Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most MIL threads ..

141 replies

Treetrim · 01/01/2023 13:15

Make the MIL look quite normal but the DIL can seem seem odd, unkind , anxious and generally ungrateful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ladysodor · 25/02/2023 15:24

I’m 60 years old this year. My MIL died last year at the age of 87. After a few early years of misunderstandings we forged a nice relationship. Believe me, most of the stories here (all very petty and childish) will soon be a distant memory. It’s honestly not worth all the effort of keeping a grudge forever.

SerafinasGoose · 25/02/2023 15:19

MiL threads (and wedding ones) draw maximum participation and optimum conflict. It's fairly clear a none-too-small proportion of threads on both these themes are wind-ups.

Just the other day, one MiL thread became so patently ridiculous that not even MNHQ were buying it anymore. The thread was pulled.

PrinceHaz · 25/02/2023 14:26

I don’t agree. Sometimes I get that vibe but very often they only go to the trouble of writing about the problems they have with their MIL because they genuinely do have them.
Key themes are often: cutting child’s hair without mentioning it, nasty comments about their house, looks etc, favouritism of other family members, letting themselves into the house without any notice, staying in the house for long sojourns and son leaving them with his wife while he goes to work.
These things are all unpleasant for a daughter in law and fair enough to get upset about.

Neodymium · 03/01/2023 13:17

Ariautec · 02/01/2023 21:53

But I can say that about my parents. Disinterested. That is the way they are, not because they are the ‘in-laws’ ( they are that too) but just because they want their own life. I think it reflects the lack of role models they had, being brought up themselves by ineffective parents.

My parents went abroad when my first DC was two days old. They came for Christmas dinner when the same child was three weeks old and didn't lift a finger ( me post cesarian). They moved abroad, they didn't keep in regular contact, no normal family events attended. They missed my DC’s christening because ‘the flights were expensive’. They've missed family funerals, supporting me as a single parent, house moves, key celebrations in my DC’s lives.
Now my DC’s are quite indifferent to them, the relationship is lax, contact very infrequent. My parents are back in this country, but often lonely. They don't make an effort for any of us, never invite us anywhere or celebrate with us.

But that is them, as parents and inlaws, not only as inlaws.

It’s sad isn’t it. Some people just aren’t interested. Probably the first to complain too when they are old and no one visits them. It’s a two way street in my opinion. If you don’t have time for children or grandchildren and don’t build a relationship with them, then don’t expect them to care for you when you need it.

dhs dad is if possible worse than mil. He pissed off overseas to live (‘there’s nothing for me here’) and the only contact we have is conspiracy theory crazy crap. He has never shown the slightest interest in our kids and has only met 1 as a baby before he moved.

I tell dh that when department of foreign affairs ring to say he’s died over there I will not be paying to repatriate his remains.

sidesplittinglol · 03/01/2023 12:59

NantsIngonyamaBagithiBaba · 01/01/2023 14:12

Agree.
The majority of MIL threads I read, I think the DIL is the problem and being rather pathetically controlling.

Don't get me started on the ones who blame their hormones for being a twat to their MIL, yet strangely don't have the same feelings towards anyone in their family.

This.

Ariautec · 02/01/2023 21:53

Neodymium · 02/01/2023 20:35

My MIL is completely disinterested in our family. We see her once a year at Xmas. This year, she came Boxing Day with sil and then decided to leave when bil left with him, but didn’t say goodbye or thanks for having me to me. I had no idea she was leaving (I was the host).

She didn’t come to visit me in hospital with any of the children, claiming it was too far (though with middle ds she decided, 3 months before my due date, to book a visit to see a ‘last minute’ trip to see a dying relative, and booked for 2 weeks either side of my due date). Sil had her 2 children in the same hospital and it wasn’t too far for her to visit then.

she never shows any interest in anything my kids do, and when they show her things they have done, she just says ‘yes that’s fine’ no praise or anything.

one day she will be lonely in a nursing home and my kids will not want to visit her as they have no relationship with her.

But I can say that about my parents. Disinterested. That is the way they are, not because they are the ‘in-laws’ ( they are that too) but just because they want their own life. I think it reflects the lack of role models they had, being brought up themselves by ineffective parents.

My parents went abroad when my first DC was two days old. They came for Christmas dinner when the same child was three weeks old and didn't lift a finger ( me post cesarian). They moved abroad, they didn't keep in regular contact, no normal family events attended. They missed my DC’s christening because ‘the flights were expensive’. They've missed family funerals, supporting me as a single parent, house moves, key celebrations in my DC’s lives.
Now my DC’s are quite indifferent to them, the relationship is lax, contact very infrequent. My parents are back in this country, but often lonely. They don't make an effort for any of us, never invite us anywhere or celebrate with us.

But that is them, as parents and inlaws, not only as inlaws.

Neodymium · 02/01/2023 20:35

My MIL is completely disinterested in our family. We see her once a year at Xmas. This year, she came Boxing Day with sil and then decided to leave when bil left with him, but didn’t say goodbye or thanks for having me to me. I had no idea she was leaving (I was the host).

