Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have questions about sex/gender

294 replies

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 10:59

N/C for obvious reasons as likely to get called transphobic but genuinely just confused & want to understand.

I'm a cis woman & therefore clearly have no understanding of what it feels like to be trans & it's hard to have a conversation with people about it. Firstly, I don't think trans people should have to put in the emotional labour to explain (but equally I don't know how you get to understand without having conversations) and secondly, having questions inevitably gets you labelled as a bigot.

I've never questioned what it feels like to be a woman. I just feel like me & I've never thought that how I feel is defined by my sex. I like things that are stereotypically male pursuits & dislike things that are stereotypically female pursuits (and equally vice versa). I'm bisexual so don't fit the "norm" in that respect either.

I feel like wanting to change your gender plays into the gender stereotypes moreso than if you just lived how you wanted to live (wore what you want, liked what you want etc). If there's no intention of ever fully transitioning (I know people that aren't) then I don't understand why you need to say you're the opposite gender. Surely you're just you?!

I know several trans people and obviously respect their pronouns and treat them with the same respect and kindness I would anyone I know. Regardless of the fact I don't understand.

OP posts:
Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 17:13

And yep - that’s me- Afterfire. I name changed. No real reason.

Happiestwithtea · 01/01/2023 17:13

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 17:05

I just see a lot of hatred in a lot of posts here towards people who aren’t deserving of it and I don’t like it.

Hatred? Please report any hatred you see. It will be quickly deleted.

If you interpret discussion as hatred and it is merely robust discussion that you don’t like, the posts will stand. And that might be an indication that your interpretation is prejudiced not the intention of the poster.

I have reported posts - on this thread as well as others- and they have been deleted. So I’m clearly not being over sensitive.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 17:12

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:52

If I don’t agree with something I will say it. My views on trans are actually far more complicated than people want them to be. I am actually somewhere in the middle with it all and I am learning by reading other peoples posts just as people are reading mine. That’s what happens in a forum. I am not prejudiced against any particular posters. What I don’t like is regular posters ganging up on me - and others who dare to have a slightly different viewpoint- and effectively laughing at me by just spamming phrases or giggling between themselves as if were all some uneducated idiots. And I will call people out on that, because it’s bullying.

I am not trying to shape the discussion to my own needs. In fact I don’t have any needs. I am a middle aged, mum of 2, long time married. I just see a lot of hatred in a lot of posts here towards people who aren’t deserving of it and I don’t like it. That’s it.

What you are 'calling out' is any number of individual posters who disagree with you.

What you are labelling 'hatred' is seen by others as women saying no and insisting on logic over emotions.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 17:07

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:36

That’s not what I meant at all. As usual you can’t say anything about this without people jumping on you!

The point I was making - and you’ve managed to illustrate so well in your reply - is that here we have someone openly asking a question, which actually - whatever you think about all these issues- is a good way to openly discuss things with someone who clearly hasn’t made their mind up yet. And yet that poster is shot down immediately by people saying “well you’ve lost me at cis” What good does that do anyone? It’s just shutting down discussion. That’s what I meant by aggressive. There’s no need for it and it actually damages the debate because it makes people look ridiculous.

You are reading all posts as though they are written by a single poster.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 17:05

I just see a lot of hatred in a lot of posts here towards people who aren’t deserving of it and I don’t like it.

Hatred? Please report any hatred you see. It will be quickly deleted.

If you interpret discussion as hatred and it is merely robust discussion that you don’t like, the posts will stand. And that might be an indication that your interpretation is prejudiced not the intention of the poster.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 17:03

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:52

If I don’t agree with something I will say it. My views on trans are actually far more complicated than people want them to be. I am actually somewhere in the middle with it all and I am learning by reading other peoples posts just as people are reading mine. That’s what happens in a forum. I am not prejudiced against any particular posters. What I don’t like is regular posters ganging up on me - and others who dare to have a slightly different viewpoint- and effectively laughing at me by just spamming phrases or giggling between themselves as if were all some uneducated idiots. And I will call people out on that, because it’s bullying.

I am not trying to shape the discussion to my own needs. In fact I don’t have any needs. I am a middle aged, mum of 2, long time married. I just see a lot of hatred in a lot of posts here towards people who aren’t deserving of it and I don’t like it. That’s it.

Yet your posts on another thread are littered with disparaging remarks about the MN FWR board.

