Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dislike my teenage daughter

808 replies

Iwishitwasdifferent · 01/01/2023 18:23

Shes spoilt, rude and downright unkind to me. She can ruin any occasion with her behaviour and just doesn’t seem to care about me or the rest of her family.

Me, my DH (her dad) and her youngest sister who is 10 suffer as a result of her behaviour everyday and it’s getting to the point where we are all on countdown as to when she will leave home. She’s 17 so if she goes to university it will be in the next year or so.

I can see how this sounds and if I was reading it I would think what an awful thing for a parent to write. Background is she has always been a much loved child and DH and I have provided a loving secure home. DH and I both worked part time so there would always be a parent at home which meant DD always had friends back, was able to do lots of clubs and has an active social life. We have paid for her to attend clubs at school and this year are paying for her to go on a school trip to USA. We are not rich by any means so have explained to DD this will mean cutting back in other areas.

I don’t expect any praise or credit from DD for being a decent parent but I have told her I don’t expect to be treated like shit, which we all are.

Went to the theatre on Boxing Day and DD spent the whole time moaning about something or other, why had we got this train and not another one, why were our seats so crap, why couldn’t we pay £14 for a small coke for her, then moaning about the restaurant after, the food was crap, the service was crap etc etc My other DD and I needed the loo and she even moaned about that “why did we not have control of our bladder” this was our first trip to the loo in about 5 hours!

She insults my appearance asking why I don’t dye my hair, why I wasn’t wearing makeup, criticising my clothes and calling DH a “short man”. She feels it is ok to say all these hurtful things despite having parents who love her and try to do the best for her.

I just dislike her so much and am so concerned that this is who she is and will never change. Her personality is just awful. Friends tell me it’s because she’s a teenager but does this mean all teenagers are cruel?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
141mum · 23/09/2023 18:58

Don’t offer her a choice, she’s 17 not 7. God you poor thing. Cook, if she don’t want it tough, don’t leave lots in fridge so u can just help herself, a few days she will be hungry.

bendmeoverbackwards · 22/01/2023 09:58

@Whycantibetangy thank you for reminding me of the rope, I’ve seen this before. Glad to hear there is light at the end of the tunnel! I’m currently struggling with my autistic nearly 16 year old dd. I made the mistake of allowing her autism to dominate and I made too many excuses for her behaviour. She still needs firm boundaries and we’re trying to put those in place now.

Whycantibetangy · 22/01/2023 09:45

@mubbybeck its so good isnt it. It really helped me reframe things in my mind. Instead of arguing, I breathe and hold the rope, shes 17 now and still thrashing but has calmed down considerably. The boundaries are there, she doesn’t always respect them and we have ongoing battles re laundry, dirty pots, staying out late, college work etc but nothing like the all out war that was yrs 13-15 😭

shes growing up and growing out of it as she finds her place on the world. We too will get through it, with our surviving teenagers rage support group, aka friends with wine 😂

mubbybeck · 22/01/2023 08:21

Whycantibetangy · 21/01/2023 23:41

@Iwishitwasdifferent OP I have been thinking about you and dug out this wonderful piece which every parent should read. It helped me start to understand my teen so much more than I did.

Hold the Rope

Thank you for posting this! I’m having major struggles with my 13 year old son but having read this piece I’m viewing him so differently. I almost can’t wait for him to get out of bed so I can start holding onto his rope instead of my usual let go and throw the end back at him! I’m ready for a new tactic, thank you.

Whycantibetangy · 21/01/2023 23:41

@Iwishitwasdifferent OP I have been thinking about you and dug out this wonderful piece which every parent should read. It helped me start to understand my teen so much more than I did.

Hold the Rope

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 20:10

?

Liorae · 16/01/2023 19:28

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 16:56

Several people noted that the poster had a particularly severe style of parenting, removing just about everything from their child's room. I wondered whether this is a cultural difference?

I bet you did.

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 16:56

Liorae · 16/01/2023 13:16

And if she is?

Several people noted that the poster had a particularly severe style of parenting, removing just about everything from their child's room. I wondered whether this is a cultural difference?

Liorae · 16/01/2023 13:16

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 12:15

Are you American posting on a British website? Behavior rather than behaviour seems to give this away.

