Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have questions about sex/gender

294 replies

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 10:59

N/C for obvious reasons as likely to get called transphobic but genuinely just confused & want to understand.

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans & it's hard to have a conversation with people about it. Firstly, I don't think trans people should have to put in the emotional labour to explain (but equally I don't know how you get to understand without having conversations) and secondly, having questions inevitably gets you labelled as a bigot.

I've never questioned what it feels like to be a woman. I just feel like me & I've never thought that how I feel is defined by my sex. I like things that are stereotypically male pursuits & dislike things that are stereotypically female pursuits (and equally vice versa). I'm bisexual so don't fit the "norm" in that respect either.

I feel like wanting to change your gender plays into the gender stereotypes moreso than if you just lived how you wanted to live (wore what you want, liked what you want etc). If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

I know several trans people and obviously respect their pronouns and treat them with the same respect and kindness I would anyone I know. Regardless of the fact I don't understand.

OP posts:
DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 01/01/2023 15:57

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 15:44

Have you just assumed that samphire isn't transgender?

I suspect many people are transgender if you dig deeply

I mean any female person who thinks women only describes their biology is strictly speaking transgender
Any female who doesn't feel aligned with any gender identify is strictly speaking transgender

, it's just many don't really care or don't want to be associated with the transgender community

I think the opposite.

I am biologically female, I don't think my relationship to gender stereotype affects my femaleness at all. I am fully woman even though I do not wear dresses, never had my nails done, go rock climbing, etc etc. Women can do and be what they want. It dowsn't make them trans men.

From what is happening amongst my friends daughters it seems that those who are not 'feminine' and / or are physically attracted to women, are now being defined as 'Trans'. Why? Why cannot they be young women who like short hair and dungarees and may or may not be attracted to other women? However 'deep' they dig? Why do these preferences , orientations, personality qualities, make them Transgendered?

And does this matter? Yes, it can do. A study many years ago showed that young people who followed certain fashionable logos (was it to do with the Beastie Boys and Swastikas?) revealed that once young people knew what the swastikas were and were challenged they would rather adopt the politics behind the logo than drop a logo that signalled them as 'cool' and at one with their peers.

This matters when an identity of Trans can lead to irreversible puberty blockers etc. which have been dispensed on an affirmation model.

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 15:55

I used cis as a point of clarity I suppose. But perhaps I understand less than I thought.

It's not a term I'd use in general conversation or to describe myself irl.

OP posts:
YoBeaches · 01/01/2023 15:54

@SuperPup86 you are aware of social contagion?

The fixation that men can do woman better than women can. That woman is a feeling, something that can be worn. The female is not what makes a woman.

That girls can fix their self hate, their worth in society, their sexual trauma, by becoming boys and rejecting their bodies. Removing their breasts and their uterus.

That under developed, infertile yet legally consenting adults can fulfil a whole host of paedophilic desires.

That in some countries it's better to be "a woman born in a man's body" than it is to be a gay man. Because the punishment for being gay, is death.

That womens rights are eroded with every step. Our opportunity, access and freedom in a fair and democratic society is saueezed. That laws are changed to allow anyone to be a woman, just because they say they are.

Wake up. This isn't a few people. It's a whole movement of sadistic patriarchy.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 15:45

Mm! Just remember you brought her into this thread. Not me!

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 15:44

Have you just assumed that samphire isn't transgender?

I suspect many people are transgender if you dig deeply

I mean any female person who thinks women only describes their biology is strictly speaking transgender
Any female who doesn't feel aligned with any gender identify is strictly speaking transgender

, it's just many don't really care or don't want to be associated with the transgender community

NalaNana · 01/01/2023 15:41

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist oh for heavens sake why are you so interested in directing this conversation to JKR's views? OP isn't asking about JKR, she's trying to understand trans people, why can't you see that JKR is not going to aid her in that understanding?

Of course they have a bias, they are trans, but isn't that the point of what she's searching for? If she was asking to understand the perspective of a gender critical voice directing her (or anyone else) to JKR would be reasonable.

I also haven't said she's transphobic so you're arguing with yourself about that point.

You aren't in a position to dictate what is or isn't offensive to a trans person, or what they should or shouldn't be bothered by. You aren't trans. It isn't up to you.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 15:39

Once you accept that gender is real and determined by sex you create significant numbers of transgender people because gender isn't actually determined by sex at all - it's more closely related to personality than sex - eg you like pink and hate maths is nothing to do with sex

Historically transgender just referred to people with severe body dysmophpia - like anorexia but focussed on sex markers

With teenage girls you tend to have the 2 overlap because the changing female body is pretty freaky and associated with sexual abuse that most girls don't want

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 15:34

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

Because they are not really that tiny a % of the population these days.

Any parent of teens most likely knows at least one as a place to start.

strawberry2017 · 01/01/2023 15:26

Why did you refer to yourself as a cis women? You are a women.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 15:25

Somanysocks · 01/01/2023 12:34

Yup, me too

Me too

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 15:23

NalaNana · 01/01/2023 12:55

There are plenty of trans people who make content on sites like YouTube. If you want to hear from trans people about their experience (without actually asking them) I'd start by having a look?

I've found a link to a video of a trans man and his wife reacting to a JK Rowling essay - it's been ages since I watched it but I seem to remember it covering some main points.

