Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most MIL threads ..

141 replies

Treetrim · 01/01/2023 13:15

Make the MIL look quite normal but the DIL can seem seem odd, unkind , anxious and generally ungrateful.

OP posts:
ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 17:08

@Calphurnia88 ..really?? .. but it's been presented as the height of pettiness? ..

A loving reasonable Grandma spoiling her gc?

Is this the real problem right here?

Perception? ..

namechangeforthisoneeee · 01/01/2023 16:54

user1471505494 · 01/01/2023 13:34

I just hope that all the women who have sons will remember their treatment of their MILs and see what happens to them

Totally agree. I don't like my MIL, she's a nob. I find myself being petty back, sneakily ...but then have to check myself and stop it as I think about my son and how I wouldn't want his wife to treat me like that (even if I was a nob first) 😂

Calphurnia88 · 01/01/2023 16:53

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 13:35

There was where this woman’s mother in law regularly looks after her son. One morning the mother in law takes out the toddler grandson while the poster is having a lie in. When they return, the poster learns a shocking, unfathomable truth about what the grandmother had done to the child while they were out for two hours. If you reading this, please sit down before you continue reading, you will lose your balance and your head will spin at the utter cruelty shown by the grandmother towards her grandchild.

She fed the child a custard tart at a cafe.

Yes you read that right. And some of the other posters were equally as outraged as the poster. May I add that the child had no allergies or any specific reason why a custard tart should be a problem.

Not sure if OP ever recovered from the trauma or if the Mother in law was apprehended by the authorities, or if indeed the child went onto lead the lift of an egg custard tart addict.

I remember this thread.

The grandma had taken the baby out without informing either of the parents, so when mum woke up to find baby missing she was understandably concerned.

The baby was only 7 months old. Considering current guidance is to wean from 6 months, starting with fruit and vegetables, then a custard tart would be a problem for a lot of parents (it certainly would be for me).

HTH 🙃

Ariautec · 01/01/2023 16:52

I blame the men....😆😉

In my experience, anything for an easy life.

Not communicating clearly enough with their wife or mother. Not setting boundaries. IME not something up until the last minute which creates more issues than needed. Not thinking to include their own family and just going along with their wife who often puts her family first.

Two things I've learnt. This is about two adults ( man and wife, initially often young ) both with families, both with traditions, expectations, neither family being wrong, just different. We are expecting two young people to negotiate this with fairness, politeness and maturity.

The other thing I've learnt is - communicate - build open and honest relationships, talk, discuss, compromise, try something new but treat both sides of the family the same.

StephanieSuperpowers · 01/01/2023 16:49

Particularly annoying and in the same vein is “She’s had her turn”. Indeed she has had her turn to be the mother of small children, now it’s her turn to be granny.

And the idea that a granny would not be maternal is very, very strange and I think, a bit unnatural.

PipsBaby · 01/01/2023 16:47

@Flossflower I have known instances of this also, which I think is incredibly sad.

In one case, the MIL messaged her son numerous times claiming that the DIL was continuing to breastfeed purely to punish her and stop her from forming a bond with the child and demand he stand up to her. The child was only 2 months old.

Flossflower · 01/01/2023 16:45

Babys not baby’s. I can’t edit

Blossomtoes · 01/01/2023 16:35

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 16:24

The first sentence is a perfect example of OP’s point.

A grandparent wanting their grandchildren to stay over at their house so they can spoil them in the absence of their parents, is now wait for it….’crazy’. Not sure what kind of childhood most people on MN had. But for most people, the best times they had in their childhood was when staying over at the grandparents. Because your parents raised you and your grandparents spoilt you. That’s what creates normal, balance human beings, if indeed you are lucky enough to have grandparents living near you.

This place is very, very strange.

This. Particularly annoying and in the same vein is “She’s had her turn”. Indeed she has had her turn to be the mother of small children, now it’s her turn to be granny. The relationship between my mum and my son was one of the most loving and beautiful I’ve ever seen, it lasted 40 years until she died. Grandparents can play an incredibly positive role if they’re allowed to.

Flossflower · 01/01/2023 16:34

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 16:24

The first sentence is a perfect example of OP’s point.

A grandparent wanting their grandchildren to stay over at their house so they can spoil them in the absence of their parents, is now wait for it….’crazy’. Not sure what kind of childhood most people on MN had. But for most people, the best times they had in their childhood was when staying over at the grandparents. Because your parents raised you and your grandparents spoilt you. That’s what creates normal, balance human beings, if indeed you are lucky enough to have grandparents living near you.