And if she is?

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 12:22

It makes a difference if DH supports you too. Mine had a very busy job and was a lazy Dad, because he was tired. Sometimes he could be quite bad-tempered with all of us too. He's much more relaxed now that our children are adults. It wasn't easy and I'm sure our daughter would have been easier if he'd have said things like "don't speak to your mother like that." Our son has been very easy - just a different personality. Friends who have sent children to private school have a much easier time with their behaviour (there are other issues regarding the high expectations of some of the schools, causing burn-out, but that's different). Private schools have a zero tolerance to poor behaviour, which is easy to implement, because class sizes are smaller, the children can be expelled etc.

WhatsForDinner100 · 16/01/2023 12:15

Gottaloveit · 12/01/2023 06:23

After constant battles we removed everything from his room but the mattress and blanket. We'd paid for it so technically it was not his. He had to earn it back, with good behavior, and chores.

Are you American posting on a British website? Behavior rather than behaviour seems to give this away.

NellyBarney · 14/01/2023 21:19

Iwishitwasdifferent · 02/01/2023 20:36

I’ve been reading all the messages. Yes I have wondered if DD is autistic. However, she has always been social, lots of friends, lots of clubs and interests, popular at school and well liked. Doing well with her studies and teachers rave about her. She was chosen to represent her school for a major sporting event. Her friends when they have witnessed her awful behaviour at home are visibly shocked and some have even picked her up on it. I remember taking her and a friend out for a meal and the friend actually telling my dd not to be so rude to me!!

The trip on Boxing Day was to see a show she wanted to see. But as soon as we left the house her obsession with time keeping started up. I have learnt not to give specific times. If I said for example we’re leaving at 9 if we didn’t leave at 9 on the dot then she starts getting angrier and angrier. In the car even though we have plenty of time to drive to the venue she will go on and on and on about being late. We can’t have the radio on as she says it gives her “sensory overload” intact her behaviour just deteriorates and I have wondered if it is because we’re in unfamiliar surroundings and she can’t cope.

In terms of punishment and consequences I have just given one. DD had a huge pile of dirty washing in her room getting bigger and bigger. I’ve been asking her for days to put on a wash to which she screamed (and yes she does scream I’m not over exaggerating) NO GET OUT. So today I gave her one hour to put a wash on with the consequence that she can’t have any friends over unless she does this. She did it!

This sounds so similar to my autistic dd. I love her and we get on pretty well, I genuinely enjoy her company, but only since I realised she has ASD - tweaking my behaviour and becoming more aware of how she ticks made a huge She is Little Miss Perfect in school - the best behaved, polite, popular girl, excelling academically, in music, competitive in sport, loves sleepovers and boarding school life. But all this is 'masking', it's social interaction that is very draining for her, so once she comes home, she just turns from Jekyll into Hyde. When we ask her why she is grumpy and no longer polite, she will simply and honesty reply: 'because you love me unconditionally. I don't need to act here. You can't kick me out. At school, they can expell me. They can give me bad marks. You are my parents.' That's the honesty and logic only ASD can deliver 😀What we found helps is 1. Accepting that her 'resting face' is a sort of annoyed/angry/despising look, but that doesn't mean she actually feels like that. She can look like that and feel happy/grateful/neutral etc. Her actual mood/thoughts can be totally different from her facial and body language.

  1. Making a plan beforehand. Asking her to tidy up now won't work. Making a plan that her room gets tidied every Saturday afternoon works better. Or agreeing a meal plan. My dd is happy to cook her own meal as long as she can decide/stick to something she likes. 3. Allowing her a lot of agency, but being clear about consequences. Since early primary school, I never got involved with school work, music practice etc. Her responsibility, her consequences if she misses something. 4. Not droning on about her behaviour. My dd will find it extremely irritating if I tell her how her behaviour hurts me/her brother. Taking myself away from her or not doing something for/with her or stopping an outing will work better. There need to be consequences, but no crying, complaining, begging her to be nice. The more emotions I have/show, the more she will get irritated 5. Accept unfiltered honesty. I just have to accept that autism means unfiltered honesty: if you are short, grey etc, an autistic dc will tell you. They don't mean it necessarily in a mean way, it's just factual and obvious to them. I have come to like it, as I also know that when she says something nice to me, it is also 100% true.
My dd little brother is also the kindest, most sensitive soul. They are polar opposites at home, but none of them is better as a person than the other, they are just differently wired. My dd needs loads of space - physically and emotionally. So I tend to only take her out 1:1, not together with her dB if I can avoid it.
Another1bitesTheDust · 14/01/2023 10:47