She didn’t come to visit me in hospital with any of the children, claiming it was too far (though with middle ds she decided, 3 months before my due date, to book a visit to see a ‘last minute’ trip to see a dying relative, and booked for 2 weeks either side of my due date). Sil had her 2 children in the same hospital and it wasn’t too far for her to visit then.

she never shows any interest in anything my kids do, and when they show her things they have done, she just says ‘yes that’s fine’ no praise or anything.

one day she will be lonely in a nursing home and my kids will not want to visit her as they have no relationship with her.

Franticbutterfly · 02/01/2023 20:24

Treetrim · 01/01/2023 13:15

Make the MIL look quite normal but the DIL can seem seem odd, unkind , anxious and generally ungrateful.

I bet you have a nice MIL who is lovely to you and your DH, who doesn't put you both down at every turn and didn't cause major damage to your DH's mental health for the first 25 years of his life. I hope that this is case for you, sadly for many, it is not.

I would say that of all the people I have ever known my MIL has said more unkind things to me than anyone else ever has...particularly in my 20's, when I was a vulnerable new Mum, miles away from my own DM/wider family, my DH hadn't yet become the man he is today, and so I always remained extremely polite to her despite her putdowns. Thankfully we don't live nearby to her any longer and I now brush it off and laugh at her snidey comments.

Newgirls · 02/01/2023 11:17

lovelypidgeon · 01/01/2023 20:46

I think in relation to involvement with young grandchildren some MILs do need to remember that there IS a huge difference between their relationship with their DIL and the DIL's relationship with her own mother. The very early days of motherhood can be difficult- recovering from the physical issues of giving birth, getting to grips with breastfeeding, hormonal changes, lack of sleep etc. I think it's perfectly reasonable that a new mother feels more comfortable having her own mother around when she's dealing with these pretty personal changes than she does having someone she personally isn't as close to around. Too often I think people in general forget that the mother of a new baby has her own right to privacy and dignity. Personally I'm really happy that my DC have a strong relationship with all their grandparents and have enjoyed time alone being spoiled by them once they were old enough but when I felt vulnerable etc the only people I wanted around other than for short visits were DH and my own mother. I think a lot of MIL/DIL conflicts would be resolved more easily if MILs (and their friends and family) could see that this is not personal and doesn't mean that there is a competition between the 2 sets of grandparents from day 1.

Very wise

DixonD · 02/01/2023 00:14

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 14:30

Infact this reminds me

There used to be a prolific poster who was strangely drawn to mil threads.

The usual where a mil is driving her son and Dil to divorce through boundary bludgeoning behaviour.
And this poster could never ever see it. . once she admitted she and her mil didn't see eye to eye, but in things like political parties and they " rubbed along". .ergo.. everyone should manage like I have. Being utterly blind to people's actual suffering on a level far worse than opposing voter's??

I remember that poster. If you (have nothing else better to do!) search for old MIL threads this poster is on almost every one. Suddenly disappeared one day, or perhaps name changed.

Boulshired · 01/01/2023 23:49

Enbite · 01/01/2023 23:43

I just can’t believe someone would feed a 7 month old a custard tart!!! Surely even in olden days that wouldn’t have been advisable?! I can’t say I’d be happy to with this either.

I’d imagine it would be the filling and as you can still buy egg custard baby food in a jar the olden days is not that different than now.

Enbite · 01/01/2023 23:43

I just can’t believe someone would feed a 7 month old a custard tart!!! Surely even in olden days that wouldn’t have been advisable?! I can’t say I’d be happy to with this either.

paintitallover · 01/01/2023 23:32

'Hearing yes and no, even when only implied'. That's a great point.

ancientgran · 01/01/2023 23:05

Mine was a nightmare but I did my best to encourage DH to keep in touch with her. I knew it mattered to her but I also worried about how he would feel one day when it was too late to see her. I didn't think that would be good for his mental health so I did my best to rise above it but sometimes it was hard. I did actually lose it with her once and things did improve so maybe I should have done that earlier. It is hard isn't it.

One thing made me sad, when our first baby was born my MIL visited us in hospital, one of the first things she said was don't ever ask me to look after the baby so we never did. When she died we found a photo of her with the baby and on the back she had written how sad she was that she wasn't allowed to have more time with her. I suppose she'd forgotten what she said but what she had written was so pathetic that I felt bad and sad.

Murphs1 · 01/01/2023 22:59

If you have a controlling difficult mil then you can understand some of these threads. Obviously there are difficult mils and there are difficult dils, but if you can’t voice it here, where can you?
Agree though some are just looking for issues with their mils, I read many and laugh and think you should meet mine 😁

Murphs1 · 01/01/2023 22:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 22:39

Stunning creamer I agree.
My mil was absolutely horrible to her mil, DH said he never spent an Xmas with her.
And as an old lady she shunned her from her home and had her for a few hours only.