This place is very, very strange.

I look after my grandchildren overnight all the time but not when they were small baby’s under 3 months.
There have been cases of MILs wanting DILs to stop breastfeeding so they could have their baby children overnight.

Sandinmyknickers · 01/01/2023 16:28

It's not surprising that the relationship is often weird though, because whilst there are some DILs and MILs who get on great and love each other, ultimately it is forcing two new family members together who have potentially different ways of doing things and haven't "chosen" each other, but are now "family ". Plus add in generally "women vs. women", the relationships many mothers have with their "perfect" sons, other internalised misogyny, and the complications of any mother/daughter relationship but without the unconditional love and history....yeah its often going to be weird.... can't see how that's a surprise

scooobie · 01/01/2023 16:28

As someone who has a the MIL from hell, think childhood abuse which resulted in years of therapy for DH. I find it amusing to listen to others moan on about the annoying things theirs do. Which are often decidedly trivial and tbh I find those who will happily accept loads of childcare and then spend ages slagging off their PIL’s (& the way they look after their children) fairly abhorrent.

I know of one family where the 82 year old MIL picks up from school every day but the Mum hasn’t got a good word to say about her. Most of the vitriol is around the way MIL sometimes brings sweets to pick up. They wouldn’t be able to work without her. To use some cliches they don’t know how lucky they are and you don’t know what you’ve got ‘til it’s gone.

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 16:24

Flossflower · 01/01/2023 16:09

Sorry but I think the mil’s Who want their baby grandchildren to stay at their house to play being mummy again are crazy. I also think the ones who stay unwanted for ages at the sons houses are very selfish. I only have daughters but they would soon tell me where to go if I tried this( I have my own life too).
I do think it is a son thing with mothers. My mother in her 90s came out with a whole load of horrible things about my SIL. My SIL is one of the nicest people you could meet and never thinks badly about anyone. She does my mum’s shopping. I think my mum sees her as competition for my brother’s affections. My brother is the golden child

The first sentence is a perfect example of OP’s point.

A grandparent wanting their grandchildren to stay over at their house so they can spoil them in the absence of their parents, is now wait for it….’crazy’. Not sure what kind of childhood most people on MN had. But for most people, the best times they had in their childhood was when staying over at the grandparents. Because your parents raised you and your grandparents spoilt you. That’s what creates normal, balance human beings, if indeed you are lucky enough to have grandparents living near you.

This place is very, very strange.

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 16:19

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 15:37

@UWhatNow . If you think the custard tart scenario is common occurrence then you haven't been on many Dil/mil threads

It’s surprisingly common. A grandparent having the audacity to feed their child anything other than raw broccoli and tap water sets women off in this forum for some reason.

Vallmo47 · 01/01/2023 16:19

I think the MIL/DIL relationship is an exceptionally difficult one and no one comes out looking good on many occasions. I say that as someone who was really close with her MIL before countless fall outs. I busted my butt to make the relationship work because I truly understand it must be hard for both parties. It’s hard having someone come in and step on your toes in a motherly fashion, someone who won’t ever be your mum and really should mind their own business more often. It’s hard being MIL because in many cases the DIL favours their side of the family. I’ve taken a massive step back now because we were getting on each other’s nerves. It’s no one’s fault entirely, people just clash.
Oh and there have been so many threads making MIL’s sound horrible that it’s only fair to admit DIL’s have their flaws too. ;)
One thing I have learned is that it’s very important to let new parents raise their own kids - if you don’t interfere in their decisions it’s easy to get on with each other. Don’t ask heated questions, just follow their lead and parent like you’ve watched them do. Offer support but don’t keep nagging. Then I’m sure the MIL/DIL relationship will be more easily managed.

StrawberryWater · 01/01/2023 16:17

Some do make me scratch my head and I think sometimes people are looking for a fight or making some very inconsequential point their hill to die on.

However many, including myself, have genuine reasons for not wanting a relationship with our MILs (mine is an alcoholic for example and as OH refuses to speak to her then I won’t entertain her either).

PipsBaby · 01/01/2023 16:13

Womencanlift · 01/01/2023 16:05

I am usually on the MIL side too on these threads. A lot of DIL posters seem very precious

These evil, batshit, interfering MILs have done at least one thing right - raised their son well enough that the DIL has fell in love with them enough to marry them/live with them

I know of 3 grown men currently in therapy for trauma caused by their parents. Trauma that came to light when they had their own families and realised the extent of the damage done and now refuse to allow this trauma to trickle down another generation.