Your daughter appears to be completely aware as to the fallen, messed up world that she has been brought into- and she’s rebelling. She’s not the first. She’s furious, she’s exasperated and she’s trapped here. She’s smart. The world is a chaotic mess and children see and experience more than we can ever know. Children have senses that adults are completely closed off to. As we age, we tend to believe what we are told in the media- but children aren’t fooled. I think your daughter is smarter and more intuitive than you know and she is rebelling against a system that is completely failing- she knows it, but you are still hanging on. Poor kids of this generation! So many are suiciding! Who the fuck would bring an innocent child into this mess? I applaud her to be honest. She is baffled as to why you brought her into this nightmare. Covid and lockdowns for the last 3 years and now inflation, war, recession, division, poverty, homelessness and then instagram telling her she has to look like Kim Kardashian to bag herself a Man? I hope more kids rebel just like your daughter is! Thank God they can see through all this bullshit and they refuse to participate in it and they are refusing to participate. Tell her you love her and you are proud of her. See what happens….

BellePeppa · 14/01/2023 09:59

yikes88 · 03/01/2023 21:50

For work for example , would her attitude do her any favours ? For uni also...will she make friends and learn to give and take? I doubt it. Time to be cruel to be kind op. Don't expect her not to buck against it, make it difficult , be a moo, strop. But , you did not give into all her strops as a kid, don't do it now. This is just my opinion . You don't have to take it. Just stay strong and take care op.

The thing is she does behave well at school and has friends and behaves well with them. She is able to maintain her executive self but this drops when she comes home.

And actually where I think her parents have provided a loving home environment is that she feels safe enough to " act out" . The reason I think her behaviours have become so entrenched seems to be because the same methods ( removal of certain privileges and at times - when provoked - of love) that the parents have tried have not helped her over the years and there hasn't seemed to be - as yet - that much desire to explore this further or seek expert advice and support for their daughter - and themselves.

With respect to the many posters who think that without escalating punishments, she's going to end up unable to function in the real world - this is a really interesting post by the child psychologist Laura Markham Laura Markham about why punishments don't work in the long run - it's aimed at younger children but the evidence behind it holds true for older children.
www.ahaparenting.com/read/Consequences-Punishment

As she notes at the end - "just because it's a cold, cruel world, I wouldn't make my child sleep without blankets to prepare him. Would you?" And that's the thing, parenting for those under 18 - and I don't get the she's nearly an adult view because "emerging adulthood " is very much occurring from 18- 25 - is not about treating your DC as if they're in employed in the corporate world.... As noted though, she is able to function with friends, at school and at sports....I'm sure with the right support , her daughter's behaviour and the whole family dynamic has every chance of improving.

I suspect, that her DD has completely unintentionally not had her emotional needs sufficiently met and things might now be escalating because of unknown external factors occurring at school or even internal anxieties about friendship issues/ school politics that her parents are as yet unaware of.

Also, in my work over the last 20 years or so, I have had much experience with managing high achieving 18- 25 year olds and interestingly, I've noticed those from textbook tiger parented families - often but not always from Amy Chua type backgrounds - who I suspect were perfectly behaved at home and their parents' friends probably wondered at their impeccable behaviour, have more often than not struggled with perfectionism, anxiety, depression and I'm sorry to say have been at times quite deceitful when things have gone wrong...

Very interesting article. I took the natural consequences approach, usually with a ‘chat’ about the behaviour once the dust had settled. It makes a lot of sense as punishments just cause more resentment and friction.

WoeBeCome · 14/01/2023 09:30

@Coffeeandcake15 thats so reassuring. I wonder what mine will be like when they get older. My primary school child just came and told me that he can tell me anything and that I always sort his worries out. He gets unwanted thoughts in the evening about doing bad things. I hope it lasts but it seems it might not.