No you are not targeting posters and I did not say that. However your posts about ‘shutting down’ discussion here look hypocritical in light of your posts elsewhere which can only be read as an attempt to shame posters.

I am not trying to shape the discussion to my own needs

OK. But your posts come across very much like those who aim to tone police, which we see very regularly.

Fairislefandango · 01/01/2023 17:01

Ok, so playing devils advocate- if you don’t believe in gender stereotypes (good) then why are you so sure you identify as a woman? (I’m asking that a little bit cheekily because clearly you do, as do I).

I don't think many (actual) women would say they 'identify' as a woman. They, like me, would say they are a woman. Generally it's only people who factually, categorically and provably aren't something who feel the need to identify as it.

Aa someone saidon a thread the other day:
In order to allow male people to be women, womanhood for all women has to be limited to only things that can be achieved by males even though this change, so crucial to trans women's identy as women, makes the concept of womanhood superficial and almost entirely meaningless.

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:52

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 16:45

I think on other threads you have made your own prejudices about regular MN feminist posters pretty clear actually.

Or are your constant shaming posts not designed the silence, or at least shape, discussion to suit your own needs?

If I don’t agree with something I will say it. My views on trans are actually far more complicated than people want them to be. I am actually somewhere in the middle with it all and I am learning by reading other peoples posts just as people are reading mine. That’s what happens in a forum. I am not prejudiced against any particular posters. What I don’t like is regular posters ganging up on me - and others who dare to have a slightly different viewpoint- and effectively laughing at me by just spamming phrases or giggling between themselves as if were all some uneducated idiots. And I will call people out on that, because it’s bullying.

I am not trying to shape the discussion to my own needs. In fact I don’t have any needs. I am a middle aged, mum of 2, long time married. I just see a lot of hatred in a lot of posts here towards people who aren’t deserving of it and I don’t like it. That’s it.

belowfrozen · 01/01/2023 16:46

Echobelly · 01/01/2023 13:21

I wondered about whether people couldn't just present how they want, but I was quite struck by a video from a trans woman explaining that she did try just presenting as female, but for her the 'him' and 'sirs' directed to her she found impossible to cope with as they profoundly did not fit her sense of self.

My teen identifies as non binary and has said they have 'never felt female'; I have said to them that that's normal, no one really 'feels' a gender, and then it struck me that's possibly one thing that defines trans people - that they 'feel' a gender where others don't, because it doesn't fit what they have been presumed to be.

But would any child 'feel female' or 'feel male' . I'm sure DC just feel like them. DD is into lots of stereotypical boy stuff. DS is more caring and soft.
Both are totally normal.
I think they are fed so much garbage about what they should like / do / wear it makes them think they aren't in the right box

OMG12 · 01/01/2023 16:46

Your first issue is assuming that all trans people want to change sex because they feel like a member of the opposite sex. Although TRAs actively push this one reason approach, there are many reasons people claim to be trans. This is a disservice to everyone (except the people who are pushing this idea). In truth the closest a trans person can get to feeling like a woman, is to not feel like their stereotype of a man. There is not a feeling of being a woman, we are individuals- in short feeling like a woman can only ever be a stereotype which is usually harmful to women (CIs is superfluous)

the trans community are 0.03% of the UK population- yet they want the whole of society to be shaped to their needs even where it overrides the needs of 51%.

Helleofabore · 01/01/2023 16:45

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:36

That’s not what I meant at all. As usual you can’t say anything about this without people jumping on you!

The point I was making - and you’ve managed to illustrate so well in your reply - is that here we have someone openly asking a question, which actually - whatever you think about all these issues- is a good way to openly discuss things with someone who clearly hasn’t made their mind up yet. And yet that poster is shot down immediately by people saying “well you’ve lost me at cis” What good does that do anyone? It’s just shutting down discussion. That’s what I meant by aggressive. There’s no need for it and it actually damages the debate because it makes people look ridiculous.

I think on other threads you have made your own prejudices about regular MN feminist posters pretty clear actually.

Or are your constant shaming posts not designed the silence, or at least shape, discussion to suit your own needs?

MrNorrell · 01/01/2023 16:38

Ok, so playing devils advocate- if you don’t believe in gender stereotypes (good) then why are you so sure you identify as a woman? (I’m asking that a little bit cheekily because clearly you do, as do I). So you wouldn’t be happy with someone referring to you as a “he” or “they / them” because you are a woman, you know you’re a woman

I don't identify as a woman any more than I identify as 5'2" or Caucasian. I'm of the female sex, I'm a human being, and I'm above the age of majority. These aren't things I've identified into, this is just material reality.