Karma definitely bit her on the arse. .

All I know is as a mil I will try and be as respectfully as I can be and ask.

Respect my DC lives even if I have to bite my tongue because I'm not the last word,I am not the expert on anything.

And if relationship break down and I genuinely want to repair it I will be reflective and humble. I will genuinely listen.

pictoosh · 01/01/2023 21:58

"Yes and some men have wives who are like that. Remember that MiLs were once DiLs. There is no sudden transformation when your son has children. The same women who can be nightmare MiLs were probably nightmare DiLs. I just don't get why people can't see it can either side that's a nightmare."

I agree.

Calphurnia88 · 01/01/2023 21:58

Treetrim · 01/01/2023 13:15

Make the MIL look quite normal but the DIL can seem seem odd, unkind , anxious and generally ungrateful.

No, I would say the majority of MIL threads make the MIL seem moderately to extremely unreasonable. There is the odd thread where the DIL is clearly in the wrong, but the ratio probably isn't dissimilar to threads about other relations e.g. husbands, or even friends. Obviously we're only hearing one side of the story but you can say the same for any thread on Mumsnet where the OP is complaining about someone or something.

What is interesting in MIL threads are the responses, as they seem to elicit such extremes from both sides. In and amongst the more balanced replies, you have posters who advise OP to go NC no matter how big or small the misdemeanor is (unhelpful), and on the other end of the scale, you have posters who seem to think a slight on one MIL is a slight on all MIL, and will therefore appear to bend over backwards to defend the most bizarre behaviour (also unhelpful). In both instances I suspect these posters are projecting negative relationships with their own MIL/DIL.

The one reply I always find strange on MIL threads is 'just wait until your son has a DC!' , etc - this isn't the gotcha moment these posters think it is, as presumably OP will remember how annoying it was when MIL did X and therefore won't do X when they're in the same position.

Stunningscreamer · 01/01/2023 21:50

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:30

Another blooming I guess it depends on whether he's allowed to stick up for his wife?
Some men are in fog and they have a parents who doesn't care for their feelings, only whether they tow their line..

Yes and some men have wives who are like that. Remember that MiLs were once DiLs. There is no sudden transformation when your son has children. The same women who can be nightmare MiLs were probably nightmare DiLs. I just don't get why people can't see it can either side that's a nightmare.

Stunningscreamer · 01/01/2023 21:46

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:33

Stunning screamer absolutely and yes it does happen.

But if your child suddenly or gradually cut you off what would you do?

I would be questioning myself, why? Have I said something, do I like their partners? How are we different/alike/ would my company make them feel good or bad??

Am I cheery or am I a little miserable? What's going on for them? Am I respectfull, do I make them feel bad?

Surely for people we really love a little self reflection is the least we can do and then to ask nicely or apologize?

Yes and that goes both ways.

Olinguita · 01/01/2023 21:42

lovelypidgeon · 01/01/2023 20:46

I think in relation to involvement with young grandchildren some MILs do need to remember that there IS a huge difference between their relationship with their DIL and the DIL's relationship with her own mother. The very early days of motherhood can be difficult- recovering from the physical issues of giving birth, getting to grips with breastfeeding, hormonal changes, lack of sleep etc. I think it's perfectly reasonable that a new mother feels more comfortable having her own mother around when she's dealing with these pretty personal changes than she does having someone she personally isn't as close to around. Too often I think people in general forget that the mother of a new baby has her own right to privacy and dignity. Personally I'm really happy that my DC have a strong relationship with all their grandparents and have enjoyed time alone being spoiled by them once they were old enough but when I felt vulnerable etc the only people I wanted around other than for short visits were DH and my own mother. I think a lot of MIL/DIL conflicts would be resolved more easily if MILs (and their friends and family) could see that this is not personal and doesn't mean that there is a competition between the 2 sets of grandparents from day 1.

This, with bells on.
MILs who are insensitive to DILs' need for privacy and dignity in the immediate aftermath of birth do themselves absolutely no favours and can do a lot of long-term damage to the MIL/DIL relationship. It is a hugely vulnerable and emotional time for a new mum. Not saying MIL should be shut out, but it's astonishing to me how many of them both on here and in real life have absolutely zero regards for the wellbeing of the new mum.
Mine stayed with us for two months when my son was a newborn and it was bloody awful. She was about as useful as a chocolate teapot, had no regard for my privacy, amplified tensions between me and my sleep deprived husband and treated the baby like he was some kind of emotional support animal. Our relationship has not recovered.

Mummyof287 · 01/01/2023 21:10

Ha! Maybe sometimes, but if I wrote a thread (or a book) on my toxic self centered and morally dysfunctional MIL you would certainly be thinking the opposite!

123boom · 01/01/2023 20:49

Another thread about mil posts!

healthadvice123 · 01/01/2023 20:46

I think a lot on here who are very precious about their kids and a bit ott about it all
We all love our kids of course but mil allowing one more chocolate button than you do is really not a battle to have

Swipe left for the next trending thread