There is a booked called the Orchid and the Dandelion which is about the nature/nurture debate regarding children’s sensitivity. It was really interesting if you’re interested. The research shows that some children are naturally more sensitive. Some are less sensitive. However, parenting does make a difference but it makes more of a difference to those children who are naturally more sensitive. Both good and bad parenting.

Coffeeandcake15 · 14/01/2023 09:16

These posts often feel alien to me, this is not a brag but I’ve never experienced any of the problems that many people experience with their teenage children on Mumsnet, I also have friends who have said similar with regards to their teenage children. I don’t know if I’m just lucky, or why I haven’t had the challenges a lot of people have had, is it luck, nature or nurture? I have had minor disagreements with DS who is 17 this year but we’ve never had big arguments and we’ve never raised our voices at each other, he’s never swore at me and doesn’t swear at home, he offers to help at home, he respects boundaries too. I know this sounds like a brag but it’s honestly not, is it mostly down to the nature of the child that influences any difficulties. It would be interesting to read any studies that indicate how the nature of the child plays a role.

Pumperthepumper · 13/01/2023 19:58

Gottaloveit · 12/01/2023 06:23

After constant battles we removed everything from his room but the mattress and blanket. We'd paid for it so technically it was not his. He had to earn it back, with good behavior, and chores.

Thats absolutely grim, and not something to be proud of.

Algor1thm · 13/01/2023 19:51

Gottaloveit · 12/01/2023 06:23

After constant battles we removed everything from his room but the mattress and blanket. We'd paid for it so technically it was not his. He had to earn it back, with good behavior, and chores.

Bloody hell, poor kid 😔

Gottaloveit · 12/01/2023 06:23

After constant battles we removed everything from his room but the mattress and blanket. We'd paid for it so technically it was not his. He had to earn it back, with good behavior, and chores.

NeelyOHara1 · 11/01/2023 18:56

@redskydelight fwiw I've realised I posted on the wrong thread 😳so please cancel your despair at Mumsnet 😬

mandlerparr · 09/01/2023 18:23

Tough love, maybe. But some therapy also, maybe? your youngest has spent most of her life as a child of divorce, after all. And possibly with less family income than her siblings for many of those years. And how many people besides dad have moved out? We don't always realize it, but younger siblings, especially if there is a large age gap, feel a lot of loss when older siblings leave the home.

Laststraw1 · 09/01/2023 15:07

My daughter 17 is similar. We barely speak with her now and we have separate dinners - kids and adults eat separately as she causes such arguments over nothing, or says something unkind that it ruins the dinner. Or she will sit all moody and not speak and it’s like having a black cloud sitting with us (son 15 comment).

She told us she will tell us what she is getting for her 18th as it’s her 18th! Nope she will get what we want to give her and the same as we have her older brother and not a penny more. (Or at all at this rate).

We are also on count down to uni!

WhatsForDinner100 · 08/01/2023 09:54

Continued from previous post:

A friend of mine lost her son in a horrendous car crash, where he was trapped with friends in a burning car. She adored him. I started to try to focus on the good in my daughter afterwards. Our lives became much calmer when I gave us some space. After a while, she wanted to go on walks with me, watch a film occasionally etc. There would still be the occasional flare up, but I tried to take it less personally, even though it hurt. Uni was the best thing, as I posted several messages ago. She used to ring up for a chat between lectures, if she was out shopping etc & we hadn't spoken so much in years. She's now graduated and has gone travelling. Your relationship is for the rest of your lives and needs to be sorted out asap, before it get stuck in a rut.

WhatsForDinner100 · 08/01/2023 09:12

Have a bit of space from each other for a while. Don't get drawn into any arguments, avoid any controversial topics which you know will lead to a flare up. If she wants to stay in her room, let her. Go out for a walk if you need some space. Have a few single portions of food in the freezer so that she can eat separately if she prefers, or else join you. Start to look for positives so that you can see her in a diifferent light.

A friend of min

GWBistired · 08/01/2023 09:11

@RambamThankyouMam do you actually have teenagers?

Swipe left for the next trending thread