If someone calls me he/they then it might be vaguely irritating but it's not something I'm going to get too het up about. It doesn't negate the fact I'm an adult human female.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 16:38

Calling themselves cis did rather suggest that they do know what gender and therefore transgender must be

Which given the amount of fake innocents that we get will make people suspicious

The OP has made it clear however that it was a misunderstanding on her part

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 16:36

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 15:15

You mean female posters here say no, vehemently or men, TRAs shouting at, spitting at, pushing shoving, wobbling their titties at women?

Women's words or make actions?

That’s not what I meant at all. As usual you can’t say anything about this without people jumping on you!

The point I was making - and you’ve managed to illustrate so well in your reply - is that here we have someone openly asking a question, which actually - whatever you think about all these issues- is a good way to openly discuss things with someone who clearly hasn’t made their mind up yet. And yet that poster is shot down immediately by people saying “well you’ve lost me at cis” What good does that do anyone? It’s just shutting down discussion. That’s what I meant by aggressive. There’s no need for it and it actually damages the debate because it makes people look ridiculous.

YoBeaches · 01/01/2023 16:34

Stereotypicallyconfused · 01/01/2023 15:55

I used cis as a point of clarity I suppose. But perhaps I understand less than I thought.

It's not a term I'd use in general conversation or to describe myself irl.

OP you are a woman. And anyone who is not a woman is a man.

No matter what they wear, feel or who they sleep with.

Anything else is a social construct with several variations of motivation and purpose.

Shelefttheweb · 01/01/2023 16:31

Our sex is why we are oppressed, gender is how we are oppressed

Creepinglight · 01/01/2023 16:23

Rookiemama1 · 01/01/2023 13:17

Asking questions doesn’t make you a bigot in my opinion. It’s more the people who rubbish transgenderism or say it’s silly or make believe without attempting to understand what it is or how it feels. It’s the people who dismiss it or try to change the minds of transgender people are bigots. I think even if one doesn’t understand it there’s nothing stopping everyone from being tolerant and accepting.

With the greatest respect, you appear to be rubbishing those who are critical of gender ideology without having understood their arguments. If you had taken time to look into their arguments, you would understand why they argue for people being accepting and tolerant of the need for women to have single sex spaces.

Calling people bigoted without first fully understanding their position is surely quite bigoted?

Creepinglight · 01/01/2023 16:17

If you state that people should be able to present how they like while remaining in their biological sex status, you'll be accused of being a transphobe

Yeah, they should really be accusing those people of being a feminist. At least that would be accurate.

PauliString · 01/01/2023 16:17

SuperPup86 · 01/01/2023 12:12

I'm always curious by the amount of posters on threads such as this - or twitter - who have 'several trans friends' or similar and often claim that of course it poses no issues bla bla bla.

For such a small percentage of the population I find it odd that your average person seems to know quite so many.

Really? Four of our friends and family have teenage/twenties daughters who are now transboys/transmen. At least two have had surgery. One of those has a brother who is currently using a female name and a sister who is apparently nonbinary. There’s also one transwoman though we’re not often in touch since the transition broke up the family.

Maybe it’s because we know a lot of scientists and techies, who often tend to be neurodiverse, and that tends to run in families.

GrimDamnFanjo · 01/01/2023 16:16

One of the most confusing aspects relates to language.
For me there are two biological sexes - there really isn't a third sex or intersex etc which is often dragged into discussions.

Then you have gender. Gender is a social construct - norms vary according to the society you live in.
If I go back to my A level sociology then I remember learning about societies where women went out and hunted and men stayed home and cooked to greatly paraphrase.

The big issue now is people believing gender can and should replace sex. This causes all kinds of problems. As biological women we understand our sex has oppressed us. We can point to clear biological differences between ourselves and men which mean we are different.

Replace sex with gender and we get
Men removing women from sport at all levels - from the three 800m medal winners at Rio to college women losing sports scholarships to fund university education.

Men, who commit most crime and most violent crime having easy access to womens spaces, prisons, rape support centres etc. we all know NAMALT but I'd choose to be in those spaces with unknown biological women not men. And that's before you consider there are sex offenders who will do pretty much anything to be able to commit crimes, so putting on a dress is an easy win,

We even have stonewall advocating same gender attraction and lesbians being told to include men in their dating pool.
What is being gay about if it isn't same sex attraction?