This is what you posted. A couple discussing the JKR essay. They have a bias, it shows. You, not OP could discuss this in more detail had you read JKRs own words. You say you have... so you will know that she said nothing that any trans individual would be bothered by. Assuming of course they too had read her words and not those of others discussing them.

Many here have seen and heard all sorts of total crap about what JKR is supposed to have said. And nobody has yet managed to supply a direct quote to back any of it up! You are merely the latest in a long line of posters trying to use disinformation to make a point.

NalaNana · 01/01/2023 15:16

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist I never said JKR was transphobic - OP was looking to understand trans people and I suggested a trans YouTuber to her. I chose that video because it's one of the few I've seen and remembered that it covered lots of mainstream discussion points. OP wants to understand the trans perspective hence it being helpful to her to hear trans voices rather than yours, mine or JKR for that matter.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 15:15

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 14:31

Totally agree. Everyone is so aggressive about this and it isn’t necessary.

You mean female posters here say no, vehemently or men, TRAs shouting at, spitting at, pushing shoving, wobbling their titties at women?

Women's words or make actions?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 15:13

NalaNana · 01/01/2023 13:47

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist i already have

Then you know she said nothing transphobic.

Or could quote, using only sentences she actually typed, what is was JKR said that was transphobic.

Abitofalark · 01/01/2023 14:44

You are a woman, plain and simple. No qualifying letters or words are required before that plain word in order to say what you are and be understood.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 14:43

By calling yourself cis you are giving yourself a gender

Why do you think that your sex should determine that gender ?

Shelefttheweb · 01/01/2023 14:42

Ok, so playing devils advocate- if you don’t believe in gender stereotypes (good) then why are you so sure you identify as a woman?

The word ‘woman’ refers to adult female humans; our physical sex. Gendered stereotypes are sexist and harmful to women, reducing us down to regressive stereotypes is oppressive to women. By playing along with the idea that a man who wears a dress is ‘she’ you are suggesting that women are only women because they wear dresses. This is offensive nonsense. Women have nothing in common with Transwomen that we do not have in common with all other men.

You are also ignoring autogynaephilia (AGP) which is what drives most male transitions, not gender dysphoria. This is a paraphilia (sexual proclivity) where they are turned on by the idea of others seeing them as a women. Many transwomen (transvestites) acknowledge this. So for these men women are unconsenting participants in their sex life. Why should I support a man getting his sexual kicks by calling him ‘she’?

sanityisamyth · 01/01/2023 14:35

blacksax · 01/01/2023 11:41

You lost me at 'cis'.

Same.

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 14:31

Yaslana · 01/01/2023 13:44

And this is exactly why its difficult to ask questions and get sensible answers - sure I know why you dont like 'cis' and its not your job to educate people.

But likewise if someone is asking questions, your dismissive and rude response only shuts doors and gives mn users a bad name

Totally agree. Everyone is so aggressive about this and it isn’t necessary.

FourTeaFallOut · 01/01/2023 14:29

RandomPerson42 · 01/01/2023 13:50

People are people, all other pointless labels are bullshit imho.

We are all different but humans like to form groups and gangs so they have a perpetual us and them, this causes all bigotry and prejudices.

🤨 People are people? Which are the people occupying 96% of prisons and responsible for the most amount of physical and sexual violence? Just a collection of individuals with nothing in common?

Bigdamnheroes · 01/01/2023 14:15

@WallaceinAnderland I agree. I feel great sympathy with them but I do think it is reprehensible that we are allowing children under 18 to damage themselves with hormone blockers and mutilate their bodies with surgery, often leaving them sterile in the name of being inclusive.

Mental health treatment is what they should be being referred for, not surgery to mangle their genitals.

WallaceinAnderland · 01/01/2023 14:09

Bigdamnheroes · 01/01/2023 13:46

I think gender dysphoria is one of those things like depression. You can read descriptions and have it explained a million ways, a million times by a million people but you never really 'get it' unless you experience it for yourself.

And no-one can expect the whole world to lie about reality just to alleviate some uncomfortable symptoms experienced by a tiny proportion of society.

Let alone try to enforce it. People won't do it and the kick back of resistance will actually be harder for those genuinely suffering from dysphoria.

Appletreefarmyard · 01/01/2023 14:01

Quite a few of points of dispute boil down to what can and can't be an 'identity'.

There are aspects of the self that are material and objective - such as our sex, whether we have one leg or two, our height, our weight and our age. These cannot be identified in to / out of.

Society doesn't take a neutral view on many material aspects of self - and this changes over time and is different in different cultures. Societies tend to have widely accepted ideas about what being a certain age, sex, size means. If an individual doesn't agree with these ideas or if they don't think they apply to themselves, material reality is not wrong - the that dominant ideas in society don't align with their own.

For me, the solution lays in getting society to less prescriptive about the social meanings/ expectations given to material aspects of self.

Where individuals are distressed by their bodies, and this is separate to societal expectations, this is a mental health issue

RandomPerson42 · 01/01/2023 13:50

People are people, all other pointless labels are bullshit imho.

We are all different but humans like to form groups and gangs so they have a perpetual us and them, this causes all bigotry and prejudices.

NalaNana · 01/01/2023 13:47

@SamphirethePogoingStickerist i already have

Swipe left for the next trending thread