People do not fall in love with their spouses because of how their parents raised them. To take credit for an entire persons personality and traits, is ridiculous.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 16:11

Women can lift...this is oft trotted out as an excuse.

The raising of someone doesn't make them into someone.
Not in my view anyways. I love my DH because we share the same values. Those values are completely opposed to pils values.
My DH is naturally opposite to pils and unfortunately when a meanness rears its ugly head that because of his childhood conditioning ( over money).

My own DC are complete beings with their own personality both very different.
I have not done anything to create those personalitys I can only encourage the usual stuff...being kind etc.

Therefore I think this " they raised the dh " is a moot point but perhaps one grapsed by those very mills who believe they own their son's??

Flossflower · 01/01/2023 16:09

Sorry but I think the mil’s Who want their baby grandchildren to stay at their house to play being mummy again are crazy. I also think the ones who stay unwanted for ages at the sons houses are very selfish. I only have daughters but they would soon tell me where to go if I tried this( I have my own life too).
I do think it is a son thing with mothers. My mother in her 90s came out with a whole load of horrible things about my SIL. My SIL is one of the nicest people you could meet and never thinks badly about anyone. She does my mum’s shopping. I think my mum sees her as competition for my brother’s affections. My brother is the golden child

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 16:07

@PipsBaby ..yes of course but I've not read of dils demanding a key for "anytime access" to their pils house or bursting in on mils after gynecology surgery and making demand's on them or demanding fil does X yz .

Or storming into Mils home and telling them where they have gone wrong with decor and cleaning and then rearranging their personal things or reaching into Mils dirty laundry to hand wash her pants.

Etc etc.

Womencanlift · 01/01/2023 16:05

I am usually on the MIL side too on these threads. A lot of DIL posters seem very precious

These evil, batshit, interfering MILs have done at least one thing right - raised their son well enough that the DIL has fell in love with them enough to marry them/live with them

Catsstillrock · 01/01/2023 15:56

occasionally. But mostly it is, as others have said the MIL being disrespectful / interfering / controlling / trying to re-live their own years of mothering rather than considering that they are a grandmother now and should ask and follow their DILs lead not impose their ideas / choices.

i have a son and think hard about what I have learned from my MIL. It’s a long list of ‘DONTS ’:

  • don’t visit too early after the birth, insist on taking newborn out and then stay out too long.
  • don’t try to undermine breastfeeding (or mothers choice of how to feed her baby. If my DIL bottle feeds I’ll back her all the way)
  • don’t buy load and load of clothes for the children, insist they wear them, ignore children’s choices and tell them off for being ungrateful
  • don’t insist on a long visit to you booked before baby is born, then fill that visit with long days out and many hours in the car, and ask constantly why the baby is crying
  • Don’t wake the baby up when your husband tells you to
  • Don’t appear in your DILs bedroom at 5am saying you should take the newborn
  • dont push your DIL to go out for the evening, promise to call if newborn is distressed and then not call when they’re crying really hard.
  • don’t undermine your sons parenting, tell him to hit his children for discipline, tell him his wife is mothering / parenting wrong.
  • don’t tell your granddaughters they can’t play with cars as they’re a toy for boys
  • dont tell your grandsons they must have short hair otherwise people will think they’re a girl.
  • don’t talk a lot about how your grandchildren ‘don’t resemble anyone in the (your) family’. Strangers frequently tell your DIL her children strongly resemble her, it’s just you that has never noticed that. Or is DIL not part of your family, then?
PipsBaby · 01/01/2023 15:52

Also, I know "not all MIL", just as it wouldn't be "all DILs" either. These woman have been brought together not by choice, but by circumstance. Surely it would be ridiculous to assume all would get along. People will always rub eachother up the wrong way, or clash.

PipsBaby · 01/01/2023 15:50

@pictoosh "determined to rule" what exactly? Their own life? Their child's life?

I find this take very strange. And some of the comments on here mention something similar, especially those saying the DIL is insecure, demanding, whiney, controlling... but what exactly are they doing to deserve these descriptions? Aren't they just setting boundaries within their own lives and raising their own family? Much like the MILs did in their own time.

Therefore isn't this thread proving the DILs right? That some MILs have no understanding or respect for the boundaries these woman (and their husbands) are setting for their own families. Which enables friction and resentment.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 15:37

@UWhatNow . If you think the custard tart scenario is common occurrence then you haven't been on many Dil/mil threads

Newyearhappy · 01/01/2023 15:34

Absolutely . I nearly always find myself on the side of the MIL.