023 23:30

Is it true nurses work 3 long shifts a week, covering 37.5hrs or whatever in that time? That sounds like a benefit over teaching to me, where you work pretty long days anyway (not that long but not way off). Obviously not a reason in itself to switch but something I'm curious about!

It depends on your trust some places do 3 shifts a week 3 weeks then 4 shifts on week 4. Some places give you a longer "break" (you don't get it if busy short staffed) so alternate 3 week 4 week shifts. Some places don't do 12.5 hour shifts it's 7 hours so you have to do 14 hours if you want to double up.

No you don't always get to leave on time , I've had to stay quite a lot as there's not been enough staffing to go and I need to finish notes/incident reports. I've been on shift and no NIC has come to relieve me , Legally.you can't leave a shift until a nurse has replaced you. I do 3 months of nights per year usually one month every 3 months.

mackthepony · 02/01/2023 02:07

Have you considered teaching abroad? Adult Ed? TEFL?

Velda · 02/01/2023 00:32

Nursing isn’t as bad as teaching. At least people agree that they need to be paid more and don’t call them lazy. And they can earn a decent hourly rate through an agency, and don’t have 3 months a year where they can’t work or get paid.

However, nursing isn’t great either. Nurses are still overworked and underpaid, just not as much as teachers are. In your shoes I’d leave the public sector entirely and get a well paid job doing something completely unrelated.

WhatLikeItsHard · 02/01/2023 00:24

Whee · 01/01/2023 23:30

Is it true nurses work 3 long shifts a week, covering 37.5hrs or whatever in that time? That sounds like a benefit over teaching to me, where you work pretty long days anyway (not that long but not way off). Obviously not a reason in itself to switch but something I'm curious about!

Yes, in my hospital ward nurses work 12.5 hour shifts, with two breaks of 30 minutes which are unpaid. So 11.5 hours of paid work per shift. If you are full time, you will need to do 150 hours every four weeks, and usually do 3 long shifts for 3 weeks out of 4, and 4 long shifts for one week out of 4.

It sounds great on paper, but you will also usually be switching between day and night shifts. You could be down to work four night shifts in a row, start Thursday night at 7pm, finish at 7.30am on Monday, and be expected to come back in at 7am on Tuesday for a 12.5 hour day shift. Go home at 7.30pm on Tuesday and then back in at 7pm Wednesday for a night shift.

In my worst job, I got switched between days and nights on an average of 6 times every month. It really fucks your physical and mental health.

I don't work on a ward now and don't work nights. I prefer working slightly shorter shifts of 9 - 11 hours in my current job. I don't know any ward nurses who actually work full time: the most anyone I know does is 34.5 hours, because it means you don't have a week of 4 long shifts. Most people work 30 hours, so 2 shifts one week, 3 the next.

talkingmorenonsense · 02/01/2023 00:24

Whee · 01/01/2023 23:30

Is it true nurses work 3 long shifts a week, covering 37.5hrs or whatever in that time? That sounds like a benefit over teaching to me, where you work pretty long days anyway (not that long but not way off). Obviously not a reason in itself to switch but something I'm curious about!

It all depends on where you work. I used to do 10 hour shifts, so pretty much worked four days a week.

bubblegumunicorn · 01/01/2023 23:35

Have you looked at nursing apprenticeships? Have a chat with your local trust as they may be able to get you trained to band 5 in 18 months you will only have to take a small if any pay cut whilst training too I'm about to do this! Once I graduate in the summer!

Whee · 01/01/2023 23:30

Is it true nurses work 3 long shifts a week, covering 37.5hrs or whatever in that time? That sounds like a benefit over teaching to me, where you work pretty long days anyway (not that long but not way off). Obviously not a reason in itself to switch but something I'm curious about!

WhatLikeItsHard · 01/01/2023 23:21

Also if you enjoy teaching in general, then you could qualify as a nurse with the aim of becoming either a lecturer in nursing at a uni, or a practice development facilitator. I know people who have done this less than 5 years after qualifying.

paintitallover · 01/01/2023 23:12

I've known a couple of nurses who have bounced from education to health, or vice versa. It depends on the actual job and employer, sometimes.

