Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fining children and expecting other parent to enforce it?

256 replies

SpottyDressingRoom · 01/01/2023 13:51

Ex is angry because dc1 has not been answering exs calls and dc2 is angry with him (ex) and was rude to him on the phone.

I have had serious talk to dc2 about rudeness and would support warning and enforcement of agreed discipline for future repeat, but ex wants to fine him £25, with no warning, to be taken from his Xmas money that dc has already received and I would have to enforce.

Ex also wants to impose the same fine on dc1 for not answering calls and for me to similarly enforce it.

I don't use money fines here. I have explained my consequences which are applied and well understood by the dc, but he has decided that he wants to impose fines, £5 per transgression, enforced by me.

AIBU to object to being made into his enforcer and made to use his consequence framework which I don't use here because I don't think it's fair?

OP posts:
BlackFriday · 01/01/2023 15:52

Why would you back up shorty discipline methods that won't do anything to repaint the shaky relationship he appears to have with his dc?
Maybe he needs to ask himself why his sons don't wish to speak to him often.

andweallsingalong · 01/01/2023 15:51

I think you need to get your ex out of your head and think what you want.

Your house, your rules.

Why is ex calling on your time? If he sees them regularly could your stance be "you don't need to call, you saw them this week, if the boys want to call you in between that's up to them, but I won't be forcing them to".

I struggle with him wanting to punish as it feels controlling to insist on regular calls. More difficult with the other DC as its not clear why he is angry with dad, but punishment for feelings always feels off to me, because of the hard bottling them up can do.

I think you need to decide whether you think your boys did anything wrong before telling them off.

As far as punishment I agree with pp. His punishment, he deals with it. He can't take money given to them by others though, agree with pp if he fines it comes out of the pocket money he gives them otherwise its stealing money given to them for their benefit by others.

Iizzyb · 01/01/2023 15:49

Frankly op dc's age 12 and 16 are old enough to decide whether to speak to their df or not and generally whether to answer their phones.

If they don't want to speak to him, surely that gives a message to him.

If he isn't nice to them why should they answer their phones?

And frankly why are you being his enforcer here?

Stick up for your kids. He sounds a horrid df who deserves to have his calls ignored.

They at least deserve to have one decent parent though. Please be that one x

Theunamedcat · 01/01/2023 15:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Honestly I've met men (a man) like this in real life he also removes all monies given to his children from his family so I don't spend it the children don't see any of it and it doesn't go into savings for them either he takes it and spends it on himself he tells his family I remove it and keep it if they actually saw or even spoke to there grandchildren they would get the truth but that's far too much for them to do

KettrickenSmiled · 01/01/2023 15:45

I was honesty expecting everyone to say I had to back ex up and was bu.

Jesus.
How long have you been split from ex, & what number did he do on you to make you feel you somehow still ought to be dancing to his tune?

As DC1 is now 16, surely he can make up his own mind whether he wants to talk to or even see his dad?

This sounds like a last-ditch attempt at control by ex, because DC1 is pulling away, & DC2 is now responding with rudeness. I'd be keener on establishing the reasons for that rudeness than punishing it. Mainly because your ex is batshit, & I'd believe your sons over his version of reality.

deeperthanallroses · 01/01/2023 15:45

I’m so sad you might have thought we would all say you should be doing this! I’d undermine the hell out of shitty parent it’s like that. I suggest you tell him: ‘I won’t be doing anything so ridiculous. Their Christmas money is theirs to keep (talk to the dc about this and support them to open a bank account ifyou think they need help in resisting handing over their Christmas money to ex for ‘fines’). You call very frequently, I’ve now told them dad will call once every second day on my contact time and they have agreed to try to answer for that frequency of calling, which is still far more than I speak ti them when they are with you. It would help if you discussed suitable times with them; they are people with lives. I’m doing you a huge favour you don’t deserve here, as they are also people rapidly getting closer to adulthood who will soon be able to make their own decisions regarding contact, if you don’t change your approach you won’t like those decisions. No need to thank me, I’m doing it for my children.

Lindy2 · 01/01/2023 15:45

He's your ex. You really don't need to entertain this rubbish.

Your eldest child is 16 and is old enough to decide what, if any, relationship he wants with this man. To be honest, I can fully understand why they choose not to answer the phone to him.

DuchessofSandwich · 01/01/2023 15:44

It's the kids right to have contact with their dad, not the other way around. At their ages, if they don't want it, that's it.

You divorced this man, he shouldn't have any control over your parenting decisions. And please let the kids choose for themselves how much contact they want with their dad, any sane judge will listen to them.

Singleandproud · 01/01/2023 15:42

I reckon he either over extended himself at Christmas or has developed a gambling habit and needs access to money fast. Do not support him, do not remove the children's gifts from them.

Put boundaries in place so the boys talk to him 6pm on Sundays when he doesn't have them if it is normally an EOW arrangement and midweek if he doesn't see them during the week and that's it. The boys need to be able to relax.

The 16 year old can decide to see or speak to your ex and the younger one isn't too far off of that age too.

Topseyt123 · 01/01/2023 15:42

He sounds like an arse and your boys have the measure of him.