So to me it's a clear choice. Sex should not be replaced in law or society by gender.

MilkToastHoney · 01/01/2023 16:14

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 11:52

Ok, so playing devils advocate- if you don’t believe in gender stereotypes (good) then why are you so sure you identify as a woman? (I’m asking that a little bit cheekily because clearly you do, as do I). So you wouldn’t be happy with someone referring to you as a “he” or “they / them” because you are a woman, you
know you’re a woman. From what I understand from those I know who are trans, they too “know” they identify as whatever they introduce themselves as. Nothing to do with clothes, or whatever else. If you wouldn’t be happy with someone calling you “he” or they / them then you can’t expect others not to want to change their own pronouns to suit them.

You can’t just choose what you identify as though.
I could say I identify as a cat and say that’s how I feel but it wouldn’t be fair to expect others to go along with it and pretend they think I’m an actual cat.

Or I could ‘identify’ as a 6 year old and insist in going to a children’s swimming class and children’s gymnastics class.
I could speak in a baby voice and wear my hair in bunches and a pinafore and t-bar shoes.
I should expect all the other parents to be happy with me in their child’s swimming class and changing room and to pretend that they really believe I’m 6. They should treat me like all the other 6 year olds and invite me to their child’s birthday party and on play dates.

I don’t want to address a man wearing lipstick and a skirt as a woman and call him she/her and share my gym changing room with him, pretending I really believe he’s a woman. Just no. If he wants to wear lipstick and whatever clothes he chooses then great, no issues with men in make up or whatever, I just don’t want to pretend I think a man is a woman.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 16:12

I certainly have never been upset at being called a he/him

I think men are more likely offended as to be a women is seen as lesser in society

Creepinglight · 01/01/2023 16:10

Afterfire · 01/01/2023 11:52

Ok, so playing devils advocate- if you don’t believe in gender stereotypes (good) then why are you so sure you identify as a woman? (I’m asking that a little bit cheekily because clearly you do, as do I). So you wouldn’t be happy with someone referring to you as a “he” or “they / them” because you are a woman, you
know you’re a woman. From what I understand from those I know who are trans, they too “know” they identify as whatever they introduce themselves as. Nothing to do with clothes, or whatever else. If you wouldn’t be happy with someone calling you “he” or they / them then you can’t expect others not to want to change their own pronouns to suit them.

Woman isn't an identity. Its a sex. I know I am a woman because I am of the female sex. There is nothing else that makes me, or anyone else, a woman.

midgetastic · 01/01/2023 16:09

I think dreaming you are actually almost agreeing

You don't think that you have a gender that aligns with your sex and you don't see why anyone should

Which according to stonewall definition actually makes you transgender whether you like it or not

And if everyone who fits the stonewall definition stood up to be counted - what we are actually doing is showing how to be transgender without needing to be changed in any way , no damaging treatments, without the need to make a song and dance over it , without being special in any way

Feel you don't meet the current gender requirements- no bother
Hate your body and hate the way others treat you because of it? Change them not you

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 01/01/2023 16:04

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 01/01/2023 15:57

I think the opposite.

I am biologically female, I don't think my relationship to gender stereotype affects my femaleness at all. I am fully woman even though I do not wear dresses, never had my nails done, go rock climbing, etc etc. Women can do and be what they want. It dowsn't make them trans men.

From what is happening amongst my friends daughters it seems that those who are not 'feminine' and / or are physically attracted to women, are now being defined as 'Trans'. Why? Why cannot they be young women who like short hair and dungarees and may or may not be attracted to other women? However 'deep' they dig? Why do these preferences , orientations, personality qualities, make them Transgendered?

And does this matter? Yes, it can do. A study many years ago showed that young people who followed certain fashionable logos (was it to do with the Beastie Boys and Swastikas?) revealed that once young people knew what the swastikas were and were challenged they would rather adopt the politics behind the logo than drop a logo that signalled them as 'cool' and at one with their peers.

This matters when an identity of Trans can lead to irreversible puberty blockers etc. which have been dispensed on an affirmation model.

Oh don't worry. Midge is pointing out the weird logic gender identity comes wrapped up in. Not any reality. If you take any gender identity, Stonewall's umbrella definition you end up realising that every human being on the planet has a unique gender.

And then you just can't unsee the stupidity of it all!