IwillrunIwillfly · 01/01/2023 23:02

I'm a nurse and I love my job. Lots of people have already warned you of the stresses etc so I won't repeat them, but wanted to say if you can move to Scotland to study, it's still free to study nursing here and we still have the bursary. You'd need to be living here the summer before you start to qualify I think but would mean you don't end up with any more student loans etc.

talkingmorenonsense · 01/01/2023 22:57

When I did my nurse training, there was a primary school teacher in my class. She loved being a nurse and ended up working on a healthcare of the elderly ward. She adored the older patients and they loved her. She said it was the very best decision she had ever made.

endofthelinefinally · 01/01/2023 22:55

NotRainingToday · 01/01/2023 22:43

Oh, ok.
I am very senior in research from early discovery to end of phase 1 and nearly everyone I hire has a STEM degree. Maybe by phase 3 it doesn't matter?

Correct. The clinical staff in the hospital do everything. The CRA visits all sites, monitors, supports and checks everything. Especially all the legal and ethical documents. They have to know the protocol inside out and be excellent with people generally. And help with all the invoices and supplies as the clinicians hate that bit.

Fifi00 · 01/01/2023 22:55

As part of my nurse training I did a placement in a SEMH school and there was smaller class sizes. Minimal restraints , it seemed an easier job than mine. I've had my hair pulled out, bites , punched in the chest the works. Nursing isn't easy at all.

FunctionalSkills · 01/01/2023 22:49

I'm old and still have a bit of a view like that - looking at professions that all need retraining. We should have a thread where it's explained about other jobs and more importantly how to transfer into them!

Testina · 01/01/2023 22:45

You trained as a teacher, you’re thinking you’d rather do nursing, and you applied for Border Force.

It’s a little bit like a child’s view of jobs: teacher, nurse, police officer*.

I would step away from “traditional” name jobs for a moment, and look at all the different jobs out there - especially looking beyond public sector. Just seems a bit restrictive to me.

*I know BF isn’t a police officer, but the general impression when seeing your 3 options together

NotRainingToday · 01/01/2023 22:43

endofthelinefinally · 01/01/2023 22:38

I am talking about phase 3 clinical trials. Really interesting job.

Oh, ok.
I am very senior in research from early discovery to end of phase 1 and nearly everyone I hire has a STEM degree. Maybe by phase 3 it doesn't matter?

endofthelinefinally · 01/01/2023 22:38

NotRainingToday · 01/01/2023 22:12

Except that the OP has literally none of the qualifications for what you suggest

I am talking about phase 3 clinical trials. Really interesting job.

Sugargliderwombat · 01/01/2023 22:38

Or languages in a private or primary school?

Sugargliderwombat · 01/01/2023 22:37

How about an SEN school? Or a school in a hospital?

WhatLikeItsHard · 01/01/2023 22:25

Oh and apply for a bank HCA job at a hospital, I earned £17 an hour for a Sunday shift nearly a decade ago.

WhatLikeItsHard · 01/01/2023 22:24

I'm a nurse, and have a love hate relationship with my job, but I do enjoy it overall, and am now in a niche area. I work part time as a band 6 and do agency work as well. I couldn't work 5 standard days a week, and like the flexibility I have now.

The thing I love most about nursing is the job variety: I've worked in a few different areas in the same hospital, and they were all completely different. I've worked on two wards, one of which I HATED, and I would rather quit nursing entirely than ever have to go back to, and the other one I really enjoyed and was sad to leave. That said, all of the jobs I have had have been stressful in one way or another.

Before I trained as a nurse, I was a teaching assistant in a special needs school. I went into nursing with the aim of becoming a school nurse, but then massively changed my mind once I started training.

If your main motivation is money, then I wouldn't look at going into nursing right now. You could always look at it further down the road, when you're in a better financial position.

If I were you, I would look at jobs as a special needs teacher. I used to work as a teaching assistant for a special needs residential school. It would probably involve a lot of challenging behaviour.

Fairislefandango · 01/01/2023 22:19

I've been a languages teacher for 28 years, but was part time for years while my dc were still youngish. I've just gone back full time, age 51. It's very full-on and tiring, but I'm enjoying it. The key is to find a really good school, but it took me a long time to get a job at one! There are basically virtually no behaviour issues
I'd rather pull my own teeth out than be a nurse or a carer though...

endofthelinefinally · 01/01/2023 22:16

NotRainingToday · 01/01/2023 22:12

Except that the OP has literally none of the qualifications for what you suggest

CRA just needs a degree. The best CRA I worked with just had an English degree. She was excellent. The companies train them up. It is mostly software and data capture support, site visits and protocol monitoring.