Tell him that no, you will not be fining them, that it is a ridiculous idea and that you have no intention of taking instructions from him yourself either.

I can see why he is an ex, but you need to stop letting him continue to control you. At the ages your children are they are beginning to have choices over whether and when they see their dad anyway. Surely.

Also, teenagers rarely answer their phones. I'd be very wealthy now if I had managed to issue mine with a fixed penalty notice every time a phone went unanswered. Not that I would do anything so foolish anyway.

KettrickenSmiled · 01/01/2023 15:41

SpottyDressingRoom · 01/01/2023 14:14

Ok - he calls a lot. I really disagree with any punishment for not answering. Their relationship is rocky in any case.

He has now told dc1 directly that he will be fining him and that I'll be taking his money. Ex expects fined money to be given to him (ex). I'm not sure how to manage this so as not to undermine ex but also not be dragged into his shit 'discipline' methods?

WHAT?

It's no longer your job to cover for your ex's fuckwittery.
You do NOT need to present a united front, when the basic premise is madness.
It is your job to advocate your your kids, not to prop up your ex's insane ideas about punishment.

If the kids are not answering, maybe it's because they really, really don't want to. You said the relationship has been rocky - do NOT force them to comply with a parent who is acting so unreasonably.

He can tell DC1 anything he likes. Doesn't mean YOU need to comply.
In fact, I would be far more concerned with talking to DC1 about how he is feeling about his dad's expectations for frequent phone contact, & finding out what has been making these calls so unpleasant he is actively avoiding them.

You avoid being dragged into ex's shit discipline methods by laughing at them, telling your DC why you disagree & will not be complying, & telling your ex to piss off with his madness.

KillingLoneliness · 01/01/2023 15:40

YANBU I’d be telling the ex to jog on, who on earth “fines” their children!?

biscuiteer · 01/01/2023 15:38

Is he a tory by any chance?

OMG12 · 01/01/2023 15:38

Quite frankly I can see why the kids don’t want to take his calls. He’s a test and trying to control you and the kids. Was he this much of an abusive control freak when you were married. Just tell him it’s not happening. You are not married, he has bo control over what you do and you would like to maintain a good relationship with your children even if he is happy to wreck his. Then just say it won’t be discussed again. If he tries to bring up the point just totally ignore it and talk about something else. There’s a reason he is your ex!

KettrickenSmiled · 01/01/2023 15:36

Ex is a controlling little twat.

AIBU to object to being made into his enforcer and made to use his consequence framework which I don't use here because I don't think it's fair?

Don't even bother objecting.
Answering him in any serious way will make him believe his stupid notion has credibility.
Just don't bother responding. Mute him on comms, so if he wants to have a little tantrum, he's only having an argument with himself. Check in when you can be arsed, & still don't bother responding.

Maybe if he wasn't such a twat, his kids would want to talk to him.

Wetblanket78 · 01/01/2023 15:35

No he's a tw@t tell him he's being ridiculous. What's wrong with an apology? That money was given to him as a gift. Nobody has the right to take it off him.

category12 · 01/01/2023 15:33

Perhaps your ex should work on making his phone calls something the dc look forward to and want to answer!

There's no way I'd be his proxy nor supporting that form of discipline.

Sallyh87 · 01/01/2023 15:32

Does he just want £50?

Can I fine people who are rude to me or don’t answer my calls? I work in HR so trust me, it would be a steady income stream 😂

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 01/01/2023 15:30

Tell him as a consequence of being rude on the phone/ ignoring calls you have removed the children's phones as you think the punishment should meet the crime. Therefore he will have to support you in enforcing this punishment by not contacting the children for X number of days

Daffodilsandtuplips · 01/01/2023 15:30

I can see why he’s your ex and I can see why your sons don’t want to speak to him.
He comes across as a controlling bully. No, don’t ‘fine’ them, he has no right to take their Christmas money.

kingtamponthefurred · 01/01/2023 15:27

Tell him fines are for wimps and you have sewn up the children's mouths with string, so they won't be able to speak to him for the foreseeable future.

Jem57 · 01/01/2023 15:26

Tell him to do one,sounds a wonderful Dad,NOT

Forestwalks · 01/01/2023 15:25

Just seen your eldest is 16! It’s his money and he has every right not to hand over his money.

You need to stick up for your kids here and say that your house your rules.

poor kids.

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 01/01/2023 15:23

OhChristmasTreeOhChristmasTreeFaLaLa · 01/01/2023 15:18

Bizarre punishment, I mean if he wanted to do this and take it out of the pocket money HE gives them well that's on his watch (not something I'd do personally). He can't take money off them that relatives have given them, no. It's effectively stealing christmas money from them, it isn't his money to take. Also what happens when they run out of money, will he just keep furture birthday money too to cover it? If my husband enforced this with me we'd be bankrupt, I'm terrible for leaving my phone on silent or in another room etc.

Can see why he's an ex.

My guess is he will withhold child maintence payments if he makes any

strawberry2017 · 01/01/2023 15:22

Wtf? They are old enough to decide if they want to speak to him and if they don't want to then it's tough.
He can't honestly expect you to take money from them and give it to them.